Published debate record
4 eligible one-on-one scorecards. Average published score: 85/100. Scores describe these debates, not the person's overall ability or worth.
Cameron Bertuzzi vs Justin Schieber: The Problem of Evil · 2019
Schieber's comparative suffering case prevailed overall, while Bertuzzi's likelihood objection and limited-information defense exposed a serious weakness in the final skeptical-theism reply.
Cameron Bertuzzi: 78 · Justin Schieber: 87. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Eric Hernandez vs Justin Schieber: Does God Exist? · 2023
Hernandez defended theistic grounds for morality, reason, and consciousness; Schieber pressed stronger naturalistic alternatives and evidential challenges from suffering, hostility, and hiddenness.
Eric Hernandez: 74 · Justin Schieber: 85. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Randal Rauser vs Justin Schieber — Does God Exist? · 2015
Schieber’s comparative naturalist case better connects simplicity, hiddenness, cosmic hostility, and suffering to the motion, while Rauser offers serious epistemic and moral replies.
Randal Rauser: 76 · Justin Schieber: 83. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.
Justin Schieber vs Randal Rauser — Religious Disagreement and God · 2017
Schieber’s calibrated comparative case outscored Rauser’s thoughtful but insufficiently evidenced appeals to permissive divine reasons and underdetermination.
Justin Schieber: 85 · Randal Rauser: 78. Scores assess the reasoning in this debate.