Published debate record
6 eligible one-on-one scorecards. Average published score: 77.7/100. Scores describe these debates, not the person's overall ability or worth.
Joel Settecase vs Tom Jump: Is There Evidence for God? · 2025
Settecase exposed gaps between self-certainty and universal necessity, while Jump effectively separated objective relations from descriptions and challenged divine sustenance.
Joel Settecase: 84 · Tom Jump: 78. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Michael Jones vs Tom Jump: Does God Exist? · 2019
Jones defended theistic idealism through consciousness and emergent spacetime; Jump pressed underdetermination, epistemic limits, natural alternatives, and the explanatory cost of divine attributes.
Michael Jones: 76 · Tom Jump: 80. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Does Analytic Idealism Explain Consciousness Better? Bernardo Kastrup vs. Tom Jump · 2023
Kastrup narrowly wins by pressing materialism’s qualitative explanatory gap, while Jump preserves materialism’s viability through epistemic caution, composition challenges, and realization possibilities.
Bernardo Kastrup: 83 · Tom Jump: 80. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Eric Hernandez vs Tom Jump: Free Will, Consciousness, and the Existence of the Soul · 2019
Hernandez defends a nonphysical soul through rational agency, mental properties, personhood, and private consciousness; Jump prevails by emphasizing coherence, physical explanation, and predictive evidence.
Eric Hernandez: 72 · Tom Jump: 78. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
James Anderson vs Tom Jump: Logic and Belief in God · 2020
Anderson develops stronger distinctions about shared truth and representation; Jump effectively separates necessary reality from contingent language, while the divine-mind route remains incomplete.
James Anderson: 79 · Tom Jump: 74. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Jonathan McLatchie vs Tom Jump — Does God Exist? · 2019
McLatchie’s cumulative Bayesian case narrowly prevailed, while Jump’s underdetermination challenges exposed unresolved comparisons behind its numerical confidence.
Jonathan McLatchie: 79 · Tom Jump: 76. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Team and other excluded appearances
These records do not contribute to individual averages.
Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle vs Aron Ra and TJump: Is Christianity True? · 2023
The Knechtles defend Jesus through Gospel reliability, resurrection, grace, love, and worldview fit; Aron Ra and TJump challenge miracle testimony, biblical contradictions, religious borrowing, and evidential standards.
Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle: 66 · Aron Ra and Tom Jump: 76. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.