[ { "number": 1, "id": "craig-oconnor-god-debate-2026", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs William Lane Craig: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do cosmology, fine-tuning, morality, resurrection, and suffering support or undermine Christian theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TAW6-_L4z9M", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 82, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.95, "evidenceWarrant": 62.92999999999999, "responsiveness": 83.22500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.415, "precisionClarity": 77.9, "calibrationCharity": 70.67500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.81, "evidenceWarrant": 74.19, "responsiveness": 79.65, "relevanceBurden": 83.87, "precisionClarity": 84.8, "calibrationCharity": 88.07 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.86, "evidenceWarrant": 11.260000000000005, "responsiveness": -3.575000000000003, "relevanceBurden": -1.5450000000000017, "precisionClarity": 6.8999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 17.394999999999982 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.215, "evidenceWarrant": 2.252000000000001, "responsiveness": -0.7150000000000006, "relevanceBurden": -0.23175000000000023, "precisionClarity": 0.6899999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.7394999999999983 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.05025000000000279 }, { "number": 2, "id": "craig-hitchens-god-existence-2009", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Christopher Hitchens: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do cosmology, fine-tuning, morality, resurrection, suffering, and religion's record make Christian theism more plausible than atheism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0tYm41hb48o", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 82, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.39999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 66.595, "responsiveness": 83.53, "relevanceBurden": 83.725, "precisionClarity": 85.6, "calibrationCharity": 70.265 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.342, "evidenceWarrant": 75.372, "responsiveness": 85.858, "relevanceBurden": 84.052, "precisionClarity": 85.2, "calibrationCharity": 82.264 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.942000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 8.777000000000001, "responsiveness": 2.328000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 0.3270000000000124, "precisionClarity": -0.3999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 11.998999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2355000000000018, "evidenceWarrant": 1.7554000000000003, "responsiveness": 0.4656000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 0.049050000000001856, "precisionClarity": -0.03999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 1.1998999999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6654500000000052 }, { "number": 3, "id": "hitchens-dsouza-religion-problem-2010", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Dinesh D'Souza: Is Religion the Problem?", "motion": "Is religion the problem, or does the God hypothesis better explain life, morality, purpose, and human experience than secular doubt?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9V85OykSDT8", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 75, "con_gap": -8, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Hitchens", "con": "Dinesh D'Souza" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.732, "evidenceWarrant": 73.982, "responsiveness": 89.352, "relevanceBurden": 86.49000000000001, "precisionClarity": 84.44999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.52799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.385, "evidenceWarrant": 62.875, "responsiveness": 80.85999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.43, "precisionClarity": 80.125, "calibrationCharity": 66.97 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.346999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 11.107, "responsiveness": 8.492000000000019, "relevanceBurden": 0.060000000000002274, "precisionClarity": 4.324999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 13.557999999999993 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5867499999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2214, "responsiveness": 1.698400000000004, "relevanceBurden": 0.009000000000000341, "precisionClarity": 0.4324999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 1.3557999999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3038500000000006 }, { "number": 4, "id": "lennox-atkins-science-explain-everything-2019", "title": "John Lennox vs Peter Atkins: Can Science Explain Everything?", "motion": "Can science explain everything worth explaining, or do rationality, miracles, purpose, origins, morality, and meaning require a different kind of explanation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fSYwCaFkYno", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 77, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Peter Atkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.64800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 69.808, "responsiveness": 94.214, "relevanceBurden": 89.026, "precisionClarity": 89.24000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 81.06400000000002 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 73.86, "evidenceWarrant": 65.175, "responsiveness": 85.874, "relevanceBurden": 85.961, "precisionClarity": 77.71, "calibrationCharity": 72.506 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 5, "id": "dillahunty-ten-bruggencate-reasonable-god-2014", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Sye Ten Bruggencate: Is It Reasonable to Believe God Exists?", "motion": "Is belief in God reasonable, and can truth, logic, knowledge, induction, and evidence be accounted for without Christian revelation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OL8LREmbDi0", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 64, "con": 88, "con_gap": 24, "speakers": { "pro": "Sye Ten Bruggencate", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 24, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 60.5, "evidenceWarrant": 47.225, "responsiveness": 69.475, "relevanceBurden": 83.60000000000001, "precisionClarity": 75.0, "calibrationCharity": 56.625 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.74, "evidenceWarrant": 79.335, "responsiveness": 93.76, "relevanceBurden": 86.47, "precisionClarity": 93.05, "calibrationCharity": 89.705 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 27.239999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 32.10999999999999, "responsiveness": 24.28500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 2.8699999999999903, "precisionClarity": 18.049999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 33.08 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 6.809999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 6.421999999999999, "responsiveness": 4.857000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 0.43049999999999855, "precisionClarity": 1.8049999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 3.308 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3674999999999997 }, { "number": 6, "id": "dsouza-dillahunty-god-woman-2023", "title": "Dinesh D'Souza vs Matt Dillahunty: Does God Exist? What Is a Woman?", "motion": "Should beliefs about God, gender, politics, and social welfare be guided by faith-informed inference, empirical evidence, or secular-humanist consequences?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEM1AhlH9eI", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 87, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Dinesh D'Souza", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.567, "evidenceWarrant": 65.99199999999999, "responsiveness": 78.118, "relevanceBurden": 83.958, "precisionClarity": 79.505, "calibrationCharity": 75.18100000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.99, "evidenceWarrant": 77.975, "responsiveness": 93.025, "relevanceBurden": 88.95, "precisionClarity": 86.80000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 85.275 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.423000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 11.983000000000004, "responsiveness": 14.90700000000001, "relevanceBurden": 4.992000000000004, "precisionClarity": 7.295000000000016, "calibrationCharity": 10.093999999999994 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.6057500000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 2.3966000000000007, "responsiveness": 2.9814000000000025, "relevanceBurden": 0.7488000000000007, "precisionClarity": 0.7295000000000016, "calibrationCharity": 1.0093999999999994 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.47145000000000614 }, { "number": 7, "id": "wood-oconnor-jesus-claim-god-2025", "title": "David Wood vs Alex O'Connor: Did Jesus Claim to Be God?", "motion": "Did Jesus personally claim divine identity, or do the relevant texts better show delegated authority, divine name-bearing, and later high christology?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hrN4Mn8m1w", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 90, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "David Wood", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.514, "evidenceWarrant": 78.408, "responsiveness": 94.60999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 88.14600000000002, "precisionClarity": 81.33999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 74.82799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.304, "evidenceWarrant": 83.812, "responsiveness": 98.34400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.24000000000001, "precisionClarity": 93.72, "calibrationCharity": 90.902 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.790000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 5.403999999999996, "responsiveness": 3.734000000000023, "relevanceBurden": -0.9060000000000059, "precisionClarity": 12.38000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 16.074000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.1975000000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0807999999999993, "responsiveness": 0.7468000000000047, "relevanceBurden": -0.13590000000000088, "precisionClarity": 1.238000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.6074000000000013 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.26539999999999253 }, { "number": 8, "id": "wood-shermer-god-exist-2022", "title": "David Wood vs Michael Shermer: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does science, morality, evil, and explanatory method support theism more strongly than skeptical naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKd2Ht5Bs-k", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 80, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "David Wood", "con": "Michael Shermer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.995, "evidenceWarrant": 65.325, "responsiveness": 67.41, "relevanceBurden": 83.231, "precisionClarity": 82.8, "calibrationCharity": 68.559 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.56, "evidenceWarrant": 79.057, "responsiveness": 71.973, "relevanceBurden": 83.616, "precisionClarity": 85.50999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.41 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.564999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 13.732, "responsiveness": 4.563000000000002, "relevanceBurden": 0.3850000000000051, "precisionClarity": 2.7099999999999937, "calibrationCharity": 11.850999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8912499999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 2.7464, "responsiveness": 0.9126000000000005, "relevanceBurden": 0.057750000000000766, "precisionClarity": 0.2709999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 1.1851 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06409999999999982 }, { "number": 9, "id": "peterson-dillahunty-god-debate-2023", "title": "Jordan Peterson vs Matt Dillahunty: The Greatest God Debate In History", "motion": "Does God-language name a real supernatural being, or does it function mainly as a religious, moral, and psychological substrate for meaning?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nQUg4QeI_Y", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 89, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 16, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.95, "evidenceWarrant": 64.25, "responsiveness": 74.55000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.75, "precisionClarity": 74.875, "calibrationCharity": 69.25 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 89.22500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 79.775, "responsiveness": 94.14999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 88.80000000000001, "precisionClarity": 92.5, "calibrationCharity": 89.825 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 16.275000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 15.525000000000006, "responsiveness": 19.59999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 5.050000000000011, "precisionClarity": 17.625, "calibrationCharity": 20.575000000000003 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.068750000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 3.1050000000000013, "responsiveness": 3.9199999999999964, "relevanceBurden": 0.7575000000000017, "precisionClarity": 1.7625000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 2.0575000000000006 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.32874999999999766 }, { "number": 10, "id": "craig-harris-moral-foundations-2011", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Sam Harris: The God Debate II", "motion": "Are the foundations of moral values and duties natural or supernatural?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqaHXKLRKzg", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 79, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Sam Harris" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.683, "evidenceWarrant": 68.92999999999999, "responsiveness": 86.559, "relevanceBurden": 84.701, "precisionClarity": 84.8, "calibrationCharity": 70.496 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.65, "evidenceWarrant": 73.035, "responsiveness": 80.12, "relevanceBurden": 84.66, "precisionClarity": 84.1, "calibrationCharity": 74.23 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.9669999999999987, "evidenceWarrant": 4.105000000000004, "responsiveness": -6.438999999999993, "relevanceBurden": -0.04099999999999682, "precisionClarity": -0.7000000000000028, "calibrationCharity": 3.734000000000009 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.4917499999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8210000000000008, "responsiveness": -1.2877999999999987, "relevanceBurden": -0.006149999999999522, "precisionClarity": -0.07000000000000028, "calibrationCharity": 0.3734000000000009 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3222000000000029 }, { "number": 11, "id": "dsouza-ehrman-god-suffering-evil-2025", "title": "Dinesh D'Souza vs Bart Ehrman: God, Suffering, and Evil", "motion": "Can belief in a loving, powerful God survive the scale of suffering and evil in the world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XtWjEjdYvLA", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 87, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Dinesh D'Souza", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.22, "evidenceWarrant": 70.636, "responsiveness": 82.086, "relevanceBurden": 85.494, "precisionClarity": 79.62, "calibrationCharity": 75.428 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.14000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 80.45, "responsiveness": 90.3, "relevanceBurden": 87.06, "precisionClarity": 86.60000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 86.98 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.920000000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 9.814000000000007, "responsiveness": 8.213999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 1.5660000000000025, "precisionClarity": 6.980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 11.552000000000007 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.230000000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9628000000000014, "responsiveness": 1.6427999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.23490000000000036, "precisionClarity": 0.6980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 1.1552000000000007 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.0762999999999936 }, { "number": 12, "id": "settecase-jump-evidence-for-god-2025", "title": "Joel Settecase vs Tom Jump: Is There Evidence for God?", "motion": "Does evidence for God exist, or are logic, mathematics, and intelligibility better explained without Christian theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XLcRd3RjdjA", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 78, "con_gap": -6, "speakers": { "pro": "Joel Settecase", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.3, "evidenceWarrant": 73.19, "responsiveness": 98.00000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.05000000000001, "precisionClarity": 89.9, "calibrationCharity": 77.96 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 73.876, "evidenceWarrant": 68.552, "responsiveness": 88.91999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.76199999999999, "precisionClarity": 80.67999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 72.136 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -6.423999999999992, "evidenceWarrant": -4.637999999999991, "responsiveness": -9.080000000000027, "relevanceBurden": 0.7119999999999749, "precisionClarity": -9.220000000000013, "calibrationCharity": -5.823999999999998 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.605999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": -0.9275999999999982, "responsiveness": -1.8160000000000054, "relevanceBurden": 0.10679999999999623, "precisionClarity": -0.9220000000000014, "calibrationCharity": -0.5823999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2527999999999935 }, { "number": 13, "id": "knechtle-oconnor-christian-morality-2025", "title": "Cliffe Knechtle vs Alex O'Connor: Christianity, Scripture, and Morality", "motion": "Can Christianity's claims about forgiveness, morality, divine judgment, conquest, and slavery withstand skeptical objections?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8RZarGC8B4", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 87, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe Knechtle", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.695, "evidenceWarrant": 62.58, "responsiveness": 85.265, "relevanceBurden": 83.75999999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.30000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 64.04 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.97399999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 83.65200000000002, "responsiveness": 85.28, "relevanceBurden": 84.408, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 91.024 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.278999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 21.072000000000017, "responsiveness": 0.015000000000000568, "relevanceBurden": 0.6480000000000103, "precisionClarity": 9.699999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 26.983999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.819749999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 4.214400000000004, "responsiveness": 0.0030000000000001137, "relevanceBurden": 0.09720000000000155, "precisionClarity": 0.9699999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 2.6983999999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.8027500000000032 }, { "number": 14, "id": "jones-carrier-god-existence-2025", "title": "Michael Jones vs Richard Carrier: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does the evidence from consciousness, emergence, morality, and cosmology make theism more plausible than naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ht_SVm0GWBs", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 73, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 70.66900000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 60.699000000000005, "responsiveness": 85.883, "relevanceBurden": 87.18, "precisionClarity": 76.11500000000001, "calibrationCharity": 65.149 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 68.08699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 61.274, "responsiveness": 86.19, "relevanceBurden": 87.513, "precisionClarity": 73.975, "calibrationCharity": 65.298 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.582000000000022, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5749999999999957, "responsiveness": 0.30700000000000216, "relevanceBurden": 0.3329999999999984, "precisionClarity": -2.140000000000015, "calibrationCharity": 0.1490000000000009 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.6455000000000055, "evidenceWarrant": 0.11499999999999916, "responsiveness": 0.06140000000000043, "relevanceBurden": 0.04994999999999976, "precisionClarity": -0.2140000000000015, "calibrationCharity": 0.014900000000000092 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3817499999999925 }, { "number": 15, "id": "hitchens-lennox-is-god-great-2017", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs John Lennox: Is God Great?", "motion": "Is God great, and does Christian theism better explain science, morality, dignity, and hope than Hitchens's anti-theistic critique?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5OXPlUCGScY", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 81, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.88, "evidenceWarrant": 65.445, "responsiveness": 82.08000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.84, "precisionClarity": 85.99999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 68.08999999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.971, "evidenceWarrant": 72.264, "responsiveness": 88.50800000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.22, "precisionClarity": 85.25, "calibrationCharity": 76.938 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.091000000000008, "evidenceWarrant": 6.819000000000003, "responsiveness": 6.427999999999997, "relevanceBurden": -4.6200000000000045, "precisionClarity": -0.7499999999999858, "calibrationCharity": 8.848000000000013 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.272750000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3638000000000006, "responsiveness": 1.2855999999999996, "relevanceBurden": -0.6930000000000006, "precisionClarity": -0.07499999999999858, "calibrationCharity": 0.8848000000000014 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.03895000000000426 }, { "number": 16, "id": "hirsi-ali-dawkins-god-debate-2024", "title": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali vs Richard Dawkins: The God Debate", "motion": "Can Hirsi Ali's Christian turn be justified by personal experience, truth, and civilizational need, or should Dawkins's atheist truth test reject it?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DBsHdHMvucs", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 84, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.03999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 58.875, "responsiveness": 78.285, "relevanceBurden": 84.81, "precisionClarity": 79.9, "calibrationCharity": 70.635 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.014, "evidenceWarrant": 74.698, "responsiveness": 87.78399999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.97000000000001, "precisionClarity": 88.18, "calibrationCharity": 80.914 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.974000000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 15.822999999999993, "responsiveness": 9.498999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 3.160000000000011, "precisionClarity": 8.280000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 10.278999999999996 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.743500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 3.1645999999999987, "responsiveness": 1.899799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.4740000000000016, "precisionClarity": 0.8280000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 1.0278999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.13780000000000037 }, { "number": 17, "id": "collins-oconnor-god-existence-2024", "title": "Francis Collins vs Alex O'Connor: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Do fine-tuning, morality, resurrection, revelation, and beauty make Christian theism more plausible than O'Connor's skeptical agnosticism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXBGvNc2mvU", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 88, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Francis Collins", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.31899999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 68.318, "responsiveness": 85.521, "relevanceBurden": 86.914, "precisionClarity": 79.62, "calibrationCharity": 74.46000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.38499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 78.225, "responsiveness": 96.92999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 88.82, "precisionClarity": 93.60000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 87.66499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.066000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 9.906999999999996, "responsiveness": 11.408999999999992, "relevanceBurden": 1.9059999999999917, "precisionClarity": 13.980000000000018, "calibrationCharity": 13.204999999999984 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.7665000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9813999999999994, "responsiveness": 2.2817999999999983, "relevanceBurden": 0.28589999999999877, "precisionClarity": 1.398000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 1.3204999999999985 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -1.034099999999997 }, { "number": 18, "id": "williams-goff-oldfield-oconnor-between-god-atheism-2024", "title": "Rowan Williams, Philip Goff, Elizabeth Oldfield, and Alex O'Connor: Between God and Atheism", "motion": "Do fine-tuning, suffering, religious experience, practice, and purpose make Christianity or a God-ish hypothesis more plausible than atheist skepticism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9WnOYHi5k4g", "date": "2026-05-28", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Rowan Williams, Philip Goff, and Elizabeth Oldfield", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 19, "id": "harris-oconnor-objective-morality-2024", "title": "Sam Harris vs Alex O'Connor: Objective Morality and Emotivism", "motion": "Can objective morality be grounded in facts about conscious well-being, or does ethical language reduce to emotive expression plus instrumental science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_pprQXq1eCA", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 88, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Sam Harris", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 11, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.48, "evidenceWarrant": 70.02, "responsiveness": 71.12, "relevanceBurden": 83.21000000000001, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 79.68 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.39, "evidenceWarrant": 77.42, "responsiveness": 96.9, "relevanceBurden": 81.69, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 91.39999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 20, "id": "hitchens-hitchens-iraq-god-2008", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Peter Hitchens: Iraq, God, and Moral Authority", "motion": "Was the invasion of Iraq defensible, and does religion supply or corrupt moral authority?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngjQs_QjSwc", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 77, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Hitchens", "con": "Peter Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.575, "evidenceWarrant": 71.83, "responsiveness": 84.56, "relevanceBurden": 82.3, "precisionClarity": 80.6, "calibrationCharity": 75.11 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.56, "evidenceWarrant": 67.76, "responsiveness": 84.53999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.12, "precisionClarity": 77.55000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 72.50999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.015000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 4.069999999999993, "responsiveness": 0.020000000000010232, "relevanceBurden": -1.8200000000000074, "precisionClarity": 3.049999999999983, "calibrationCharity": 2.6000000000000085 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0037500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8139999999999987, "responsiveness": 0.004000000000002046, "relevanceBurden": -0.2730000000000011, "precisionClarity": 0.30499999999999833, "calibrationCharity": 0.26000000000000084 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.11374999999999913 }, { "number": 21, "id": "hitchens-wolpe-great-god-debate-2010", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Rabbi David Wolpe: The Great God Debate", "motion": "Does religious faith reveal God, moral meaning, and human freedom, or does it replace reason with projection, authority, and harmful consolation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2kZRAOXEFPI", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 76, "con_gap": -9, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Hitchens", "con": "Rabbi David Wolpe" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.328, "evidenceWarrant": 75.052, "responsiveness": 91.226, "relevanceBurden": 85.27199999999999, "precisionClarity": 87.88, "calibrationCharity": 84.3 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.04, "evidenceWarrant": 62.35, "responsiveness": 82.56, "relevanceBurden": 81.76, "precisionClarity": 81.9, "calibrationCharity": 74.69 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.287999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 12.702000000000005, "responsiveness": 8.665999999999997, "relevanceBurden": 3.5119999999999862, "precisionClarity": 5.97999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 9.61 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.321999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 2.5404000000000013, "responsiveness": 1.7331999999999994, "relevanceBurden": 0.5267999999999979, "precisionClarity": 0.597999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 0.961 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.31860000000000355 }, { "number": 22, "id": "turek-hitchens-god-existence-2008", "title": "Frank Turek vs Christopher Hitchens: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do cosmology, design, morality, consciousness, and Christian claims outweigh the anti-theist critique of religion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S7WBEJJlYWU", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 81, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.92, "evidenceWarrant": 59.8, "responsiveness": 84.25999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 82.42999999999999, "precisionClarity": 81.35, "calibrationCharity": 63.870000000000005 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.226, "evidenceWarrant": 73.35, "responsiveness": 83.74600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.944, "precisionClarity": 84.25, "calibrationCharity": 74.298 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.305999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 13.549999999999997, "responsiveness": -0.5139999999999816, "relevanceBurden": 4.51400000000001, "precisionClarity": 2.9000000000000057, "calibrationCharity": 10.427999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.8264999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 2.7099999999999995, "responsiveness": -0.10279999999999632, "relevanceBurden": 0.6771000000000015, "precisionClarity": 0.2900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 1.0427999999999997 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.44360000000000444 }, { "number": 23, "id": "oconnor-biddle-objective-morality-2024", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Craig Biddle: Is Morality Objective?", "motion": "Is morality objectively grounded in the factual requirements of human life, or are moral claims expressions of emotion without truth value?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4JGJRmldQE", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 89, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Craig Biddle", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.825, "evidenceWarrant": 71.78099999999999, "responsiveness": 92.773, "relevanceBurden": 87.638, "precisionClarity": 88.11, "calibrationCharity": 75.525 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.42999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 82.63499999999999, "responsiveness": 96.21499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.64999999999999, "precisionClarity": 91.7, "calibrationCharity": 88.32499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 24, "id": "hitchens-olasky-religion-grace-2007", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Marvin Olasky: Religion, Grace, and Secular Morality", "motion": "Does religion poison everything, or does Christianity provide grace, charity, moral transformation, and historical credibility that defeat that charge?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lcHMSNiI97w", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Hitchens", "con": "Marvin Olasky" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.215, "evidenceWarrant": 70.23, "responsiveness": 90.31500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.76499999999999, "precisionClarity": 82.45, "calibrationCharity": 74.845 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.24699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.10799999999999, "responsiveness": 89.16199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.679, "precisionClarity": 89.86000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 79.976 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.0319999999999823, "evidenceWarrant": 0.1220000000000141, "responsiveness": 1.15300000000002, "relevanceBurden": -2.9140000000000157, "precisionClarity": -7.410000000000011, "calibrationCharity": -5.131 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.5079999999999956, "evidenceWarrant": 0.024400000000002822, "responsiveness": 0.23060000000000402, "relevanceBurden": -0.4371000000000023, "precisionClarity": -0.7410000000000011, "calibrationCharity": -0.5131 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.05580000000000784 }, { "number": 25, "id": "hitchens-ramadan-islam-peace-2010", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Tariq Ramadan: Is Islam a Religion of Peace?", "motion": "Is Islam a religion of peace, or do its claims, institutions, and enforcement patterns make that description untenable?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMraxhd9Z9Q", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Hitchens", "con": "Tariq Ramadan" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.245, "evidenceWarrant": 72.625, "responsiveness": 84.89, "relevanceBurden": 86.6, "precisionClarity": 79.7, "calibrationCharity": 75.585 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.55, "evidenceWarrant": 74.02499999999999, "responsiveness": 76.7, "relevanceBurden": 88.6, "precisionClarity": 89.0, "calibrationCharity": 82.625 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -5.304999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": -1.3999999999999915, "responsiveness": 8.189999999999998, "relevanceBurden": -2.0, "precisionClarity": -9.299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": -7.040000000000006 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.3262499999999982, "evidenceWarrant": -0.2799999999999983, "responsiveness": 1.6379999999999997, "relevanceBurden": -0.3, "precisionClarity": -0.9299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": -0.7040000000000006 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.09775000000000289 }, { "number": 26, "id": "turek-hitchens-reality-theism-atheism-2011", "title": "Frank Turek vs Christopher Hitchens: What Best Explains Reality?", "motion": "What best explains reality: theism, with a personal creator and revelation, or atheism, with no supernatural dimension?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uDCDTaKfzXU", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 83, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.22, "evidenceWarrant": 61.790000000000006, "responsiveness": 81.565, "relevanceBurden": 86.75999999999999, "precisionClarity": 82.7, "calibrationCharity": 62.985 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.505, "evidenceWarrant": 71.165, "responsiveness": 92.955, "relevanceBurden": 85.42999999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.0, "calibrationCharity": 78.565 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.284999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 9.375, "responsiveness": 11.39, "relevanceBurden": -1.3299999999999983, "precisionClarity": 7.299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 15.579999999999998 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.821249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 1.875, "responsiveness": 2.278, "relevanceBurden": -0.19949999999999973, "precisionClarity": 0.7299999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 1.5579999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06274999999999942 }, { "number": 27, "id": "oconnor-turek-evil-moral-argument-2017", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Frank Turek: The Moral Argument Debate", "motion": "Does evil and objective morality point to God, or can agnostic atheism explain moral experience without accepting a divine moral ground?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b5a3MxIqZOs", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 87, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.112, "evidenceWarrant": 61.252, "responsiveness": 94.172, "relevanceBurden": 83.708, "precisionClarity": 75.64, "calibrationCharity": 70.7 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.52, "evidenceWarrant": 78.96000000000001, "responsiveness": 92.896, "relevanceBurden": 86.06, "precisionClarity": 89.10000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 89.17999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.408000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 17.708000000000006, "responsiveness": -1.2759999999999962, "relevanceBurden": 2.352000000000004, "precisionClarity": 13.460000000000008, "calibrationCharity": 18.47999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.8520000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 3.541600000000001, "responsiveness": -0.25519999999999926, "relevanceBurden": 0.35280000000000056, "precisionClarity": 1.346000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.847999999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3147999999999964 }, { "number": 28, "id": "turek-shermer-reality-theism-atheism-2018", "title": "Frank Turek vs Michael Shermer: What Best Explains Reality?", "motion": "What best explains reality: theism grounded in God as the cause of creation, reason, information, morality, evil, and science, or skeptical naturalism grounded in evidence and scientific inquiry?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aZn7XUFSmA", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 83, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Michael Shermer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.04799999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 60.29600000000001, "responsiveness": 79.56299999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.38799999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.55, "calibrationCharity": 61.763999999999996 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.653, "evidenceWarrant": 76.41, "responsiveness": 88.86, "relevanceBurden": 85.351, "precisionClarity": 85.57000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 80.505 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 13.605000000000018, "evidenceWarrant": 16.11399999999999, "responsiveness": 9.297000000000011, "relevanceBurden": -0.03699999999999193, "precisionClarity": 6.02000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 18.741 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.4012500000000045, "evidenceWarrant": 3.222799999999998, "responsiveness": 1.8594000000000024, "relevanceBurden": -0.005549999999998789, "precisionClarity": 0.6020000000000011, "calibrationCharity": 1.8741 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.04599999999999227 }, { "number": 29, "id": "turek-silverman-reality-theism-atheism-2013", "title": "Frank Turek vs David Silverman: Which Better Explains Reality?", "motion": "Which better explains reality: theism, with God as the ground of creation, reason, information, morality, evil, and science, or atheism, with natural inquiry and human responsibility?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzP07nEwNP8", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 78, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "David Silverman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.45, "evidenceWarrant": 64.044, "responsiveness": 86.222, "relevanceBurden": 87.08399999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.2, "calibrationCharity": 72.02799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.82399999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 66.96, "responsiveness": 82.11600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 86.52, "calibrationCharity": 73.236 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.373999999999981, "evidenceWarrant": 2.915999999999997, "responsiveness": -4.10599999999998, "relevanceBurden": -0.08399999999998897, "precisionClarity": 7.319999999999993, "calibrationCharity": 1.2080000000000126 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.8434999999999953, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5831999999999994, "responsiveness": -0.8211999999999962, "relevanceBurden": -0.012599999999998345, "precisionClarity": 0.7319999999999993, "calibrationCharity": 0.12080000000000127 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.44570000000000065 }, { "number": 30, "id": "lowder-turek-naturalism-theism-2016", "title": "Jeffery Jay Lowder vs Frank Turek: Naturalism or Theism?", "motion": "What better explains reality: naturalism, where the physical explains the mental, or theism, where God grounds creation, reason, information, morality, evil, and science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ENZYEPpR2Jc", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 70, "con_gap": -15, "speakers": { "pro": "Jeffery Jay Lowder", "con": "Frank Turek" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.94900000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 77.931, "responsiveness": 91.64699999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.557, "precisionClarity": 89.08, "calibrationCharity": 84.82000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 66.88199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 57.306, "responsiveness": 75.897, "relevanceBurden": 83.34299999999999, "precisionClarity": 77.25, "calibrationCharity": 62.821 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 17.06700000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 20.625, "responsiveness": 15.749999999999986, "relevanceBurden": 3.214000000000013, "precisionClarity": 11.829999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 21.99900000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.266750000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 4.125, "responsiveness": 3.1499999999999972, "relevanceBurden": 0.4821000000000019, "precisionClarity": 1.1829999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 2.199900000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.40675000000000594 }, { "number": 31, "id": "oconnor-craig-resurrection-2023", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs William Lane Craig: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence make Jesus' resurrection the best explanation of the facts, or should skeptical alternatives and evidential caution prevent that conclusion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WsUwyC2cwNg", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 88, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 14, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 87.72500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.125, "responsiveness": 88.875, "relevanceBurden": 86.17500000000001, "precisionClarity": 86.75, "calibrationCharity": 84.175 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.64999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 79.45, "responsiveness": 98.44999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.3, "precisionClarity": 89.5, "calibrationCharity": 90.55 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.924999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3250000000000028, "responsiveness": 9.574999999999989, "relevanceBurden": -1.8750000000000142, "precisionClarity": 2.75, "calibrationCharity": 6.375 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.23124999999999574, "evidenceWarrant": 0.26500000000000057, "responsiveness": 1.9149999999999978, "relevanceBurden": -0.2812500000000021, "precisionClarity": 0.275, "calibrationCharity": 0.6375000000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -1.042499999999992 }, { "number": 32, "id": "knechtle-oconnor-halper-biblical-god-2024", "title": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle vs Alex O'Connor and Phil Halper: Does the Biblical God Exist?", "motion": "Does the biblical God exist, given moral experience, Jesus, scripture, animal suffering, biblical violence, religious geography, and resurrection evidence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypRtARVG1BA", "date": "2026-05-30", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 76, "con": 86, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Alex O'Connor and Phil Halper" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 33, "id": "craig-carroll-god-cosmology-2014", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Sean Carroll: God and Cosmology", "motion": "Does contemporary cosmology make God's existence more probable, or do naturalistic cosmological models better explain the universe without theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X0qKZqPy9T8", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 90, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Sean Carroll" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.76199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.762, "responsiveness": 91.128, "relevanceBurden": 82.464, "precisionClarity": 86.16, "calibrationCharity": 76.68199999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.184, "evidenceWarrant": 83.19399999999999, "responsiveness": 98.24200000000002, "relevanceBurden": 86.744, "precisionClarity": 95.00000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 86.626 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.422000000000011, "evidenceWarrant": 6.431999999999988, "responsiveness": 7.1140000000000185, "relevanceBurden": 4.280000000000001, "precisionClarity": 8.840000000000018, "calibrationCharity": 9.944000000000017 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8555000000000028, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2863999999999978, "responsiveness": 1.4228000000000038, "relevanceBurden": 0.6420000000000001, "precisionClarity": 0.8840000000000018, "calibrationCharity": 0.9944000000000017 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.08510000000000773 }, { "number": 34, "id": "goff-carroll-consciousness-fundamental-2023", "title": "Philip Goff vs Sean Carroll: Is Consciousness Fundamental?", "motion": "Is consciousness a fundamental feature of reality, or can physicalism explain conscious experience through higher-level descriptions of the physical world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rCPCyri1rXU", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 84, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Philip Goff", "con": "Sean Carroll" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.13, "evidenceWarrant": 75.69, "responsiveness": 89.31500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 88.45, "precisionClarity": 91.25, "calibrationCharity": 83.78999999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.525, "evidenceWarrant": 77.126, "responsiveness": 88.726, "relevanceBurden": 82.89599999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.81, "calibrationCharity": 82.934 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 35, "id": "carroll-shermer-hutchinson-dsouza-science-religion-2012", "title": "Sean Carroll and Michael Shermer vs Ian Hutchinson and Dinesh D'Souza: Has Science Refuted Religion?", "motion": "Has science refuted religion, or does that claim overreach by confusing scientific method with scientism and by ignoring non-scientific forms of evidence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ulykALV2FQ8", "date": "2026-05-30", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 81, "con": 84, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Sean Carroll and Michael Shermer", "con": "Ian Hutchinson and Dinesh D'Souza" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 36, "id": "carroll-halvorson-metaphysics-worldview-2016", "title": "Sean Carroll vs Hans Halvorson: Metaphysics", "motion": "How should scientific knowledge be integrated into naturalist and theistic worldviews, and do cosmology, fine-tuning, quantum mechanics, consciousness, morality, and meaning favor either metaphysical picture?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ku6tLuEjmTY", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 87, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Sean Carroll", "con": "Hans Halvorson" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.45400000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 76.02199999999999, "responsiveness": 85.68, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 90.20000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 82.81 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.11000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 77.90599999999999, "responsiveness": 94.92, "relevanceBurden": 85.56, "precisionClarity": 89.19999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 90.108 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -3.656000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": -1.8840000000000003, "responsiveness": -9.239999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 1.4399999999999977, "precisionClarity": 1.0000000000000284, "calibrationCharity": -7.298000000000002 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.9140000000000015, "evidenceWarrant": -0.3768000000000001, "responsiveness": -1.847999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.21599999999999966, "precisionClarity": 0.10000000000000285, "calibrationCharity": -0.7298000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5525999999999982 }, { "number": 37, "id": "ehrman-bass-resurrection-history-2023", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs Justin Bass: Did Jesus of Nazareth Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus of Nazareth historically rise from the dead, and do the early resurrection appearances, the unexpected messianic claim, Christianity's spread, and later visions make that explanation plausible?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LVUQAVQS1-U", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 88, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Justin Bass", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.114, "evidenceWarrant": 68.19, "responsiveness": 83.642, "relevanceBurden": 84.46, "precisionClarity": 78.68, "calibrationCharity": 76.668 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.74000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 80.9, "responsiveness": 95.46000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 89.86, "precisionClarity": 87.6, "calibrationCharity": 86.83999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.626000000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 12.710000000000008, "responsiveness": 11.818000000000012, "relevanceBurden": 5.400000000000006, "precisionClarity": 8.919999999999987, "calibrationCharity": 10.171999999999983 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.906500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 2.5420000000000016, "responsiveness": 2.3636000000000026, "relevanceBurden": 0.8100000000000008, "precisionClarity": 0.8919999999999988, "calibrationCharity": 1.0171999999999983 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5313000000000034 }, { "number": 38, "id": "mcdowell-ehrman-moral-objectivity-2026", "title": "Sean McDowell vs Bart Ehrman: The Moral Argument, Guilt, and the Teachings of Jesus", "motion": "Do Jesus' teachings and the West's moral transformation point to objective moral truths grounded beyond human preference, or can morality be explained as historically shaped human inclination without divine grounding?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cz57BuQOCmQ", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 82, "con_gap": -4, "speakers": { "pro": "Sean McDowell", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 86.901, "evidenceWarrant": 78.108, "responsiveness": 91.23, "relevanceBurden": 88.24, "precisionClarity": 88.49, "calibrationCharity": 87.28500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.31, "evidenceWarrant": 74.751, "responsiveness": 84.314, "relevanceBurden": 87.16, "precisionClarity": 87.94, "calibrationCharity": 76.092 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 39, "id": "lambert-jones-christian-faith-skepticism-2021", "title": "Derek Lambert vs Michael Jones: Atheist and Christian Discussion", "motion": "Can Christian belief be rationally sustained amid skeptical challenges about faith, hell, resurrection evidence, biblical reliability, religious experience, the Exodus, and parallels with other ancient traditions?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SEZu7Ej2SzU", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 81, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Derek Lambert" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.74, "evidenceWarrant": 68.85000000000001, "responsiveness": 73.47, "relevanceBurden": 82.19, "precisionClarity": 89.60000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 81.98 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.884, "evidenceWarrant": 73.124, "responsiveness": 80.928, "relevanceBurden": 82.256, "precisionClarity": 92.2, "calibrationCharity": 85.434 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1440000000000055, "evidenceWarrant": 4.273999999999987, "responsiveness": 7.457999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.0660000000000025, "precisionClarity": 2.5999999999999943, "calibrationCharity": 3.4539999999999935 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.28600000000000136, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8547999999999973, "responsiveness": 1.4915999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.009900000000000376, "precisionClarity": 0.25999999999999945, "calibrationCharity": 0.3453999999999994 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -1.2476999999999978 }, { "number": 40, "id": "enoch-bush-objective-moral-truths-2026", "title": "David Enoch vs Lance Bush: Are There Objective Moral Truths?", "motion": "Are there objective moral truths, and does moral realism or global normative anti-realism better explain ordinary moral judgment, deliberation, language, and disagreement?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWZuHxO4WcA", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 84, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "David Enoch", "con": "Lance Bush" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.015, "evidenceWarrant": 77.30499999999999, "responsiveness": 92.85499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.32500000000002, "precisionClarity": 91.95, "calibrationCharity": 82.63000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.49, "evidenceWarrant": 72.565, "responsiveness": 94.47, "relevanceBurden": 80.834, "precisionClarity": 91.95, "calibrationCharity": 84.30499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 41, "id": "huemer-bush-objective-moral-facts-2024", "title": "Michael Huemer vs Lance Bush: Do Objective Moral Facts Exist?", "motion": "Do objective moral facts exist, and can ethical intuitionism establish moral realism against anti-realist quietism, folk metaethical indeterminacy, and language-use objections?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cc16nceSWiU", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 83, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Huemer", "con": "Lance Bush" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.465, "evidenceWarrant": 77.1, "responsiveness": 89.615, "relevanceBurden": 86.45, "precisionClarity": 87.35, "calibrationCharity": 84.46499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.917, "evidenceWarrant": 72.19800000000001, "responsiveness": 94.292, "relevanceBurden": 81.872, "precisionClarity": 85.10000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 88.041 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 42, "id": "schmid-tomaszewski-divine-simplicity-2020", "title": "Joe Schmid vs Chris Tomaszewski: Is Divine Simplicity True?", "motion": "Is divine simplicity, understood as God's absence of real intrinsic parts or composition, coherent with classical theism, Trinitarian doctrine, divine freedom, and omniscient knowledge of contingent reality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rX6di0Au5Kg", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 87, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "con": "Joseph Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 15, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.725, "evidenceWarrant": 76.975, "responsiveness": 97.095, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 91.5, "calibrationCharity": 83.595 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.155, "evidenceWarrant": 81.435, "responsiveness": 93.68, "relevanceBurden": 85.48, "precisionClarity": 88.5, "calibrationCharity": 86.275 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.430000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 4.460000000000008, "responsiveness": -3.414999999999992, "relevanceBurden": -1.519999999999996, "precisionClarity": -3.0, "calibrationCharity": 2.680000000000007 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1075000000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8920000000000017, "responsiveness": -0.6829999999999985, "relevanceBurden": -0.2279999999999994, "precisionClarity": -0.30000000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 0.2680000000000007 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.05650000000000621 }, { "number": 43, "id": "meyer-halper-cosmology-fine-tuning-2026", "title": "Stephen Meyer vs Phil Halper: The Big Bang and Fine-Tuning", "motion": "Does modern cosmology, especially Big Bang evidence and cosmic fine-tuning, make theism or intelligent design a better explanation than naturalistic early-universe models?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsrfL58iLlE", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 90, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Meyer", "con": "Phil Halper" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.625, "evidenceWarrant": 69.97500000000001, "responsiveness": 88.6, "relevanceBurden": 86.725, "precisionClarity": 79.5, "calibrationCharity": 69.6 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 89.6, "evidenceWarrant": 82.025, "responsiveness": 96.14, "relevanceBurden": 87.62, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 85.775 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.974999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 12.049999999999997, "responsiveness": 7.540000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 0.8950000000000102, "precisionClarity": 15.5, "calibrationCharity": 16.17500000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.2437499999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 2.4099999999999997, "responsiveness": 1.5080000000000013, "relevanceBurden": 0.13425000000000153, "precisionClarity": 1.55, "calibrationCharity": 1.6175000000000013 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5364999999999966 }, { "number": 44, "id": "oconnor-biddle-free-will-2025", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Craig Biddle: Free Will - Do You Have It?", "motion": "Do human beings have free will, either as ultimate control over action or as a volitional capacity to focus and use reason?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G17N2CgrXXU", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 82, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Craig Biddle", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.175, "evidenceWarrant": 66.5, "responsiveness": 80.325, "relevanceBurden": 87.65, "precisionClarity": 85.5, "calibrationCharity": 72.47500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.13499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 74.785, "responsiveness": 88.46, "relevanceBurden": 83.23999999999998, "precisionClarity": 81.8, "calibrationCharity": 82.255 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 45, "id": "singer-frazier-swinburne-oconnor-morality-2025", "title": "Peter Singer, Jessica Frazier, Richard Swinburne, and Alex O'Connor: The Mystery of Morality", "motion": "Are moral truths real features of reason, consciousness, religion, or emergent human life, or are moral claims best understood as expressions of feeling?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rI1OevN2FDI", "date": "2026-06-01", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 82, "con": 80, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Peter Singer, Jessica Frazier, Richard Swinburne", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 14, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 46, "id": "shapiro-oconnor-atheist-delusion-society-2023", "title": "Ben Shapiro vs Alex O'Connor: The Atheist Delusion, Free Will, and Society", "motion": "Does atheism depend on borrowed religious or extra-natural assumptions about free will, morality, reason, and social order, or can secular life face the truth without religious scaffolding?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yspPYcJHI3k", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 87, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "Ben Shapiro", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 16, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.39000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 58.08500000000001, "responsiveness": 76.24, "relevanceBurden": 83.39999999999999, "precisionClarity": 71.4, "calibrationCharity": 66.715 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.03999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 80.34500000000001, "responsiveness": 91.565, "relevanceBurden": 84.6, "precisionClarity": 92.0, "calibrationCharity": 89.39999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.649999999999977, "evidenceWarrant": 22.260000000000005, "responsiveness": 15.325000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 1.2000000000000028, "precisionClarity": 20.599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 22.684999999999988 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.9124999999999943, "evidenceWarrant": 4.452000000000001, "responsiveness": 3.065000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.1800000000000004, "precisionClarity": 2.0599999999999996, "calibrationCharity": 2.268499999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.06200000000000472 }, { "number": 47, "id": "jones-krauss-christianity-secular-ethics-2025", "title": "Michael Jones vs Lawrence Krauss: Christianity or Secular Ethics - What's Best for Society?", "motion": "Which is better for society: Christianity, understood as a Christian-value society with a largely Christian population, or secular ethics?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yef-BFukQWg", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 76, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Lawrence Krauss" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.84, "evidenceWarrant": 72.46, "responsiveness": 88.88000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.94, "precisionClarity": 78.3, "calibrationCharity": 70.4 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.31400000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 66.548, "responsiveness": 82.66600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.32, "precisionClarity": 79.6, "calibrationCharity": 69.40599999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.5259999999999962, "evidenceWarrant": -5.911999999999992, "responsiveness": -6.213999999999999, "relevanceBurden": -0.6200000000000045, "precisionClarity": 1.2999999999999972, "calibrationCharity": -0.994000000000014 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.38149999999999906, "evidenceWarrant": -1.1823999999999983, "responsiveness": -1.2428, "relevanceBurden": -0.09300000000000068, "precisionClarity": 0.12999999999999973, "calibrationCharity": -0.0994000000000014 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.13090000000000046 }, { "number": 48, "id": "scrivener-folley-hiddenness-evil-moral-narrative-2025", "title": "Glen Scrivener vs Joe Folley: Morality, Evil, Consciousness, and Christian Narrative", "motion": "Does Christian theism better account for hiddenness, evil, consciousness, morality, and moral progress than agnostic or naturalistic alternatives?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BzHMdTeQww", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 84, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Glen Scrivener", "con": "Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 15, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.29, "evidenceWarrant": 65.816, "responsiveness": 70.37899999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.079, "precisionClarity": 78.95, "calibrationCharity": 76.09199999999998 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.86, "evidenceWarrant": 77.82499999999999, "responsiveness": 76.905, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 90.285 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 13.569999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 12.008999999999986, "responsiveness": 6.5260000000000105, "relevanceBurden": 1.9210000000000065, "precisionClarity": 16.049999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 14.193000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.3924999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": 2.4017999999999975, "responsiveness": 1.3052000000000021, "relevanceBurden": 0.28815000000000096, "precisionClarity": 1.6049999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 1.4193000000000013 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.41194999999999915 }, { "number": 49, "id": "dyer-dillahunty-transcendental-theism-2019", "title": "Jay Dyer vs Matt Dillahunty: Transcendental Argument for Theism", "motion": "Does the transcendental argument show that Orthodox Christian theism is needed to ground logic, truth, induction, ethics, and knowledge?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AajJBhdRpDA", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 89, "con_gap": 13, "speakers": { "pro": "Jay Dyer", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 13, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.901, "evidenceWarrant": 64.031, "responsiveness": 81.26, "relevanceBurden": 83.91600000000001, "precisionClarity": 87.9, "calibrationCharity": 69.667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.2, "evidenceWarrant": 80.565, "responsiveness": 97.61666666666667, "relevanceBurden": 87.15833333333333, "precisionClarity": 94.46666666666667, "calibrationCharity": 88.51333333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 14.299000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 16.533999999999992, "responsiveness": 16.35666666666667, "relevanceBurden": 3.2423333333333204, "precisionClarity": 6.566666666666663, "calibrationCharity": 18.846333333333334 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.5747500000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 3.3067999999999986, "responsiveness": 3.271333333333334, "relevanceBurden": 0.48634999999999806, "precisionClarity": 0.6566666666666663, "calibrationCharity": 1.8846333333333334 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.180533333333333 }, { "number": 50, "id": "knechtle-dillahunty-christianity-true-2023", "title": "Cliffe Knechtle vs Matt Dillahunty: Is Christianity True?", "motion": "Is Christianity true, and do the Gospels, resurrection claims, moral meaning, and human value give sufficient warrant for Christian faith?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAg3H1LU1Yw", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 90, "con_gap": 17, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe Knechtle", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 17, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.28, "evidenceWarrant": 63.305, "responsiveness": 73.21, "relevanceBurden": 83.64500000000001, "precisionClarity": 79.35, "calibrationCharity": 67.42 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 90.02, "evidenceWarrant": 80.08500000000001, "responsiveness": 96.07499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.56, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 90.505 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 16.739999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 16.78000000000001, "responsiveness": 22.864999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 1.914999999999992, "precisionClarity": 15.650000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 23.084999999999994 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.184999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 3.3560000000000016, "responsiveness": 4.5729999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 0.2872499999999988, "precisionClarity": 1.5650000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 2.3084999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.7252500000000026 }, { "number": 51, "id": "lennox-atkins-duelling-professors-2012", "title": "John Lennox vs Peter Atkins: Duelling Professors on Science and God", "motion": "Do science, design, DNA, natural law, morality, and human experience point toward Christian theism or toward an atheistic naturalist account?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gMS7WTHnho", "date": "2026-08-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 72, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Peter Atkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.815, "evidenceWarrant": 67.03999999999999, "responsiveness": 89.48, "relevanceBurden": 84.24, "precisionClarity": 85.65, "calibrationCharity": 72.27499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 68.24600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 60.329, "responsiveness": 74.719, "relevanceBurden": 87.052, "precisionClarity": 75.815, "calibrationCharity": 69.466 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -9.568999999999988, "evidenceWarrant": -6.710999999999991, "responsiveness": -14.76100000000001, "relevanceBurden": 2.812000000000012, "precisionClarity": -9.835000000000008, "calibrationCharity": -2.8089999999999975 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -2.392249999999997, "evidenceWarrant": -1.3421999999999983, "responsiveness": -2.952200000000002, "relevanceBurden": 0.4218000000000018, "precisionClarity": -0.9835000000000008, "calibrationCharity": -0.28089999999999976 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5292499999999967 }, { "number": 52, "id": "horn-dillahunty-resurrection-reasonable-2021", "title": "Trent Horn vs Matt Dillahunty: Is Belief in the Resurrection Reasonable?", "motion": "Is it reasonable to believe Jesus of Nazareth rose from the dead, given historical testimony, expected evidence, background knowledge, and standards for unusual claims?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7V6UNSvHVDM", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 83, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.66000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 72.4, "responsiveness": 89.98, "relevanceBurden": 85.93999999999998, "precisionClarity": 81.99999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 74.96 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.93199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 74.872, "responsiveness": 90.16, "relevanceBurden": 85.88, "precisionClarity": 85.32, "calibrationCharity": 78.94 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2719999999999771, "evidenceWarrant": 2.471999999999994, "responsiveness": 0.1799999999999926, "relevanceBurden": -0.05999999999998806, "precisionClarity": 3.3200000000000074, "calibrationCharity": 3.980000000000004 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.3179999999999943, "evidenceWarrant": 0.49439999999999884, "responsiveness": 0.035999999999998526, "relevanceBurden": -0.008999999999998209, "precisionClarity": 0.33200000000000074, "calibrationCharity": 0.3980000000000004 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5693999999999946 }, { "number": 53, "id": "oconnor-dsouza-bible-true-2024", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Dinesh D'Souza: Is the Bible True?", "motion": "Is the Bible true in historical, moral, allegorical, theological, and revelatory senses, or do contradictions and morally troubling texts undermine its truth claims?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMKkX8qRHsw", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 91, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Dinesh D'Souza", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.64, "evidenceWarrant": 70.27000000000001, "responsiveness": 76.505, "relevanceBurden": 85.245, "precisionClarity": 75.0, "calibrationCharity": 70.015 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 92.01499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 88.36, "responsiveness": 93.255, "relevanceBurden": 86.885, "precisionClarity": 92.95, "calibrationCharity": 92.24000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 17.374999999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 18.08999999999999, "responsiveness": 16.75, "relevanceBurden": 1.6400000000000006, "precisionClarity": 17.950000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 22.22500000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.3437499999999964, "evidenceWarrant": 3.617999999999998, "responsiveness": 3.35, "relevanceBurden": 0.24600000000000008, "precisionClarity": 1.7950000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 2.222500000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5752499999999969 }, { "number": 54, "id": "jones-law-christianity-humanism-future-2025", "title": "Michael Jones vs Stephen Law: Christianity vs Humanism", "motion": "Does Christianity or humanism offer a brighter future for humanity, especially for moral formation, social health, human rights, truth, and pluralistic freedom?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UOwOCGIPzQ", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 81, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Stephen Law" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.85499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 61.91, "responsiveness": 66.86, "relevanceBurden": 88.19, "precisionClarity": 74.375, "calibrationCharity": 67.635 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.16799999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 73.5, "responsiveness": 79.62500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.843, "precisionClarity": 84.17999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.53399999999998 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.313000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 11.590000000000003, "responsiveness": 12.765000000000015, "relevanceBurden": -1.3469999999999942, "precisionClarity": 9.804999999999993, "calibrationCharity": 12.898999999999972 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5782500000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 2.318000000000001, "responsiveness": 2.553000000000003, "relevanceBurden": -0.20204999999999912, "precisionClarity": 0.9804999999999993, "calibrationCharity": 1.2898999999999974 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5176000000000016 }, { "number": 55, "id": "craig-malpass-kalam-nothing-2026", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Alex Malpass: Can Something Come From Nothing?", "motion": "Does the Kalam cosmological argument show that the universe began to exist, has a cause, and points to a personal creator?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQBY5K-Ns2Y", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 91, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 16, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.564, "evidenceWarrant": 64.016, "responsiveness": 86.46199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.722, "precisionClarity": 83.11999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 69.944 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 91.123, "evidenceWarrant": 84.56800000000001, "responsiveness": 97.51700000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.416, "precisionClarity": 93.1, "calibrationCharity": 92.95700000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 21.55900000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 20.552000000000007, "responsiveness": 11.055000000000021, "relevanceBurden": 1.6940000000000026, "precisionClarity": 9.980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 23.013000000000005 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 5.389750000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 4.110400000000001, "responsiveness": 2.2110000000000043, "relevanceBurden": 0.2541000000000004, "precisionClarity": 0.9980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 2.301300000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.7354499999999895 }, { "number": 56, "id": "huemer-lutz-morality-real-2026", "title": "Mike Huemer vs Matt Lutz: Is Morality Real?", "motion": "Are there objective moral facts, and can moral knowledge be justified by appearances rather than only by best-explanation evidence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-w2auo-Y5Wg", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 88, "con": 81, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Huemer", "con": "Matt Lutz" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.765, "evidenceWarrant": 80.42999999999999, "responsiveness": 98.04, "relevanceBurden": 85.745, "precisionClarity": 91.7, "calibrationCharity": 88.375 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.275, "evidenceWarrant": 69.35000000000001, "responsiveness": 91.575, "relevanceBurden": 84.19999999999999, "precisionClarity": 87.0, "calibrationCharity": 76.425 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 57, "id": "scrivener-dillahunty-atheism-morality-2020", "title": "Glen Scrivener vs Matt Dillahunty: Can Atheism Deliver a Better World?", "motion": "Can atheism or secular humanism provide a better moral foundation for society than Christianity?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B3-sjyDYO2I", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 86, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Glen Scrivener", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.44, "evidenceWarrant": 66.58, "responsiveness": 70.595, "relevanceBurden": 86.46, "precisionClarity": 81.0, "calibrationCharity": 73.255 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.27499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.58, "responsiveness": 87.13, "relevanceBurden": 84.67, "precisionClarity": 92.5, "calibrationCharity": 85.685 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.834999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 9.0, "responsiveness": 16.534999999999997, "relevanceBurden": -1.789999999999992, "precisionClarity": 11.5, "calibrationCharity": 12.430000000000007 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7087499999999984, "evidenceWarrant": 1.8, "responsiveness": 3.3069999999999995, "relevanceBurden": -0.2684999999999988, "precisionClarity": 1.1500000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.2430000000000008 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.059749999999999304 }, { "number": 58, "id": "dillahunty-slick-secular-humanism-christianity-2016", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Matt Slick: Is Secular Humanism Superior to Christianity?", "motion": "Is secular humanism superior to Christianity at achieving human flourishing, rational decision-making, moral reasoning, and conflict resolution?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKlycI9ZKsY", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 74, "con_gap": -8, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Dillahunty", "con": "Matt Slick" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.46000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 72.26, "responsiveness": 83.28, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 89.9, "calibrationCharity": 80.07 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 70.72399999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 58.525999999999996, "responsiveness": 79.646, "relevanceBurden": 84.972, "precisionClarity": 85.56, "calibrationCharity": 67.34400000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.736000000000018, "evidenceWarrant": 13.734000000000009, "responsiveness": 3.6340000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 2.028000000000006, "precisionClarity": 4.340000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 12.725999999999985 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.9340000000000046, "evidenceWarrant": 2.746800000000002, "responsiveness": 0.7268000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.30420000000000086, "precisionClarity": 0.4340000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 1.2725999999999986 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4184000000000072 }, { "number": 59, "id": "bollore-halper-god-science-evidence-2026", "title": "Michel-Yves Bollore vs Phil Halper: Does Science Point to God?", "motion": "Do cosmology, fine-tuning, origin-of-life research, biblical claims, and suffering make the Christian God more or less plausible?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oeYze2psUpw", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 69, "con": 88, "con_gap": 19, "speakers": { "pro": "Michel-Yves Bolloré", "con": "Phil Halper" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 19, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 63.785000000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 53.265, "responsiveness": 77.75, "relevanceBurden": 85.55999999999999, "precisionClarity": 76.6, "calibrationCharity": 60.52 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.3, "evidenceWarrant": 82.37, "responsiveness": 92.91, "relevanceBurden": 87.18499999999999, "precisionClarity": 91.75, "calibrationCharity": 86.305 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 24.514999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 29.105000000000004, "responsiveness": 15.159999999999997, "relevanceBurden": 1.625, "precisionClarity": 15.150000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 25.785000000000004 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 6.128749999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 5.8210000000000015, "responsiveness": 3.0319999999999996, "relevanceBurden": 0.24375, "precisionClarity": 1.5150000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 2.5785000000000005 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.31899999999999906 }, { "number": 60, "id": "horn-oconnor-jesus-resurrection-2026", "title": "Trent Horn vs Alex O'Connor: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus physically rise from the dead, and do early Christian testimony, rival miracle claims, martyrdom, and the empty tomb make that conclusion historically reasonable?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bu-7IHp3oGQ", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 86, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.52, "evidenceWarrant": 72.554, "responsiveness": 74.586, "relevanceBurden": 83.001, "precisionClarity": 82.46000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 77.081 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.361, "evidenceWarrant": 78.36999999999999, "responsiveness": 94.91399999999999, "relevanceBurden": 81.36800000000001, "precisionClarity": 91.72, "calibrationCharity": 87.463 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.841000000000008, "evidenceWarrant": 5.815999999999988, "responsiveness": 20.32799999999999, "relevanceBurden": -1.6329999999999956, "precisionClarity": 9.259999999999991, "calibrationCharity": 10.38199999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.210250000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 1.1631999999999978, "responsiveness": 4.065599999999998, "relevanceBurden": -0.24494999999999933, "precisionClarity": 0.9259999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.0381999999999991 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.158299999999997 }, { "number": 61, "id": "scrivener-oconnor-morality-bible-slavery-2026", "title": "Glen Scrivener vs Alex O'Connor: Morality, Freedom, Slavery, and the Bible", "motion": "Did Christian faith give the modern West its beliefs in kindness, equality, freedom, consent, and abolition, or are those values better explained by mixed traditions, social struggle, and secular moral development?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ZnVNM8lkGw", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 89, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Glen Scrivener", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.86500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 69.41499999999999, "responsiveness": 95.33500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.54, "precisionClarity": 79.55, "calibrationCharity": 71.34 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 90.33500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 81.245, "responsiveness": 98.405, "relevanceBurden": 82.77, "precisionClarity": 89.44999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 88.75 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.469999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 11.830000000000013, "responsiveness": 3.069999999999993, "relevanceBurden": -3.7700000000000102, "precisionClarity": 9.899999999999991, "calibrationCharity": 17.409999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.8674999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 2.3660000000000028, "responsiveness": 0.6139999999999987, "relevanceBurden": -0.5655000000000016, "precisionClarity": 0.9899999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.7409999999999997 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.012999999999998124 }, { "number": 62, "id": "pageau-folley-logos-meaning-resurrection-2026", "title": "Jonathan Pageau vs Joe Folley: Genesis, Jesus, Science, and Faith", "motion": "Do patterns, symbolism, Genesis, resurrection, worship, and social meaning point toward God as Logos, or can they be explained by human cognition, pragmatic abstraction, and bottom-up social life?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fJ05WWnyj2g", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 88, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan Pageau", "con": "Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.231, "evidenceWarrant": 64.741, "responsiveness": 78.84400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.236, "precisionClarity": 80.84, "calibrationCharity": 73.34700000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 90.849, "evidenceWarrant": 81.105, "responsiveness": 88.015, "relevanceBurden": 86.304, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 90.443 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 17.61800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 16.364000000000004, "responsiveness": 9.170999999999992, "relevanceBurden": 0.06799999999999784, "precisionClarity": 14.159999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 17.09599999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.404500000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 3.272800000000001, "responsiveness": 1.8341999999999985, "relevanceBurden": 0.010199999999999676, "precisionClarity": 1.4159999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 1.7095999999999991 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6472999999999995 }, { "number": 63, "id": "butt-shermer-god-bible-2023", "title": "Kyle Butt vs Michael Shermer: Does the God of the Bible Exist?", "motion": "Does the God of the Bible exist, and do causation, design, morality, Jesus, religious diversity, suffering, and evidential standards support or undermine that claim?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1TgI3cfeM8", "date": "2026-08-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 86, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Kyle Butt", "con": "Michael Shermer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.615, "evidenceWarrant": 58.114999999999995, "responsiveness": 78.23, "relevanceBurden": 80.64, "precisionClarity": 77.30000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 63.47 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.53999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.35, "responsiveness": 96.05999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 90.9, "calibrationCharity": 82.85 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.924999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 18.235, "responsiveness": 17.829999999999984, "relevanceBurden": 6.359999999999999, "precisionClarity": 13.599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 19.379999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.9812499999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 3.6470000000000002, "responsiveness": 3.565999999999997, "relevanceBurden": 0.9539999999999998, "precisionClarity": 1.3599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 1.9379999999999997 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4462499999999956 }, { "number": 64, "id": "pine-watkins-god-existence-2020", "title": "Gregory Pine vs Ben Watkins: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do Thomistic arguments from being, act and potency, divine simplicity, revelation, evil, freedom, and changing knowledge support or undermine classical theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QMwHUijmqo", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 86, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Gregory Pine", "con": "Ben Watkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.39999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.97, "responsiveness": 83.6, "relevanceBurden": 85.785, "precisionClarity": 84.05, "calibrationCharity": 75.31 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.135, "evidenceWarrant": 77.17, "responsiveness": 95.01, "relevanceBurden": 86.99999999999999, "precisionClarity": 89.9, "calibrationCharity": 84.195 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.735000000000014, "evidenceWarrant": 6.200000000000003, "responsiveness": 11.41000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 1.2149999999999892, "precisionClarity": 5.8500000000000085, "calibrationCharity": 8.884999999999991 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4337500000000034, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2400000000000007, "responsiveness": 2.2820000000000022, "relevanceBurden": 0.18224999999999839, "precisionClarity": 0.5850000000000009, "calibrationCharity": 0.8884999999999992 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3884999999999952 }, { "number": 65, "id": "donahue-malpass-fine-tuning-god-2026", "title": "Miles K. Donahue vs Alex Malpass: Does Fine-Tuning Point to God?", "motion": "Does cosmic fine-tuning provide strong evidence for God, or can naturalistic alternatives, hypothesis-space ambiguity, and doubts about divine psychology undercut that inference?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2UtMbB_gazg", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 80, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Miles Donahue", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.85000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 65.65, "responsiveness": 91.50000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.99999999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.0, "calibrationCharity": 75.65 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.52, "evidenceWarrant": 67.745, "responsiveness": 91.915, "relevanceBurden": 80.49, "precisionClarity": 81.0, "calibrationCharity": 80.86999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6699999999999875, "evidenceWarrant": 2.094999999999999, "responsiveness": 0.41499999999999204, "relevanceBurden": -4.509999999999991, "precisionClarity": -3.0, "calibrationCharity": 5.219999999999985 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.4174999999999969, "evidenceWarrant": 0.4189999999999998, "responsiveness": 0.08299999999999841, "relevanceBurden": -0.6764999999999987, "precisionClarity": -0.30000000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 0.5219999999999985 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5350000000000051 }, { "number": 66, "id": "donahue-fodor-case-against-christianity-2025", "title": "Miles K. Donahue vs James Fodor: The Case Against Christianity", "motion": "Do philosophical arguments, biblical beauty, religious experience, and resurrection evidence make Christianity credible, or do evil, disagreement, expert dissent, and Christian moral failure make it unlikely?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jOYiPLT41wM", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 83, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Miles Donahue", "con": "James Fodor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.665, "evidenceWarrant": 68.775, "responsiveness": 90.70000000000002, "relevanceBurden": 85.56, "precisionClarity": 87.69999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 79.57499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.066, "evidenceWarrant": 75.939, "responsiveness": 79.705, "relevanceBurden": 83.58, "precisionClarity": 91.0, "calibrationCharity": 89.886 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.400999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 7.163999999999987, "responsiveness": -10.995000000000019, "relevanceBurden": -1.980000000000004, "precisionClarity": 3.3000000000000114, "calibrationCharity": 10.311000000000007 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.600249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 1.4327999999999976, "responsiveness": -2.199000000000004, "relevanceBurden": -0.2970000000000006, "precisionClarity": 0.3300000000000012, "calibrationCharity": 1.0311000000000008 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.10185000000000577 }, { "number": 67, "id": "jones-fodor-digital-physics-god-2021", "title": "Michael Jones vs James Fodor: The Digital Physics Argument for God", "motion": "Does digital physics, emergent spacetime, quantum information, and idealist metaphysics make God the best explanation of reality, or is a materialist ontology simpler and better disciplined?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b2HZu6BcxHU", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 87, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "James Fodor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 16, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.908, "evidenceWarrant": 58.592, "responsiveness": 76.43599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.079, "precisionClarity": 76.8, "calibrationCharity": 67.658 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.26299999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.91199999999999, "responsiveness": 98.55499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.566, "precisionClarity": 87.92, "calibrationCharity": 85.492 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 18.35499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 18.319999999999993, "responsiveness": 22.119, "relevanceBurden": 2.487000000000009, "precisionClarity": 11.120000000000005, "calibrationCharity": 17.834000000000003 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.588749999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 3.663999999999999, "responsiveness": 4.4238, "relevanceBurden": 0.3730500000000013, "precisionClarity": 1.1120000000000005, "calibrationCharity": 1.7834000000000003 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.05500000000000149 }, { "number": 68, "id": "jones-dillahunty-quantum-idealism-demonstrability-2026", "title": "Michael Jones vs Matt Dillahunty: Quantum Idealism and Demonstrability", "motion": "Does quantum mechanics and idealism provide good reason to treat consciousness or a divine mind as fundamental, or does the claim fail public demonstrability and physical-interaction tests?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6CLpuRu7R9o", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 69, "con": 86, "con_gap": 17, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 17, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.45, "evidenceWarrant": 59.900000000000006, "responsiveness": 67.39999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 80.6, "precisionClarity": 75.0, "calibrationCharity": 64.65 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.80000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 77.1, "responsiveness": 97.825, "relevanceBurden": 84.3, "precisionClarity": 86.5, "calibrationCharity": 82.55 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.350000000000009, "evidenceWarrant": 17.19999999999999, "responsiveness": 30.42500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 3.700000000000003, "precisionClarity": 11.5, "calibrationCharity": 17.89999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.837500000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 3.4399999999999977, "responsiveness": 6.085000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 0.5550000000000004, "precisionClarity": 1.1500000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.7899999999999991 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.1424999999999983 }, { "number": 69, "id": "winger-dillahunty-resurrection-unreasonable-2019", "title": "Mike Winger vs Matt Dillahunty: Is Belief in the Resurrection Unreasonable?", "motion": "Is belief in Jesus' resurrection reasonable given the historical claims, testimonial sources, rival explanations, and evidential burden for supernatural causation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2FGgkubhZM", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 86, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Mike Winger", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.454, "evidenceWarrant": 73.72, "responsiveness": 86.27799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.76, "precisionClarity": 85.17999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 69.99799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.66600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.63, "responsiveness": 94.684, "relevanceBurden": 88.03, "precisionClarity": 84.2, "calibrationCharity": 82.36000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.2120000000000175, "evidenceWarrant": 4.909999999999997, "responsiveness": 8.406000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 4.269999999999996, "precisionClarity": -0.9799999999999898, "calibrationCharity": 12.362000000000023 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8030000000000044, "evidenceWarrant": 0.9819999999999993, "responsiveness": 1.6812000000000014, "relevanceBurden": 0.6404999999999994, "precisionClarity": -0.09799999999999898, "calibrationCharity": 1.2362000000000024 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.24490000000000833 }, { "number": 70, "id": "malpass-anderson-logic-god-2021", "title": "Alex Malpass vs James Anderson: Does Logic Prove God?", "motion": "Does the existence of necessary truths or laws of logic support a necessarily existing divine mind, or can propositions be explained without God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4qpwVLLebng", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 82, "con_gap": -4, "speakers": { "pro": "James Anderson", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.845, "evidenceWarrant": 77.785, "responsiveness": 96.1, "relevanceBurden": 82.22999999999999, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 87.505 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.53999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.97, "responsiveness": 82.16999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 82.6, "precisionClarity": 83.69999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 89.85999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.3050000000000068, "evidenceWarrant": -1.8149999999999977, "responsiveness": -13.930000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 0.37000000000000455, "precisionClarity": -11.300000000000011, "calibrationCharity": 2.3549999999999898 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.3262500000000017, "evidenceWarrant": -0.36299999999999955, "responsiveness": -2.7860000000000014, "relevanceBurden": 0.05550000000000068, "precisionClarity": -1.1300000000000012, "calibrationCharity": 0.235499999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3142500000000039 }, { "number": 71, "id": "hitchens-kushner-gomes-god-religion-morality-2009", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Harold Kushner and Peter Gomes: God, Religion, and Morality", "motion": "Does belief in God and religious tradition provide necessary moral meaning, resilience, and communal wisdom, or does religion add false claims, sectarian authority, and distinctive moral harms?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZxhOh75jn4Q", "date": "2026-06-11", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 81, "con": 86, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Harold Kushner and Peter Gomes", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 72, "id": "dyer-malpass-tag-argument-2019", "title": "Jay Dyer vs Alex Malpass: The TAG Argument", "motion": "Does the transcendental argument show that logic, induction, knowledge, and ethics require the Orthodox Christian God, or can those preconditions be understood without that presupposition?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gK-rwG392Uc", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 91, "con_gap": 17, "speakers": { "pro": "Jay Dyer", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 17, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.184, "evidenceWarrant": 65.65, "responsiveness": 75.438, "relevanceBurden": 86.34, "precisionClarity": 78.72, "calibrationCharity": 70.21 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 90.748, "evidenceWarrant": 83.78599999999999, "responsiveness": 97.34400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.31800000000001, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 91.908 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 18.564000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 18.13599999999998, "responsiveness": 21.906000000000006, "relevanceBurden": -0.02199999999999136, "precisionClarity": 16.28, "calibrationCharity": 21.698000000000008 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.641000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 3.6271999999999966, "responsiveness": 4.3812000000000015, "relevanceBurden": -0.0032999999999987037, "precisionClarity": 1.6280000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 2.169800000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5560999999999972 }, { "number": 73, "id": "hawkins-folley-free-will-compatibilism-2026", "title": "Nathan Hawkins vs Joe Folley: Do We Really Have Free Will?", "motion": "Does human freedom require libertarian alternative possibilities and sourcehood, or can compatibilist notions of will, responsibility, and practical agency survive determinism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I5uYVxLdaO0", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 89, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Nathan Hawkins", "con": "Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.935, "evidenceWarrant": 72.63, "responsiveness": 96.25500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.41000000000001, "precisionClarity": 84.3, "calibrationCharity": 82.415 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.875, "evidenceWarrant": 79.8, "responsiveness": 96.72500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.8, "precisionClarity": 89.5, "calibrationCharity": 92.44999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 74, "id": "rasmussen-malpass-suffering-causal-finitism-2021", "title": "Josh Rasmussen vs Alex Malpass: Suffering, Theism, and Causal Finitism", "motion": "Do Grim Reaper-style paradoxes support causal finitism, and does the existence and distribution of suffering favor theism or the hypothesis of indifference?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MfCQBynjgnw", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 89, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Josh Rasmussen", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.74600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 70.944, "responsiveness": 91.236, "relevanceBurden": 84.084, "precisionClarity": 88.1, "calibrationCharity": 81.15799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.81800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 82.03999999999999, "responsiveness": 95.22999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 82.17599999999999, "precisionClarity": 93.2, "calibrationCharity": 91.232 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.072000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 11.09599999999999, "responsiveness": 3.9939999999999856, "relevanceBurden": -1.9080000000000155, "precisionClarity": 5.1000000000000085, "calibrationCharity": 10.074000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.2680000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 2.219199999999998, "responsiveness": 0.7987999999999972, "relevanceBurden": -0.2862000000000023, "precisionClarity": 0.5100000000000009, "calibrationCharity": 1.0074000000000012 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.48280000000000456 }, { "number": 75, "id": "rasmussen-clifton-contingency-argument-2019", "title": "Josh Rasmussen vs Scott Clifton: Is the Contingency Argument Persuasive?", "motion": "Is the argument from contingency persuasive in moving from contingent reality to a necessary or automatically actual foundation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgiWkE1lhII", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 87, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Josh Rasmussen", "con": "Scott Clifton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.93, "evidenceWarrant": 72.66, "responsiveness": 75.69, "relevanceBurden": 86.935, "precisionClarity": 85.1, "calibrationCharity": 82.47999999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.217, "evidenceWarrant": 77.275, "responsiveness": 89.795, "relevanceBurden": 91.615, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 92.50800000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.286999999999992, "evidenceWarrant": 4.615000000000009, "responsiveness": 14.105000000000004, "relevanceBurden": 4.679999999999993, "precisionClarity": 9.900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 10.02800000000002 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.571749999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 0.9230000000000018, "responsiveness": 2.821000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.7019999999999988, "precisionClarity": 0.9900000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 1.0028000000000021 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.010550000000002058 }, { "number": 76, "id": "craig-oppy-mathematics-theism-2020", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Graham Oppy: Does Math Point to God?", "motion": "Does the surprising applicability of mathematics to the physical world support theism better than naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WE1y00bwCU", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 84, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.374, "evidenceWarrant": 70.514, "responsiveness": 87.26199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.702, "precisionClarity": 87.62, "calibrationCharity": 76.29399999999998 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.16, "evidenceWarrant": 74.43599999999999, "responsiveness": 86.324, "relevanceBurden": 85.322, "precisionClarity": 88.6, "calibrationCharity": 84.36 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.786000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 3.921999999999997, "responsiveness": -0.9379999999999882, "relevanceBurden": -2.3799999999999955, "precisionClarity": 0.9799999999999898, "calibrationCharity": 8.066000000000017 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1965000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7843999999999994, "responsiveness": -0.18759999999999766, "relevanceBurden": -0.3569999999999993, "precisionClarity": 0.09799999999999898, "calibrationCharity": 0.8066000000000018 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.6590999999999965 }, { "number": 77, "id": "feser-oppy-arguments-for-god-2020", "title": "Ed Feser vs Graham Oppy: Are There Any Good Arguments for God?", "motion": "Are there good arguments for God, and does Feser's Aristotelian proof survive Oppy's theory-comparison and persistence objections?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m-80lQOlNOs", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 81, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Ed Feser", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 84.98800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 76.756, "responsiveness": 95.836, "relevanceBurden": 83.06, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 85.96600000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.136, "evidenceWarrant": 67.578, "responsiveness": 95.20799999999998, "relevanceBurden": 86.11199999999998, "precisionClarity": 91.41999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 73.068 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -8.852000000000018, "evidenceWarrant": -9.177999999999997, "responsiveness": -0.6280000000000143, "relevanceBurden": 3.0519999999999783, "precisionClarity": -3.5800000000000125, "calibrationCharity": -12.89800000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -2.2130000000000045, "evidenceWarrant": -1.8355999999999995, "responsiveness": -0.12560000000000288, "relevanceBurden": 0.4577999999999967, "precisionClarity": -0.35800000000000126, "calibrationCharity": -1.2898000000000012 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.36420000000001274 }, { "number": 78, "id": "albrecht-oppy-resurrection-ancient-christianity-2023", "title": "William Albrecht vs Graham Oppy: Resurrection and Ancient Christianity", "motion": "Do Paul's letters, Gospel transmission, hostile witnesses, and early church structures make the bodily resurrection and Catholic continuity historically credible?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YzvidaGO3m4", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "William Albrecht", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.053, "evidenceWarrant": 68.37700000000001, "responsiveness": 80.576, "relevanceBurden": 81.41199999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.38, "calibrationCharity": 72.691 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.935, "evidenceWarrant": 70.35, "responsiveness": 89.869, "relevanceBurden": 84.25, "precisionClarity": 86.48, "calibrationCharity": 87.533 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.882000000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9729999999999848, "responsiveness": 9.293000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 2.838000000000008, "precisionClarity": 7.1000000000000085, "calibrationCharity": 14.841999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7205000000000013, "evidenceWarrant": 0.39459999999999695, "responsiveness": 1.8586000000000014, "relevanceBurden": 0.4257000000000012, "precisionClarity": 0.7100000000000009, "calibrationCharity": 1.4842 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.40639999999999876 }, { "number": 79, "id": "swinburne-oppy-theism-probability-2022", "title": "Richard Swinburne vs Graham Oppy: Is Theism Probable?", "motion": "Is theism more probable than naturalism when judged by simplicity, explanatory scope, fine-tuning, consciousness, and modality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hKw3d3qOYSo", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 85, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Swinburne", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.495, "evidenceWarrant": 68.97, "responsiveness": 92.33, "relevanceBurden": 81.975, "precisionClarity": 86.25, "calibrationCharity": 73.105 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.985, "evidenceWarrant": 74.28, "responsiveness": 97.55999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 77.58999999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.8, "calibrationCharity": 86.71 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.489999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 5.310000000000002, "responsiveness": 5.22999999999999, "relevanceBurden": -4.385000000000005, "precisionClarity": 4.549999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 13.60499999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8724999999999987, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0620000000000005, "responsiveness": 1.045999999999998, "relevanceBurden": -0.6577500000000007, "precisionClarity": 0.45499999999999974, "calibrationCharity": 1.3604999999999992 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.13824999999999577 }, { "number": 80, "id": "rasmussen-schmid-argument-from-limits-2023", "title": "Josh Rasmussen vs Joe Schmid: The Argument from Limits", "motion": "Does the argument from arbitrary limits successfully move from a fundamental reality or necessary foundation toward God-like perfection?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lt1wN10yOY4", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 90, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Josh Rasmussen", "con": "Joseph Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.233, "evidenceWarrant": 74.311, "responsiveness": 95.102, "relevanceBurden": 85.764, "precisionClarity": 84.3, "calibrationCharity": 86.78 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.41000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 80.85000000000001, "responsiveness": 98.27000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.36999999999999, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 91.70500000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.177000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 6.5390000000000015, "responsiveness": 3.1680000000000064, "relevanceBurden": 0.6059999999999945, "precisionClarity": 10.700000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 4.925000000000011 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7942500000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3078000000000003, "responsiveness": 0.6336000000000013, "relevanceBurden": 0.09089999999999918, "precisionClarity": 1.0700000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 0.49250000000000116 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.6109499999999963 }, { "number": 81, "id": "rasmussen-oppy-ultimate-reality-naturalism-2020", "title": "Josh Rasmussen vs Graham Oppy: Theism, Naturalism, and Ultimate Reality", "motion": "Is a theistic supreme foundation or a naturalistic initial reality the better account of ultimate reality, mind, and worldview simplicity?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YhqFdIb13bk", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 85, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Josh Rasmussen", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.65, "evidenceWarrant": 71.6, "responsiveness": 88.95, "relevanceBurden": 81.30000000000001, "precisionClarity": 79.75, "calibrationCharity": 84.05 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.07499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.2, "responsiveness": 91.825, "relevanceBurden": 81.44999999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.5, "calibrationCharity": 85.275 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.424999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": 4.6000000000000085, "responsiveness": 2.875, "relevanceBurden": 0.14999999999997726, "precisionClarity": 6.75, "calibrationCharity": 1.2250000000000085 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6062499999999957, "evidenceWarrant": 0.9200000000000017, "responsiveness": 0.5750000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.02249999999999659, "precisionClarity": 0.675, "calibrationCharity": 0.12250000000000086 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.0787500000000052 }, { "number": 82, "id": "bush-mcallister-moral-anti-realism-realism-2025", "title": "Lance Bush vs Derek McAllister: Moral Anti-Realism vs Realism", "motion": "Does moral realism have a common-sense, historical, or semantic advantage over moral anti-realism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ya02MOhQMV8", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 90, "con": 76, "con_gap": -14, "speakers": { "pro": "Lance Bush", "con": "Derek McAllister" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 89.836, "evidenceWarrant": 81.114, "responsiveness": 98.346, "relevanceBurden": 84.146, "precisionClarity": 93.20000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 92.112 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.108, "evidenceWarrant": 67.05199999999999, "responsiveness": 85.20400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 79.628, "precisionClarity": 75.0, "calibrationCharity": 76.806 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 83, "id": "loke-oppy-kalam-causal-principle-2020", "title": "Andrew Loke vs Graham Oppy: Is the Kalam Sound?", "motion": "Does Loke's reformulated Kalam cosmological argument successfully establish a beginningless personal creator of the universe?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a8NrTv-Durc", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 86, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Andrew Loke", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.424, "evidenceWarrant": 63.638, "responsiveness": 81.19399999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.422, "precisionClarity": 77.4, "calibrationCharity": 69.552 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.4, "evidenceWarrant": 76.61999999999999, "responsiveness": 95.82, "relevanceBurden": 87.8, "precisionClarity": 90.5, "calibrationCharity": 83.8 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.975999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 12.981999999999992, "responsiveness": 14.626000000000005, "relevanceBurden": 1.3780000000000001, "precisionClarity": 13.099999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 14.24799999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.9939999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 2.5963999999999987, "responsiveness": 2.925200000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.20670000000000002, "precisionClarity": 1.3099999999999996, "calibrationCharity": 1.4247999999999992 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.45709999999999873 }, { "number": 84, "id": "krauss-meyer-lamoureux-god-science-universe-2016", "title": "Lawrence Krauss vs Stephen Meyer and Denis Lamoureux: God, Science, and the Universe", "motion": "Do cosmology, evolution, and biological information point beyond scientific naturalism to God, design, or a theistic interpretation of nature?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mMuy58DaqOk", "date": "2026-06-23", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 86, "con": 83, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Lawrence Krauss", "con": "Stephen Meyer and Denis Lamoureux" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 } }, { "number": 85, "id": "atkins-fox-god-science-future-humanity-2024", "title": "Peter Atkins vs Keith Fox: God vs Science Debate", "motion": "Do science, evolution, and future technology make God unnecessary, or do value, personhood, origins, and hope point beyond scientific materialism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2pDEBRG_9_Q", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 85, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Peter Atkins", "con": "Keith Fox" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.516, "evidenceWarrant": 56.5, "responsiveness": 78.69399999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.612, "precisionClarity": 70.05, "calibrationCharity": 55.24 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.914, "evidenceWarrant": 74.488, "responsiveness": 92.68199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 82.536, "precisionClarity": 90.52, "calibrationCharity": 86.668 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -17.397999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": -17.988, "responsiveness": -13.988, "relevanceBurden": 5.075999999999993, "precisionClarity": -20.47, "calibrationCharity": -31.428000000000004 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -4.349499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": -3.5976, "responsiveness": -2.7976, "relevanceBurden": 0.761399999999999, "precisionClarity": -2.047, "calibrationCharity": -3.1428000000000007 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.17310000000000159 }, { "number": 86, "id": "egnor-dillahunty-god-existence-2021", "title": "Michael Egnor vs Matt Dillahunty: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do Thomistic proofs, moral law, and natural theology meet the burden of proof against skeptical atheism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yahf0t5mK5g", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 83, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Egnor", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 66.61, "evidenceWarrant": 59.464999999999996, "responsiveness": 74.66999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 76.15, "calibrationCharity": 67.695 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.72, "evidenceWarrant": 76.42, "responsiveness": 82.78, "relevanceBurden": 88.875, "precisionClarity": 87.15, "calibrationCharity": 80.46 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 16.11, "evidenceWarrant": 16.955000000000005, "responsiveness": 8.110000000000014, "relevanceBurden": 1.875, "precisionClarity": 11.0, "calibrationCharity": 12.765 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.0275, "evidenceWarrant": 3.3910000000000013, "responsiveness": 1.6220000000000028, "relevanceBurden": 0.28125, "precisionClarity": 1.1, "calibrationCharity": 1.2765000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.30174999999999486 }, { "number": 87, "id": "christopoulos-dillahunty-resurrection-historical-event-2024", "title": "Than Christopoulos vs Matt Dillahunty: Is the Resurrection a Historical Event?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence make Jesus' resurrection more probable than competing hypotheses?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSQWIWY9gYg", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 88, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Than Christopoulos", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.636, "evidenceWarrant": 70.34599999999999, "responsiveness": 85.829, "relevanceBurden": 85.745, "precisionClarity": 78.6, "calibrationCharity": 73.673 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.765, "evidenceWarrant": 77.296, "responsiveness": 98.70200000000001, "relevanceBurden": 90.21, "precisionClarity": 88.5, "calibrationCharity": 83.714 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.129000000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 6.950000000000017, "responsiveness": 12.873000000000019, "relevanceBurden": 4.464999999999989, "precisionClarity": 9.900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 10.040999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5322500000000012, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3900000000000035, "responsiveness": 2.5746000000000038, "relevanceBurden": 0.6697499999999984, "precisionClarity": 0.9900000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 1.0040999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.1607000000000074 }, { "number": 88, "id": "sechler-dillahunty-perfect-mind-universe-2022", "title": "Zac Sechler vs Matt Dillahunty: Did a Perfect Mind Create the Universe?", "motion": "Did a perfect mind create the universe, and do simplicity, moral agents, beauty, fine-tuning, meaning, and purpose favor that hypothesis over non-theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FUPOouj5jNg", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 83, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Zac Sechler", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.23499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 62.42, "responsiveness": 85.80999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.72, "precisionClarity": 83.95, "calibrationCharity": 79.53 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.88499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 73.48, "responsiveness": 95.41499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.3, "precisionClarity": 86.25, "calibrationCharity": 78.285 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6500000000000057, "evidenceWarrant": 11.060000000000002, "responsiveness": 9.605000000000004, "relevanceBurden": -1.4200000000000017, "precisionClarity": 2.299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": -1.2450000000000045 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.4125000000000014, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2120000000000006, "responsiveness": 1.921000000000001, "relevanceBurden": -0.21300000000000024, "precisionClarity": 0.22999999999999973, "calibrationCharity": -0.12450000000000046 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4380000000000024 }, { "number": 89, "id": "bignon-oppy-religious-experience-god-2022", "title": "Guillaume Bignon vs Graham Oppy: Religious Experience and the Case for God", "motion": "Can Bignon's conversion story, religious experience, and supporting arguments rationally support Christian belief, or do rival experiences and naturalist explanations undercut their evidential force?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4KCJXMeM9WQ", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 87, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Guillaume Bignon", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.97, "evidenceWarrant": 66.06, "responsiveness": 93.665, "relevanceBurden": 85.02, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 81.44500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.745, "evidenceWarrant": 76.86, "responsiveness": 96.35, "relevanceBurden": 85.82, "precisionClarity": 86.0, "calibrationCharity": 90.675 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.775000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 10.799999999999997, "responsiveness": 2.684999999999988, "relevanceBurden": 0.7999999999999972, "precisionClarity": -2.0, "calibrationCharity": 9.22999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4437500000000014, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1599999999999997, "responsiveness": 0.5369999999999976, "relevanceBurden": 0.11999999999999957, "precisionClarity": -0.2, "calibrationCharity": 0.922999999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.016250000000002984 }, { "number": 90, "id": "akin-ehrman-gospels-historically-reliable-2022", "title": "Jimmy Akin vs Bart Ehrman: Are the Gospels Historically Reliable?", "motion": "Are the canonical Gospels historically reliable despite alleged contradictions in the birth narratives, resurrection accounts, and Jesus' self-presentation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zn7lmu0pek0", "date": "2026-08-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 88, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Jimmy Akin", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.31, "evidenceWarrant": 73.744, "responsiveness": 82.93700000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.618, "precisionClarity": 79.7, "calibrationCharity": 78.543 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.3, "evidenceWarrant": 81.96300000000001, "responsiveness": 94.32300000000001, "relevanceBurden": 91.542, "precisionClarity": 84.61, "calibrationCharity": 85.189 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.989999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 8.219000000000008, "responsiveness": 11.385999999999996, "relevanceBurden": 3.9240000000000066, "precisionClarity": 4.909999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 6.645999999999987 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4974999999999987, "evidenceWarrant": 1.6438000000000017, "responsiveness": 2.2771999999999992, "relevanceBurden": 0.588600000000001, "precisionClarity": 0.49099999999999966, "calibrationCharity": 0.6645999999999987 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.16269999999999918 }, { "number": 91, "id": "cutter-oppy-mind-brain-harmony-god-2025", "title": "Brian Cutter vs Graham Oppy: Does Mind-Brain Harmony Point to God?", "motion": "Does psychophysical harmony, the apparent fit between conscious states and physical or functional states, provide evidence for God over naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dmTLjiGWgpE", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 85, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Brian Cutter", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.58800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 76.608, "responsiveness": 92.96000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 85.08, "calibrationCharity": 81.536 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.708, "evidenceWarrant": 73.86999999999999, "responsiveness": 97.878, "relevanceBurden": 85.152, "precisionClarity": 89.79999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 78.98 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.8800000000000097, "evidenceWarrant": -2.7380000000000138, "responsiveness": 4.917999999999992, "relevanceBurden": -1.847999999999999, "precisionClarity": 4.719999999999985, "calibrationCharity": -2.5559999999999974 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.4700000000000024, "evidenceWarrant": -0.5476000000000028, "responsiveness": 0.9835999999999985, "relevanceBurden": -0.27719999999999984, "precisionClarity": 0.4719999999999985, "calibrationCharity": -0.25559999999999977 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.09480000000000782 }, { "number": 92, "id": "craig-malpass-universe-begin-exist-2020", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Alex Malpass: Did the Universe Begin to Exist?", "motion": "Do actual-infinity and successive-addition arguments give adequate philosophical support for the Kalam claim that the universe began to exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uWo9qU2dhpQ", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 90, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Alex Malpass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.78999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 68.5, "responsiveness": 92.06, "relevanceBurden": 85.53, "precisionClarity": 86.1, "calibrationCharity": 69.30000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 89.69999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 84.45599999999999, "responsiveness": 98.474, "relevanceBurden": 84.768, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 91.70400000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 16.909999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 15.955999999999989, "responsiveness": 6.4140000000000015, "relevanceBurden": -0.7620000000000005, "precisionClarity": 8.900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 22.403999999999996 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.227499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 3.191199999999998, "responsiveness": 1.2828000000000004, "relevanceBurden": -0.11430000000000007, "precisionClarity": 0.8900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 2.2403999999999997 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.7175999999999974 }, { "number": 93, "id": "hunter-dillahunty-christian-god-exist-2019", "title": "Braxton Hunter vs Matt Dillahunty: Does the Christian God Exist?", "motion": "Does the Christian God exist, and do libertarian freedom, the Kalam argument, resurrection evidence, hiddenness, and inconsistent revelation make Christian theism more reasonable than skepticism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9Uktg9nLx8", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 86, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Braxton Hunter", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.94, "evidenceWarrant": 64.24000000000001, "responsiveness": 86.735, "relevanceBurden": 86.37, "precisionClarity": 80.80000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 71.97 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.233, "evidenceWarrant": 78.204, "responsiveness": 89.338, "relevanceBurden": 87.67500000000001, "precisionClarity": 93.0, "calibrationCharity": 86.07499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.293000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 13.963999999999984, "responsiveness": 2.6029999999999944, "relevanceBurden": 1.3050000000000068, "precisionClarity": 12.199999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 14.10499999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.0732500000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 2.792799999999997, "responsiveness": 0.520599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.195750000000001, "precisionClarity": 1.2199999999999989, "calibrationCharity": 1.410499999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.21289999999999587 }, { "number": 94, "id": "swinburne-huemer-theism-coherent-2026", "title": "Richard Swinburne vs Michael Huemer: Is Theism Coherent?", "motion": "Is theism coherent, especially if God is described as omnipotent, omniscient, perfectly good, and infinite in power or knowledge?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IkAU6zAYLU", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 83, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Swinburne", "con": "Michael Huemer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.022, "evidenceWarrant": 67.628, "responsiveness": 78.41699999999999, "relevanceBurden": 80.668, "precisionClarity": 83.24, "calibrationCharity": 72.417 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.865, "evidenceWarrant": 75.48, "responsiveness": 94.225, "relevanceBurden": 86.93, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 73.57499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.842999999999989, "evidenceWarrant": 7.852000000000004, "responsiveness": 15.808000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 6.2620000000000005, "precisionClarity": 4.760000000000005, "calibrationCharity": 1.157999999999987 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4607499999999973, "evidenceWarrant": 1.570400000000001, "responsiveness": 3.1616000000000017, "relevanceBurden": 0.9393, "precisionClarity": 0.47600000000000053, "calibrationCharity": 0.11579999999999871 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.27615000000000034 }, { "number": 95, "id": "craig-frazier-goff-folley-god-reality-2026", "title": "William Lane Craig, Jessica Frazier, Philip Goff, and Joe Folley: Did God Create Reality?", "motion": "Did God create physical reality, and does classical theism best explain the universe, objective meaning, mystical experience, consciousness, and moral obligation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZVMMO_kgtDQ", "date": "2026-07-02", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Jessica Frazier, Philip Goff, and Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 4 } }, { "number": 96, "id": "knechtle-aronra-tjump-christianity-true-2023", "title": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle vs Aron Ra and TJump: Is Christianity True?", "motion": "Is Christianity true, and do the Gospels, resurrection claims, moral experience, human meaning, and biblical history justify Christian faith over skeptical naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4nK7NmDAfkA", "date": "2026-07-13", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 66, "con": 76, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Aron Ra and Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 14, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 2 } }, { "number": 97, "id": "holland-grayling-christianity-human-values-2019", "title": "Tom Holland vs A. C. Grayling: Did Christianity Give Us Our Human Values?", "motion": "Did Christianity give the modern West its human values, or do dignity, equality, humanism, science, and moral concern owe more to classical, Axial Age, Enlightenment, and secular sources?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7eSyz3BaVK8", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 84, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Tom Holland", "con": "AC Grayling" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.257, "evidenceWarrant": 69.33, "responsiveness": 81.685, "relevanceBurden": 87.739, "precisionClarity": 73.125, "calibrationCharity": 71.97800000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.71000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.005, "responsiveness": 87.1, "relevanceBurden": 85.865, "precisionClarity": 81.75, "calibrationCharity": 81.19 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.453000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 8.674999999999997, "responsiveness": 5.414999999999992, "relevanceBurden": -1.8740000000000094, "precisionClarity": 8.625, "calibrationCharity": 9.211999999999989 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6132500000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 1.7349999999999994, "responsiveness": 1.0829999999999984, "relevanceBurden": -0.2811000000000014, "precisionClarity": 0.8625, "calibrationCharity": 0.9211999999999989 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.06615000000000393 }, { "number": 98, "id": "craig-grayling-evil-god-reasonable-2011", "title": "William Lane Craig vs A. C. Grayling: Is Belief in God Reasonable in Light of Evil?", "motion": "Is belief in God reasonable in light of tsunamis, childhood cancer, moral evil, and the apparent harshness of the natural world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vs7ArUMuQyg", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 86, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "AC Grayling" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.605, "evidenceWarrant": 72.175, "responsiveness": 92.36, "relevanceBurden": 85.37, "precisionClarity": 94.3, "calibrationCharity": 82.38499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.79599999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.36699999999999, "responsiveness": 97.182, "relevanceBurden": 84.47999999999999, "precisionClarity": 91.78, "calibrationCharity": 84.703 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.8090000000000117, "evidenceWarrant": 4.191999999999993, "responsiveness": 4.822000000000003, "relevanceBurden": -0.8900000000000148, "precisionClarity": -2.519999999999996, "calibrationCharity": 2.318000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.4522500000000029, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8383999999999987, "responsiveness": 0.9644000000000006, "relevanceBurden": -0.1335000000000022, "precisionClarity": -0.2519999999999996, "calibrationCharity": 0.23180000000000123 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.8031500000000042 }, { "number": 99, "id": "jones-jump-digital-physics-god-2019", "title": "Michael Jones vs Tom Jump: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do emergent spacetime, quantum consciousness, idealism, and the limits of metaphysical knowledge make theism more reasonable than naturalistic alternatives?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UWCvKiWjV0g", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 80, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.78, "evidenceWarrant": 60.44, "responsiveness": 90.78, "relevanceBurden": 85.91999999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.825, "calibrationCharity": 69.805 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.867, "evidenceWarrant": 65.889, "responsiveness": 97.30600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.20599999999999, "precisionClarity": 80.865, "calibrationCharity": 71.413 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.087000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 5.448999999999998, "responsiveness": 6.5260000000000105, "relevanceBurden": 1.2860000000000014, "precisionClarity": 1.039999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.6079999999999899 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0217500000000008, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0897999999999997, "responsiveness": 1.3052000000000021, "relevanceBurden": 0.1929000000000002, "precisionClarity": 0.1039999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 0.160799999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.12554999999999916 }, { "number": 100, "id": "jones-dillahunty-emergent-mind-god-2020", "title": "Michael Jones vs Matt Dillahunty: Reason to Believe in God?", "motion": "Do digital physics, cosmic consciousness, and introspective idealism provide good reasons to believe in a necessary immaterial mind, or do those arguments fail demonstrability, probability, and burden-of-proof standards?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGxSf4zJAso", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 91, "con_gap": 18, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 18, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 70.074, "evidenceWarrant": 61.95300000000001, "responsiveness": 83.69300000000001, "relevanceBurden": 81.86999999999999, "precisionClarity": 73.5, "calibrationCharity": 65.124 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 92.58999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 85.71500000000002, "responsiveness": 98.52, "relevanceBurden": 83.85, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 92.02000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 22.51599999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 23.762000000000008, "responsiveness": 14.826999999999984, "relevanceBurden": 1.980000000000004, "precisionClarity": 21.5, "calibrationCharity": 26.896000000000015 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 5.628999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 4.7524000000000015, "responsiveness": 2.965399999999997, "relevanceBurden": 0.2970000000000006, "precisionClarity": 2.15, "calibrationCharity": 2.6896000000000018 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4833999999999996 }, { "number": 101, "id": "woodford-scrivener-religion-poisons-everything-2026", "title": "Stephen Woodford vs Glen Scrivener: Does Religion Poison Everything?", "motion": "Does religion poison everything by adding doctrine, dogma, revelation, and moral harm to human decency, or does Christianity supply the sacred ideals and institutions that made modern compassion possible?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8J-WOwrq6bE", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 80, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Woodford", "con": "Glen Scrivener" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.96199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.994, "responsiveness": 94.90800000000002, "relevanceBurden": 85.02000000000001, "precisionClarity": 81.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 78.26599999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.27, "evidenceWarrant": 69.976, "responsiveness": 91.912, "relevanceBurden": 82.28399999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.2, "calibrationCharity": 74.312 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.691999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0180000000000007, "responsiveness": 2.9960000000000093, "relevanceBurden": 2.7360000000000184, "precisionClarity": 2.1999999999999886, "calibrationCharity": 3.9539999999999935 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.9229999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": 0.20360000000000014, "responsiveness": 0.5992000000000018, "relevanceBurden": 0.41040000000000276, "precisionClarity": 0.21999999999999886, "calibrationCharity": 0.39539999999999936 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.24839999999999884 }, { "number": 102, "id": "woodford-brierley-christianity-rational-2019", "title": "Stephen Woodford vs Justin Brierley: Is Christianity Rational?", "motion": "Is Christianity rational, and do its claims about God, morality, reason, and resurrection meet proportionate evidential standards?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfAWALcKf2w", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 77, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Woodford", "con": "Justin Brierley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.445, "evidenceWarrant": 72.63, "responsiveness": 90.085, "relevanceBurden": 84.84, "precisionClarity": 85.15, "calibrationCharity": 78.07 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.265, "evidenceWarrant": 66.254, "responsiveness": 83.502, "relevanceBurden": 83.6, "precisionClarity": 80.93, "calibrationCharity": 70.376 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.179999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 6.375999999999991, "responsiveness": 6.582999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 1.240000000000009, "precisionClarity": 4.219999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 7.693999999999988 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2949999999999982, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2751999999999981, "responsiveness": 1.3165999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.18600000000000136, "precisionClarity": 0.42199999999999993, "calibrationCharity": 0.7693999999999989 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2641999999999962 }, { "number": 103, "id": "woodford-edwards-rational-belief-god-2023", "title": "Stephen Woodford vs Simon Edwards: Is It Rational to Believe in God?", "motion": "Is belief in an all-powerful, all-loving God rational given alleged gratuitous evil, salvation confusion, rationality, design, and morality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g1TlLCSn_5o", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 78, "con_gap": -4, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Woodford", "con": "Simon Edwards" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.03999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.095, "responsiveness": 88.78, "relevanceBurden": 78.28, "precisionClarity": 87.0, "calibrationCharity": 80.405 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.08, "evidenceWarrant": 65.02, "responsiveness": 84.78999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 81.27, "precisionClarity": 85.4, "calibrationCharity": 76.08999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.959999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 11.075000000000003, "responsiveness": 3.990000000000009, "relevanceBurden": -2.989999999999995, "precisionClarity": 1.5999999999999943, "calibrationCharity": 4.315000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7399999999999984, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2150000000000007, "responsiveness": 0.7980000000000018, "relevanceBurden": -0.44849999999999923, "precisionClarity": 0.15999999999999945, "calibrationCharity": 0.4315000000000012 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.8960000000000026 }, { "number": 104, "id": "oconnor-baker-hytch-argument-from-reason-2020", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Max Baker-Hytch: The Argument for God From Reason", "motion": "Does rationality undermine naturalism and make a theistic or otherwise non-naturalist account of mind more probable?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kI5j2b7ZtXw", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 82, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Max Baker-Hytch", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.85, "evidenceWarrant": 75.32, "responsiveness": 92.245, "relevanceBurden": 84.64999999999999, "precisionClarity": 91.8, "calibrationCharity": 81.095 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.80000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 73.8, "responsiveness": 91.74000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.08999999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.0, "calibrationCharity": 81.64000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -3.049999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": -1.519999999999996, "responsiveness": -0.5049999999999955, "relevanceBurden": 0.4399999999999977, "precisionClarity": -7.799999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 0.5450000000000159 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.7624999999999957, "evidenceWarrant": -0.3039999999999992, "responsiveness": -0.10099999999999909, "relevanceBurden": 0.06599999999999966, "precisionClarity": -0.7799999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 0.054500000000001596 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.17300000000000737 }, { "number": 105, "id": "craig-williams-hossenfelder-zizek-god-reality-2026", "title": "William Lane Craig and Rowan Williams vs Sabine Hossenfelder and Slavoj Žižek: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God belong in our best account of reality, given cosmology, explanation, resurrection claims, suffering, religious practice, and the limits of science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=spiiYYgi9Wg", "date": "2026-07-23", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 82, "con": 81, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig and Rowan Williams", "con": "Sabine Hossenfelder and Slavoj Žižek" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 4 } }, { "number": 106, "id": "peterson-blackmore-god-meaning-life-2018", "title": "Jordan Peterson vs Susan Blackmore: Do We Need God to Make Sense of Life?", "motion": "Do humans need God, religious stories, or religiously inherited values to make sense of life, meaning, morality, suffering, and action?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syP-OtdCIho", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 85, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Susan Blackmore" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.962, "evidenceWarrant": 60.248999999999995, "responsiveness": 84.50599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.832, "precisionClarity": 77.3, "calibrationCharity": 65.473 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.138, "evidenceWarrant": 71.774, "responsiveness": 96.336, "relevanceBurden": 84.252, "precisionClarity": 89.88000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 85.078 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 13.176000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 11.525000000000006, "responsiveness": 11.830000000000013, "relevanceBurden": -1.5799999999999983, "precisionClarity": 12.580000000000013, "calibrationCharity": 19.605000000000004 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.2940000000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 2.305000000000001, "responsiveness": 2.3660000000000028, "relevanceBurden": -0.23699999999999974, "precisionClarity": 1.2580000000000013, "calibrationCharity": 1.9605000000000006 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.05349999999999433 }, { "number": 107, "id": "lennox-ruse-science-faith-evidence-god-2018", "title": "John Lennox vs Michael Ruse: Science, Faith, and the Evidence for God", "motion": "Do science, mathematics, miracle claims, moral experience, and the problem of evil support an evidence-based Christian faith or a more cautious agnostic naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrnXdzQRISM", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 85, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Michael Ruse" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.22, "evidenceWarrant": 64.96000000000001, "responsiveness": 84.99, "relevanceBurden": 84.52, "precisionClarity": 90.2, "calibrationCharity": 73.29 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.29, "evidenceWarrant": 74.02, "responsiveness": 93.97, "relevanceBurden": 86.88, "precisionClarity": 88.80000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 82.81 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.070000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 9.059999999999988, "responsiveness": 8.980000000000004, "relevanceBurden": 2.3599999999999994, "precisionClarity": -1.3999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 9.519999999999996 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2675000000000018, "evidenceWarrant": 1.8119999999999976, "responsiveness": 1.796000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.3539999999999999, "precisionClarity": -0.13999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 0.9519999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.04150000000000098 }, { "number": 108, "id": "ward-ruse-mind-consciousness-god-2013", "title": "Keith Ward vs Michael Ruse: Mind, Consciousness, and God", "motion": "Does human consciousness, religious and moral experience, and free agency make best sense within a God-centered mind-first reality, or can agnostic naturalism absorb those mysteries without theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOy29aP7wDc", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Keith Ward", "con": "Michael Ruse" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.40799999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 65.937, "responsiveness": 90.1, "relevanceBurden": 82.30799999999999, "precisionClarity": 89.78, "calibrationCharity": 82.395 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.953, "evidenceWarrant": 72.009, "responsiveness": 85.88799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.868, "precisionClarity": 91.80000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 81.748 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.545000000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 6.072000000000003, "responsiveness": -4.212000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 1.5600000000000023, "precisionClarity": 2.0200000000000102, "calibrationCharity": -0.6469999999999914 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.886250000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2144000000000006, "responsiveness": -0.8424000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 0.23400000000000032, "precisionClarity": 0.20200000000000104, "calibrationCharity": -0.06469999999999913 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6295500000000063 }, { "number": 109, "id": "mclatchie-oconnor-theism-naturalism-reality-2022", "title": "Jonathan McLatchie vs Alex O'Connor: Theism or Naturalism?", "motion": "Theism or naturalism: which provides a better account of reality, including biological information, resurrection testimony, divine hiddenness, religious geography, and suffering?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rnIQFI1pYLM", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 83, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.09, "evidenceWarrant": 60.59, "responsiveness": 78.36999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.0, "precisionClarity": 80.85, "calibrationCharity": 68.26 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.39999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.85000000000001, "responsiveness": 90.95000000000002, "relevanceBurden": 85.1, "precisionClarity": 90.5, "calibrationCharity": 82.775 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.309999999999988, "evidenceWarrant": 10.260000000000005, "responsiveness": 12.580000000000027, "relevanceBurden": 0.09999999999999432, "precisionClarity": 9.650000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 14.515 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.327499999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 2.052000000000001, "responsiveness": 2.5160000000000053, "relevanceBurden": 0.014999999999999146, "precisionClarity": 0.9650000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 1.4515000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3270000000000035 }, { "number": 110, "id": "tour-garte-evolution-agency-christian-faith-2025", "title": "James Tour vs Sy Garte: Evolution, Agency, and Christian Faith", "motion": "Can Christian faith be reconciled with evolutionary theory by emphasizing agency, cognition, and natural genetic engineering, or do unresolved mechanisms in origins, body plans, fossils, and human uniqueness make evolutionary confidence overreach?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cqfPJQg8m5U", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 80, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "James Tour", "con": "Sy Garte" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.55999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 73.63, "responsiveness": 69.735, "relevanceBurden": 84.225, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 82.94500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.07000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 71.80499999999999, "responsiveness": 83.045, "relevanceBurden": 84.14, "precisionClarity": 84.0, "calibrationCharity": 76.795 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 111, "id": "tour-farina-origin-life-cluelessness-2023", "title": "Dave Farina vs James Tour: Are We Clueless About the Origin of Life?", "motion": "Are scientists currently clueless about the origin of life, or do prebiotic chemistry, ribozyme research, and systems chemistry already provide viable pathways toward abiogenesis?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KvGdllx9pJU", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 79, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "James Tour", "con": "Dave Farina" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.184, "evidenceWarrant": 64.75099999999999, "responsiveness": 92.483, "relevanceBurden": 87.064, "precisionClarity": 74.795, "calibrationCharity": 72.91 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.66699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 69.27499999999999, "responsiveness": 86.895, "relevanceBurden": 83.776, "precisionClarity": 73.825, "calibrationCharity": 75.64000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 112, "id": "copan-woodford-belief-god-reasonable-2024", "title": "Paul Copan vs Stephen Woodford: Is Belief in God Reasonable?", "motion": "Is belief in God reasonable, given cosmology, fine-tuning, consciousness, rationality, morality, evil, religious history, and the record of scientific explanation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQda8Cywqvo", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 81, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Paul Copan", "con": "Stephen Woodford" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.50999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 67.75500000000001, "responsiveness": 87.19, "relevanceBurden": 83.46, "precisionClarity": 81.6, "calibrationCharity": 69.9 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.44, "evidenceWarrant": 71.55000000000001, "responsiveness": 93.21, "relevanceBurden": 85.56, "precisionClarity": 82.3, "calibrationCharity": 75.18 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.930000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 3.7950000000000017, "responsiveness": 6.019999999999996, "relevanceBurden": 2.1000000000000085, "precisionClarity": 0.7000000000000028, "calibrationCharity": 5.280000000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.7325000000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7590000000000003, "responsiveness": 1.2039999999999993, "relevanceBurden": 0.3150000000000013, "precisionClarity": 0.07000000000000028, "calibrationCharity": 0.5280000000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6085000000000029 }, { "number": 113, "id": "dirckx-woodford-god-suffering-2024", "title": "Sharon Dirckx vs Stephen Woodford: Why Doesn't God Stop Suffering?", "motion": "Does the reality of suffering make belief in an all-powerful, all-loving God unreasonable, or does the Christian framework of a broken world, divine presence, justice, and future healing make better sense of it?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQetkofYXvI", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 80, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Sharon Dirckx", "con": "Stephen Woodford" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.70000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 69.44999999999999, "responsiveness": 78.39999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 81.6, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 80.4 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.5, "evidenceWarrant": 68.3, "responsiveness": 96.60000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.6, "precisionClarity": 79.25, "calibrationCharity": 70.35 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -4.200000000000017, "evidenceWarrant": -1.1499999999999915, "responsiveness": 18.200000000000017, "relevanceBurden": 6.0, "precisionClarity": -8.75, "calibrationCharity": -10.050000000000011 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.0500000000000043, "evidenceWarrant": -0.22999999999999832, "responsiveness": 3.6400000000000037, "relevanceBurden": 0.8999999999999999, "precisionClarity": -0.875, "calibrationCharity": -1.0050000000000012 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3799999999999999 }, { "number": 114, "id": "dirckx-goff-consciousness-points-god-2019", "title": "Sharon Dirckx vs Philip Goff: Does Consciousness Point to God?", "motion": "Does consciousness point beyond materialism to God, or can a non-theistic panpsychist framework explain conscious experience without adding theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ef2vvT5GfoE", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 81, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Sharon Dirckx", "con": "Philip Goff" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.38333333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 71.94166666666666, "responsiveness": 72.7, "relevanceBurden": 86.53333333333333, "precisionClarity": 91.33333333333334, "calibrationCharity": 80.56666666666666 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.83500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 73.28999999999999, "responsiveness": 80.025, "relevanceBurden": 87.395, "precisionClarity": 90.25, "calibrationCharity": 80.07499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4516666666666822, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3483333333333292, "responsiveness": 7.325000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 0.8616666666666646, "precisionClarity": -1.0833333333333428, "calibrationCharity": -0.49166666666667425 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.36291666666667055, "evidenceWarrant": 0.26966666666666583, "responsiveness": 1.4650000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 0.12924999999999967, "precisionClarity": -0.10833333333333428, "calibrationCharity": -0.04916666666666743 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06933333333333502 }, { "number": 115, "id": "horn-bertuzzi-oconnor-schmid-problem-evil-2022", "title": "Trent Horn and Cameron Bertuzzi vs Alex O'Connor and Joe Schmid: Problem of Evil", "motion": "Does suffering, especially animal suffering and apparently gratuitous evil, make perfect-being theism improbable, or can theodicy, skeptical theism, higher goods, and Christian hope answer the challenge?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxUgziZ4vro", "date": "2026-07-28", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 78, "con": 84, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn and Cameron Bertuzzi", "con": "Alex O'Connor and Joe Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 26, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 116, "id": "bertuzzi-schieber-evil-evidence-2019", "title": "Cameron Bertuzzi vs Justin Schieber: The Problem of Evil", "motion": "Do facts about pain, pleasure, languishing, and horrendous evil count as evidence for naturalism over theism, or can soul-building and skeptical theism neutralize that evidential force?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=huOwbSrl-xw", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 87, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Cameron Bertuzzi", "con": "Justin Schieber" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.295, "evidenceWarrant": 66.125, "responsiveness": 84.63, "relevanceBurden": 86.33999999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.0, "calibrationCharity": 72.94000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.67, "evidenceWarrant": 78.19, "responsiveness": 96.22, "relevanceBurden": 85.55999999999999, "precisionClarity": 92.6, "calibrationCharity": 80.97 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.375, "evidenceWarrant": 12.064999999999998, "responsiveness": 11.590000000000003, "relevanceBurden": -0.7800000000000011, "precisionClarity": 9.599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 8.029999999999987 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.34375, "evidenceWarrant": 2.413, "responsiveness": 2.318000000000001, "relevanceBurden": -0.11700000000000016, "precisionClarity": 0.9599999999999995, "calibrationCharity": 0.8029999999999987 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2792500000000011 }, { "number": 117, "id": "bertuzzi-oconnor-contingency-argument-2018", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Cameron Bertuzzi: Something From Nothing?", "motion": "Does the contingency argument show that contingent reality requires a necessary foundation identifiable as God, or can determinism, composition worries, and a necessary-universe option block the inference?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DGpkGRoLBQ8", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 87, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Cameron Bertuzzi", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.862, "evidenceWarrant": 70.804, "responsiveness": 85.962, "relevanceBurden": 84.866, "precisionClarity": 85.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 78.778 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.86999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.99, "responsiveness": 97.75000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 92.8, "precisionClarity": 85.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 85.83 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.0079999999999956, "evidenceWarrant": 6.185999999999993, "responsiveness": 11.788000000000011, "relevanceBurden": 7.9339999999999975, "precisionClarity": 0.0, "calibrationCharity": 7.0519999999999925 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.7519999999999989, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2371999999999987, "responsiveness": 2.3576000000000024, "relevanceBurden": 1.1900999999999995, "precisionClarity": 0.0, "calibrationCharity": 0.7051999999999993 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.24209999999999887 }, { "number": 118, "id": "hernandez-schieber-god-existence-2023", "title": "Eric Hernandez vs Justin Schieber: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does theism or atheistic naturalism better explain evil, objective morality, knowledge, rationality, consciousness, free will, animal suffering, cosmic hostility, and non-resistant nonbelief?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sy1lUHGIQCQ", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 85, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Eric Hernandez", "con": "Justin Schieber" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.97, "evidenceWarrant": 62.559999999999995, "responsiveness": 82.16, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 77.1, "calibrationCharity": 65.82 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.67200000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 74.50999999999999, "responsiveness": 94.52799999999998, "relevanceBurden": 85.43199999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.0, "calibrationCharity": 84.234 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.702000000000012, "evidenceWarrant": 11.949999999999996, "responsiveness": 12.36799999999998, "relevanceBurden": -1.568000000000012, "precisionClarity": 12.900000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 18.414 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.925500000000003, "evidenceWarrant": 2.3899999999999992, "responsiveness": 2.4735999999999962, "relevanceBurden": -0.2352000000000018, "precisionClarity": 1.2900000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 1.8414000000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.314700000000002 }, { "number": 119, "id": "jones-oconnor-hell-2023", "title": "Michael Jones vs Alex O'Connor: Does God Send People to Hell?", "motion": "Can the Christian doctrine of hell be morally justified as self-chosen exile, sanctifying grace, and possible annihilation rather than external torture?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kOzmwGmiDHQ", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 87, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.82600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 66.574, "responsiveness": 92.02199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.78, "precisionClarity": 81.64, "calibrationCharity": 78.78999999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.06000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 77.08, "responsiveness": 92.55, "relevanceBurden": 85.19999999999999, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 88.55000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.234000000000009, "evidenceWarrant": 10.506, "responsiveness": 0.5280000000000058, "relevanceBurden": -0.5800000000000125, "precisionClarity": 13.36, "calibrationCharity": 9.76000000000002 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.308500000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1012, "responsiveness": 0.10560000000000117, "relevanceBurden": -0.08700000000000187, "precisionClarity": 1.336, "calibrationCharity": 0.976000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.25969999999999605 }, { "number": 120, "id": "mclatchie-oconnor-christianity-true-2019", "title": "Jonathan McLatchie vs Alex O'Connor: Is Christianity True?", "motion": "Is Christianity true, especially in light of resurrection evidence, Gospel reliability, and the moral authority of biblical teaching?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=woqy13ZkeqM", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 83, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.33399999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 74.59, "responsiveness": 90.26400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.231, "precisionClarity": 83.72, "calibrationCharity": 78.398 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.95233333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 75.885, "responsiveness": 84.36533333333334, "relevanceBurden": 82.67599999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.86, "calibrationCharity": 81.19166666666668 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.6183333333333536, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2950000000000017, "responsiveness": -5.898666666666671, "relevanceBurden": -1.5550000000000068, "precisionClarity": 1.1400000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 2.793666666666681 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.6545833333333384, "evidenceWarrant": 0.25900000000000034, "responsiveness": -1.1797333333333342, "relevanceBurden": -0.233250000000001, "precisionClarity": 0.11400000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 0.2793666666666681 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.1060333333333283 }, { "number": 121, "id": "dawkins-lennox-science-buried-god-2017", "title": "Richard Dawkins vs John Lennox: Has Science Buried God?", "motion": "Has science buried God, or can Christian theism still explain rationality, design, miracles, morality, and fine-tuning?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OVEuQg_Mglw", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 82, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.19, "evidenceWarrant": 64.605, "responsiveness": 73.4, "relevanceBurden": 85.3, "precisionClarity": 86.7, "calibrationCharity": 75.94 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.6, "evidenceWarrant": 74.2, "responsiveness": 87.75000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.225, "precisionClarity": 86.5, "calibrationCharity": 76.625 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.409999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 9.594999999999999, "responsiveness": 14.350000000000009, "relevanceBurden": -1.0750000000000028, "precisionClarity": -0.20000000000000284, "calibrationCharity": 0.6850000000000023 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1024999999999991, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9189999999999998, "responsiveness": 2.870000000000002, "relevanceBurden": -0.16125000000000042, "precisionClarity": -0.020000000000000285, "calibrationCharity": 0.06850000000000023 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2212499999999995 }, { "number": 122, "id": "horn-oconnor-god-existence-2020", "title": "Trent Horn vs Alex O'Connor: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do contingency, sufficient reason, moral realism, evil, animal suffering, and quantum randomness support or undermine theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5PF1JgXOKDQ", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 83, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.98400000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 63.696, "responsiveness": 87.90799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.94, "precisionClarity": 81.16, "calibrationCharity": 71.36200000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.762, "evidenceWarrant": 73.964, "responsiveness": 93.422, "relevanceBurden": 85.2, "precisionClarity": 90.19999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 86.32 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.777999999999992, "evidenceWarrant": 10.268, "responsiveness": 5.51400000000001, "relevanceBurden": -2.739999999999995, "precisionClarity": 9.039999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 14.957999999999984 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.694499999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 2.0536000000000003, "responsiveness": 1.102800000000002, "relevanceBurden": -0.4109999999999992, "precisionClarity": 0.9039999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.4957999999999985 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.8396999999999988 }, { "number": 123, "id": "oconnor-pine-divine-hiddenness-2024", "title": "Gregory Pine vs Alex O'Connor: The Divine Hiddenness Problem", "motion": "Does divine hiddenness, uneven religious geography, sincere nonbelief, hell, and original sin count against Catholic theism, or can grace, providence, and creaturely agency explain them?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8k9A7d2Wnjk", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 87, "con_gap": 13, "speakers": { "pro": "Gregory Pine", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 13, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.51, "evidenceWarrant": 64.33, "responsiveness": 66.74499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.41999999999999, "precisionClarity": 79.0, "calibrationCharity": 74.565 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.22999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.72, "responsiveness": 96.74, "relevanceBurden": 84.29999999999998, "precisionClarity": 93.0, "calibrationCharity": 89.1 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.719999999999985, "evidenceWarrant": 11.39, "responsiveness": 29.995000000000005, "relevanceBurden": -0.12000000000000455, "precisionClarity": 14.0, "calibrationCharity": 14.534999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.429999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 2.278, "responsiveness": 5.999000000000001, "relevanceBurden": -0.018000000000000682, "precisionClarity": 1.4000000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.4534999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5424999999999969 }, { "number": 124, "id": "harris-peterson-god-atheism-bible-2018", "title": "Sam Harris vs Jordan Peterson: God, Atheism, The Bible, Jesus", "motion": "Can religious stories, God-language, and biblical tradition ground moral truth and meaning, or should moral realism, well-being, and open inquiry replace dogmatic religious frameworks?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jey_CzIOfYE", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 84, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Sam Harris" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.33999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 67.35499999999999, "responsiveness": 84.30499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.89, "precisionClarity": 76.35, "calibrationCharity": 79.78 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.40700000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 74.988, "responsiveness": 91.684, "relevanceBurden": 84.39, "precisionClarity": 83.42, "calibrationCharity": 83.08099999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.067000000000021, "evidenceWarrant": 7.63300000000001, "responsiveness": 7.379000000000005, "relevanceBurden": 0.5, "precisionClarity": 7.070000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 3.3009999999999877 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.0167500000000054, "evidenceWarrant": 1.526600000000002, "responsiveness": 1.475800000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.075, "precisionClarity": 0.7070000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 0.3300999999999988 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.13125000000000764 }, { "number": 125, "id": "knechtles-oconnor-bible-ethics-grace-2024", "title": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle vs Alex O'Connor: Bible Slavery, Women, and Forgiveness", "motion": "Can Christian scripture and the gospel of grace give a coherent account of suffering, gender, slavery, violence, forgiveness, and salvation, or do those texts and doctrines create unresolved moral problems?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r8RZarGC8B4", "date": "2026-07-29", "model": null, "rubric": null, "pro": 74, "con": 86, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe and Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 126, "id": "craig-clifton-kalam-cosmological-argument-2021", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Scott Clifton: The Kalam Cosmological Argument", "motion": "Does the Kalam causal premise justify a transcendent cause of the universe, or is ordinary causation too bound to space, time, and material conditions to support that inference?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TmYCwjU_5Wc", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 88, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Scott Clifton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.212, "evidenceWarrant": 70.324, "responsiveness": 94.416, "relevanceBurden": 87.66799999999999, "precisionClarity": 87.08, "calibrationCharity": 75.91199999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.272, "evidenceWarrant": 80.09200000000001, "responsiveness": 98.652, "relevanceBurden": 84.43599999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.60000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 89.21199999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.060000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 9.768000000000015, "responsiveness": 4.236000000000004, "relevanceBurden": -3.2319999999999993, "precisionClarity": 3.5200000000000102, "calibrationCharity": 13.299999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.2650000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9536000000000031, "responsiveness": 0.8472000000000008, "relevanceBurden": -0.4847999999999999, "precisionClarity": 0.35200000000000103, "calibrationCharity": 1.3299999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.26300000000000523 }, { "number": 127, "id": "slick-clifton-objective-morality-god-2014", "title": "Matt Slick vs Scott Clifton: Does Objective Morality Require God?", "motion": "Does objective morality require God as its necessary foundation, or can secular moral reasoning explain the relevant moral truths and obligations?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uJeKS705aXs", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 89, "con_gap": 19, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Slick", "con": "Scott Clifton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 19, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 65.13, "evidenceWarrant": 61.31999999999999, "responsiveness": 73.06, "relevanceBurden": 84.9, "precisionClarity": 77.2, "calibrationCharity": 62.43000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.51999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 82.80000000000001, "responsiveness": 95.86000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.48, "precisionClarity": 93.2, "calibrationCharity": 89.58 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 22.389999999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 21.480000000000018, "responsiveness": 22.80000000000001, "relevanceBurden": -0.4200000000000017, "precisionClarity": 16.0, "calibrationCharity": 27.14999999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 5.597499999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 4.296000000000004, "responsiveness": 4.560000000000002, "relevanceBurden": -0.06300000000000025, "precisionClarity": 1.6, "calibrationCharity": 2.7149999999999994 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2944999999999993 }, { "number": 128, "id": "craig-law-evil-god-challenge-2011", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Stephen Law: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do Craig's cumulative arguments overcome Law's evidential problem of evil and evil-God symmetry challenge?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=APfd7B3CEhI", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 88, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Stephen Law" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.93, "evidenceWarrant": 65.16, "responsiveness": 77.8, "relevanceBurden": 85.14, "precisionClarity": 85.85, "calibrationCharity": 67.78 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.0, "evidenceWarrant": 80.96000000000001, "responsiveness": 89.83, "relevanceBurden": 88.81, "precisionClarity": 92.6, "calibrationCharity": 91.145 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 14.069999999999993, "evidenceWarrant": 15.800000000000011, "responsiveness": 12.030000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 3.6700000000000017, "precisionClarity": 6.75, "calibrationCharity": 23.364999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.5174999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": 3.1600000000000024, "responsiveness": 2.4060000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 0.5505000000000002, "precisionClarity": 0.675, "calibrationCharity": 2.3364999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.645500000000002 }, { "number": 129, "id": "plantinga-law-eaan-rational-belief-2010", "title": "Alvin Plantinga vs Stephen Law: Is the EAAN Successful?", "motion": "Is the evolutionary argument against naturalism successful at showing that naturalism plus evolution gives its believers a defeater for trusting their cognitive faculties?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAJHkRkWCm0", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 81, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Alvin Plantinga", "con": "Stephen Law" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.575, "evidenceWarrant": 69.94999999999999, "responsiveness": 90.025, "relevanceBurden": 86.45, "precisionClarity": 88.5, "calibrationCharity": 74.95 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.875, "evidenceWarrant": 70.125, "responsiveness": 86.5625, "relevanceBurden": 86.32499999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.375, "calibrationCharity": 82.1875 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 130, "id": "licona-carrier-resurrection-history-2010", "title": "Mike Licona vs Richard Carrier: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead, and does the resurrection hypothesis better explain early Christian testimony than naturalistic alternatives?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0IpKHdVLZb4", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 83, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.05, "evidenceWarrant": 67.45, "responsiveness": 92.17500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.2, "precisionClarity": 78.75, "calibrationCharity": 75.85 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.3, "evidenceWarrant": 71.875, "responsiveness": 98.05, "relevanceBurden": 85.925, "precisionClarity": 79.5, "calibrationCharity": 78.75 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.25, "evidenceWarrant": 4.424999999999997, "responsiveness": 5.874999999999986, "relevanceBurden": -1.2750000000000057, "precisionClarity": 0.75, "calibrationCharity": 2.9000000000000057 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.3125, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8849999999999995, "responsiveness": 1.1749999999999972, "relevanceBurden": -0.19125000000000084, "precisionClarity": 0.07500000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 0.2900000000000006 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.45375000000000343 }, { "number": 131, "id": "boyce-carrier-historical-jesus-mythicism-2022", "title": "Stephen Boyce vs Richard Carrier: Did Jesus Exist?", "motion": "Did Jesus exist as a historical person, or did early Christian belief begin with a celestial or mythic Christ later placed in history?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bC-Uj92Cpvg", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 83, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Boyce", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.17333333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 68.245, "responsiveness": 86.54166666666666, "relevanceBurden": 79.75333333333333, "precisionClarity": 83.66666666666666, "calibrationCharity": 72.95666666666668 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.23, "evidenceWarrant": 72.555, "responsiveness": 94.98499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.24499999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.3, "calibrationCharity": 78.02 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 132, "id": "mclatchie-carrier-paul-celestial-jesus-2018", "title": "Jonathan McLatchie vs Richard Carrier: Did Paul Believe in a Celestial Jesus?", "motion": "Did Paul understand Jesus as an earthly historical person, or as a celestial figure whose death and resurrection occurred in a mythic heavenly realm?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCcq8G-WzJM", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 83, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.08, "evidenceWarrant": 75.27, "responsiveness": 83.74000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 82.4, "precisionClarity": 82.25, "calibrationCharity": 73.94500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.74999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 71.885, "responsiveness": 93.30600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.773, "precisionClarity": 90.2, "calibrationCharity": 72.581 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 133, "id": "hawkins-folley-free-will-idealism-2026", "title": "Nathan Hawkins vs Joe Folley: Free Will, Compatibilism, and Idealism", "motion": "Can libertarian free will and Bradleyan idealism answer determinist and naturalist pressure better than compatibilist pragmatism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSXawgwSZQs", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 85, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Nathan Hawkins", "con": "Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.825, "evidenceWarrant": 66.81, "responsiveness": 89.45, "relevanceBurden": 85.70499999999998, "precisionClarity": 79.0, "calibrationCharity": 71.19500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.13, "evidenceWarrant": 76.63999999999999, "responsiveness": 95.13, "relevanceBurden": 84.22, "precisionClarity": 85.2, "calibrationCharity": 89.04 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 134, "id": "macdonald-carrier-jesus-mythicism-mimesis-2025", "title": "Dennis R. MacDonald vs Richard Carrier: Did Jesus Exist?", "motion": "Did Jesus exist as a historical Jewish teacher later mythologized, or did early Christianity begin with a revelatory Christ only later placed in history?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a2sBEFE3etc", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 81, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Dennis R. MacDonald", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.00500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 69.09, "responsiveness": 88.58500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.71000000000001, "precisionClarity": 82.05, "calibrationCharity": 73.40499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.521, "evidenceWarrant": 67.901, "responsiveness": 91.48, "relevanceBurden": 84.207, "precisionClarity": 85.8, "calibrationCharity": 75.728 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 135, "id": "ehrman-price-historical-jesus-mythicism-2016", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs Robert Price: Did Jesus Exist?", "motion": "Did a first-century Jewish preacher named Jesus exist behind the Christian traditions, or did Christianity develop from mythic and scriptural materials without such a person?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GzjYmpwbHEA", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 81, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Bart Ehrman", "con": "Robert Price" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 86.08500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 77.235, "responsiveness": 94.33500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 88.95, "precisionClarity": 82.75, "calibrationCharity": 78.29 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.60000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 70.125, "responsiveness": 93.47500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 82.875, "precisionClarity": 84.5, "calibrationCharity": 79.60000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 136, "id": "douthat-ehrman-resurrection-gospel-history-2026", "title": "Ross Douthat vs Bart Ehrman: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "How much historical confidence should readers place in the Gospels and resurrection accounts: reliable witness traces or later traditions shaped by memory, theology, and debate?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V7EwdZ0Z_gc", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 86, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Ross Douthat", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.935, "evidenceWarrant": 74.29, "responsiveness": 95.09, "relevanceBurden": 83.625, "precisionClarity": 83.65, "calibrationCharity": 84.415 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.11000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 81.255, "responsiveness": 86.10500000000002, "relevanceBurden": 82.86, "precisionClarity": 93.0, "calibrationCharity": 87.05 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.175000000000011, "evidenceWarrant": 6.964999999999989, "responsiveness": -8.984999999999985, "relevanceBurden": -0.7650000000000006, "precisionClarity": 9.349999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 2.634999999999991 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0437500000000028, "evidenceWarrant": 1.392999999999998, "responsiveness": -1.796999999999997, "relevanceBurden": -0.11475000000000007, "precisionClarity": 0.9349999999999995, "calibrationCharity": 0.2634999999999991 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.27649999999999775 }, { "number": 137, "id": "price-craig-resurrection-historical-analogy-1999", "title": "Robert Price vs William Lane Craig: Did Jesus Rise From the Dead?", "motion": "Do the earliest Christian sources establish burial, an empty tomb, appearances, and resurrection belief such that God raising Jesus best explains the evidence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pba-YNVWaa0", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 80, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Robert Price" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.19999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.628, "responsiveness": 87.208, "relevanceBurden": 88.228, "precisionClarity": 85.48, "calibrationCharity": 73.628 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.156, "evidenceWarrant": 65.584, "responsiveness": 92.94800000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.35600000000001, "precisionClarity": 81.52, "calibrationCharity": 74.46 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -6.043999999999983, "evidenceWarrant": -10.043999999999997, "responsiveness": 5.740000000000009, "relevanceBurden": -1.8719999999999857, "precisionClarity": -3.960000000000008, "calibrationCharity": 0.8319999999999936 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.5109999999999957, "evidenceWarrant": -2.0087999999999995, "responsiveness": 1.148000000000002, "relevanceBurden": -0.28079999999999783, "precisionClarity": -0.3960000000000008, "calibrationCharity": 0.08319999999999937 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.03460000000000729 }, { "number": 138, "id": "albrecht-price-bodily-resurrection-2022", "title": "William Albrecht vs Robert Price: Did Jesus Bodily Rise from the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus Christ bodily rise from the dead, as early Christian sources claim?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CqpFmw4pwrY", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 80, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Albrecht", "con": "Robert Price" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.37499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.975, "responsiveness": 85.63499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.14500000000001, "precisionClarity": 78.6, "calibrationCharity": 72.46000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.299, "evidenceWarrant": 72.153, "responsiveness": 89.70500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.966, "precisionClarity": 78.3, "calibrationCharity": 72.985 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.924000000000021, "evidenceWarrant": 1.1780000000000115, "responsiveness": 4.070000000000022, "relevanceBurden": 1.8209999999999837, "precisionClarity": -0.29999999999999716, "calibrationCharity": 0.5249999999999915 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.7310000000000052, "evidenceWarrant": 0.2356000000000023, "responsiveness": 0.8140000000000044, "relevanceBurden": 0.27314999999999756, "precisionClarity": -0.029999999999999718, "calibrationCharity": 0.05249999999999915 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.07625000000000881 }, { "number": 139, "id": "adelstein-dillahunty-belief-god-2025", "title": "Matthew Adelstein vs Matt Dillahunty: Should We Believe in God?", "motion": "Should we believe in an all-knowing, all-powerful, morally perfect being?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vHxAw5-RXIw", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 89, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Matthew Adelstein", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.38799999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 69.646, "responsiveness": 91.15199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 88.062, "precisionClarity": 79.88, "calibrationCharity": 75.27199999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.768, "evidenceWarrant": 82.26299999999999, "responsiveness": 98.539, "relevanceBurden": 83.33, "precisionClarity": 94.22, "calibrationCharity": 88.768 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.38000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 12.61699999999999, "responsiveness": 7.387000000000015, "relevanceBurden": -4.731999999999999, "precisionClarity": 14.340000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 13.49600000000001 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5950000000000024, "evidenceWarrant": 2.5233999999999983, "responsiveness": 1.477400000000003, "relevanceBurden": -0.7097999999999999, "precisionClarity": 1.4340000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 1.349600000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6696000000000044 }, { "number": 140, "id": "rhodes-dillahunty-evidence-god-2021", "title": "Kenny Rhodes vs Matt Dillahunty: Is There Evidence for God?", "motion": "Is there good evidence for the existence of the God of classical theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0Q_KMN64bk", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 88, "con_gap": 18, "speakers": { "pro": "Kenny Rhodes", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 18, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 63.419999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 55.935, "responsiveness": 81.795, "relevanceBurden": 85.58999999999999, "precisionClarity": 76.2, "calibrationCharity": 61.275 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.835, "evidenceWarrant": 82.765, "responsiveness": 93.64, "relevanceBurden": 85.74, "precisionClarity": 93.4, "calibrationCharity": 87.42 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 24.415, "evidenceWarrant": 26.83, "responsiveness": 11.844999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.15000000000000568, "precisionClarity": 17.200000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 26.145000000000003 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 6.10375, "evidenceWarrant": 5.366, "responsiveness": 2.3689999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.022500000000000853, "precisionClarity": 1.7200000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 2.6145000000000005 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.1957500000000003 }, { "number": 141, "id": "fischer-dillahunty-axiomatic-evidence-god-2020", "title": "Ben Fischer vs Matt Dillahunty: Is There Good Evidence for God?", "motion": "Is there good evidence for God, rather than merely an asserted epistemic starting point?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KByryLId3dQ", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 86, "con_gap": 18, "speakers": { "pro": "Ben Fischer", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 18, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 65.444, "evidenceWarrant": 54.07833333333333, "responsiveness": 70.12100000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.83466666666666, "precisionClarity": 72.09166666666667, "calibrationCharity": 65.58566666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.878, "evidenceWarrant": 81.399, "responsiveness": 81.45799999999998, "relevanceBurden": 87.786, "precisionClarity": 93.63999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 86.75099999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 23.433999999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 27.320666666666668, "responsiveness": 11.336999999999975, "relevanceBurden": 3.951333333333338, "precisionClarity": 21.548333333333318, "calibrationCharity": 21.165333333333322 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 5.858499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 5.464133333333334, "responsiveness": 2.267399999999995, "relevanceBurden": 0.5927000000000007, "precisionClarity": 2.154833333333332, "calibrationCharity": 2.1165333333333325 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4540999999999933 }, { "number": 142, "id": "comfort-dillahunty-gospel-atonement-2020", "title": "Ray Comfort vs Matt Dillahunty: Does the Gospel Make Sense?", "motion": "Does the Christian gospel's account of sin, atonement, and salvation make moral and explanatory sense?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cRCbvfyiu0s", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 86, "con_gap": 18, "speakers": { "pro": "Ray Comfort", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 18, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 63.891999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 50.331999999999994, "responsiveness": 75.299, "relevanceBurden": 84.25200000000001, "precisionClarity": 79.71, "calibrationCharity": 56.650000000000006 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.465, "evidenceWarrant": 78.62200000000001, "responsiveness": 96.169, "relevanceBurden": 85.70400000000001, "precisionClarity": 90.69, "calibrationCharity": 81.385 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 19.573000000000008, "evidenceWarrant": 28.29000000000002, "responsiveness": 20.86999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 1.4519999999999982, "precisionClarity": 10.980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 24.735 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.893250000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 5.658000000000005, "responsiveness": 4.173999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.21779999999999972, "precisionClarity": 1.0980000000000005, "calibrationCharity": 2.4735 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.514550000000007 }, { "number": 143, "id": "vela-dillahunty-transcendental-evidence-god-2020", "title": "Tyler Vela vs Matt Dillahunty: Is There Good Evidence for God?", "motion": "Do laws of logic and other transcendental facts provide good evidence for a necessary personal God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kf0Us__r9SQ", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 84, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Tyler Vela", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.89, "evidenceWarrant": 63.334999999999994, "responsiveness": 86.395, "relevanceBurden": 84.84, "precisionClarity": 79.7, "calibrationCharity": 66.255 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.25, "evidenceWarrant": 74.05, "responsiveness": 93.575, "relevanceBurden": 87.0, "precisionClarity": 87.5, "calibrationCharity": 82.72500000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.36, "evidenceWarrant": 10.715000000000003, "responsiveness": 7.180000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 2.1599999999999966, "precisionClarity": 7.799999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 16.470000000000013 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.34, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1430000000000007, "responsiveness": 1.4360000000000015, "relevanceBurden": 0.32399999999999946, "precisionClarity": 0.7799999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 1.6470000000000014 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6700000000000035 }, { "number": 144, "id": "plantinga-dennett-evolution-naturalism-2018", "title": "Alvin Plantinga vs Daniel Dennett: Science, Religion, and Evolution", "motion": "Are evolutionary science and theistic religion compatible, and does naturalism plus evolution undercut trust in human cognition?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f06J2R4MwGA", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 84, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Alvin Plantinga", "con": "Daniel Dennett" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.91600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 72.946, "responsiveness": 86.376, "relevanceBurden": 86.938, "precisionClarity": 90.75999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 81.75 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.42, "evidenceWarrant": 73.32000000000001, "responsiveness": 92.41, "relevanceBurden": 84.38, "precisionClarity": 85.4, "calibrationCharity": 82.91 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -0.4960000000000093, "evidenceWarrant": 0.37400000000000944, "responsiveness": 6.033999999999992, "relevanceBurden": -2.558000000000007, "precisionClarity": -5.359999999999985, "calibrationCharity": 1.1599999999999966 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.12400000000000233, "evidenceWarrant": 0.07480000000000189, "responsiveness": 1.2067999999999985, "relevanceBurden": -0.38370000000000104, "precisionClarity": -0.5359999999999986, "calibrationCharity": 0.11599999999999966 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.6461000000000019 }, { "number": 145, "id": "dennett-dsouza-god-human-invention-2007", "title": "Daniel Dennett vs Dinesh D'Souza: Is God a Human Invention?", "motion": "Is God a human invention, or do cosmological fine-tuning, morality, consciousness, and religious experience provide rational support for a real divine creator?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocZh8vhz_Hs", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 75, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Daniel Dennett", "con": "Dinesh D'Souza" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.375, "evidenceWarrant": 67.95, "responsiveness": 81.975, "relevanceBurden": 86.79999999999998, "precisionClarity": 84.5, "calibrationCharity": 78.02499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 71.75999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 64.21, "responsiveness": 79.05000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.345, "precisionClarity": 78.45, "calibrationCharity": 71.35 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.615000000000009, "evidenceWarrant": 3.740000000000009, "responsiveness": 2.924999999999983, "relevanceBurden": 2.454999999999984, "precisionClarity": 6.049999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 6.674999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.4037500000000023, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7480000000000019, "responsiveness": 0.5849999999999966, "relevanceBurden": 0.3682499999999976, "precisionClarity": 0.6049999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 0.6674999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3774999999999977 }, { "number": 146, "id": "harris-dennett-free-will-2018", "title": "Sam Harris vs Daniel Dennett: Does Free Will Exist?", "motion": "Does determinism or indeterminism undermine free will and moral responsibility, or can reasons-responsive agency provide a compatibilist form of freedom worth preserving?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_J_9DKIAn48", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 88, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Sam Harris", "con": "Daniel Dennett" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.99699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 72.24799999999999, "responsiveness": 87.85600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.10399999999998, "precisionClarity": 84.0, "calibrationCharity": 80.124 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.66199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 77.42, "responsiveness": 95.654, "relevanceBurden": 86.46000000000001, "precisionClarity": 92.19999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 86.41 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 147, "id": "dennett-clayton-naturalism-ultimate-reality-2012", "title": "Daniel Dennett vs Philip Clayton: Naturalism and Ultimate Reality", "motion": "Does naturalism fully explain mind, intentionality, morality, and reality, or does a religious account of ultimate reality offer an additional explanatory framework?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h-I_9e5qxnc", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 82, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Daniel Dennett", "con": "Philip Clayton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.25800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 74.67999999999999, "responsiveness": 93.74400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 89.662, "precisionClarity": 92.04, "calibrationCharity": 77.01 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.37499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 72.46600000000001, "responsiveness": 92.59599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 81.79700000000001, "precisionClarity": 84.64, "calibrationCharity": 83.961 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.883000000000024, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2139999999999844, "responsiveness": 1.1480000000000246, "relevanceBurden": 7.864999999999995, "precisionClarity": 7.400000000000006, "calibrationCharity": -6.950999999999993 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.220750000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 0.4427999999999969, "responsiveness": 0.2296000000000049, "relevanceBurden": 1.1797499999999992, "precisionClarity": 0.7400000000000007, "calibrationCharity": -0.6950999999999994 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.8821999999999917 }, { "number": 148, "id": "baggett-dillahunty-moral-argument-2018", "title": "David Baggett vs Matt Dillahunty: The Moral Argument for God", "motion": "Do objective moral facts, moral knowledge, moral transformation, and moral rationality make theism a better explanation than secular ethical theories?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWeOWtmCoCs", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 86, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "David Baggett", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.654, "evidenceWarrant": 74.477, "responsiveness": 90.19300000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.44, "precisionClarity": 88.35, "calibrationCharity": 87.869 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.975, "evidenceWarrant": 76.05, "responsiveness": 95.635, "relevanceBurden": 86.5, "precisionClarity": 89.9, "calibrationCharity": 86.80499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.679000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 1.5729999999999933, "responsiveness": 5.441999999999993, "relevanceBurden": 3.0600000000000023, "precisionClarity": 1.5500000000000114, "calibrationCharity": -1.0640000000000072 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.4197500000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 0.31459999999999866, "responsiveness": 1.0883999999999987, "relevanceBurden": 0.4590000000000003, "precisionClarity": 0.15500000000000114, "calibrationCharity": -0.10640000000000072 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.49084999999999757 }, { "number": 149, "id": "alexander-moody-carroll-novella-death-2014", "title": "Eben Alexander and Raymond Moody vs Sean Carroll and Steven Novella: Is Death Final?", "motion": "Does consciousness survive bodily death, or are near-death experiences and reports of apparent contact with the dead better explained as brain-based and psychological phenomena?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=07EYacr3rBg", "date": "2026-07-31", "model": "5.6 Terra Extra High", "rubric": null, "pro": 58, "con": 86, "con_gap": 28, "speakers": { "pro": "Eben Alexander and Raymond Moody", "con": "Sean Carroll and Steven Novella" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 10, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 150, "id": "licona-dillahunty-resurrection-evidence-2017", "title": "Mike Licona vs Matt Dillahunty: Was Jesus Raised from the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead, and can historical evidence plus allegedly supernatural phenomena justify that conclusion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IW9w6c2RWmA", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 88, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.71000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 69.17, "responsiveness": 85.295, "relevanceBurden": 85.305, "precisionClarity": 79.60000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 72.73 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.34, "evidenceWarrant": 80.715, "responsiveness": 96.19, "relevanceBurden": 86.24000000000001, "precisionClarity": 92.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 84.74999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.6299999999999955, "evidenceWarrant": 11.545000000000002, "responsiveness": 10.894999999999996, "relevanceBurden": 0.9350000000000023, "precisionClarity": 12.799999999999983, "calibrationCharity": 12.019999999999982 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6574999999999989, "evidenceWarrant": 2.3090000000000006, "responsiveness": 2.1789999999999994, "relevanceBurden": 0.14025000000000035, "precisionClarity": 1.2799999999999985, "calibrationCharity": 1.2019999999999982 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.23225000000000406 }, { "number": 151, "id": "wood-dillahunty-god-secular-humanism-2020", "title": "David Wood vs Matt Dillahunty: God or Secular Humanism?", "motion": "Which gives a better foundation for ethics: God or secular humanism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2SjOn8arv8", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 84, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "David Wood", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.429, "evidenceWarrant": 64.754, "responsiveness": 89.54399999999998, "relevanceBurden": 86.32399999999998, "precisionClarity": 84.4, "calibrationCharity": 73.54299999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.938, "evidenceWarrant": 76.197, "responsiveness": 90.868, "relevanceBurden": 84.84, "precisionClarity": 86.8, "calibrationCharity": 81.5 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.509, "evidenceWarrant": 11.442999999999998, "responsiveness": 1.3240000000000123, "relevanceBurden": -1.4839999999999804, "precisionClarity": 2.3999999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 7.957000000000008 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.87725, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2885999999999997, "responsiveness": 0.2648000000000025, "relevanceBurden": -0.22259999999999705, "precisionClarity": 0.23999999999999916, "calibrationCharity": 0.7957000000000009 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.24375000000000568 }, { "number": 152, "id": "knechtle-aron-ra-god-existence-2023", "title": "Stuart Knechtle vs Aron Ra: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist, and do design, morality, logic, and experience support that conclusion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9r_XAIksLdI", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 78, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Aron Ra" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.924, "evidenceWarrant": 56.529999999999994, "responsiveness": 74.676, "relevanceBurden": 84.388, "precisionClarity": 78.92, "calibrationCharity": 69.63600000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.686, "evidenceWarrant": 67.92099999999999, "responsiveness": 83.175, "relevanceBurden": 86.79599999999999, "precisionClarity": 81.27, "calibrationCharity": 71.082 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.762, "evidenceWarrant": 11.390999999999998, "responsiveness": 8.498999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 2.407999999999987, "precisionClarity": 2.3499999999999943, "calibrationCharity": 1.4459999999999837 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.4405, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2781999999999996, "responsiveness": 1.699799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.361199999999998, "precisionClarity": 0.23499999999999943, "calibrationCharity": 0.14459999999999837 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.15929999999999467 }, { "number": 153, "id": "oconnor-carter-free-will-determinism-2024", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Dr Alex Carter: Free Will and Determinism", "motion": "Do determinism and unchosen desires eliminate free will, or can determined agents be free when acting voluntarily and without coercion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRpsJgYVl-8", "date": "2026-08-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 82, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Alex O'Connor", "con": "Alex Carter" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.74616666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 71.64016666666667, "responsiveness": 84.94200000000001, "relevanceBurden": 80.22916666666667, "precisionClarity": 80.44, "calibrationCharity": 73.84366666666666 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.56666666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 73.57466666666666, "responsiveness": 89.59533333333334, "relevanceBurden": 86.01733333333334, "precisionClarity": 81.82000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 83.38066666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 154, "id": "koukl-oconnor-kanojia-nonbelief-harm-2025", "title": "Greg Koukl, Alex O'Connor, and Alok Kanojia: Does Nonbelief Cause More Harm Than Good?", "motion": "Does nonbelief leave people without the purpose and moral grounding needed to flourish, or can secular and spiritual practices sustain meaningful lives without Christian theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Esu8BXLBmZ4", "date": "2026-07-31", "model": "5.6 Terra Extra High", "rubric": null, "pro": 67, "con": 79, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Greg Koukl", "con": "Alex O'Connor and Alok Kanojia" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 } }, { "number": 155, "id": "turek-shermer-morality-god-science-2015", "title": "Frank Turek vs Michael Shermer: Is Morality Better Explained by God or Science?", "motion": "Is objective morality better explained by God as its personal ground, or by science, evolution, and human flourishing?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HKKofNwvt1k", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 79, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Michael Shermer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.475, "evidenceWarrant": 63.0, "responsiveness": 85.825, "relevanceBurden": 83.05000000000001, "precisionClarity": 79.125, "calibrationCharity": 67.575 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.16, "evidenceWarrant": 69.54, "responsiveness": 86.175, "relevanceBurden": 85.38, "precisionClarity": 78.85, "calibrationCharity": 71.41 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.685000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 6.540000000000006, "responsiveness": 0.3499999999999943, "relevanceBurden": 2.329999999999984, "precisionClarity": -0.2750000000000057, "calibrationCharity": 3.8349999999999937 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1712500000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 1.3080000000000014, "responsiveness": 0.06999999999999887, "relevanceBurden": 0.3494999999999976, "precisionClarity": -0.02750000000000057, "calibrationCharity": 0.3834999999999994 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.25474999999999737 }, { "number": 156, "id": "harris-prager-religion-morality-public-reason-2014", "title": "Sam Harris vs Dennis Prager: Religion, Morality, and Public Reason", "motion": "Does religious belief better ground moral knowledge and identify social evil, or can secular ethical realism guide moral progress without sacred texts?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elMi_IzlD40", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 81, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Dennis Prager", "con": "Sam Harris" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 13, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.35, "evidenceWarrant": 54.29999999999999, "responsiveness": 77.45, "relevanceBurden": 83.19999999999999, "precisionClarity": 75.0, "calibrationCharity": 63.949999999999996 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.89, "evidenceWarrant": 70.86, "responsiveness": 85.26, "relevanceBurden": 83.75999999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.3, "calibrationCharity": 79.97999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.540000000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 16.56000000000001, "responsiveness": 7.810000000000002, "relevanceBurden": 0.5600000000000023, "precisionClarity": 8.299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 16.029999999999994 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.1350000000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 3.312000000000002, "responsiveness": 1.5620000000000005, "relevanceBurden": 0.08400000000000034, "precisionClarity": 0.8299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 1.6029999999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.47399999999999665 }, { "number": 157, "id": "dillahunty-howitt-christianity-true-2023", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Lewis Howitt: Is Christianity True?", "motion": "Is Christianity true, and do the grounding of logic, a necessary cause, divine hiddenness, and the relation of reason to revelation support or undermine it?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13PnL6QyMEw", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 88, "con_gap": 17, "speakers": { "pro": "Lewis Howitt", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 17, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 66.455, "evidenceWarrant": 57.1, "responsiveness": 78.375, "relevanceBurden": 83.25, "precisionClarity": 76.0, "calibrationCharity": 65.75 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.776, "evidenceWarrant": 79.899, "responsiveness": 93.18299999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.348, "precisionClarity": 93.72, "calibrationCharity": 88.338 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 21.320999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 22.799, "responsiveness": 14.807999999999993, "relevanceBurden": 2.097999999999999, "precisionClarity": 17.72, "calibrationCharity": 22.587999999999994 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 5.3302499999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 4.5598, "responsiveness": 2.961599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 0.3146999999999998, "precisionClarity": 1.772, "calibrationCharity": 2.2587999999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.19714999999999705 }, { "number": 158, "id": "dillahunty-mclatchie-resurrection-evidence-2020", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Jonathan McLatchie: Is There Strong Evidence for the Resurrection?", "motion": "Is there strong historical evidence that Jesus rose from the dead, or are the surviving Christian reports too indirect and insufficiently testable to establish a resurrection?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a-wIaCRIdOA", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 83, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.646, "evidenceWarrant": 69.298, "responsiveness": 80.98599999999999, "relevanceBurden": 81.51499999999999, "precisionClarity": 82.30000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 73.37899999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.535, "evidenceWarrant": 73.802, "responsiveness": 90.059, "relevanceBurden": 80.60499999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 81.269 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.888999999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 4.504000000000005, "responsiveness": 9.073000000000008, "relevanceBurden": -0.9099999999999966, "precisionClarity": 3.09999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 7.890000000000015 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.222249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 0.900800000000001, "responsiveness": 1.8146000000000015, "relevanceBurden": -0.13649999999999948, "precisionClarity": 0.30999999999999805, "calibrationCharity": 0.7890000000000015 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.09984999999999822 }, { "number": 159, "id": "wood-aron-ra-naturalism-2023", "title": "David Wood vs Aron Ra: Is Naturalism True?", "motion": "Is naturalism true, or does an evolutionary naturalist account of human cognition undermine the rational confidence required to affirm naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dto5DQ7GBEQ", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 79, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "David Wood", "con": "Aron Ra" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.245, "evidenceWarrant": 71.32, "responsiveness": 88.67499999999998, "relevanceBurden": 84.41499999999999, "precisionClarity": 80.7, "calibrationCharity": 77.455 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.69999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 68.14, "responsiveness": 81.35000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.72, "precisionClarity": 84.0, "calibrationCharity": 82.95000000000002 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 160, "id": "pinker-douthat-do-we-need-god-2026", "title": "Steven Pinker vs Ross Douthat: Do We Need God?", "motion": "Are people and societies better off with belief in God, or can secular reason and institutions provide morality, purpose, and social cooperation more effectively?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jWCLONu7DM", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 85, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Ross Douthat", "con": "Steven Pinker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.712, "evidenceWarrant": 67.234, "responsiveness": 90.71400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 82.02, "precisionClarity": 84.2, "calibrationCharity": 75.78 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.434, "evidenceWarrant": 77.762, "responsiveness": 94.55700000000002, "relevanceBurden": 85.854, "precisionClarity": 82.34, "calibrationCharity": 83.482 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.721999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 10.528000000000006, "responsiveness": 3.8430000000000035, "relevanceBurden": 3.834000000000003, "precisionClarity": -1.8599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 7.701999999999998 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1804999999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1056000000000012, "responsiveness": 0.7686000000000007, "relevanceBurden": 0.5751000000000005, "precisionClarity": -0.18599999999999994, "calibrationCharity": 0.7701999999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2140000000000013 }, { "number": 161, "id": "craig-millican-does-god-exist-2011", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Peter Millican: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does the evidence from cosmology, fine-tuning, morality, Jesus' resurrection, and religious experience make Christian theism more reasonable than skeptical atheism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9JVRy7bR7zI", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 87, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Peter Millican" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.336, "evidenceWarrant": 66.132, "responsiveness": 84.137, "relevanceBurden": 83.461, "precisionClarity": 73.74, "calibrationCharity": 65.133 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.36000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 77.3, "responsiveness": 95.38000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.79999999999998, "precisionClarity": 90.8, "calibrationCharity": 84.215 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.024000000000015, "evidenceWarrant": 11.167999999999992, "responsiveness": 11.24300000000001, "relevanceBurden": 2.3389999999999844, "precisionClarity": 17.060000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 19.082000000000008 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.006000000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 2.2335999999999987, "responsiveness": 2.248600000000002, "relevanceBurden": 0.35084999999999766, "precisionClarity": 1.7060000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 1.9082000000000008 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5467499999999959 }, { "number": 162, "id": "craig-kagan-god-morality-2009", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Shelly Kagan: Is God Necessary for Morality?", "motion": "Is God necessary for objective moral values, duties, human significance, and accountability, or can a secular moral realism provide an adequate foundation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rm2wShHJ2iA", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 85, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Shelly Kagan" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.455, "evidenceWarrant": 66.595, "responsiveness": 83.13000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.525, "precisionClarity": 83.89999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 67.86500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.135, "evidenceWarrant": 77.27, "responsiveness": 93.89999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.58000000000001, "precisionClarity": 88.3, "calibrationCharity": 85.755 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.680000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 10.674999999999997, "responsiveness": 10.769999999999982, "relevanceBurden": 0.05500000000000682, "precisionClarity": 4.400000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 17.889999999999986 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.1700000000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1349999999999993, "responsiveness": 2.1539999999999964, "relevanceBurden": 0.008250000000001022, "precisionClarity": 0.4400000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 1.7889999999999988 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.6962499999999974 }, { "number": 163, "id": "craig-draper-existence-of-god-1997", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Paul Draper: The Existence of God", "motion": "Does the total evidence concerning the universe, life, morality, Jesus, religious experience, suffering, and hiddenness favor theism over naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lK3jVNbG2-s", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 85, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Paul Draper" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.408, "evidenceWarrant": 68.41999999999999, "responsiveness": 82.872, "relevanceBurden": 83.884, "precisionClarity": 80.88, "calibrationCharity": 73.804 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.46199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.552, "responsiveness": 93.206, "relevanceBurden": 87.768, "precisionClarity": 86.4, "calibrationCharity": 82.596 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.053999999999988, "evidenceWarrant": 7.132000000000019, "responsiveness": 10.334000000000003, "relevanceBurden": 3.8840000000000003, "precisionClarity": 5.52000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 8.792000000000002 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.513499999999997, "evidenceWarrant": 1.4264000000000039, "responsiveness": 2.0668000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 0.5826, "precisionClarity": 0.552000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 0.8792000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.02050000000000285 }, { "number": 164, "id": "craig-wielenberg-god-morality-2018", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Erik Wielenberg: God and Morality", "motion": "What is the best account of objective moral values and duties: the nature and commands of God or godless normative realism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xHhmuqBW6Dw", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 84, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Erik Wielenberg" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.76499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.41499999999999, "responsiveness": 90.145, "relevanceBurden": 84.7, "precisionClarity": 87.8, "calibrationCharity": 69.71000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.035, "evidenceWarrant": 76.28999999999999, "responsiveness": 91.275, "relevanceBurden": 85.9, "precisionClarity": 91.5, "calibrationCharity": 79.95 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.27000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 5.875, "responsiveness": 1.1300000000000097, "relevanceBurden": 1.2000000000000028, "precisionClarity": 3.700000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 10.239999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3175000000000026, "evidenceWarrant": 1.175, "responsiveness": 0.22600000000000195, "relevanceBurden": 0.1800000000000004, "precisionClarity": 0.37000000000000033, "calibrationCharity": 1.0239999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.29250000000000487 }, { "number": 165, "id": "craig-rosenberg-faith-god-reasonable-2013", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Alex Rosenberg: Is Faith in God Reasonable?", "motion": "Is belief in the personal God of classical theism intellectually reasonable?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bhfkhq-CM84", "date": "2026-08-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 76, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Alex Rosenberg" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.228, "evidenceWarrant": 71.80600000000001, "responsiveness": 88.116, "relevanceBurden": 83.424, "precisionClarity": 85.44, "calibrationCharity": 78.15199999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.304, "evidenceWarrant": 67.644, "responsiveness": 87.564, "relevanceBurden": 84.538, "precisionClarity": 75.34, "calibrationCharity": 68.184 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -6.923999999999992, "evidenceWarrant": -4.162000000000006, "responsiveness": -0.5520000000000067, "relevanceBurden": 1.11399999999999, "precisionClarity": -10.099999999999994, "calibrationCharity": -9.96799999999999 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.730999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": -0.8324000000000013, "responsiveness": -0.11040000000000134, "relevanceBurden": 0.1670999999999985, "precisionClarity": -1.0099999999999996, "calibrationCharity": -0.996799999999999 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.4864999999999995 }, { "number": 166, "id": "craig-atkins-does-god-exist-2011", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Peter Atkins: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist as the transcendent personal cause and moral foundation of reality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ssq-S5M8wsY", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 73, "con_gap": -10, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Peter Atkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.16, "evidenceWarrant": 74.02999999999999, "responsiveness": 89.62, "relevanceBurden": 81.60000000000001, "precisionClarity": 87.65, "calibrationCharity": 79.49 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 69.698, "evidenceWarrant": 62.317, "responsiveness": 76.223, "relevanceBurden": 86.932, "precisionClarity": 77.67, "calibrationCharity": 67.49300000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -13.462000000000003, "evidenceWarrant": -11.712999999999987, "responsiveness": -13.397000000000006, "relevanceBurden": 5.331999999999994, "precisionClarity": -9.980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": -11.996999999999986 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -3.365500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": -2.3425999999999974, "responsiveness": -2.679400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 0.7997999999999991, "precisionClarity": -0.9980000000000004, "calibrationCharity": -1.1996999999999987 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2146000000000008 }, { "number": 167, "id": "craig-shook-existence-god-2008", "title": "William Lane Craig vs John Shook: The Existence of God", "motion": "Does the available philosophical, scientific, moral, historical, and experiential evidence support God's existence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L3FOgiASYY0", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "John Shook" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 21, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.175, "evidenceWarrant": 66.75, "responsiveness": 85.49000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 81.38999999999999, "precisionClarity": 77.325, "calibrationCharity": 68.28 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.76799999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 74.032, "responsiveness": 92.31, "relevanceBurden": 84.71799999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.36, "calibrationCharity": 81.387 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.592999999999989, "evidenceWarrant": 7.2819999999999965, "responsiveness": 6.819999999999993, "relevanceBurden": 3.328000000000003, "precisionClarity": 9.034999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 13.107 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3982499999999973, "evidenceWarrant": 1.4563999999999995, "responsiveness": 1.3639999999999988, "relevanceBurden": 0.4992000000000004, "precisionClarity": 0.9034999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 1.3107 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.06795000000000417 }, { "number": 168, "id": "craig-krauss-evidence-god-2012", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Lawrence Krauss: Is There Evidence for God?", "motion": "Does the greater weight of philosophical, scientific, moral, and historical evidence support God's existence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqANWuXQ3Z0", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 81, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Lawrence Krauss" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.615, "evidenceWarrant": 73.71000000000001, "responsiveness": 94.71000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 88.94999999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.50000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 70.615 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.97000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 72.128, "responsiveness": 93.053, "relevanceBurden": 86.404, "precisionClarity": 82.38, "calibrationCharity": 75.92699999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -3.644999999999982, "evidenceWarrant": -1.5820000000000078, "responsiveness": -1.6570000000000107, "relevanceBurden": -2.5459999999999923, "precisionClarity": -4.120000000000019, "calibrationCharity": 5.311999999999998 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.9112499999999955, "evidenceWarrant": -0.31640000000000157, "responsiveness": -0.33140000000000214, "relevanceBurden": -0.38189999999999885, "precisionClarity": -0.4120000000000019, "calibrationCharity": 0.5311999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.1782499999999998 }, { "number": 169, "id": "lennox-krauss-universe-god-question-2013", "title": "John Lennox vs Lawrence Krauss: Science, the Universe, and the God Question", "motion": "Do modern cosmology, fine-tuning, and the universe's existence support a divine mind or a self-contained natural account?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yotpTOKLZ00", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 84, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Lawrence Krauss" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.915, "evidenceWarrant": 66.565, "responsiveness": 72.67, "relevanceBurden": 81.38499999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.5, "calibrationCharity": 73.19500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.285, "evidenceWarrant": 76.806, "responsiveness": 83.134, "relevanceBurden": 85.57900000000001, "precisionClarity": 87.15999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 86.87199999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.36999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 10.241, "responsiveness": 10.463999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 4.194000000000017, "precisionClarity": 1.6599999999999824, "calibrationCharity": 13.676999999999978 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8424999999999976, "evidenceWarrant": 2.0482, "responsiveness": 2.0928, "relevanceBurden": 0.6291000000000025, "precisionClarity": 0.16599999999999826, "calibrationCharity": 1.367699999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.14629999999999654 }, { "number": 170, "id": "singer-lennox-is-there-god-2011", "title": "Peter Singer vs John Lennox: Is There a God?", "motion": "Given science, human rationality, morality, suffering, and the historical claims about Jesus, is belief in the biblical God rational?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HoTILnpd3q8", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 86, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Peter Singer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.122, "evidenceWarrant": 62.202, "responsiveness": 77.99000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.208, "precisionClarity": 81.47999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 70.312 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.14800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 79.652, "responsiveness": 87.57199999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.51599999999999, "precisionClarity": 90.5, "calibrationCharity": 87.148 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.02600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 17.450000000000003, "responsiveness": 9.58199999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.3079999999999927, "precisionClarity": 9.02000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 16.836 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.7565000000000026, "evidenceWarrant": 3.4900000000000007, "responsiveness": 1.9163999999999959, "relevanceBurden": 0.04619999999999891, "precisionClarity": 0.902000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 1.6836 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.20530000000000115 }, { "number": 171, "id": "hitchens-blair-religion-force-good-2010", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Tony Blair: Is Religion a Force for Good in the World?", "motion": "On balance, is religion a force for good in the world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbEyhU-L3iE", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 85, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Tony Blair", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.33000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 71.37, "responsiveness": 90.21, "relevanceBurden": 86.82, "precisionClarity": 87.5, "calibrationCharity": 84.71 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.11399999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 74.084, "responsiveness": 91.772, "relevanceBurden": 87.072, "precisionClarity": 86.47999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 81.594 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.783999999999978, "evidenceWarrant": 2.7139999999999986, "responsiveness": 1.5620000000000118, "relevanceBurden": 0.25200000000000955, "precisionClarity": -1.0200000000000102, "calibrationCharity": -3.1159999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1959999999999944, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5427999999999997, "responsiveness": 0.3124000000000024, "relevanceBurden": 0.03780000000000143, "precisionClarity": -0.10200000000000103, "calibrationCharity": -0.3116 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3246000000000031 }, { "number": 172, "id": "hitchens-mcgrath-religious-belief-2007", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Alister McGrath: Poison or Cure? Religious Belief in the Modern World", "motion": "Is religious belief in the modern world intellectually credible and morally constructive, or is it an evidentially unsupported source of coercion and harm?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Xc0kbM4tBYE", "date": "2026-08-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 80, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Alister McGrath", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.76533333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 72.40366666666668, "responsiveness": 70.93033333333332, "relevanceBurden": 85.13333333333333, "precisionClarity": 88.8, "calibrationCharity": 87.20333333333333 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.5, "evidenceWarrant": 74.17999999999999, "responsiveness": 79.18, "relevanceBurden": 83.255, "precisionClarity": 84.5, "calibrationCharity": 74.33 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.265333333333345, "evidenceWarrant": 1.7763333333333122, "responsiveness": 8.249666666666684, "relevanceBurden": -1.8783333333333303, "precisionClarity": -4.299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": -12.873333333333335 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.31633333333333624, "evidenceWarrant": 0.35526666666666246, "responsiveness": 1.6499333333333368, "relevanceBurden": -0.28174999999999956, "precisionClarity": -0.4299999999999997, "calibrationCharity": -1.2873333333333337 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3102166666666699 }, { "number": 173, "id": "onaiyekan-widdecombe-fry-hitchens-catholic-church-force-good-2009", "title": "John Onaiyekan & Ann Widdecombe vs Stephen Fry & Christopher Hitchens: The Catholic Church Is a Force for Good in the World", "motion": "Is the Catholic Church, considered as an institution and global social force, a force for good in the world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JZRcYaAYWg4", "date": "2026-08-01", "model": "5.6 Terra Extra High", "rubric": null, "pro": 78, "con": 92, "con_gap": 14, "speakers": { "pro": "John Onaiyekan and Ann Widdecombe", "con": "Stephen Fry and Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 10, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 174, "id": "dawkins-williams-kenny-humanity-ultimate-origins-2012", "title": "Richard Dawkins, Rowan Williams & Anthony Kenny: Humanity's Ultimate Origins", "motion": "Can the nature and ultimate origins of human beings be explained by evolutionary naturalism, or does a theistic account add indispensable explanation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zruhc7XqSxo", "date": "2026-08-01", "model": "5.6 Terra Extra High", "rubric": null, "pro": 86, "con": 90, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Rowan Williams", "con": "Richard Dawkins and Anthony Kenny" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 10, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 3 } }, { "number": 175, "id": "oppy-pearce-is-there-a-god-2022", "title": "Graham Oppy vs Kenny Pearce: Is There a God?", "motion": "Does theism offer a better overall explanation of reality than naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SyhMlwsQuqc", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 88, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Kenny Pearce", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.815, "evidenceWarrant": 71.92, "responsiveness": 94.14, "relevanceBurden": 82.88, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 86.29 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.03999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 78.115, "responsiveness": 97.085, "relevanceBurden": 86.96, "precisionClarity": 93.05, "calibrationCharity": 89.35499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.224999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": 6.194999999999993, "responsiveness": 2.944999999999993, "relevanceBurden": 4.079999999999998, "precisionClarity": 5.049999999999997, "calibrationCharity": 3.0649999999999835 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3062499999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2389999999999988, "responsiveness": 0.5889999999999986, "relevanceBurden": 0.6119999999999998, "precisionClarity": 0.5049999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 0.3064999999999984 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5577499999999942 }, { "number": 176, "id": "ehrman-peter-williams-gospels-historically-reliable-2018", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs Peter J. Williams: Are the Gospels Historically Reliable?", "motion": "Are the canonical Gospels historically reliable accounts of Jesus' life, teaching, death, and resurrection?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=foLI3KGbMnk", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 86, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Peter J. Williams", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.11299999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 73.829, "responsiveness": 88.372, "relevanceBurden": 85.484, "precisionClarity": 84.94999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.45899999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 89.305, "evidenceWarrant": 81.405, "responsiveness": 83.69, "relevanceBurden": 82.86, "precisionClarity": 92.80000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 85.75999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.192000000000021, "evidenceWarrant": 7.576000000000008, "responsiveness": -4.682000000000002, "relevanceBurden": -2.6239999999999952, "precisionClarity": 7.850000000000023, "calibrationCharity": 5.301000000000002 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.0480000000000054, "evidenceWarrant": 1.5152000000000017, "responsiveness": -0.9364000000000005, "relevanceBurden": -0.3935999999999993, "precisionClarity": 0.7850000000000024, "calibrationCharity": 0.5301000000000002 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.54830000000001 }, { "number": 177, "id": "ehrman-wallace-trust-text-new-testament-2011", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs Daniel B. Wallace: Can We Trust the Text of the New Testament?", "motion": "Can textual criticism recover the wording of the original New Testament with enough confidence for the text to be trusted?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRHjZCKRIu4", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 88, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Daniel B. Wallace", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.169, "evidenceWarrant": 76.007, "responsiveness": 89.06700000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.38999999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.50999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.936 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 89.95666666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 80.60666666666665, "responsiveness": 93.26933333333332, "relevanceBurden": 85.59933333333332, "precisionClarity": 93.06666666666668, "calibrationCharity": 88.02533333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.7876666666666665, "evidenceWarrant": 4.59966666666665, "responsiveness": 4.202333333333314, "relevanceBurden": -0.7906666666666666, "precisionClarity": 8.556666666666686, "calibrationCharity": 7.089333333333329 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6969166666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 0.91993333333333, "responsiveness": 0.8404666666666629, "relevanceBurden": -0.11859999999999998, "precisionClarity": 0.8556666666666687, "calibrationCharity": 0.708933333333333 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.09668333333333834 }, { "number": 178, "id": "ehrman-licona-who-wrote-gospels-2025", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs Michael Licona: Who Wrote the Gospels?", "motion": "Were the canonical Gospels written by, or under the authority of, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xTCPigOQabY", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 87, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.006, "evidenceWarrant": 72.30300000000001, "responsiveness": 86.843, "relevanceBurden": 84.05000000000001, "precisionClarity": 88.39999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 76.962 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.253, "evidenceWarrant": 80.454, "responsiveness": 95.741, "relevanceBurden": 83.16999999999999, "precisionClarity": 91.14999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 85.00500000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.247, "evidenceWarrant": 8.150999999999982, "responsiveness": 8.897999999999996, "relevanceBurden": -0.8800000000000239, "precisionClarity": 2.75, "calibrationCharity": 8.043000000000006 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.06175, "evidenceWarrant": 1.6301999999999965, "responsiveness": 1.7795999999999994, "relevanceBurden": -0.1320000000000036, "precisionClarity": 0.275, "calibrationCharity": 0.8043000000000007 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.41884999999999284 }, { "number": 179, "id": "craig-ehrman-historical-evidence-resurrection-2006", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Bart Ehrman: Is There Historical Evidence for the Resurrection?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence make Jesus' bodily resurrection the best explanation of what followed his crucifixion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MW5_nJYSKyk", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 83, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.58, "evidenceWarrant": 75.345, "responsiveness": 91.765, "relevanceBurden": 89.27499999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.44999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 75.96499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.64, "evidenceWarrant": 72.47500000000001, "responsiveness": 95.99000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.28999999999999, "precisionClarity": 87.1, "calibrationCharity": 76.515 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -3.9399999999999977, "evidenceWarrant": -2.8699999999999903, "responsiveness": 4.2250000000000085, "relevanceBurden": -3.9849999999999994, "precisionClarity": 3.6500000000000057, "calibrationCharity": 0.5500000000000114 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.9849999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": -0.5739999999999981, "responsiveness": 0.8450000000000017, "relevanceBurden": -0.5977499999999999, "precisionClarity": 0.3650000000000006, "calibrationCharity": 0.05500000000000114 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.10825000000000606 }, { "number": 180, "id": "ally-licona-did-jesus-rise-dead-2004", "title": "Shabir Ally vs Michael Licona: Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence establish that Jesus physically rose from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eoiScvG3Emo", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 85, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Shabir Ally" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 84.0, "evidenceWarrant": 76.2, "responsiveness": 91.57499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 84.375, "precisionClarity": 82.5, "calibrationCharity": 74.675 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.55, "evidenceWarrant": 75.225, "responsiveness": 91.7, "relevanceBurden": 90.15, "precisionClarity": 83.5, "calibrationCharity": 82.325 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 181, "id": "habermas-flew-did-jesus-rise-dead-2000", "title": "Gary Habermas vs Antony Flew: Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence make Jesus' bodily resurrection a rational conclusion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ksa8uGe21rw", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 87, "con": 86, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Gary Habermas", "con": "Antony Flew" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 87.37, "evidenceWarrant": 79.83500000000001, "responsiveness": 95.57000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.66, "precisionClarity": 88.7, "calibrationCharity": 84.8 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.885, "evidenceWarrant": 74.32, "responsiveness": 97.86500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 88.875, "precisionClarity": 85.7, "calibrationCharity": 84.83 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.4849999999999994, "evidenceWarrant": -5.515000000000015, "responsiveness": 2.2950000000000017, "relevanceBurden": 4.215000000000003, "precisionClarity": -3.0, "calibrationCharity": 0.030000000000001137 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.6212499999999999, "evidenceWarrant": -1.103000000000003, "responsiveness": 0.45900000000000035, "relevanceBurden": 0.6322500000000005, "precisionClarity": -0.30000000000000004, "calibrationCharity": 0.0030000000000001137 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06999999999999806 }, { "number": 182, "id": "white-ally-sin-salvation-quran-bible-2013", "title": "James White vs Shabir Ally: Sin and Salvation in the Qur'an and the Bible", "motion": "Which account of sin and salvation—the Qur'an's direct forgiveness and moral accounting or the Bible's grace through Christ's atonement—is more coherent and scripturally grounded?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ee9c45dSHiY", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 79, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "James White", "con": "Shabir Ally" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.407, "evidenceWarrant": 74.149, "responsiveness": 79.84899999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.58, "precisionClarity": 84.36, "calibrationCharity": 73.107 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.22, "evidenceWarrant": 71.105, "responsiveness": 83.27499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 85.86, "precisionClarity": 83.8, "calibrationCharity": 71.355 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 183, "id": "enoch-clarke-doane-moral-realism-objectivity-2026", "title": "David Enoch vs Justin Clarke-Doane: Moral Realism and Objectivity", "motion": "Can stance-independent moral facts genuinely vindicate normative objectivity by settling what agents should do?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WrywAaDvvw", "date": "2026-08-25", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 88, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "David Enoch", "con": "Justin Clarke-Doane" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.68, "evidenceWarrant": 73.145, "responsiveness": 94.85500000000002, "relevanceBurden": 87.03999999999999, "precisionClarity": 88.1, "calibrationCharity": 84.38499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.77, "evidenceWarrant": 77.35, "responsiveness": 97.61999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 90.25, "precisionClarity": 92.1, "calibrationCharity": 89.67 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 184, "id": "enoch-sampson-loeb-lutz-moral-realism-2024", "title": "David Enoch & Eric Sampson vs Don Loeb & Matthew Lutz: Is Moral Realism True?", "motion": "Are there stance-independent moral facts that people can know and that supply genuinely categorical reasons for action?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Uw9szL-3MA", "date": "2026-08-01", "model": "5.6 Terra Extra High", "rubric": null, "pro": 92, "con": 91, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "David Enoch & Eric Sampson", "con": "Don Loeb & Matthew Lutz" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Historical multi-speaker assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 12, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 185, "id": "dennett-caruso-free-will-responsibility-2021", "title": "Daniel Dennett vs Gregg Caruso: Free Will and Moral Responsibility", "motion": "Does the natural human capacity for reasons-responsive control justify free will, moral desert, and responsibility practices?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxhA7S3q49o", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 89, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Daniel Dennett", "con": "Gregg Caruso" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.57000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 68.972, "responsiveness": 91.548, "relevanceBurden": 87.068, "precisionClarity": 83.67999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 70.57600000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.25800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.503, "responsiveness": 95.68, "relevanceBurden": 90.887, "precisionClarity": 95.0, "calibrationCharity": 89.3 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 186, "id": "huemer-sapolsky-free-will-determinism-2024", "title": "Michael Huemer vs Robert Sapolsky: Does Free Will Exist—and Does It Matter?", "motion": "Do people sometimes control which of multiple genuinely available actions occurs, and does that freedom justify responsibility?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FjAYvhv1-Lg", "date": "2026-08-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 80, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Huemer", "con": "Robert Sapolsky" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.883, "evidenceWarrant": 72.55799999999999, "responsiveness": 91.59299999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.80499999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.32, "calibrationCharity": 79.04400000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.385, "evidenceWarrant": 73.485, "responsiveness": 87.24, "relevanceBurden": 86.90499999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.25, "calibrationCharity": 71.41999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 187, "id": "ward-dennett-more-than-matter-2019", "title": "Keith Ward vs Daniel Dennett: Are We More Than Matter?", "motion": "Are consciousness, personal identity, purpose, value, and free agency irreducible to the physical world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mongL_2KMGg", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Keith Ward", "con": "Daniel Dennett" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.33699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 61.722, "responsiveness": 85.357, "relevanceBurden": 88.006, "precisionClarity": 84.22, "calibrationCharity": 71.305 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.01, "evidenceWarrant": 72.52, "responsiveness": 93.864, "relevanceBurden": 87.65599999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.82000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 78.594 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 188, "id": "kastrup-blackmore-consciousness-idealism-2023", "title": "Bernardo Kastrup vs Susan Blackmore: What Is Consciousness?", "motion": "Is consciousness the ontological foundation of reality rather than an emergent property of matter?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X4YVgM2HPMk", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 86, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Bernardo Kastrup", "con": "Susan Blackmore" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.325, "evidenceWarrant": 71.57499999999999, "responsiveness": 95.6, "relevanceBurden": 82.25, "precisionClarity": 88.0, "calibrationCharity": 83.8 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.22500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 75.025, "responsiveness": 95.675, "relevanceBurden": 85.8, "precisionClarity": 85.75, "calibrationCharity": 90.14999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 189, "id": "tour-cronin-origin-of-life-2020", "title": "James Tour vs Lee Cronin: Are We Close to Discovering the Origin of Life?", "motion": "Does current origin-of-life research substantially overstate how close it is to explaining the emergence of life?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3DHvNRK452c", "date": "2026-08-22", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 80, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "James Tour", "con": "Lee Cronin" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.851, "evidenceWarrant": 69.62400000000001, "responsiveness": 91.461, "relevanceBurden": 88.172, "precisionClarity": 87.06, "calibrationCharity": 76.49099999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.70766666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 68.82133333333333, "responsiveness": 84.70400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 84.66933333333334, "precisionClarity": 79.2, "calibrationCharity": 83.834 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 190, "id": "huemer-oppy-souls-personal-identity-2022", "title": "Michael Huemer vs Graham Oppy: Do Souls Exist?", "motion": "Do conscious persons possess nonphysical mental substances that can survive bodily death?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gxSi0htNihk", "date": "2026-08-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 84, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Huemer", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.14999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 64.35000000000001, "responsiveness": 79.71999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 83.50999999999999, "precisionClarity": 88.6, "calibrationCharity": 76.35499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.482, "evidenceWarrant": 76.79, "responsiveness": 88.64500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 80.705, "precisionClarity": 90.8, "calibrationCharity": 85.334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 191, "id": "ruse-rana-origin-life-evolution-design-2013", "title": "Michael Ruse vs Fuz Rana: Evolution or Design at Life's Origin?", "motion": "Are natural processes sufficient to explain the origin of life and the complexity of the cell?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2CnZ3n8I5b8", "date": "2026-08-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 81, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Ruse", "con": "Fuz Rana" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.72, "evidenceWarrant": 73.65, "responsiveness": 89.17000000000002, "relevanceBurden": 80.51999999999998, "precisionClarity": 87.0, "calibrationCharity": 81.0 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.152, "evidenceWarrant": 71.564, "responsiveness": 91.91199999999998, "relevanceBurden": 82.556, "precisionClarity": 86.72, "calibrationCharity": 74.616 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.567999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 2.0860000000000127, "responsiveness": -2.741999999999962, "relevanceBurden": -2.0360000000000156, "precisionClarity": 0.28000000000000114, "calibrationCharity": 6.384 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.8919999999999995, "evidenceWarrant": 0.41720000000000257, "responsiveness": -0.5483999999999923, "relevanceBurden": -0.30540000000000234, "precisionClarity": 0.028000000000000115, "calibrationCharity": 0.6384000000000001 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.12180000000000746 }, { "number": 192, "id": "tour-swamidass-origin-life-chemistry-2020", "title": "James Tour vs S. Joshua Swamidass: How Close Is Origin-of-Life Science?", "motion": "Has science come meaningfully close to explaining how life first arose from nonliving chemistry?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJgr38h_3H0", "date": "2026-08-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 78, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "James Tour", "con": "S. Joshua Swamidass" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.06, "evidenceWarrant": 73.31, "responsiveness": 84.57, "relevanceBurden": 84.12, "precisionClarity": 78.8, "calibrationCharity": 75.38499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.455, "evidenceWarrant": 67.27499999999999, "responsiveness": 74.28, "relevanceBurden": 87.10999999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.9, "calibrationCharity": 76.72500000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 193, "id": "crossan-licona-historical-jesus-2018", "title": "John Dominic Crossan vs Michael Licona: Who Was the Historical Jesus?", "motion": "What can historians verify about Jesus, and do the sources support his divine identity and bodily resurrection?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p_7bQlh8uWc", "date": "2026-08-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 84, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "John Dominic Crossan", "con": "Michael Licona" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.32000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 73.69999999999999, "responsiveness": 83.89, "relevanceBurden": 87.63, "precisionClarity": 86.19999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 79.65 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.29999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 76.79400000000001, "responsiveness": 91.114, "relevanceBurden": 83.357, "precisionClarity": 84.53999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 80.003 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 194, "id": "swinburne-millican-does-god-exist-2022", "title": "Richard Swinburne vs Peter Millican: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Is God the simplest and most probable explanation of the universe and its general features?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcNR4vJdcE4", "date": "2026-08-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 88, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Swinburne", "con": "Peter Millican" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.385, "evidenceWarrant": 71.67500000000001, "responsiveness": 91.57000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 90.12, "precisionClarity": 79.3, "calibrationCharity": 72.895 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.495, "evidenceWarrant": 81.655, "responsiveness": 98.25, "relevanceBurden": 83.71, "precisionClarity": 90.69999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 89.515 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.109999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 9.97999999999999, "responsiveness": 6.679999999999993, "relevanceBurden": -6.410000000000011, "precisionClarity": 11.399999999999991, "calibrationCharity": 16.620000000000005 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7774999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 1.995999999999998, "responsiveness": 1.3359999999999985, "relevanceBurden": -0.9615000000000016, "precisionClarity": 1.1399999999999992, "calibrationCharity": 1.6620000000000006 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.05000000000000515 }, { "number": 195, "id": "russell-copleston-existence-of-god-1948", "title": "Bertrand Russell vs Frederick Copleston: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Can God's existence be established through contingency, religious experience, or moral obligation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wMsbD1L5IlQ", "date": "2026-08-15", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 80, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Frederick Copleston", "con": "Bertrand Russell" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "earlier", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.55, "evidenceWarrant": 65.67, "responsiveness": 94.85, "relevanceBurden": 76.47999999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.16, "calibrationCharity": 69.77000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.15599999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 73.65899999999999, "responsiveness": 84.22200000000001, "relevanceBurden": 79.144, "precisionClarity": 85.20000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 79.55199999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.6059999999999945, "evidenceWarrant": 7.98899999999999, "responsiveness": -10.627999999999986, "relevanceBurden": 2.6640000000000157, "precisionClarity": -0.9599999999999795, "calibrationCharity": 9.781999999999982 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1514999999999986, "evidenceWarrant": 1.597799999999998, "responsiveness": -2.1255999999999973, "relevanceBurden": 0.39960000000000234, "precisionClarity": -0.09599999999999796, "calibrationCharity": 0.9781999999999983 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.09449999999999781 }, { "number": 196, "id": "huemer-rasmussen-god-existence-2026", "title": "Michael Huemer vs Joshua Rasmussen: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-8n2SGFSL8", "date": "2026-08-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 79, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Josh Rasmussen", "con": "Michael Huemer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.8, "evidenceWarrant": 66.55, "responsiveness": 83.875, "relevanceBurden": 81.60000000000001, "precisionClarity": 77.77499999999999, "calibrationCharity": 75.35000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.0425, "evidenceWarrant": 70.0925, "responsiveness": 84.58500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 82.2975, "precisionClarity": 80.8475, "calibrationCharity": 79.49 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.242500000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 3.542500000000004, "responsiveness": 0.710000000000008, "relevanceBurden": 0.6974999999999909, "precisionClarity": 3.072500000000005, "calibrationCharity": 4.139999999999986 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.5606250000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7085000000000008, "responsiveness": 0.1420000000000016, "relevanceBurden": 0.10462499999999864, "precisionClarity": 0.3072500000000005, "calibrationCharity": 0.41399999999999865 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.23700000000000188 }, { "number": 197, "id": "mcgilchrist-seth-consciousness-god-2026", "title": "Iain McGilchrist vs Anil Seth: Does Consciousness Point to God?", "motion": "Does consciousness fundamentally pervade reality and point toward God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hdhTpkGggK0", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 83, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "Iain McGilchrist", "con": "Anil Seth" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.94772727272726, "evidenceWarrant": 58.786363636363646, "responsiveness": 79.12954545454545, "relevanceBurden": 80.12045454545455, "precisionClarity": 82.88181818181819, "calibrationCharity": 73.72045454545454 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.16583333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 76.02583333333334, "responsiveness": 83.80083333333334, "relevanceBurden": 82.46291666666666, "precisionClarity": 86.46791666666665, "calibrationCharity": 87.01333333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.218106060606075, "evidenceWarrant": 17.239469696969692, "responsiveness": 4.6712878787878935, "relevanceBurden": 2.342462121212108, "precisionClarity": 3.5860984848484634, "calibrationCharity": 13.292878787878792 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.554526515151519, "evidenceWarrant": 3.4478939393939387, "responsiveness": 0.9342575757575787, "relevanceBurden": 0.3513693181818162, "precisionClarity": 0.35860984848484634, "calibrationCharity": 1.3292878787878792 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.024054924242422615 }, { "number": 198, "id": "ferrer-dillahunty-god-morality-2018", "title": "John Ferrer vs Matt Dillahunty: Do We Need God for Morality?", "motion": "Do we need God for morality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EigYzeXngq4", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 67, "con": 83, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "John Ferrer", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 27, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 16, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 64.71964285714286, "evidenceWarrant": 53.03839285714285, "responsiveness": 79.35714285714286, "relevanceBurden": 74.46964285714286, "precisionClarity": 73.41696428571429, "calibrationCharity": 61.37232142857143 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.18333333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 72.33333333333333, "responsiveness": 89.3, "relevanceBurden": 85.44166666666666, "precisionClarity": 85.73333333333332, "calibrationCharity": 78.98333333333333 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 18.46369047619048, "evidenceWarrant": 19.294940476190476, "responsiveness": 9.942857142857136, "relevanceBurden": 10.972023809523805, "precisionClarity": 12.316369047619034, "calibrationCharity": 17.611011904761902 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.61592261904762, "evidenceWarrant": 3.8589880952380953, "responsiveness": 1.9885714285714273, "relevanceBurden": 1.6458035714285706, "precisionClarity": 1.2316369047619036, "calibrationCharity": 1.7611011904761904 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.8979761904761929 }, { "number": 199, "id": "crummett-watkins-soul-existence-2020", "title": "Dustin Crummett vs Ben Watkins: Does the Soul Exist?", "motion": "Does the soul exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNaMCEYgKLo", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 81, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Dustin Crummett", "con": "Ben Watkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.71136363636363, "evidenceWarrant": 72.9309090909091, "responsiveness": 86.55045454545456, "relevanceBurden": 86.18818181818182, "precisionClarity": 84.92863636363636, "calibrationCharity": 85.77499999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.72500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 74.4, "responsiveness": 85.8, "relevanceBurden": 86.025, "precisionClarity": 80.325, "calibrationCharity": 83.30000000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 200, "id": "craig-stenger-god-existence-2010", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Victor Stenger: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EjOs62PJciI", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 69, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Victor Stenger" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 42, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.74916666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 63.060833333333335, "responsiveness": 85.05916666666667, "relevanceBurden": 81.44166666666666, "precisionClarity": 79.8975, "calibrationCharity": 67.81583333333333 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 67.68166666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 57.57357142857143, "responsiveness": 78.19500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 73.03535714285715, "precisionClarity": 73.17071428571427, "calibrationCharity": 61.010714285714286 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -9.067499999999995, "evidenceWarrant": -5.487261904761908, "responsiveness": -6.864166666666662, "relevanceBurden": -8.406309523809512, "precisionClarity": -6.726785714285725, "calibrationCharity": -6.805119047619044 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -2.266874999999999, "evidenceWarrant": -1.0974523809523817, "responsiveness": -1.3728333333333325, "relevanceBurden": -1.2609464285714267, "precisionClarity": -0.6726785714285726, "calibrationCharity": -0.6805119047619045 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.35129761904761647 }, { "number": 201, "id": "hernandez-dillahunty-soul-existence-2015", "title": "Does the Soul Exist? Eric Hernandez vs. Matt Dillahunty", "motion": "Does the soul exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xgPSRVLMjEk", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 82, "con_gap": 14, "speakers": { "pro": "Eric Hernandez", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "religion-adjacent, but no explicit theist-vs-non-theist side comparison", "public_moves": 45, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 64.66454545454546, "evidenceWarrant": 57.08321969696969, "responsiveness": 76.90768939393939, "relevanceBurden": 75.37083333333332, "precisionClarity": 77.95409090909091, "calibrationCharity": 60.08681818181818 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.95333333333335, "evidenceWarrant": 73.195, "responsiveness": 88.01166666666667, "relevanceBurden": 85.17999999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.09333333333333, "calibrationCharity": 80.15416666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 202, "id": "dawkins-lennox-god-delusion-2007", "title": "Is Belief in God a Delusion? Richard Dawkins vs. John Lennox", "motion": "Is belief in the Christian God a delusion?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zF5bPI92-5o", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 72, "con_gap": -4, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Dawkins", "con": "John Lennox" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 39, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.27233333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 66.974, "responsiveness": 81.42366666666666, "relevanceBurden": 78.51066666666667, "precisionClarity": 80.952, "calibrationCharity": 71.07333333333334 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 71.86060606060606, "evidenceWarrant": 63.60757575757576, "responsiveness": 76.15969696969698, "relevanceBurden": 75.6930303030303, "precisionClarity": 79.70757575757577, "calibrationCharity": 69.02969696969697 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.411727272727276, "evidenceWarrant": 3.3664242424242445, "responsiveness": 5.263969696969681, "relevanceBurden": 2.8176363636363675, "precisionClarity": 1.2444242424242304, "calibrationCharity": 2.0436363636363666 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.102931818181819, "evidenceWarrant": 0.6732848484848489, "responsiveness": 1.0527939393939363, "relevanceBurden": 0.4226454545454551, "precisionClarity": 0.12444242424242305, "calibrationCharity": 0.20436363636363666 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.41953787878788074 }, { "number": 203, "id": "craig-flew-god-existence-1998", "title": "Does God Exist? William Lane Craig vs. Antony Flew", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NixhL0CoH2s", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 77, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Antony Flew" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 7, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.0875, "evidenceWarrant": 62.45, "responsiveness": 84.0625, "relevanceBurden": 80.5875, "precisionClarity": 80.81249999999999, "calibrationCharity": 64.95 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.66522727272728, "evidenceWarrant": 68.0040909090909, "responsiveness": 82.345, "relevanceBurden": 80.26840909090907, "precisionClarity": 79.225, "calibrationCharity": 73.65454545454546 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.577727272727273, "evidenceWarrant": 5.5540909090909025, "responsiveness": -1.7175000000000011, "relevanceBurden": -0.3190909090909315, "precisionClarity": -1.5874999999999915, "calibrationCharity": 8.704545454545453 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3944318181818183, "evidenceWarrant": 1.1108181818181806, "responsiveness": -0.34350000000000025, "relevanceBurden": -0.047863636363639724, "precisionClarity": -0.15874999999999917, "calibrationCharity": 0.8704545454545454 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.17440909090909473 }, { "number": 204, "id": "singer-dsouza-morality-without-god-2008", "title": "Can There Be Morality Without God? Dinesh D'Souza vs. Peter Singer", "motion": "Can there be morality without God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jcwWliq8PDI", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 81, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Dinesh D'Souza", "con": "Peter Singer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.8685119047619, "evidenceWarrant": 60.60142857142857, "responsiveness": 80.14845238095238, "relevanceBurden": 78.31089285714285, "precisionClarity": 76.67940476190476, "calibrationCharity": 63.802083333333336 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.02880952380951, "evidenceWarrant": 73.36142857142856, "responsiveness": 85.43738095238096, "relevanceBurden": 84.70666666666666, "precisionClarity": 83.23095238095237, "calibrationCharity": 81.39214285714286 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 13.160297619047611, "evidenceWarrant": 12.759999999999991, "responsiveness": 5.288928571428585, "relevanceBurden": 6.395773809523817, "precisionClarity": 6.551547619047611, "calibrationCharity": 17.590059523809522 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.290074404761903, "evidenceWarrant": 2.5519999999999983, "responsiveness": 1.057785714285717, "relevanceBurden": 0.9593660714285726, "precisionClarity": 0.6551547619047611, "calibrationCharity": 1.7590059523809523 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2733869047619031 }, { "number": 205, "id": "horn-watkins-god-existence-2021", "title": "Does God Exist? Trent Horn vs. Ben Watkins", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GTPwaU3JAU8", "date": "2026-08-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 75, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Ben Watkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 26, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.43833333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 60.88333333333334, "responsiveness": 80.30000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 76.13833333333334, "precisionClarity": 75.57833333333333, "calibrationCharity": 66.25916666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.245, "evidenceWarrant": 65.15, "responsiveness": 84.07, "relevanceBurden": 80.23, "precisionClarity": 77.92, "calibrationCharity": 68.63 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.806666666666672, "evidenceWarrant": 4.266666666666666, "responsiveness": 3.769999999999982, "relevanceBurden": 4.091666666666669, "precisionClarity": 2.3416666666666686, "calibrationCharity": 2.370833333333323 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.701666666666668, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8533333333333332, "responsiveness": 0.7539999999999965, "relevanceBurden": 0.6137500000000002, "precisionClarity": 0.23416666666666686, "calibrationCharity": 0.2370833333333323 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.606000000000003 }, { "number": 206, "id": "williams-dawkins-god-science-reality-2026", "title": "God, Science and the Poetry of Reality: Rowan Williams vs. Richard Dawkins", "motion": "What best explains the poetry of reality: God or science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udxloyjbtIE", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 77, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Rowan Williams", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.05472727272728, "evidenceWarrant": 63.10000000000001, "responsiveness": 80.958, "relevanceBurden": 78.8009090909091, "precisionClarity": 78.8, "calibrationCharity": 85.46454545454546 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.48, "evidenceWarrant": 71.57000000000001, "responsiveness": 80.108, "relevanceBurden": 81.154, "precisionClarity": 80.73200000000001, "calibrationCharity": 69.858 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.425272727272727, "evidenceWarrant": 8.469999999999999, "responsiveness": -0.8499999999999943, "relevanceBurden": 2.353090909090895, "precisionClarity": 1.9320000000000164, "calibrationCharity": -15.606545454545454 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.10631818181818176, "evidenceWarrant": 1.694, "responsiveness": -0.16999999999999887, "relevanceBurden": 0.3529636363636342, "precisionClarity": 0.19320000000000165, "calibrationCharity": -1.5606545454545455 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3841727272727269 }, { "number": 207, "id": "peterson-dawkins-memes-archetypes-truth-2024", "title": "Memes, Archetypes, and Religious Truth: Jordan Peterson vs. Richard Dawkins", "motion": "Do archetypes and religious narratives convey truths that factual naturalism misses?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8wBtFNj_o5k", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 86, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.032, "evidenceWarrant": 60.964, "responsiveness": 75.298, "relevanceBurden": 81.538, "precisionClarity": 74.39, "calibrationCharity": 76.486 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.75927272727273, "evidenceWarrant": 80.01836363636363, "responsiveness": 87.43836363636365, "relevanceBurden": 85.89672727272728, "precisionClarity": 89.06545454545456, "calibrationCharity": 83.36963636363636 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.727272727272734, "evidenceWarrant": 19.054363636363632, "responsiveness": 12.140363636363645, "relevanceBurden": 4.358727272727279, "precisionClarity": 14.675454545454556, "calibrationCharity": 6.883636363636356 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.4318181818181834, "evidenceWarrant": 3.8108727272727267, "responsiveness": 2.4280727272727294, "relevanceBurden": 0.6538090909090918, "precisionClarity": 1.4675454545454558, "calibrationCharity": 0.6883636363636356 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.519518181818178 }, { "number": 208, "id": "vela-jones-divine-hiddenness-christian-love-2023", "title": "Divine Hiddenness and Christian Love: Tyler Vela vs. Michael Jones", "motion": "Is divine hiddenness compatible with Christianity’s claim that God is perfectly loving?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZZkFfvfHb0", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 78, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Tyler Vela", "con": "Michael Jones" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 20, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 4 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.05000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 71.92500000000001, "responsiveness": 88.775, "relevanceBurden": 87.35, "precisionClarity": 82.55, "calibrationCharity": 84.49999999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.69999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 70.15, "responsiveness": 83.42500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 83.15, "precisionClarity": 76.975, "calibrationCharity": 77.475 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 209, "id": "oconnor-ruegger-divine-hiddenness-loving-god-2022", "title": "Divine Hiddenness and a Loving God: Alex O'Connor vs. Lukas Ruegger", "motion": "Does divine hiddenness make the existence of a perfectly loving God unlikely?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Vc1AiY_0Ts", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 75, "con_gap": -10, "speakers": { "pro": "Alex O'Connor", "con": "Lukas Ruegger" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 5 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.76285714285714, "evidenceWarrant": 77.76285714285714, "responsiveness": 90.09714285714284, "relevanceBurden": 88.17142857142858, "precisionClarity": 86.00285714285715, "calibrationCharity": 86.01142857142857 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.006, "evidenceWarrant": 69.074, "responsiveness": 76.877, "relevanceBurden": 76.815, "precisionClarity": 77.798, "calibrationCharity": 82.66199999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.756857142857143, "evidenceWarrant": 8.688857142857145, "responsiveness": 13.220142857142847, "relevanceBurden": 11.35642857142858, "precisionClarity": 8.20485714285715, "calibrationCharity": 3.349428571428575 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.689214285714286, "evidenceWarrant": 1.7377714285714292, "responsiveness": 2.6440285714285694, "relevanceBurden": 1.703464285714287, "precisionClarity": 0.8204857142857152, "calibrationCharity": 0.33494285714285754 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.07009285714285518 }, { "number": 210, "id": "paterson-schmid-divine-hiddenness-relationship-2026", "title": "Divine Hiddenness and Religious Evidence: Joe Schmid vs. Dan Paterson", "motion": "Does divine hiddenness provide significant evidence against a perfectly loving God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ed8Gb7zaLIM", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 88, "con": 83, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Joseph Schmid", "con": "Dan Paterson" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 26, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 6 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 88.935, "evidenceWarrant": 78.89, "responsiveness": 92.38333333333333, "relevanceBurden": 92.35833333333335, "precisionClarity": 89.15666666666667, "calibrationCharity": 92.49166666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.10666666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 71.15666666666667, "responsiveness": 86.15333333333334, "relevanceBurden": 86.91833333333334, "precisionClarity": 84.695, "calibrationCharity": 89.17666666666666 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.828333333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 7.733333333333334, "responsiveness": 6.22999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 5.440000000000012, "precisionClarity": 4.461666666666673, "calibrationCharity": 3.315000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4570833333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 1.5466666666666669, "responsiveness": 1.245999999999998, "relevanceBurden": 0.8160000000000017, "precisionClarity": 0.4461666666666673, "calibrationCharity": 0.33150000000000124 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.843416666666668 }, { "number": 211, "id": "baggini-baker-hytch-divine-hiddenness-2025", "title": "Divine Hiddenness and Evidential Ambiguity: Julian Baggini vs. Max Baker-Hytch", "motion": "Does divine hiddenness provide good evidence against God's existence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djyjKuN9o98", "date": "2025-02-21", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Julian Baggini", "con": "Max Baker-Hytch" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.62022619047619, "evidenceWarrant": 69.29891666666667, "responsiveness": 85.63030952380952, "relevanceBurden": 82.39790476190475, "precisionClarity": 82.0012619047619, "calibrationCharity": 81.43744047619047 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.20854978354978, "evidenceWarrant": 70.8204329004329, "responsiveness": 85.78075757575758, "relevanceBurden": 80.16993506493506, "precisionClarity": 85.30577922077921, "calibrationCharity": 90.98361471861472 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.5883235930735964, "evidenceWarrant": -1.521516233766235, "responsiveness": -0.15044805194806088, "relevanceBurden": 2.2279696969696943, "precisionClarity": -3.3045173160173107, "calibrationCharity": -9.546174242424243 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.6470808982683991, "evidenceWarrant": -0.304303246753247, "responsiveness": -0.03008961038961218, "relevanceBurden": 0.33419545454545413, "precisionClarity": -0.3304517316017311, "calibrationCharity": -0.9546174242424244 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06765254329004033 }, { "number": 212, "id": "craig-carrier-resurrection-2009", "title": "Resurrection Evidence and Naturalistic Alternatives: William Lane Craig vs. Richard Carrier", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akd6qzFYzX8", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 80, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.975, "evidenceWarrant": 73.105, "responsiveness": 84.85666666666665, "relevanceBurden": 85.74833333333333, "precisionClarity": 85.11166666666665, "calibrationCharity": 67.99 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.685, "evidenceWarrant": 71.25, "responsiveness": 86.93, "relevanceBurden": 86.735, "precisionClarity": 80.265, "calibrationCharity": 71.095 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.289999999999992, "evidenceWarrant": -1.855000000000004, "responsiveness": 2.073333333333352, "relevanceBurden": 0.9866666666666646, "precisionClarity": -4.84666666666665, "calibrationCharity": 3.105000000000004 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.322499999999998, "evidenceWarrant": -0.37100000000000083, "responsiveness": 0.4146666666666704, "relevanceBurden": 0.1479999999999997, "precisionClarity": -0.484666666666665, "calibrationCharity": 0.31050000000000044 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.30499999999999333 }, { "number": 213, "id": "peterson-zizek-capitalism-marxism-happiness-2019", "title": "Capitalism, Marxism, and Human Happiness: Jordan Peterson vs. Slavoj Žižek", "motion": "Does capitalism provide a greater opportunity for human happiness than Marxism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lsWndfzuOc4", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 78, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Slavoj Žižek" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 26, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.38, "evidenceWarrant": 61.709999999999994, "responsiveness": 81.675, "relevanceBurden": 81.305, "precisionClarity": 75.88, "calibrationCharity": 72.855 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.71857142857144, "evidenceWarrant": 65.02071428571428, "responsiveness": 84.80285714285715, "relevanceBurden": 80.75285714285714, "precisionClarity": 76.30785714285715, "calibrationCharity": 83.37214285714286 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 214, "id": "pageau-woodford-metaphorical-truth-2020", "title": "Metaphorical Truth and Religious Patterns: Jonathan Pageau vs. Stephen Woodford", "motion": "Do religious patterns disclose enduring truths that should guide contemporary life?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CsqVRauiAn4", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 78, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan Pageau", "con": "Stephen Woodford" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.85333333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 60.149166666666666, "responsiveness": 80.76, "relevanceBurden": 81.38250000000001, "precisionClarity": 73.78500000000001, "calibrationCharity": 72.4775 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.94936363636363, "evidenceWarrant": 64.58045454545456, "responsiveness": 85.44409090909092, "relevanceBurden": 84.50972727272728, "precisionClarity": 77.18618181818181, "calibrationCharity": 76.86218181818182 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.09603030303029, "evidenceWarrant": 4.4312878787878915, "responsiveness": 4.684090909090912, "relevanceBurden": 3.127227272727268, "precisionClarity": 3.401181818181797, "calibrationCharity": 4.384681818181818 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0240075757575724, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8862575757575784, "responsiveness": 0.9368181818181824, "relevanceBurden": 0.46908409090909015, "precisionClarity": 0.34011818181817977, "calibrationCharity": 0.4384681818181818 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.09475378787878519 }, { "number": 215, "id": "horn-oconnor-christian-belief-2022", "title": "Why Be a Christian? Trent Horn vs. Alex O'Connor", "motion": "Does the available evidence warrant Christian belief?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFYrfKHSV2k", "date": "2026-08-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 84, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.13033333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 64.273, "responsiveness": 77.50966666666667, "relevanceBurden": 77.72, "precisionClarity": 79.26333333333332, "calibrationCharity": 76.006 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.53166666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 75.72233333333332, "responsiveness": 88.01466666666667, "relevanceBurden": 85.94533333333334, "precisionClarity": 87.69366666666667, "calibrationCharity": 87.65466666666669 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 12.401333333333326, "evidenceWarrant": 11.449333333333328, "responsiveness": 10.504999999999995, "relevanceBurden": 8.225333333333339, "precisionClarity": 8.430333333333351, "calibrationCharity": 11.648666666666685 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.1003333333333316, "evidenceWarrant": 2.289866666666666, "responsiveness": 2.100999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 1.2338000000000007, "precisionClarity": 0.8430333333333352, "calibrationCharity": 1.1648666666666685 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.7329000000000008 }, { "number": 216, "id": "harris-wolpe-religion-science-2007", "title": "Religion, Science, and Meaning: Sam Harris vs. David Wolpe", "motion": "Does religion provide justified knowledge and meaning beyond science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OSBaAT6WPmk", "date": "2026-08-31", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 83, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "con": "Sam Harris" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.10000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 52.6275, "responsiveness": 75.39874999999999, "relevanceBurden": 77.155, "precisionClarity": 73.80250000000001, "calibrationCharity": 67.95125 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.04, "evidenceWarrant": 73.565, "responsiveness": 88.86500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.725, "precisionClarity": 83.845, "calibrationCharity": 73.345 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 17.939999999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 20.9375, "responsiveness": 13.466250000000016, "relevanceBurden": 10.569999999999993, "precisionClarity": 10.04249999999999, "calibrationCharity": 5.393749999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.484999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 4.1875, "responsiveness": 2.6932500000000035, "relevanceBurden": 1.585499999999999, "precisionClarity": 1.004249999999999, "calibrationCharity": 0.5393749999999997 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5051249999999996 }, { "number": 217, "id": "douthat-oconnor-religious-belief-obligation-2026", "title": "Religious Belief as an Obligation: Ross Douthat vs. Alex O'Connor", "motion": "Does the available evidence make religious belief an obligation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zp4xlI6-dlY", "date": "2026-08-31", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 69, "con": 84, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Ross Douthat", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 38, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 8, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 9, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.21363636363637, "evidenceWarrant": 55.48909090909091, "responsiveness": 75.285, "relevanceBurden": 74.56818181818181, "precisionClarity": 73.54090909090908, "calibrationCharity": 79.23409090909091 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.3635, "evidenceWarrant": 72.86016666666667, "responsiveness": 88.769, "relevanceBurden": 86.3825, "precisionClarity": 83.63266666666668, "calibrationCharity": 87.22333333333333 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 17.149863636363634, "evidenceWarrant": 17.37107575757576, "responsiveness": 13.484000000000009, "relevanceBurden": 11.81431818181818, "precisionClarity": 10.091757575757597, "calibrationCharity": 7.98924242424242 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.287465909090908, "evidenceWarrant": 3.474215151515152, "responsiveness": 2.696800000000002, "relevanceBurden": 1.772147727272727, "precisionClarity": 1.0091757575757598, "calibrationCharity": 0.798924242424242 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.9612712121212095 }, { "number": 218, "id": "mcgrath-oconnor-new-atheism-failure-2023", "title": "Has New Atheism Failed? Alister McGrath vs. Alex O'Connor", "motion": "Has New Atheism failed?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MNZaLudTSgg", "date": "2026-08-31", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 83, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Alister McGrath", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.87019047619049, "evidenceWarrant": 59.17761904761904, "responsiveness": 76.74333333333334, "relevanceBurden": 76.29361904761905, "precisionClarity": 78.55742857142857, "calibrationCharity": 75.28666666666666 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.90178354978354, "evidenceWarrant": 69.27541125541126, "responsiveness": 86.00261471861472, "relevanceBurden": 84.8034632034632, "precisionClarity": 84.62510822510822, "calibrationCharity": 88.44460606060606 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.031593073593058, "evidenceWarrant": 10.097792207792217, "responsiveness": 9.259281385281383, "relevanceBurden": 8.50984415584415, "precisionClarity": 6.067679653679647, "calibrationCharity": 13.157939393939401 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5078982683982645, "evidenceWarrant": 2.0195584415584436, "responsiveness": 1.8518562770562768, "relevanceBurden": 1.2764766233766223, "precisionClarity": 0.6067679653679647, "calibrationCharity": 1.3157939393939402 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.4216484848484878 }, { "number": 219, "id": "shermer-mcgrath-god-imagination-2017", "title": "Is God a Figment of Our Imagination? Michael Shermer vs. Alister McGrath", "motion": "Is God a figment of our imagination?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eScykHWO4LY", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 72, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Shermer", "con": "Alister McGrath" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 31, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.715, "evidenceWarrant": 66.885, "responsiveness": 83.305, "relevanceBurden": 82.79, "precisionClarity": 77.53500000000001, "calibrationCharity": 76.19 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.49085714285714, "evidenceWarrant": 57.71342857142857, "responsiveness": 76.70628571428571, "relevanceBurden": 76.02599999999998, "precisionClarity": 75.30000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 80.82314285714286 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.224142857142866, "evidenceWarrant": 9.171571428571433, "responsiveness": 6.598714285714294, "relevanceBurden": 6.764000000000024, "precisionClarity": 2.2349999999999994, "calibrationCharity": -4.6331428571428575 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3060357142857164, "evidenceWarrant": 1.8343142857142867, "responsiveness": 1.3197428571428589, "relevanceBurden": 1.0146000000000035, "precisionClarity": 0.22349999999999995, "calibrationCharity": -0.4633142857142858 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.23487857142857926 }, { "number": 220, "id": "hirsi-ali-oconnor-christian-conversion-2024", "title": "Does Christian Conversion Establish Truth? Ayaan Hirsi Ali vs. Alex O'Connor", "motion": "Do personal transformation and Christianity's cultural value justify belief that Christianity is true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rEXymLAqqIs", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 83, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 37, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 11, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.03120562770563, "evidenceWarrant": 59.426285714285704, "responsiveness": 71.96037229437228, "relevanceBurden": 70.09754761904762, "precisionClarity": 76.55386363636363, "calibrationCharity": 76.18730303030303 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.89116666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 74.32791666666668, "responsiveness": 87.73483333333334, "relevanceBurden": 83.51708333333333, "precisionClarity": 85.46758333333332, "calibrationCharity": 81.8655 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.859961038961032, "evidenceWarrant": 14.901630952380977, "responsiveness": 15.774461038961064, "relevanceBurden": 13.419535714285715, "precisionClarity": 8.913719696969693, "calibrationCharity": 5.67819696969697 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.964990259740258, "evidenceWarrant": 2.9803261904761955, "responsiveness": 3.154892207792213, "relevanceBurden": 2.012930357142857, "precisionClarity": 0.8913719696969693, "calibrationCharity": 0.567819696969697 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5723306818181904 }, { "number": 221, "id": "huemer-loeb-moral-realism-2022", "title": "Is Moral Realism Better Supported? Michael Huemer vs. Don Loeb", "motion": "Is stance-independent moral realism better supported than moral anti-realism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=89cnR4pU_7k", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 82, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Huemer", "con": "Don Loeb" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.49125000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 71.35225000000001, "responsiveness": 85.737, "relevanceBurden": 83.90025, "precisionClarity": 84.22825, "calibrationCharity": 78.339 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.26761363636363, "evidenceWarrant": 71.1135606060606, "responsiveness": 86.18753787878788, "relevanceBurden": 84.4139015151515, "precisionClarity": 84.32594696969696, "calibrationCharity": 87.29708333333335 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 222, "id": "lennox-shermer-god-existence-2008", "title": "Does God Exist? John Lennox vs. Michael Shermer", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_OPWiXbSDA", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 81, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Michael Shermer" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 41, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 7, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 8, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.26521212121213, "evidenceWarrant": 65.64142424242424, "responsiveness": 79.94778787878786, "relevanceBurden": 79.49072727272728, "precisionClarity": 83.31345454545455, "calibrationCharity": 76.27945454545456 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.45425, "evidenceWarrant": 73.33350000000002, "responsiveness": 84.68625, "relevanceBurden": 83.31341666666667, "precisionClarity": 84.83366666666667, "calibrationCharity": 75.30716666666666 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.189037878787872, "evidenceWarrant": 7.692075757575779, "responsiveness": 4.738462121212137, "relevanceBurden": 3.8226893939393847, "precisionClarity": 1.5202121212121256, "calibrationCharity": -0.9722878787878955 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.547259469696968, "evidenceWarrant": 1.5384151515151558, "responsiveness": 0.9476924242424275, "relevanceBurden": 0.5734034090909077, "precisionClarity": 0.15202121212121256, "calibrationCharity": -0.09722878787878955 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.33843712121211844 }, { "number": 223, "id": "collins-dawkins-science-belief-god-2022", "title": "Science and Belief in God: Francis Collins vs. Richard Dawkins", "motion": "Does scientific understanding leave rational grounds for belief in God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SQ3EU58AzFs", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Francis Collins", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "one published theistic/religious side and one published non-theistic/skeptical side", "public_moves": 42, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.34032467532468, "evidenceWarrant": 65.06510389610389, "responsiveness": 79.73514285714286, "relevanceBurden": 78.37328571428571, "precisionClarity": 82.07371428571429, "calibrationCharity": 82.54338961038961 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.30605844155845, "evidenceWarrant": 74.84817532467532, "responsiveness": 88.02865259740261, "relevanceBurden": 85.11303896103897, "precisionClarity": 85.86957467532469, "calibrationCharity": 82.8610064935065 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.965733766233768, "evidenceWarrant": 9.783071428571432, "responsiveness": 8.29350974025975, "relevanceBurden": 6.739753246753253, "precisionClarity": 3.7958603896103966, "calibrationCharity": 0.31761688311688374 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.991433441558442, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9566142857142865, "responsiveness": 1.6587019480519503, "relevanceBurden": 1.010962987012988, "precisionClarity": 0.3795860389610397, "calibrationCharity": 0.03176168831168837 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.02906038961039492 }, { "number": 224, "id": "hossenfelder-kastrup-superdeterminism-2022", "title": "Is Superdeterminism Scientifically Justified? Sabine Hossenfelder vs. Bernardo Kastrup", "motion": "Does superdeterminism provide a scientifically justified route to resolving quantum mechanics’ measurement problem?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kJmBmopxc1k", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 82, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "con": "Bernardo Kastrup" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 39, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 6 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.2628354978355, "evidenceWarrant": 76.4370238095238, "responsiveness": 88.69775974025976, "relevanceBurden": 86.64072510822511, "precisionClarity": 87.62512987012987, "calibrationCharity": 87.77441558441559 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.82702380952381, "evidenceWarrant": 73.90416666666668, "responsiveness": 86.16488095238094, "relevanceBurden": 86.35238095238094, "precisionClarity": 83.69345238095238, "calibrationCharity": 76.26857142857142 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 225, "id": "kastrup-jump-analytic-idealism-materialism-2023", "title": "Does Analytic Idealism Explain Consciousness Better? Bernardo Kastrup vs. Tom Jump", "motion": "Does analytic idealism explain consciousness and reality better than materialism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=57zkM-vviBA", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 80, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Bernardo Kastrup", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "no position-level theist-vs-non-theist comparison", "public_moves": 40, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 2 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.10866666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 72.34166666666667, "responsiveness": 88.50800000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.71233333333333, "precisionClarity": 86.09933333333333, "calibrationCharity": 82.952 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.32000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 69.803, "responsiveness": 86.15899999999999, "relevanceBurden": 82.935, "precisionClarity": 80.753, "calibrationCharity": 83.28999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 226, "id": "horn-white-purgatory-2024", "title": "Is the Doctrine of Purgatory True? Trent Horn vs. James White", "motion": "Is the doctrine of purgatory true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zhm5_AXcqcA", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 80, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "James White" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "both published sides are theistic/religious", "public_moves": 39, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.09416666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 72.8725, "responsiveness": 84.06083333333333, "relevanceBurden": 82.82666666666667, "precisionClarity": 81.9, "calibrationCharity": 76.43750000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.51, "evidenceWarrant": 76.52000000000001, "responsiveness": 84.94166666666666, "relevanceBurden": 84.23833333333333, "precisionClarity": 80.90833333333333, "calibrationCharity": 74.39666666666668 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 227, "id": "oldfield-marriott-meaning-without-god-2026", "title": "Is God the Answer to Our Meaning Crisis? Elizabeth Oldfield vs. James Marriott", "motion": "Is life's meaning ultimately grounded in God or humanly generated within a meaningless universe?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1cYq2X67PY", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 78, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "con": "James Marriott" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "Religious purpose versus secular meaning", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.1105, "evidenceWarrant": 64.108, "responsiveness": 81.21600000000001, "relevanceBurden": 79.9005, "precisionClarity": 76.65100000000001, "calibrationCharity": 76.898 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.39727272727274, "evidenceWarrant": 66.91499999999999, "responsiveness": 82.00977272727272, "relevanceBurden": 81.89181818181818, "precisionClarity": 80.97613636363636, "calibrationCharity": 81.8334090909091 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.286772727272734, "evidenceWarrant": 2.806999999999988, "responsiveness": 0.7937727272727102, "relevanceBurden": 1.9913181818181869, "precisionClarity": 4.3251363636363465, "calibrationCharity": 4.935409090909104 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0716931818181834, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5613999999999976, "responsiveness": 0.15875454545454204, "relevanceBurden": 0.29869772727272803, "precisionClarity": 0.43251363636363466, "calibrationCharity": 0.4935409090909104 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.01659999999999595 }, { "number": 228, "id": "ehrman-evans-new-testament-misquote-jesus-2010", "title": "Does the New Testament Misquote Jesus? Bart Ehrman vs. Craig Evans", "motion": "Does the New Testament misquote Jesus?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L7gmgdk9qG8", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 83, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Bart Ehrman", "con": "Craig Evans" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Religious reliability defense versus skeptical history", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.97333333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 81.23666666666666, "responsiveness": 89.15666666666667, "relevanceBurden": 89.22999999999999, "precisionClarity": 87.49666666666666, "calibrationCharity": 78.02666666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.36083333333335, "evidenceWarrant": 81.67000000000002, "responsiveness": 80.94583333333333, "relevanceBurden": 85.28, "precisionClarity": 85.77833333333334, "calibrationCharity": 85.99583333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.612499999999983, "evidenceWarrant": -0.43333333333335133, "responsiveness": 8.21083333333334, "relevanceBurden": 3.9499999999999886, "precisionClarity": 1.7183333333333195, "calibrationCharity": -7.969166666666666 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.15312499999999574, "evidenceWarrant": -0.08666666666667028, "responsiveness": 1.642166666666668, "relevanceBurden": 0.5924999999999983, "precisionClarity": 0.17183333333333195, "calibrationCharity": -0.7969166666666667 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3239583333333429 }, { "number": 229, "id": "evans-carrier-did-jesus-exist-2016", "title": "Did Jesus Exist? Craig Evans vs. Richard Carrier", "motion": "Did Jesus exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yRBBQrScpU8", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 80, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Craig Evans", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "A historical Jesus does not imply a divine Jesus", "public_moves": 48, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 6 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.6835, "evidenceWarrant": 70.27540151515151, "responsiveness": 85.90344191919192, "relevanceBurden": 81.43399494949496, "precisionClarity": 81.99131818181817, "calibrationCharity": 73.2614292929293 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.10792424242425, "evidenceWarrant": 70.9783409090909, "responsiveness": 89.16859848484847, "relevanceBurden": 83.71362878787879, "precisionClarity": 82.03077272727273, "calibrationCharity": 73.95713636363635 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 230, "id": "kastrup-oppy-idealism-naturalism-2021", "title": "Does Analytic Idealism Better Explain Reality? Bernardo Kastrup vs. Graham Oppy", "motion": "Does analytic idealism better explain reality than scientific naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8WK-auo8Miw", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 82, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Bernardo Kastrup", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Idealism versus naturalism does not itself establish a God contrast", "public_moves": 36, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.23448051948051, "evidenceWarrant": 71.65172077922078, "responsiveness": 87.01126623376622, "relevanceBurden": 84.62247835497836, "precisionClarity": 85.07772727272727, "calibrationCharity": 82.43329004329004 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.595, "evidenceWarrant": 72.365, "responsiveness": 87.135, "relevanceBurden": 82.9575, "precisionClarity": 84.1425, "calibrationCharity": 85.86999999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 231, "id": "hernandez-aron-ra-soul-existence-2020", "title": "Does the Soul Exist? Eric Hernandez vs. Aron Ra", "motion": "Does the soul exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=utNKIpLq7HM", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 77, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Eric Hernandez", "con": "Aron Ra" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "A nonphysical soul does not itself imply God; consistent with exclusions 190/201", "public_moves": 41, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 6 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.66083333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 62.832333333333324, "responsiveness": 83.82416666666666, "relevanceBurden": 74.24533333333335, "precisionClarity": 82.59466666666665, "calibrationCharity": 70.15283333333333 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.21901515151515, "evidenceWarrant": 70.13431818181817, "responsiveness": 82.55969696969697, "relevanceBurden": 79.63492424242423, "precisionClarity": 79.2789393939394, "calibrationCharity": 75.41106060606062 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 232, "id": "goff-oppy-finite-theism-naturalism-2026", "title": "Philip Goff vs Graham Oppy: Is Finite Theism Preferable to Naturalism?", "motion": "Is finite theism preferable to naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u9ZuXmpod0Q", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 79, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Philip Goff", "con": "Graham Oppy" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Finite theism versus naturalism", "public_moves": 40, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.57604761904761, "evidenceWarrant": 66.45400000000001, "responsiveness": 87.25014285714286, "relevanceBurden": 81.26804761904762, "precisionClarity": 84.25969047619049, "calibrationCharity": 82.0292619047619 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.63214285714284, "evidenceWarrant": 66.70938095238095, "responsiveness": 84.7187619047619, "relevanceBurden": 80.44985714285714, "precisionClarity": 83.2342380952381, "calibrationCharity": 84.6387619047619 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.05609523809522443, "evidenceWarrant": 0.25538095238094627, "responsiveness": -2.5313809523809567, "relevanceBurden": -0.8181904761904804, "precisionClarity": -1.0254523809523874, "calibrationCharity": 2.6095000000000113 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.014023809523806108, "evidenceWarrant": 0.051076190476189255, "responsiveness": -0.5062761904761913, "relevanceBurden": -0.12272857142857205, "precisionClarity": -0.10254523809523874, "calibrationCharity": 0.2609500000000011 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.40550000000000563 }, { "number": 233, "id": "dawkins-mcgrath-christianity-reason-evidence-2006", "title": "Richard Dawkins vs Alister McGrath: Is Christianity Rational?", "motion": "Is Christianity a rational explanation of reality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bLdsRfkkTf4", "date": "2026-09-01", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 82, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Alister McGrath", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christianity as a rational worldview versus naturalistic atheism", "public_moves": 38, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.26063852813853, "evidenceWarrant": 56.29049242424243, "responsiveness": 73.24129112554114, "relevanceBurden": 71.64960173160173, "precisionClarity": 78.9719393939394, "calibrationCharity": 81.39008333333334 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.97627272727273, "evidenceWarrant": 70.26042424242424, "responsiveness": 88.45904545454545, "relevanceBurden": 83.94471212121212, "precisionClarity": 86.34922727272728, "calibrationCharity": 79.11259090909091 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.7156341991342, "evidenceWarrant": 13.969931818181806, "responsiveness": 15.217754329004308, "relevanceBurden": 12.295110389610386, "precisionClarity": 7.377287878787882, "calibrationCharity": -2.277492424242425 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.42890854978355, "evidenceWarrant": 2.7939863636363613, "responsiveness": 3.043550865800862, "relevanceBurden": 1.8442665584415578, "precisionClarity": 0.7377287878787883, "calibrationCharity": -0.2277492424242425 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.3793081168831236 }, { "number": 234, "id": "mcgilchrist-kastrup-consciousness-purpose-2025", "title": "Iain McGilchrist vs Bernardo Kastrup: Consciousness, God, Truth, and Purpose", "motion": "Does a participatory, value-directed account better explain consciousness and cosmic purpose than analytic idealism's perspectival account?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c66QqSHDSNI", "date": "2026-09-02", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 80, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Iain McGilchrist", "con": "Bernardo Kastrup" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Two nonstandard mind-first views; no clean religious-versus-skeptical contrast", "public_moves": 34, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.07555194805194, "evidenceWarrant": 66.21345779220779, "responsiveness": 80.66330086580086, "relevanceBurden": 79.77296536796536, "precisionClarity": 79.19290584415585, "calibrationCharity": 80.65838203463204 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.56142857142856, "evidenceWarrant": 66.77142857142856, "responsiveness": 86.13095238095238, "relevanceBurden": 84.49095238095238, "precisionClarity": 81.76333333333335, "calibrationCharity": 82.24809523809525 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 235, "id": "hernandez-jump-soul-free-will-consciousness-2019", "title": "Eric Hernandez vs Tom Jump: Free Will, Consciousness, and the Existence of the Soul", "motion": "Does a nonphysical human soul exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m7LVr5OaSAE", "date": "2026-09-02", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 78, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Eric Hernandez", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Soul existence alone is religion-adjacent, not a theism contrast", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 69.17318181818182, "evidenceWarrant": 59.39636363636364, "responsiveness": 82.97636363636363, "relevanceBurden": 77.45, "precisionClarity": 78.95681818181819, "calibrationCharity": 69.11227272727272 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.21600000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 68.771, "responsiveness": 85.952, "relevanceBurden": 81.01800000000001, "precisionClarity": 81.66699999999999, "calibrationCharity": 75.651 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 236, "id": "bush-sampson-moral-realism-2022", "title": "Eric Sampson vs Lance Bush: Is Moral Realism True?", "motion": "Is moral realism true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EHIIgQdA2e8", "date": "2026-09-02", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 81, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Eric Sampson", "con": "Lance Bush" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Moral realism versus anti-realism is not theism versus atheism", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.74, "evidenceWarrant": 73.281, "responsiveness": 84.679, "relevanceBurden": 83.112, "precisionClarity": 87.26299999999999, "calibrationCharity": 82.89399999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.88914285714286, "evidenceWarrant": 71.59285714285713, "responsiveness": 85.67171428571429, "relevanceBurden": 83.67542857142858, "precisionClarity": 84.304, "calibrationCharity": 82.00342857142856 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 237, "id": "licona-ehrman-historians-prove-resurrection-2008", "title": "Michael Licona vs Bart Ehrman: Can Historians Prove the Resurrection?", "motion": "Can historians prove that Jesus rose from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MP05c_EvgZ0", "date": "2026-09-02", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 79, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Resurrection defense versus skeptical historical method", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.41238095238094, "evidenceWarrant": 65.73238095238095, "responsiveness": 84.48952380952382, "relevanceBurden": 86.53809523809524, "precisionClarity": 82.01714285714286, "calibrationCharity": 74.80761904761904 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.96000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 67.53, "responsiveness": 87.855, "relevanceBurden": 86.73499999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.57000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 73.025 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.4523809523809348, "evidenceWarrant": 1.797619047619051, "responsiveness": 3.365476190476187, "relevanceBurden": 0.19690476190474726, "precisionClarity": 1.5528571428571496, "calibrationCharity": -1.7826190476190362 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.3630952380952337, "evidenceWarrant": 0.35952380952381024, "responsiveness": 0.6730952380952374, "relevanceBurden": 0.029535714285712087, "precisionClarity": 0.15528571428571497, "calibrationCharity": -0.17826190476190362 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.32391666666666263 }, { "number": 238, "id": "knechtle-dillahunty-christianity-rational-2023", "title": "Stuart Knechtle vs Matt Dillahunty: Is Christianity Rational?", "motion": "Is Christianity rational?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0S_Ul-kRwQ", "date": "2026-09-02", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 82, "con_gap": 14, "speakers": { "pro": "Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian rationality versus skeptical challenge", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 8, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 14, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.961, "evidenceWarrant": 55.20399999999999, "responsiveness": 77.202, "relevanceBurden": 78.353, "precisionClarity": 68.957, "calibrationCharity": 60.182 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.53133333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 72.308, "responsiveness": 87.34266666666666, "relevanceBurden": 88.03133333333334, "precisionClarity": 81.774, "calibrationCharity": 75.45599999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.570333333333338, "evidenceWarrant": 17.104000000000013, "responsiveness": 10.140666666666661, "relevanceBurden": 9.678333333333342, "precisionClarity": 12.817000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 15.273999999999987 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.8925833333333344, "evidenceWarrant": 3.420800000000003, "responsiveness": 2.0281333333333325, "relevanceBurden": 1.4517500000000012, "precisionClarity": 1.2817000000000007, "calibrationCharity": 1.5273999999999988 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.39763333333332973 }, { "number": 239, "id": "harris-peterson-religious-narrative-morality-2018", "title": "Jordan Peterson vs Sam Harris: Can Religious Narratives Ground Morality and Meaning?", "motion": "Can religious narratives provide truthful and necessary foundations for morality and meaning?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GEf6X-FueMo", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 81, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Jordan Peterson", "con": "Sam Harris" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "Religious narrative necessity versus secular alternatives", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.61749999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 63.14625, "responsiveness": 78.29875000000001, "relevanceBurden": 81.44875, "precisionClarity": 76.11625, "calibrationCharity": 74.07 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.18875, "evidenceWarrant": 71.42125, "responsiveness": 82.77499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.56, "precisionClarity": 83.07499999999999, "calibrationCharity": 77.60625 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.571250000000006, "evidenceWarrant": 8.274999999999999, "responsiveness": 4.476249999999979, "relevanceBurden": 5.111249999999998, "precisionClarity": 6.958749999999995, "calibrationCharity": 3.5362500000000097 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.6428125000000016, "evidenceWarrant": 1.6549999999999998, "responsiveness": 0.8952499999999959, "relevanceBurden": 0.7666874999999997, "precisionClarity": 0.6958749999999996, "calibrationCharity": 0.35362500000000097 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.009249999999997982 }, { "number": 240, "id": "swinburne-goff-cosmic-purpose-god-2023", "title": "Richard Swinburne vs Philip Goff: What Best Explains Cosmic Purpose?", "motion": "What best explains apparent cosmic purpose: an omnipotent God or a nontraditional purposeful cosmos?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQmBJDc2FCY", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Swinburne", "con": "Philip Goff" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Both sides defend cosmic purpose; alternatives include a limited designer", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.64399999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 65.92699999999999, "responsiveness": 81.4315, "relevanceBurden": 81.6005, "precisionClarity": 75.9505, "calibrationCharity": 75.01899999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.04666666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 72.80333333333333, "responsiveness": 86.50250000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.88166666666666, "precisionClarity": 86.18249999999999, "calibrationCharity": 82.63833333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 241, "id": "ward-law-god-existence-2015", "title": "Keith Ward vs Stephen Law: Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ll_6JtbQtHU", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 85, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "Keith Ward", "con": "Stephen Law" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Mind-like spiritual God versus evidential skepticism", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 70.44, "evidenceWarrant": 59.05200000000001, "responsiveness": 77.426, "relevanceBurden": 71.276, "precisionClarity": 72.238, "calibrationCharity": 74.905 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.02, "evidenceWarrant": 79.185, "responsiveness": 86.51500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.395, "precisionClarity": 87.175, "calibrationCharity": 84.48 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 16.58, "evidenceWarrant": 20.132999999999996, "responsiveness": 9.089000000000013, "relevanceBurden": 15.119, "precisionClarity": 14.936999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 9.575000000000003 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.145, "evidenceWarrant": 4.026599999999999, "responsiveness": 1.8178000000000027, "relevanceBurden": 2.2678499999999997, "precisionClarity": 1.4936999999999998, "calibrationCharity": 0.9575000000000004 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2915499999999991 }, { "number": 242, "id": "white-crossan-biblical-jesus-historicity-2005", "title": "James White vs John Dominic Crossan: Is the Bible True?", "motion": "Is the orthodox biblical account of Jesus of Nazareth authentic and historically accurate?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BIX7eqTllEc", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 77, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "James White", "con": "John Dominic Crossan" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Two religious readings of Jesus; consistent with Borg/Crossan exclusions", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 3 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.30199999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 72.22, "responsiveness": 81.954, "relevanceBurden": 79.152, "precisionClarity": 81.34, "calibrationCharity": 70.199 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.84342857142857, "evidenceWarrant": 70.296, "responsiveness": 80.0032857142857, "relevanceBurden": 80.10300000000001, "precisionClarity": 80.10228571428573, "calibrationCharity": 75.23842857142857 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 243, "id": "aron-ra-slick-christianity-2014", "title": "Matt Slick vs Aron Ra: Is Christianity True?", "motion": "Is Christianity true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1MwqFMO0Lqw", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 73, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Slick", "con": "Aron Ra" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian truth versus evidential challenge", "public_moves": 43, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 10, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 10, "con": 5 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.5884090909091, "evidenceWarrant": 60.54933441558442, "responsiveness": 80.2197564935065, "relevanceBurden": 75.3703961038961, "precisionClarity": 78.55795454545455, "calibrationCharity": 70.21550324675324 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.38681818181819, "evidenceWarrant": 60.59136363636363, "responsiveness": 81.1140909090909, "relevanceBurden": 79.045, "precisionClarity": 76.92454545454547, "calibrationCharity": 63.48681818181819 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.2015909090909105, "evidenceWarrant": 0.042029220779213006, "responsiveness": 0.8943344155844102, "relevanceBurden": 3.6746038961039034, "precisionClarity": -1.6334090909090833, "calibrationCharity": -6.728685064935057 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.5503977272727276, "evidenceWarrant": 0.008405844155842602, "responsiveness": 0.17886688311688204, "relevanceBurden": 0.5511905844155854, "precisionClarity": -0.16334090909090834, "calibrationCharity": -0.6728685064935057 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.6481438311688316 }, { "number": 244, "id": "jones-schmid-contingency-god-2022", "title": "Michael Jones vs Joseph Schmid: Does the Contingency Argument Support God?", "motion": "Does the contingency argument provide good reason to believe that the necessary foundation of reality is God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSxDzyox0CA", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 87, "con_gap": 14, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Joseph Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "Necessary divine mind versus insufficient identification", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 14, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.79071428571429, "evidenceWarrant": 61.451428571428565, "responsiveness": 80.34928571428571, "relevanceBurden": 78.20714285714286, "precisionClarity": 75.0442857142857, "calibrationCharity": 78.76357142857142 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.965, "evidenceWarrant": 79.225, "responsiveness": 91.65833333333333, "relevanceBurden": 88.96000000000001, "precisionClarity": 86.85666666666667, "calibrationCharity": 90.74666666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 15.174285714285716, "evidenceWarrant": 17.77357142857143, "responsiveness": 11.309047619047618, "relevanceBurden": 10.752857142857152, "precisionClarity": 11.812380952380963, "calibrationCharity": 11.983095238095245 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 3.793571428571429, "evidenceWarrant": 3.554714285714286, "responsiveness": 2.2618095238095237, "relevanceBurden": 1.6129285714285728, "precisionClarity": 1.1812380952380963, "calibrationCharity": 1.1983095238095245 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.39742857142856813 }, { "number": 245, "id": "goff-folley-consciousness-mysticism-fine-tuning-2026", "title": "Philip Goff vs Joe Folley: Consciousness, Mystical Experience, and Fine-Tuning", "motion": "Do consciousness, mystical experience, and fine-tuning support a panpsychist and theistic interpretation of reality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DB2BuBqAMIs", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 86, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Philip Goff", "con": "Joe Folley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "Explicit nontraditional theism versus skeptical objections", "public_moves": 44, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.51545454545455, "evidenceWarrant": 72.69594696969698, "responsiveness": 82.51439393939394, "relevanceBurden": 78.55939393939393, "precisionClarity": 86.62723484848485, "calibrationCharity": 83.33950757575758 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.79875000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 80.26875, "responsiveness": 88.97375, "relevanceBurden": 86.77875, "precisionClarity": 86.59125, "calibrationCharity": 89.82625000000002 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.283295454545467, "evidenceWarrant": 7.572803030303021, "responsiveness": 6.459356060606055, "relevanceBurden": 8.219356060606074, "precisionClarity": -0.03598484848484418, "calibrationCharity": 6.486742424242436 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.8208238636363667, "evidenceWarrant": 1.5145606060606043, "responsiveness": 1.291871212121211, "relevanceBurden": 1.232903409090911, "precisionClarity": -0.003598484848484418, "calibrationCharity": 0.6486742424242437 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5052348484848519 }, { "number": 246, "id": "pine-schmid-divine-simplicity-2021", "title": "Gregory Pine vs Joseph Schmid: Is Divine Simplicity True?", "motion": "Is divine simplicity true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhke5_tk6N0", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 87, "con_gap": 12, "speakers": { "pro": "Gregory Pine", "con": "Joseph Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Classical-theist doctrine versus agnostic criticism; broad-set only", "public_moves": 31, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 12, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.36809523809524, "evidenceWarrant": 67.02809523809525, "responsiveness": 73.59895238095238, "relevanceBurden": 73.36266666666666, "precisionClarity": 80.67752380952382, "calibrationCharity": 84.24733333333333 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.345, "evidenceWarrant": 80.57049999999998, "responsiveness": 89.841, "relevanceBurden": 87.3135, "precisionClarity": 88.896, "calibrationCharity": 87.80499999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.976904761904763, "evidenceWarrant": 13.542404761904734, "responsiveness": 16.24204761904761, "relevanceBurden": 13.95083333333335, "precisionClarity": 8.218476190476181, "calibrationCharity": 3.5576666666666625 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.4942261904761907, "evidenceWarrant": 2.708480952380947, "responsiveness": 3.2484095238095225, "relevanceBurden": 2.092625000000002, "precisionClarity": 0.8218476190476182, "calibrationCharity": 0.3557666666666663 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2786440476190535 }, { "number": 247, "id": "folley-scrivener-good-without-god-2025", "title": "Joe Folley vs Glen Scrivener: Goodness Without God", "motion": "Can we be good without God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4Foy83uTsBQ", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 76, "con_gap": -9, "speakers": { "pro": "Joe Folley", "con": "Glen Scrivener" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-independent goodness versus foundation in Christ", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 6 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 7 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.24842857142858, "evidenceWarrant": 78.5577142857143, "responsiveness": 86.87785714285715, "relevanceBurden": 85.0232857142857, "precisionClarity": 85.51585714285714, "calibrationCharity": 90.47728571428571 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.125, "evidenceWarrant": 69.57000000000001, "responsiveness": 80.565, "relevanceBurden": 75.4825, "precisionClarity": 81.80625, "calibrationCharity": 79.035 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 10.123428571428576, "evidenceWarrant": 8.98771428571429, "responsiveness": 6.312857142857155, "relevanceBurden": 9.540785714285704, "precisionClarity": 3.7096071428571378, "calibrationCharity": 11.442285714285717 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.530857142857144, "evidenceWarrant": 1.797542857142858, "responsiveness": 1.2625714285714311, "relevanceBurden": 1.4311178571428556, "precisionClarity": 0.3709607142857138, "calibrationCharity": 1.1442285714285718 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.4627214285714256 }, { "number": 248, "id": "tomaszewski-schmid-classical-theism-monotheism-2020", "title": "Christopher Tomaszewski vs Joe Schmid: Classical Theism and Monotheism", "motion": "Does Thomistic classical theism adequately account for abstract objects, divine uniqueness, and relations to creation?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6kdwlkceRA", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 85, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "con": "Joseph Schmid" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Classical-theist explanation versus agnostic criticism; broad-set only", "public_moves": 46, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.34300000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 76.15713636363637, "responsiveness": 83.08831818181818, "relevanceBurden": 81.356, "precisionClarity": 85.84722727272728, "calibrationCharity": 83.59436363636362 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.82207070707071, "evidenceWarrant": 77.44560606060605, "responsiveness": 88.27257575757574, "relevanceBurden": 85.00676767676768, "precisionClarity": 84.75080808080807, "calibrationCharity": 91.03954545454545 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.47907070707069, "evidenceWarrant": 1.2884696969696847, "responsiveness": 5.184257575757556, "relevanceBurden": 3.6507676767676855, "precisionClarity": -1.0964191919192103, "calibrationCharity": 7.445181818181823 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.6197676767676725, "evidenceWarrant": 0.257693939393937, "responsiveness": 1.0368515151515112, "relevanceBurden": 0.5476151515151528, "precisionClarity": -0.10964191919192104, "calibrationCharity": 0.7445181818181823 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.09680454545453498 }, { "number": 249, "id": "adelstein-bush-moral-realism-2021", "title": "Matthew Adelstein vs Lance Bush: Moral Realism", "motion": "Are there stance-independent moral facts?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zqupGKqcPck", "date": "2026-09-03", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 86, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Matthew Adelstein", "con": "Lance Bush" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Stance-independent morality is not equivalent to theism", "public_moves": 45, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.56166666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 66.9375, "responsiveness": 83.90499999999999, "relevanceBurden": 78.71249999999999, "precisionClarity": 82.88750000000002, "calibrationCharity": 83.27 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.975, "evidenceWarrant": 78.05499999999999, "responsiveness": 89.885, "relevanceBurden": 86.995, "precisionClarity": 89.7075, "calibrationCharity": 83.48750000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 250, "id": "anderson-jump-logic-belief-god-2020", "title": "James Anderson vs Tom Jump: Logic and Belief in God", "motion": "Is there reason to believe in God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6-57NNo5fA", "date": "2026-09-04", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 74, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "James Anderson", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theistic versus naturalistic explanation of logic", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.88, "evidenceWarrant": 73.18714285714286, "responsiveness": 84.03, "relevanceBurden": 79.56142857142858, "precisionClarity": 85.24857142857142, "calibrationCharity": 79.41000000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.66875, "evidenceWarrant": 67.9025, "responsiveness": 76.14375, "relevanceBurden": 76.48375, "precisionClarity": 75.10625, "calibrationCharity": 77.77125 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -4.211249999999993, "evidenceWarrant": -5.284642857142856, "responsiveness": -7.886250000000004, "relevanceBurden": -3.077678571428578, "precisionClarity": -10.142321428571421, "calibrationCharity": -1.638750000000016 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.0528124999999982, "evidenceWarrant": -1.0569285714285712, "responsiveness": -1.577250000000001, "relevanceBurden": -0.46165178571428667, "precisionClarity": -1.0142321428571421, "calibrationCharity": -0.1638750000000016 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.32675000000000054 }, { "number": 251, "id": "oconnor-baker-hytch-evil-god-challenge-2021", "title": "Alex O'Connor vs Max Baker-Hytch: Could God Be Evil?", "motion": "Does the evil-god challenge undermine belief in a wholly good God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1EwbFlV2XU", "date": "2026-09-04", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 84, "con": 83, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Alex O'Connor", "con": "Max Baker-Hytch" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Evil-God challenge versus divine-goodness defense", "public_moves": 42, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 84.21590909090908, "evidenceWarrant": 77.48454545454544, "responsiveness": 87.16340909090908, "relevanceBurden": 84.78727272727274, "precisionClarity": 85.65886363636365, "calibrationCharity": 86.70886363636365 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.4643722943723, "evidenceWarrant": 74.61619047619047, "responsiveness": 85.7723593073593, "relevanceBurden": 80.50722943722946, "precisionClarity": 87.38553030303031, "calibrationCharity": 91.08485930735932 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.248463203463217, "evidenceWarrant": 2.868354978354972, "responsiveness": 1.3910497835497893, "relevanceBurden": 4.280043290043281, "precisionClarity": -1.7266666666666595, "calibrationCharity": -4.375995670995678 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.31211580086580426, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5736709956709944, "responsiveness": 0.27820995670995785, "relevanceBurden": 0.6420064935064921, "precisionClarity": -0.17266666666666597, "calibrationCharity": -0.4375995670995678 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.4284945887445937 }, { "number": 252, "id": "jones-oconnor-evil-suffering-2020", "title": "Michael Jones vs Alex O'Connor: Would a loving God allow the evil and suffering found in our world?", "motion": "Would a loving God allow the evil and suffering found in our world?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hNF9bTESZwE", "date": "2026-09-04", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 85, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Jones", "con": "Alex O'Connor" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian permission-of-evil defense versus suffering challenge", "public_moves": 37, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.12249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 61.07940476190476, "responsiveness": 77.0502380952381, "relevanceBurden": 74.05238095238096, "precisionClarity": 81.37714285714287, "calibrationCharity": 75.13392857142856 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.20142857142856, "evidenceWarrant": 79.88642857142857, "responsiveness": 86.57142857142858, "relevanceBurden": 86.50714285714284, "precisionClarity": 88.01285714285714, "calibrationCharity": 82.52785714285714 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.078928571428577, "evidenceWarrant": 18.807023809523805, "responsiveness": 9.521190476190483, "relevanceBurden": 12.454761904761881, "precisionClarity": 6.635714285714272, "calibrationCharity": 7.393928571428589 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.269732142857144, "evidenceWarrant": 3.7614047619047613, "responsiveness": 1.9042380952380968, "relevanceBurden": 1.868214285714282, "precisionClarity": 0.6635714285714273, "calibrationCharity": 0.739392857142859 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.20655357142856978 }, { "number": 253, "id": "clifton-sechler-divine-hiddenness-hell-2022", "title": "Zac Sechler vs Scott Clifton: Is Christian belief in a loving God plausible despite divine hiddenness and the prospect of hell?", "motion": "Is Christian belief in a loving God plausible despite divine hiddenness and the prospect of hell?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Yg-YpvuteM", "date": "2026-09-04", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 83, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Zac Sechler", "con": "Scott Clifton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian plausibility versus hiddenness and hell challenge", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.174, "evidenceWarrant": 57.24144444444445, "responsiveness": 74.67855555555556, "relevanceBurden": 75.56766666666667, "precisionClarity": 77.92755555555556, "calibrationCharity": 73.743 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.4745, "evidenceWarrant": 66.7175, "responsiveness": 89.96900000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.89099999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.83449999999999, "calibrationCharity": 84.28049999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.3005, "evidenceWarrant": 9.476055555555554, "responsiveness": 15.290444444444447, "relevanceBurden": 11.323333333333323, "precisionClarity": 7.906944444444434, "calibrationCharity": 10.537499999999994 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.075125, "evidenceWarrant": 1.895211111111111, "responsiveness": 3.0580888888888893, "relevanceBurden": 1.6984999999999986, "precisionClarity": 0.7906944444444435, "calibrationCharity": 1.0537499999999995 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.42863055555555896 }, { "number": 254, "id": "knechtle-dillahunty-bowen-biblical-slavery-2021", "title": "Cliffe Knechtle & Stuart Knechtle vs Matt Dillahunty & Joshua Bowen: Is the Bible's treatment of slavery morally defensible?", "motion": "Is the Bible's treatment of slavery morally defensible?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gcszn0DvFlM", "date": "2026-09-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2 — Multi-Speaker Approximation", "pro": 69, "con": 85, "con_gap": 16, "speakers": { "pro": "Cliffe Knechtle & Stuart Knechtle", "con": "Matt Dillahunty & Joshua Bowen" }, "ranking_eligible": false, "cohort": "unlocked", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Multi-speaker team assessment; excluded from comparable position analysis", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 3 } }, { "number": 255, "id": "licona-carrier-resurrection-formal-rounds-2004", "title": "Mike Licona vs Richard Carrier — Did Jesus rise from the dead? (2004, formal rounds)", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWa3DSxETaU", "date": "2026-09-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 81, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Licona", "con": "Richard Carrier" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian resurrection case versus skeptical historical account", "public_moves": 27, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.59342857142856, "evidenceWarrant": 74.65199999999999, "responsiveness": 88.13000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.7817142857143, "precisionClarity": 84.336, "calibrationCharity": 73.87285714285714 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.53999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 72.946, "responsiveness": 89.184, "relevanceBurden": 87.02, "precisionClarity": 84.47, "calibrationCharity": 71.34 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.0534285714285687, "evidenceWarrant": -1.7059999999999889, "responsiveness": 1.0539999999999878, "relevanceBurden": -0.7617142857143051, "precisionClarity": 0.13400000000000034, "calibrationCharity": -2.5328571428571394 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.2633571428571422, "evidenceWarrant": -0.3411999999999978, "responsiveness": 0.21079999999999757, "relevanceBurden": -0.11425714285714576, "precisionClarity": 0.013400000000000035, "calibrationCharity": -0.25328571428571395 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2520999999999979 }, { "number": 256, "id": "aron-ra-jones-christianity-dangerous-formal-rounds-2019", "title": "Aron Ra vs Michael Jones — Is Christianity dangerous? (2019, formal rounds)", "motion": "Is Christianity dangerous?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bQBFY1z_RvI", "date": "2026-09-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 82, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Aron Ra", "con": "Michael Jones" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "Defense of Christianity against an atheist social-harm challenge; broad set only", "public_moves": 28, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.22, "evidenceWarrant": 66.72642857142857, "responsiveness": 81.16142857142857, "relevanceBurden": 81.12642857142858, "precisionClarity": 78.85142857142857, "calibrationCharity": 64.73428571428572 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.15205555555556, "evidenceWarrant": 77.6358888888889, "responsiveness": 84.39026984126986, "relevanceBurden": 84.14365873015873, "precisionClarity": 85.05284920634921, "calibrationCharity": 80.90398412698413 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -4.932055555555564, "evidenceWarrant": -10.90946031746033, "responsiveness": -3.2288412698412827, "relevanceBurden": -3.0172301587301575, "precisionClarity": -6.2014206349206376, "calibrationCharity": -16.16969841269841 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.233013888888891, "evidenceWarrant": -2.1818920634920658, "responsiveness": -0.6457682539682565, "relevanceBurden": -0.45258452380952363, "precisionClarity": -0.6201420634920638, "calibrationCharity": -1.616969841269841 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2496293650793584 }, { "number": 257, "id": "atkins-law-science-philosophy-formal-rounds-2014", "title": "Peter Atkins vs Stephen Law — Science or philosophy? (2014, formal rounds)", "motion": "Is science a better model for free inquiry than philosophy?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i5AyjXBgjvA", "date": "2026-09-10", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 65, "con": 82, "con_gap": 17, "speakers": { "pro": "Peter Atkins", "con": "Stephen Law" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Science versus philosophy is not a religious-versus-skeptical contrast", "public_moves": 17, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.048, "evidenceWarrant": 61.28, "responsiveness": 64.554, "relevanceBurden": 69.658, "precisionClarity": 70.896, "calibrationCharity": 50.73799999999999 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.3892857142857, "evidenceWarrant": 74.83142857142857, "responsiveness": 85.46357142857143, "relevanceBurden": 84.155, "precisionClarity": 84.47285714285714, "calibrationCharity": 83.83071428571427 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 258, "id": "white-price-bible-truth-formal-rounds-2010", "title": "James White vs Robert Price — Is the Bible true? (2010, formal rounds)", "motion": "Is the Bible true?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DmA6c0yoVrQ", "date": "2026-09-10", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 81, "con": 78, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "James White", "con": "Robert Price" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Biblical reliability defense versus skeptical history; broad set only", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.79066666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 75.72266666666667, "responsiveness": 85.483, "relevanceBurden": 83.23566666666667, "precisionClarity": 82.82633333333334, "calibrationCharity": 75.89866666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.011, "evidenceWarrant": 73.46857142857144, "responsiveness": 84.49942857142858, "relevanceBurden": 81.399, "precisionClarity": 80.80942857142857, "calibrationCharity": 74.97314285714285 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -6.779666666666671, "evidenceWarrant": -2.254095238095232, "responsiveness": -0.9835714285714232, "relevanceBurden": -1.836666666666673, "precisionClarity": -2.016904761904769, "calibrationCharity": -0.9255238095238241 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.6949166666666677, "evidenceWarrant": -0.4508190476190464, "responsiveness": -0.19671428571428465, "relevanceBurden": -0.27550000000000097, "precisionClarity": -0.2016904761904769, "calibrationCharity": -0.09255238095238241 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.08780714285714097 }, { "number": 259, "id": "kastrup-blackmore-conscious-illusion-2023", "title": "Bernardo Kastrup vs Susan Blackmore — Consciousness and illusion", "motion": "Does analytic idealism adequately explain consciousness?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrVnAWP2XEs", "date": "2026-09-11", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 85, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "Bernardo Kastrup", "con": "Susan Blackmore" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Idealism versus illusionism does not itself establish a God contrast", "public_moves": 33, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.83038095238095, "evidenceWarrant": 70.667, "responsiveness": 78.09423809523808, "relevanceBurden": 80.24795238095238, "precisionClarity": 81.91933333333333, "calibrationCharity": 66.62457142857141 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.03875000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 75.81875, "responsiveness": 89.77625, "relevanceBurden": 87.8375, "precisionClarity": 86.40750000000001, "calibrationCharity": 89.73625 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 260, "id": "boteach-hitchens-god-morality-2008", "title": "Shmuley Boteach vs Christopher Hitchens — God and morality", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vnMYL8sF7bQ", "date": "2026-09-12", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 80, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Shmuley Boteach", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Jewish theism versus atheism", "public_moves": 40, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 10, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.71150000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 65.79263636363636, "responsiveness": 82.51636363636365, "relevanceBurden": 79.30468181818182, "precisionClarity": 76.49077272727273, "calibrationCharity": 65.77381818181817 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.84860606060606, "evidenceWarrant": 73.18472727272727, "responsiveness": 87.07745454545456, "relevanceBurden": 82.79315151515151, "precisionClarity": 81.90521212121212, "calibrationCharity": 71.46727272727273 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.137106060606044, "evidenceWarrant": 7.392090909090911, "responsiveness": 4.5610909090909075, "relevanceBurden": 3.4884696969696876, "precisionClarity": 5.414439393939389, "calibrationCharity": 5.693454545454557 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.534276515151511, "evidenceWarrant": 1.4784181818181823, "responsiveness": 0.9122181818181816, "relevanceBurden": 0.5232704545454531, "precisionClarity": 0.541443939393939, "calibrationCharity": 0.5693454545454557 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.44102727272727726 }, { "number": 261, "id": "sharpton-hitchens-god-religion-morality-2007", "title": "Al Sharpton vs Christopher Hitchens — God, religion, and morality", "motion": "Is God great?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HPYxA8dYLBY", "date": "2026-09-13", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 84, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Al Sharpton", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Personal theism versus atheism", "public_moves": 31, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 7, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.63683333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 58.58091666666667, "responsiveness": 84.18691666666666, "relevanceBurden": 84.10258333333333, "precisionClarity": 81.36783333333334, "calibrationCharity": 73.83958333333334 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.99374999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 75.87875, "responsiveness": 88.76875, "relevanceBurden": 87.11125, "precisionClarity": 85.26708333333333, "calibrationCharity": 78.97 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.356916666666663, "evidenceWarrant": 17.29783333333333, "responsiveness": 4.581833333333336, "relevanceBurden": 3.00866666666667, "precisionClarity": 3.899249999999995, "calibrationCharity": 5.130416666666662 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.339229166666666, "evidenceWarrant": 3.459566666666666, "responsiveness": 0.9163666666666672, "relevanceBurden": 0.4513000000000005, "precisionClarity": 0.3899249999999995, "calibrationCharity": 0.5130416666666662 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06942916666666576 }, { "number": 262, "id": "harris-haidt-religion-moral-truth-2016", "title": "Sam Harris vs Jonathan Haidt — Religion, moral truth, and human flourishing", "motion": "Is a rational account centered on well-being sufficient to explain and guide morality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-WmmcTUkdVM", "date": "2026-09-13", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 82, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Sam Harris", "con": "Jonathan Haidt" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Two naturalistic accounts of morality", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.00755555555554, "evidenceWarrant": 70.11555555555556, "responsiveness": 86.21933333333334, "relevanceBurden": 86.02222222222223, "precisionClarity": 82.27333333333333, "calibrationCharity": 82.35777777777777 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.93028571428572, "evidenceWarrant": 71.42171428571427, "responsiveness": 84.27542857142858, "relevanceBurden": 85.79657142857143, "precisionClarity": 83.95428571428572, "calibrationCharity": 82.84628571428571 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 263, "id": "dembski-hitchens-good-god-existence-2010", "title": "William Dembski vs Christopher Hitchens — Does a good God exist?", "motion": "Does a good God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6K43WSZrmI", "date": "2026-09-18", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 79, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "William Dembski", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Broad good-God case versus skeptical objections", "public_moves": 40, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 8, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.46236363636365, "evidenceWarrant": 59.59954545454545, "responsiveness": 75.06318181818182, "relevanceBurden": 80.07609090909091, "precisionClarity": 77.06827272727273, "calibrationCharity": 65.10754545454546 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.70456493506494, "evidenceWarrant": 70.00884415584414, "responsiveness": 82.9007987012987, "relevanceBurden": 84.80255194805196, "precisionClarity": 81.56717532467532, "calibrationCharity": 71.02453896103896 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.242201298701289, "evidenceWarrant": 10.409298701298695, "responsiveness": 7.83761688311688, "relevanceBurden": 4.726461038961048, "precisionClarity": 4.498902597402591, "calibrationCharity": 5.9169935064934975 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8105503246753223, "evidenceWarrant": 2.081859740259739, "responsiveness": 1.567523376623376, "relevanceBurden": 0.7089691558441572, "precisionClarity": 0.4498902597402591, "calibrationCharity": 0.5916993506493498 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.7895077922077967 }, { "number": 264, "id": "chopra-dawkins-consciousness-purpose-spirituality-2013", "title": "Deepak Chopra vs Richard Dawkins — Consciousness, Cosmic Purpose, and Spirituality", "motion": "Does spirituality provide knowledge of consciousness, cosmic purpose, and human well-being beyond naturalistic science?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BiwLrxPb1fE", "date": "2026-09-19", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 66, "con": 86, "con_gap": 20, "speakers": { "pro": "Deepak Chopra", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Spiritual nondualism and consciousness claims do not provide a sufficiently explicit God contrast", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 63.212380952380954, "evidenceWarrant": 56.28523809523809, "responsiveness": 74.71238095238095, "relevanceBurden": 74.31142857142856, "precisionClarity": 65.36142857142858, "calibrationCharity": 59.90714285714285 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.7425, "evidenceWarrant": 77.31, "responsiveness": 89.52, "relevanceBurden": 88.1475, "precisionClarity": 87.87, "calibrationCharity": 83.2025 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 265, "id": "donahue-linford-fine-tuning-theism-2026", "title": "Miles K. Donahue vs Dan Linford — Fine-Tuning and Theism", "motion": "Does cosmic fine-tuning provide strong evidence for theism over naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ui9C6N4HFvY", "date": "2026-09-23", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 87, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Miles Donahue", "con": "Daniel Linford" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theistic fine-tuning versus naturalistic and probabilistic objections", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.83244444444445, "evidenceWarrant": 66.367, "responsiveness": 86.90177777777778, "relevanceBurden": 87.54866666666666, "precisionClarity": 84.25533333333334, "calibrationCharity": 78.68311111111112 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.12666666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 80.79888888888888, "responsiveness": 89.79722222222222, "relevanceBurden": 88.52722222222222, "precisionClarity": 86.77555555555556, "calibrationCharity": 89.28666666666666 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.294222222222217, "evidenceWarrant": 14.431888888888878, "responsiveness": 2.8954444444444363, "relevanceBurden": 0.978555555555559, "precisionClarity": 2.520222222222216, "calibrationCharity": 10.603555555555545 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.0735555555555543, "evidenceWarrant": 2.886377777777776, "responsiveness": 0.5790888888888873, "relevanceBurden": 0.14678333333333385, "precisionClarity": 0.25202222222222165, "calibrationCharity": 1.0603555555555546 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.0018166666666727949 }, { "number": 266, "id": "dillahunty-giunta-faith-rational-justification-2018", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Blake Giunta — Faith and Rational Justification", "motion": "Must God's possibility be demonstrated before belief in God can be rationally justified?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHg_NL4EUAE", "date": "2026-09-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 82, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Dillahunty", "con": "Blake Giunta" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Mind, reason & logic", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theistic justification versus a skeptical prior-possibility requirement", "public_moves": 39, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.44911904761905, "evidenceWarrant": 77.63119047619048, "responsiveness": 88.45114285714286, "relevanceBurden": 85.09954761904763, "precisionClarity": 81.76388095238096, "calibrationCharity": 82.35728571428572 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.837, "evidenceWarrant": 73.22157142857142, "responsiveness": 86.93185714285714, "relevanceBurden": 82.97285714285715, "precisionClarity": 82.61957142857143, "calibrationCharity": 83.2352857142857 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -0.38788095238095366, "evidenceWarrant": 4.40961904761906, "responsiveness": 1.519285714285715, "relevanceBurden": 2.1266904761904755, "precisionClarity": -0.8556904761904747, "calibrationCharity": -0.8779999999999717 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.09697023809523841, "evidenceWarrant": 0.881923809523812, "responsiveness": 0.30385714285714305, "relevanceBurden": 0.31900357142857133, "precisionClarity": -0.08556904761904748, "calibrationCharity": -0.08779999999999717 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.2344452380952433 }, { "number": 267, "id": "hitchens-wilson-truth-goodness-beauty-2008", "title": "Christopher Hitchens vs Douglas Wilson — Truth, Goodness, and Beauty", "motion": "Are truth, goodness, and beauty better explained by Christian theism than by atheistic naturalism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g6UU9C-WmvM", "date": "2026-09-24", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 80, "con_gap": 5, "speakers": { "pro": "Douglas Wilson", "con": "Christopher Hitchens" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian theism versus atheism across truth, goodness and beauty", "public_moves": 24, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 5, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.15400000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 63.162, "responsiveness": 81.528, "relevanceBurden": 80.704, "precisionClarity": 79.81, "calibrationCharity": 71.27 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.187, "evidenceWarrant": 73.02, "responsiveness": 87.13466666666666, "relevanceBurden": 84.731, "precisionClarity": 81.12033333333335, "calibrationCharity": 69.894 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.032999999999987, "evidenceWarrant": 9.857999999999997, "responsiveness": 5.606666666666655, "relevanceBurden": 4.027000000000001, "precisionClarity": 1.3103333333333467, "calibrationCharity": -1.3759999999999906 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2582499999999968, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9715999999999996, "responsiveness": 1.121333333333331, "relevanceBurden": 0.6040500000000001, "precisionClarity": 0.13103333333333467, "calibrationCharity": -0.13759999999999906 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.05133333333333656 }, { "number": 268, "id": "sacks-dawkins-science-religion-2012", "title": "Jonathan Sacks vs Richard Dawkins — Science and Religion", "motion": "Can religion and science form a coherent partnership?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ad3rVRdgbI", "date": "2026-09-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 85, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan Sacks", "con": "Richard Dawkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "Religious partnership with science versus naturalistic criticism; broad set only", "public_moves": 27, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.24249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 66.40750000000001, "responsiveness": 80.755, "relevanceBurden": 78.125, "precisionClarity": 82.6525, "calibrationCharity": 77.3525 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.5435, "evidenceWarrant": 79.00599999999999, "responsiveness": 90.33999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.1345, "precisionClarity": 86.424, "calibrationCharity": 82.08099999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.301000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 12.598499999999973, "responsiveness": 9.584999999999994, "relevanceBurden": 9.009500000000003, "precisionClarity": 3.771500000000003, "calibrationCharity": 4.728499999999983 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.3252500000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 2.519699999999995, "responsiveness": 1.916999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 1.3514250000000003, "precisionClarity": 0.3771500000000003, "calibrationCharity": 0.47284999999999827 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.9633749999999939 }, { "number": 269, "id": "loke-linford-physical-reality-cause-beginning-2023", "title": "Andrew Loke vs Dan Linford — Physical Reality, Causation, and Beginnings", "motion": "In light of contemporary physics, should we accept that physical reality had a cause or beginning?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WjVHREd0mvQ", "date": "2026-09-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 88, "con_gap": 18, "speakers": { "pro": "Andrew Loke", "con": "Daniel Linford" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "First-cause/agency defense versus cosmological skepticism; motion concerns cosmic origins, not a complete religious doctrine", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 18, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.09750000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 64.20666666666668, "responsiveness": 77.94500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 71.96916666666667, "precisionClarity": 73.41833333333334, "calibrationCharity": 63.18333333333334 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.17, "evidenceWarrant": 80.82944444444445, "responsiveness": 91.86638888888889, "relevanceBurden": 90.46611111111112, "precisionClarity": 88.35333333333334, "calibrationCharity": 89.10416666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 19.07249999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 16.62277777777777, "responsiveness": 13.921388888888885, "relevanceBurden": 18.496944444444452, "precisionClarity": 14.935000000000002, "calibrationCharity": 25.920833333333334 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.768124999999998, "evidenceWarrant": 3.324555555555554, "responsiveness": 2.784277777777777, "relevanceBurden": 2.774541666666668, "precisionClarity": 1.4935000000000003, "calibrationCharity": 2.5920833333333335 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.26291666666666913 }, { "number": 270, "id": "horn-barker-christian-god-2018", "title": "Trent Horn vs Dan Barker — Does the Christian God Exist?", "motion": "Does the Christian God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bIuDfh-6iUs", "date": "2026-09-26", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 71, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian-God defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.90285714285714, "evidenceWarrant": 63.760000000000005, "responsiveness": 79.16, "relevanceBurden": 80.52285714285713, "precisionClarity": 80.47714285714285, "calibrationCharity": 65.66857142857143 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 68.76472727272727, "evidenceWarrant": 62.91927272727273, "responsiveness": 78.00860606060607, "relevanceBurden": 78.01781818181817, "precisionClarity": 75.12072727272728, "calibrationCharity": 64.64072727272728 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -3.138129870129873, "evidenceWarrant": -0.8407272727272783, "responsiveness": -1.1513939393939268, "relevanceBurden": -2.505038961038963, "precisionClarity": -5.356415584415572, "calibrationCharity": -1.02784415584415 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.7845324675324683, "evidenceWarrant": -0.16814545454545568, "responsiveness": -0.23027878787878536, "relevanceBurden": -0.37575584415584445, "precisionClarity": -0.5356415584415573, "calibrationCharity": -0.102784415584415 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.19713852813852606 }, { "number": 271, "id": "craig-pigliucci-christian-god-2001", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Massimo Pigliucci — Does the Christian God Exist?", "motion": "Does the Christian God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rr2nrj3yXq8", "date": "2026-09-27", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 72, "con_gap": -6, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Massimo Pigliucci" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian-God defense versus skeptical naturalism", "public_moves": 38, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.01140909090908, "evidenceWarrant": 69.01977922077921, "responsiveness": 85.51881818181819, "relevanceBurden": 84.51272077922077, "precisionClarity": 85.452, "calibrationCharity": 66.83802597402598 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.325, "evidenceWarrant": 63.45386363636364, "responsiveness": 77.75909090909092, "relevanceBurden": 78.24568181818182, "precisionClarity": 75.72931818181819, "calibrationCharity": 66.105 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -5.6864090909090805, "evidenceWarrant": -5.5659155844155705, "responsiveness": -7.759727272727275, "relevanceBurden": -6.267038961038949, "precisionClarity": -9.722681818181812, "calibrationCharity": -0.7330259740259777 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.4216022727272701, "evidenceWarrant": -1.113183116883114, "responsiveness": -1.5519454545454552, "relevanceBurden": -0.9400558441558423, "precisionClarity": -0.9722681818181812, "calibrationCharity": -0.07330259740259777 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.07235746753246097 }, { "number": 272, "id": "mclatchie-jump-god-existence-2019", "title": "Jonathan McLatchie vs Tom Jump — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-U3IyfrnavU", "date": "2026-09-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 76, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Tom Jump" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theistic cumulative case versus atheism", "public_moves": 34, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.91974025974027, "evidenceWarrant": 66.85298701298701, "responsiveness": 88.38623376623376, "relevanceBurden": 85.33917748917749, "precisionClarity": 82.25463203463204, "calibrationCharity": 71.5022077922078 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.88578282828283, "evidenceWarrant": 60.65695707070707, "responsiveness": 89.13760101010101, "relevanceBurden": 83.95099747474748, "precisionClarity": 80.49117424242424, "calibrationCharity": 69.76444444444444 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -2.033957431457438, "evidenceWarrant": -6.196029942279942, "responsiveness": 0.7513672438672501, "relevanceBurden": -1.3881800144300058, "precisionClarity": -1.7634577922078023, "calibrationCharity": -1.7377633477633623 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.5084893578643594, "evidenceWarrant": -1.2392059884559885, "responsiveness": 0.15027344877345003, "relevanceBurden": -0.20822700216450088, "precisionClarity": -0.17634577922078024, "calibrationCharity": -0.17377633477633625 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.8442289862914847 }, { "number": 273, "id": "craig-dacey-god-existence-2004", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Austin Dacey — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pnof3-hdMOE", "date": "2026-09-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 82, "con_gap": 9, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Austin Dacey" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence case versus skeptical naturalism", "public_moves": 42, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 7, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 9, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 9, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.04454545454544, "evidenceWarrant": 61.612878787878785, "responsiveness": 79.2289393939394, "relevanceBurden": 79.60060606060605, "precisionClarity": 80.72424242424243, "calibrationCharity": 63.37681818181819 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.42999999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 72.405, "responsiveness": 88.02113636363637, "relevanceBurden": 85.56636363636363, "precisionClarity": 86.35227272727272, "calibrationCharity": 79.70386363636364 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.38545454545455, "evidenceWarrant": 10.792121212121216, "responsiveness": 8.792196969696974, "relevanceBurden": 5.9657575757575785, "precisionClarity": 5.628030303030286, "calibrationCharity": 16.32704545454545 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.0963636363636375, "evidenceWarrant": 2.1584242424242435, "responsiveness": 1.758439393939395, "relevanceBurden": 0.8948636363636367, "precisionClarity": 0.5628030303030286, "calibrationCharity": 1.632704545454545 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.10359848484848655 }, { "number": 274, "id": "ayala-barker-biblical-god-2026", "title": "Eli Ayala vs Dan Barker — Does the God of the Bible Exist?", "motion": "Does the God of the Bible exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fzP-3z3RoFM", "date": "2026-09-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 78, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Eli Ayala", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Biblical-God and transcendental defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 39, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.99667857142857, "evidenceWarrant": 60.49371428571428, "responsiveness": 79.16239285714286, "relevanceBurden": 77.64146428571428, "precisionClarity": 80.08957142857143, "calibrationCharity": 66.71164285714285 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.65882142857141, "evidenceWarrant": 66.99782142857143, "responsiveness": 85.49507142857144, "relevanceBurden": 83.48028571428571, "precisionClarity": 80.94907142857143, "calibrationCharity": 73.77485714285714 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.66214285714284, "evidenceWarrant": 6.504107142857144, "responsiveness": 6.332678571428573, "relevanceBurden": 5.8388214285714355, "precisionClarity": 0.859499999999997, "calibrationCharity": 7.063214285714295 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.16553571428571, "evidenceWarrant": 1.300821428571429, "responsiveness": 1.2665357142857148, "relevanceBurden": 0.8758232142857153, "precisionClarity": 0.08594999999999971, "calibrationCharity": 0.7063214285714295 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.5990125000000015 }, { "number": 275, "id": "craig-tooley-god-real-2010", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Michael Tooley — Is God Real?", "motion": "Is God real?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBEKUBOMA_0", "date": "2026-09-28", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 80, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Michael Tooley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence case versus skeptical naturalism", "public_moves": 46, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 75.45381673881674, "evidenceWarrant": 65.06300865800866, "responsiveness": 86.4738455988456, "relevanceBurden": 80.74318903318903, "precisionClarity": 83.46166666666667, "calibrationCharity": 69.02917027417027 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 78.02979437229438, "evidenceWarrant": 70.37362914862915, "responsiveness": 88.78766233766233, "relevanceBurden": 84.72512987012988, "precisionClarity": 84.46593073593074, "calibrationCharity": 75.59703823953825 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.5759776334776348, "evidenceWarrant": 5.310620490620494, "responsiveness": 2.313816738816726, "relevanceBurden": 3.9819408369408507, "precisionClarity": 1.0042640692640674, "calibrationCharity": 6.567867965367981 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.6439944083694087, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0621240981240987, "responsiveness": 0.46276334776334527, "relevanceBurden": 0.5972911255411276, "precisionClarity": 0.10042640692640675, "calibrationCharity": 0.6567867965367982 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.5233861832611852 }, { "number": 276, "id": "rauser-aron-ra-biblical-violence-2022", "title": "Randal Rauser vs Aron Ra — Biblical Violence and Divine Revelation", "motion": "Can one reasonably believe the Bible is revealed by God despite its violent passages?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvT2JHyxnz8", "date": "2026-09-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 77, "con_gap": -8, "speakers": { "pro": "Randal Rauser", "con": "Aron Ra" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "Reasonable divine revelation versus atheist challenge", "public_moves": 33, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 84.89800000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.545, "responsiveness": 88.14874999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.16300000000001, "precisionClarity": 87.9335, "calibrationCharity": 88.065 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 77.005, "evidenceWarrant": 65.33525, "responsiveness": 84.49674999999999, "relevanceBurden": 83.02225, "precisionClarity": 81.02975, "calibrationCharity": 72.99699999999999 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -7.893000000000015, "evidenceWarrant": -13.20975, "responsiveness": -3.652000000000001, "relevanceBurden": -3.1407500000000113, "precisionClarity": -6.903749999999988, "calibrationCharity": -15.068000000000012 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.9732500000000037, "evidenceWarrant": -2.64195, "responsiveness": -0.7304000000000003, "relevanceBurden": -0.47111250000000165, "precisionClarity": -0.6903749999999989, "calibrationCharity": -1.5068000000000012 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.01388750000000627 }, { "number": 277, "id": "shermer-scrivener-good-without-god-2024", "title": "Michael Shermer vs Glen Scrivener — Can We Be Good Without God?", "motion": "Can we be good without God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQ-g33KtZZ0", "date": "2026-09-29", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 82, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Shermer", "con": "Glen Scrivener" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian moral foundations versus secular independence", "public_moves": 33, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 79.16979797979798, "evidenceWarrant": 67.83878787878787, "responsiveness": 84.82731313131313, "relevanceBurden": 81.21199999999999, "precisionClarity": 80.79343434343434, "calibrationCharity": 79.67971717171717 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 81.166, "evidenceWarrant": 69.652, "responsiveness": 89.16399999999999, "relevanceBurden": 86.90299999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.774, "calibrationCharity": 79.94500000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.9962020202020199, "evidenceWarrant": -1.813212121212132, "responsiveness": -4.336686868686854, "relevanceBurden": -5.6910000000000025, "precisionClarity": -2.980565656565659, "calibrationCharity": -0.2652828282828352 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.49905050505050497, "evidenceWarrant": -0.36264242424242643, "responsiveness": -0.8673373737373709, "relevanceBurden": -0.8536500000000004, "precisionClarity": -0.2980565656565659, "calibrationCharity": -0.026528282828283525 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.09273484848484781 }, { "number": 278, "id": "lennox-tooley-atheism-christianity-2013", "title": "John Lennox vs Michael Tooley — Atheism and Christianity", "motion": "Is Christianity more reasonable than atheism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s3_CCw2e__I", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 73, "con": 83, "con_gap": 10, "speakers": { "pro": "John Lennox", "con": "Michael Tooley" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christianity as reasonable versus skeptical naturalism", "public_moves": 40, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 8, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 9, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 10, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.97321428571428, "evidenceWarrant": 61.192857142857136, "responsiveness": 75.98571428571428, "relevanceBurden": 77.74464285714285, "precisionClarity": 80.7375, "calibrationCharity": 72.02321428571429 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.92000000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 74.35805555555555, "responsiveness": 89.33944444444444, "relevanceBurden": 87.17000000000002, "precisionClarity": 86.22944444444444, "calibrationCharity": 81.52722222222224 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 9.946785714285738, "evidenceWarrant": 13.165198412698416, "responsiveness": 13.353730158730158, "relevanceBurden": 9.425357142857166, "precisionClarity": 5.491944444444442, "calibrationCharity": 9.504007936507946 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.4866964285714346, "evidenceWarrant": 2.6330396825396836, "responsiveness": 2.670746031746032, "relevanceBurden": 1.4138035714285748, "precisionClarity": 0.5491944444444442, "calibrationCharity": 0.9504007936507947 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.7038809523809633 }, { "number": 279, "id": "slick-barker-god-existence-2014", "title": "Matt Slick vs Dan Barker — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oPi073maMRw", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 68, "con": 76, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Slick", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 46, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 8, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 67.61008333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 55.45940151515151, "responsiveness": 76.09418506493506, "relevanceBurden": 73.88107142857142, "precisionClarity": 74.20787662337662, "calibrationCharity": 60.07897943722944 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 73.90463383838383, "evidenceWarrant": 63.92510101010101, "responsiveness": 85.93720959595959, "relevanceBurden": 81.75241161616161, "precisionClarity": 81.08291666666666, "calibrationCharity": 70.35212121212122 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.294550505050495, "evidenceWarrant": 8.465699494949497, "responsiveness": 9.843024531024525, "relevanceBurden": 7.871340187590192, "precisionClarity": 6.875040043290042, "calibrationCharity": 10.273141774891776 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.5736376262626237, "evidenceWarrant": 1.6931398989898996, "responsiveness": 1.9686049062049051, "relevanceBurden": 1.1807010281385288, "precisionClarity": 0.6875040043290043, "calibrationCharity": 1.0273141774891776 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.1309016414141393 }, { "number": 280, "id": "turek-normark-god-existence-2014", "title": "Frank Turek vs Dennis Nørmark — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t-p2eSkmyIQ", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 74, "con": 76, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Frank Turek", "con": "Dennis Nørmark" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 3 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.34830303030303, "evidenceWarrant": 62.093393939393934, "responsiveness": 81.20509090909093, "relevanceBurden": 82.64557575757576, "precisionClarity": 82.6260606060606, "calibrationCharity": 65.52284848484848 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.96909090909091, "evidenceWarrant": 65.04348484848484, "responsiveness": 82.3053787878788, "relevanceBurden": 80.9376893939394, "precisionClarity": 78.92708333333331, "calibrationCharity": 72.47431818181818 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.6207878787878798, "evidenceWarrant": 2.9500909090909033, "responsiveness": 1.1002878787878672, "relevanceBurden": -1.7078863636363621, "precisionClarity": -3.6989772727272907, "calibrationCharity": 6.951469696969696 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.9051969696969699, "evidenceWarrant": 0.5900181818181807, "responsiveness": 0.22005757575757345, "relevanceBurden": -0.2561829545454543, "precisionClarity": -0.36989772727272907, "calibrationCharity": 0.6951469696969697 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2156609848484896 }, { "number": 281, "id": "giunta-dillahunty-jesus-resurrection-2016", "title": "Blake Giunta vs Matt Dillahunty — Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3R4DYhpvNzc", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 77, "con": 84, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Blake Giunta", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Resurrection defense versus evidential skepticism", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.77, "evidenceWarrant": 67.885, "responsiveness": 80.48, "relevanceBurden": 82.91000000000001, "precisionClarity": 77.11500000000001, "calibrationCharity": 71.72 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.49775974025974, "evidenceWarrant": 77.36737012987012, "responsiveness": 85.28558441558442, "relevanceBurden": 86.67915584415584, "precisionClarity": 85.02305194805194, "calibrationCharity": 83.43506493506493 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.727759740259742, "evidenceWarrant": 9.48237012987012, "responsiveness": 4.80558441558442, "relevanceBurden": 3.769155844155833, "precisionClarity": 7.908051948051934, "calibrationCharity": 11.71506493506493 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.1819399350649356, "evidenceWarrant": 1.896474025974024, "responsiveness": 0.961116883116884, "relevanceBurden": 0.565373376623375, "precisionClarity": 0.7908051948051935, "calibrationCharity": 1.1715064935064932 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.4327840909090952 }, { "number": 282, "id": "craig-pyle-christian-god-2007", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Andrew Pyle — Does the Christian God Exist?", "motion": "Does the Christian God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wsO0ysGyjMg", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 83, "con_gap": 8, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Andrew Pyle" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian-God defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 44, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 7, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 8, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 73.79237878787879, "evidenceWarrant": 64.12073737373737, "responsiveness": 81.57329797979799, "relevanceBurden": 82.68130808080808, "precisionClarity": 82.19101515151516, "calibrationCharity": 65.60093434343435 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.46538095238094, "evidenceWarrant": 74.0827619047619, "responsiveness": 88.961, "relevanceBurden": 86.17871428571428, "precisionClarity": 85.97471428571428, "calibrationCharity": 86.52885714285715 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 8.673002164502151, "evidenceWarrant": 9.962024531024525, "responsiveness": 7.387702020202013, "relevanceBurden": 3.4974062049061985, "precisionClarity": 3.783699134199125, "calibrationCharity": 20.927922799422802 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.1682505411255377, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9924049062049052, "responsiveness": 1.4775404040404028, "relevanceBurden": 0.5246109307359298, "precisionClarity": 0.37836991341991255, "calibrationCharity": 2.0927922799422802 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.633968975468969 }, { "number": 283, "id": "dsouza-barker-god-existence-2009", "title": "Dinesh D’Souza vs Dan Barker — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AaNbTuPz1qI", "date": "2026-09-30", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 72, "con": 76, "con_gap": 4, "speakers": { "pro": "Dinesh D'Souza", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 42, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 5 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 6, "con": 5 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 71.09696103896103, "evidenceWarrant": 59.10825974025974, "responsiveness": 81.03597402597403, "relevanceBurden": 79.53870129870131, "precisionClarity": 79.65153246753246, "calibrationCharity": 64.67293506493507 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 74.77435064935065, "evidenceWarrant": 63.655974025974025, "responsiveness": 83.54883116883116, "relevanceBurden": 81.16192207792207, "precisionClarity": 80.17840259740262, "calibrationCharity": 71.74407792207792 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.677389610389625, "evidenceWarrant": 4.547714285714285, "responsiveness": 2.512857142857129, "relevanceBurden": 1.623220779220759, "precisionClarity": 0.5268701298701615, "calibrationCharity": 7.071142857142846 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.9193474025974062, "evidenceWarrant": 0.9095428571428571, "responsiveness": 0.5025714285714259, "relevanceBurden": 0.24348311688311383, "precisionClarity": 0.05268701298701615, "calibrationCharity": 0.7071142857142846 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.6652538961038963 }, { "number": 284, "id": "craig-kappel-god-existence-2012", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Klemens Kappel — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXJDSw88YVI", "date": "2026-10-04", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 84, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Klemens Kappel" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus skeptical naturalism", "public_moves": 41, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.29727272727273, "evidenceWarrant": 67.8435, "responsiveness": 82.17517424242425, "relevanceBurden": 82.93881060606063, "precisionClarity": 84.86462878787877, "calibrationCharity": 74.2577803030303 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.22064285714285, "evidenceWarrant": 72.30392857142857, "responsiveness": 90.67014285714286, "relevanceBurden": 86.99614285714286, "precisionClarity": 85.00307142857145, "calibrationCharity": 86.98642857142858 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.923370129870122, "evidenceWarrant": 4.460428571428565, "responsiveness": 8.494968614718616, "relevanceBurden": 4.057332251082229, "precisionClarity": 0.13844264069267354, "calibrationCharity": 12.728648268398274 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2308425324675305, "evidenceWarrant": 0.892085714285713, "responsiveness": 1.6989937229437233, "relevanceBurden": 0.6085998376623344, "precisionClarity": 0.013844264069267354, "calibrationCharity": 1.2728648268398275 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.28276910173160363 }, { "number": 285, "id": "butt-barker-biblical-god-2009", "title": "Kyle Butt vs Dan Barker — Does the God of the Bible Exist?", "motion": "Does the God of the Bible exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c8DEQAjVesc", "date": "2026-10-05", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 75, "con": 78, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Kyle Butt", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "Biblical-God defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 38, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 5, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 5, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 72.91071428571428, "evidenceWarrant": 64.12547619047619, "responsiveness": 85.7742857142857, "relevanceBurden": 78.46857142857144, "precisionClarity": 81.3390476190476, "calibrationCharity": 68.5704761904762 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.71571428571428, "evidenceWarrant": 68.06619047619049, "responsiveness": 88.17619047619047, "relevanceBurden": 83.46571428571428, "precisionClarity": 83.3547619047619, "calibrationCharity": 72.35873015873015 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.805000000000007, "evidenceWarrant": 3.940714285714293, "responsiveness": 2.401904761904774, "relevanceBurden": 4.997142857142848, "precisionClarity": 2.015714285714296, "calibrationCharity": 3.7882539682539544 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.7012500000000017, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7881428571428586, "responsiveness": 0.4803809523809548, "relevanceBurden": 0.7495714285714271, "precisionClarity": 0.2015714285714296, "calibrationCharity": 0.37882539682539546 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.29974206349206733 }, { "number": 286, "id": "nesan-dillahunty-jesus-prophecy-2021", "title": "Samuel Nesan vs Matt Dillahunty — Did Jesus Fulfill Prophecy?", "motion": "Did Jesus fulfill prophecy?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iRcx-eDklP0", "date": "2026-10-05", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 84, "con_gap": 6, "speakers": { "pro": "Samuel Nesan", "con": "Matt Dillahunty" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": true, "reason": "Jesus prophecy argument versus evidential skepticism", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 6, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.925, "evidenceWarrant": 65.975, "responsiveness": 82.9, "relevanceBurden": 82.47500000000001, "precisionClarity": 77.95, "calibrationCharity": 79.7 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.95719696969697, "evidenceWarrant": 76.2090909090909, "responsiveness": 90.78712121212124, "relevanceBurden": 90.2276515151515, "precisionClarity": 85.0284090909091, "calibrationCharity": 75.92840909090908 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.032196969696969, "evidenceWarrant": 10.23409090909091, "responsiveness": 7.8871212121212295, "relevanceBurden": 7.7526515151514985, "precisionClarity": 7.078409090909091, "calibrationCharity": -3.771590909090918 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.7580492424242422, "evidenceWarrant": 2.046818181818182, "responsiveness": 1.577424242424246, "relevanceBurden": 1.1628977272727248, "precisionClarity": 0.7078409090909091, "calibrationCharity": -0.37715909090909183 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.8758712121212122 }, { "number": 287, "id": "johnson-barker-god-existence-2022", "title": "Adam Lloyd Johnson vs Dan Barker — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H32WynQMke0", "date": "2026-10-05", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 77, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence case versus atheism", "public_moves": 34, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 5 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 5 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 74.5425, "evidenceWarrant": 62.203, "responsiveness": 85.76250000000002, "relevanceBurden": 84.993, "precisionClarity": 86.5035, "calibrationCharity": 79.9505 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 73.33500000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 63.077, "responsiveness": 86.668, "relevanceBurden": 83.735, "precisionClarity": 85.848, "calibrationCharity": 79.125 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.207499999999996, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8739999999999952, "responsiveness": 0.9054999999999893, "relevanceBurden": -1.2579999999999956, "precisionClarity": -0.6555000000000035, "calibrationCharity": -0.8255000000000052 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.301874999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 0.17479999999999907, "responsiveness": 0.18109999999999787, "relevanceBurden": -0.18869999999999934, "precisionClarity": -0.06555000000000036, "calibrationCharity": -0.08255000000000053 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.7172249999999978 }, { "number": 288, "id": "shermer-vandeweghe-jesus-miracles-2019", "title": "Michael Shermer vs Luuk Vandeweghe — Are the Miracles of Jesus Unbelievable?", "motion": "Are the miracles of Jesus unbelievable?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgVCo5Jeq3U", "date": "2026-10-06", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 75, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "Michael Shermer", "con": "Luuk Vandeweghe" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Credibility of Jesus miracles versus skeptical challenge", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 3 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.23080952380953, "evidenceWarrant": 74.89261904761905, "responsiveness": 82.90157142857144, "relevanceBurden": 84.81271428571429, "precisionClarity": 85.29866666666666, "calibrationCharity": 78.33533333333332 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.6869696969697, "evidenceWarrant": 65.2278787878788, "responsiveness": 82.69666666666666, "relevanceBurden": 82.99636363636364, "precisionClarity": 79.98272727272727, "calibrationCharity": 64.16333333333333 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 7.543839826839829, "evidenceWarrant": 9.664740259740256, "responsiveness": 0.20490476190478546, "relevanceBurden": 1.8163506493506532, "precisionClarity": 5.315939393939388, "calibrationCharity": 14.171999999999997 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.8859599567099572, "evidenceWarrant": 1.9329480519480513, "responsiveness": 0.04098095238095709, "relevanceBurden": 0.272452597402598, "precisionClarity": 0.5315939393939388, "calibrationCharity": 1.4171999999999998 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.9188645021644977 }, { "number": 289, "id": "wielenberg-johnson-objective-morality-2020", "title": "Erik Wielenberg vs Adam Lloyd Johnson — What Is the Best Account of Objective Morality?", "motion": "What is the best account of objective morality?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bg2WK-IIrd8", "date": "2026-10-06", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 71, "con": 82, "con_gap": 11, "speakers": { "pro": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "con": "Erik Wielenberg" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "Divine moral grounding versus non-theistic moral realism", "public_moves": 16, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 11, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 68.369, "evidenceWarrant": 62.579, "responsiveness": 73.463, "relevanceBurden": 77.462, "precisionClarity": 80.71000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 70.857 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.09, "evidenceWarrant": 71.85333333333334, "responsiveness": 87.455, "relevanceBurden": 85.44666666666666, "precisionClarity": 87.32, "calibrationCharity": 83.55333333333334 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 11.721000000000004, "evidenceWarrant": 9.274333333333338, "responsiveness": 13.992000000000004, "relevanceBurden": 7.984666666666655, "precisionClarity": 6.609999999999985, "calibrationCharity": 12.696333333333342 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 2.930250000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 1.8548666666666678, "responsiveness": 2.798400000000001, "relevanceBurden": 1.1976999999999982, "precisionClarity": 0.6609999999999986, "calibrationCharity": 1.2696333333333343 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.2881499999999999 }, { "number": 290, "id": "rauser-malpass-evidential-problem-evil-2021", "title": "Randal Rauser vs Alex Malpass — Does Suffering Provide Evidence Against Theism?", "motion": "Does suffering provide evidence against theism?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dvSd4IL35vs", "date": "2026-10-06", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 87, "con": 83, "con_gap": -4, "speakers": { "pro": "Alex Malpass", "con": "Randal Rauser" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theism under evidential suffering challenge", "public_moves": 36, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 4, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 87.688, "evidenceWarrant": 76.348, "responsiveness": 91.935, "relevanceBurden": 90.051, "precisionClarity": 86.90899999999999, "calibrationCharity": 87.104 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.9525, "evidenceWarrant": 72.56, "responsiveness": 87.80250000000001, "relevanceBurden": 86.4925, "precisionClarity": 85.6525, "calibrationCharity": 88.765 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 3.735500000000002, "evidenceWarrant": 3.7879999999999967, "responsiveness": 4.132499999999993, "relevanceBurden": 3.558499999999995, "precisionClarity": 1.2564999999999884, "calibrationCharity": -1.6610000000000014 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.9338750000000005, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7575999999999994, "responsiveness": 0.8264999999999987, "relevanceBurden": 0.5337749999999992, "precisionClarity": 0.12564999999999885, "calibrationCharity": -0.16610000000000014 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.9887000000000037 }, { "number": 291, "id": "rauser-schieber-god-existence-2015", "title": "Randal Rauser vs Justin Schieber — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y-Ju8tGlK7g", "date": "2026-10-06", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 83, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Randal Rauser", "con": "Justin Schieber" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 31, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 2, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.38587301587302, "evidenceWarrant": 65.68126984126984, "responsiveness": 79.12396825396826, "relevanceBurden": 76.58984126984127, "precisionClarity": 79.91396825396825, "calibrationCharity": 77.0231746031746 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.0591948051948, "evidenceWarrant": 72.7341645021645, "responsiveness": 87.49805627705628, "relevanceBurden": 83.62857575757576, "precisionClarity": 84.83735930735932, "calibrationCharity": 87.12936363636364 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.67332178932179, "evidenceWarrant": 7.052894660894665, "responsiveness": 8.37408802308802, "relevanceBurden": 7.038734487734487, "precisionClarity": 4.923391053391072, "calibrationCharity": 10.10618903318904 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.4183304473304474, "evidenceWarrant": 1.4105789321789333, "responsiveness": 1.6748176046176042, "relevanceBurden": 1.055810173160173, "precisionClarity": 0.4923391053391072, "calibrationCharity": 1.010618903318904 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.06249516594516891 }, { "number": 292, "id": "thomason-clifton-morality-meaning-god-2020", "title": "SJ Thomason vs Scott Clifton — Morality, Meaning and God", "motion": "Do morality and meaning point to God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycLfV4RVv5U", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 70, "con": 85, "con_gap": 15, "speakers": { "pro": "S.J. Thomason", "con": "Scott Clifton" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Morality & moral foundations", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-grounded morality and purpose versus secular alternatives", "public_moves": 31, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 15, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 66.83060606060606, "evidenceWarrant": 60.873030303030305, "responsiveness": 74.98666666666666, "relevanceBurden": 78.72878787878787, "precisionClarity": 77.90727272727273, "calibrationCharity": 67.2130303030303 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 85.27875, "evidenceWarrant": 75.1675, "responsiveness": 89.70625, "relevanceBurden": 87.285, "precisionClarity": 86.62875, "calibrationCharity": 83.68875 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 18.448143939393944, "evidenceWarrant": 14.2944696969697, "responsiveness": 14.719583333333333, "relevanceBurden": 8.556212121212127, "precisionClarity": 8.72147727272727, "calibrationCharity": 16.475719696969705 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 4.612035984848486, "evidenceWarrant": 2.85889393939394, "responsiveness": 2.9439166666666665, "relevanceBurden": 1.283431818181819, "precisionClarity": 0.872147727272727, "calibrationCharity": 1.6475719696969706 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.7820018939393911 }, { "number": 293, "id": "mcdowell-paulogia-apostolic-martyrdom-2020", "title": "Sean McDowell vs Paulogia — Apostolic Martyrdom and the Resurrection", "motion": "Are apostolic martyrdom and suffering good evidence for the resurrection?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJGRgxkzrjA", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 86, "con_gap": 0, "speakers": { "pro": "Sean McDowell", "con": "Paulogia" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Martyrdom as support for resurrection versus historical skepticism", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 0, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 87.55496969696969, "evidenceWarrant": 78.24369696969697, "responsiveness": 87.74309090909091, "relevanceBurden": 87.01169696969696, "precisionClarity": 86.16648484848484, "calibrationCharity": 87.6661212121212 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 87.83699999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 76.042, "responsiveness": 89.349, "relevanceBurden": 88.89300000000001, "precisionClarity": 85.34499999999998, "calibrationCharity": 89.409 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.28203030303029664, "evidenceWarrant": -2.201696969696968, "responsiveness": 1.605909090909094, "relevanceBurden": 1.8813030303030587, "precisionClarity": -0.8214848484848574, "calibrationCharity": 1.7428787878788086 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.07050757575757416, "evidenceWarrant": -0.44033939393939364, "responsiveness": 0.32118181818181885, "relevanceBurden": 0.2821954545454588, "precisionClarity": -0.08214848484848575, "calibrationCharity": 0.17428787878788088 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3256848484848533 }, { "number": 294, "id": "copan-rauser-canaanite-conquest-2022", "title": "Paul Copan vs Randal Rauser — The Canaanite Conquest and a God of Love", "motion": "Is the Canaanite conquest morally defensible as an act commanded by a loving God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NU4UQtuNBl8", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 85, "con_gap": 3, "speakers": { "pro": "Paul Copan", "con": "Randal Rauser" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Two Christian interpretations of conquest; not a religious-versus-skeptical contrast", "public_moves": 18, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.4755, "evidenceWarrant": 77.2995, "responsiveness": 81.38449999999999, "relevanceBurden": 87.39949999999999, "precisionClarity": 81.661, "calibrationCharity": 85.36850000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.99575, "evidenceWarrant": 79.3685, "responsiveness": 88.32050000000001, "relevanceBurden": 89.75774999999999, "precisionClarity": 85.29849999999999, "calibrationCharity": 87.6605 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 295, "id": "horn-paulogia-apostolic-sincerity-2023", "title": "Trent Horn vs Paulogia — Did the Apostles Die for a Lie?", "motion": "Does the historical evidence of suffering justify confidence in the sincerity of all the original resurrection witnesses?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sQkEbHqEv9o", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 87, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Paulogia" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": false, "reason": "Apostolic sincerity defense versus skeptical scope objection; broad historical set only, not proof of resurrection", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 86.93008333333333, "evidenceWarrant": 79.59811111111111, "responsiveness": 88.75272222222223, "relevanceBurden": 87.53086111111111, "precisionClarity": 88.07958333333333, "calibrationCharity": 88.93788888888889 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 88.19483333333334, "evidenceWarrant": 77.55066666666666, "responsiveness": 91.21983333333334, "relevanceBurden": 89.07433333333333, "precisionClarity": 88.56116666666668, "calibrationCharity": 91.7875 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2647500000000065, "evidenceWarrant": -2.0474444444444515, "responsiveness": 2.467111111111109, "relevanceBurden": 1.5434722222222206, "precisionClarity": 0.48158333333334724, "calibrationCharity": 2.849611111111102 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.3161875000000016, "evidenceWarrant": -0.40948888888889035, "responsiveness": 0.49342222222222176, "relevanceBurden": 0.23152083333333306, "precisionClarity": 0.048158333333334725, "calibrationCharity": 0.2849611111111102 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.03523888888888893 }, { "number": 296, "id": "dillahunty-rauser-humanism-christianity-2023", "title": "Matt Dillahunty vs Randal Rauser — Humanism or Christianity?", "motion": "Is secular humanism better for society than Christianity?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0T6SKpzyJ2I", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 84, "con_gap": 1, "speakers": { "pro": "Matt Dillahunty", "con": "Randal Rauser" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Religion, culture & meaning", "narrow": false, "reason": "Christian social contribution versus secular humanism; broad set only", "public_moves": 41, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 83.31766666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 73.84033333333335, "responsiveness": 89.27533333333334, "relevanceBurden": 88.13499999999999, "precisionClarity": 83.587, "calibrationCharity": 82.50166666666667 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.56192424242424, "evidenceWarrant": 73.51677272727272, "responsiveness": 89.95821212121213, "relevanceBurden": 86.33325757575757, "precisionClarity": 85.33674242424242, "calibrationCharity": 86.05998484848485 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.2442575757575725, "evidenceWarrant": 0.3235606060606244, "responsiveness": -0.6828787878787921, "relevanceBurden": 1.8017424242424198, "precisionClarity": -1.749742424242413, "calibrationCharity": -3.55831818181818 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.3110643939393931, "evidenceWarrant": 0.06471212121212488, "responsiveness": -0.13657575757575843, "relevanceBurden": 0.27026136363636294, "precisionClarity": -0.1749742424242413, "calibrationCharity": -0.355831818181818 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.3565272727272769 }, { "number": 297, "id": "winger-paulogia-resurrection-evidence-2018", "title": "Mike Winger vs Paulogia — Evidence for the Resurrection", "motion": "Is there sufficient evidence to believe in the resurrection of Jesus?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myRsIqEOT1w", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 84, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Mike Winger", "con": "Paulogia" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Resurrection case versus skeptical historical alternatives", "public_moves": 33, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.15357142857142, "evidenceWarrant": 74.80178571428571, "responsiveness": 86.6392857142857, "relevanceBurden": 86.78125, "precisionClarity": 82.7875, "calibrationCharity": 80.33035714285714 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.68666666666665, "evidenceWarrant": 72.68060606060607, "responsiveness": 89.4019696969697, "relevanceBurden": 87.22636363636363, "precisionClarity": 83.81, "calibrationCharity": 85.96348484848485 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.5330952380952283, "evidenceWarrant": -2.121179653679647, "responsiveness": 2.7626839826839955, "relevanceBurden": 0.44511363636362944, "precisionClarity": 1.022500000000008, "calibrationCharity": 5.6331277056277145 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.3832738095238071, "evidenceWarrant": -0.4242359307359294, "responsiveness": 0.5525367965367991, "relevanceBurden": 0.06676704545454441, "precisionClarity": 0.1022500000000008, "calibrationCharity": 0.5633127705627715 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.7560955086580066 }, { "number": 298, "id": "horn-lataster-god-existence-2016", "title": "Trent Horn vs Raphael Lataster — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GfV8Sy4YdSA", "date": "2026-10-07", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 79, "con": 81, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Trent Horn", "con": "Raphael Lataster" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 35, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 78.31909090909092, "evidenceWarrant": 68.08250000000001, "responsiveness": 84.45238636363635, "relevanceBurden": 85.26875, "precisionClarity": 82.76215909090911, "calibrationCharity": 72.05113636363637 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 79.548, "evidenceWarrant": 69.68800000000002, "responsiveness": 87.58800000000001, "relevanceBurden": 87.49199999999999, "precisionClarity": 80.89, "calibrationCharity": 81.068 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 1.2289090909090845, "evidenceWarrant": 1.6055000000000064, "responsiveness": 3.135613636363658, "relevanceBurden": 2.223249999999993, "precisionClarity": -1.8721590909091077, "calibrationCharity": 9.016863636363624 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.30722727272727113, "evidenceWarrant": 0.3211000000000013, "responsiveness": 0.6271227272727317, "relevanceBurden": 0.33348749999999894, "precisionClarity": -0.1872159090909108, "calibrationCharity": 0.9016863636363625 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.30340795454545466 }, { "number": 299, "id": "paulogia-jones-divine-hiddenness-2019", "title": "Paulogia vs Michael Jones — Divine Hiddenness and a Perfectly Loving God", "motion": "Does divine hiddenness count against a perfectly loving God?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GR-_l7MgLpg", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 86, "con": 83, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Paulogia", "con": "Michael Jones" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Loving-God defense versus hiddenness challenge", "public_moves": 29, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 87.584, "evidenceWarrant": 75.95200000000001, "responsiveness": 89.54799999999999, "relevanceBurden": 89.472, "precisionClarity": 87.36800000000001, "calibrationCharity": 90.62 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.36357142857143, "evidenceWarrant": 72.31214285714286, "responsiveness": 86.74285714285713, "relevanceBurden": 85.51678571428572, "precisionClarity": 84.12071428571429, "calibrationCharity": 88.41285714285713 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 4.22042857142857, "evidenceWarrant": 3.639857142857153, "responsiveness": 2.8051428571428545, "relevanceBurden": 3.955214285714277, "precisionClarity": 3.2472857142857237, "calibrationCharity": 2.2071428571428697 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.0551071428571426, "evidenceWarrant": 0.7279714285714306, "responsiveness": 0.5610285714285709, "relevanceBurden": 0.5932821428571415, "precisionClarity": 0.32472857142857237, "calibrationCharity": 0.22071428571428697 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.48283214285714493 }, { "number": 300, "id": "dennett-sapolsky-free-will-2023", "title": "Daniel Dennett vs Robert Sapolsky — Do We Have Free Will?", "motion": "Do human beings have free will?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYzFH8xqhns", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 84, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "Daniel Dennett", "con": "Robert Sapolsky" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Free will versus determinism does not itself establish a God contrast", "public_moves": 23, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 82.66361904761904, "evidenceWarrant": 73.77714285714286, "responsiveness": 86.13204761904763, "relevanceBurden": 86.52295238095238, "precisionClarity": 81.20561904761904, "calibrationCharity": 79.35490476190476 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 83.94000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 78.10666666666667, "responsiveness": 87.33000000000001, "relevanceBurden": 88.27999999999999, "precisionClarity": 84.2, "calibrationCharity": 78.52 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 301, "id": "wood-ally-resurrection-2018", "title": "David Wood vs Shabir Ally — Did Jesus Rise from the Dead?", "motion": "Did Jesus rise from the dead?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ST4RS0U5kpU", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 82, "con": 77, "con_gap": -5, "speakers": { "pro": "David Wood", "con": "Shabir Ally" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "", "topic": "", "narrow": false, "reason": "Christian resurrection versus an expressly Quranic survival/ascension alternative; interfaith contrast", "public_moves": 34, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 3, "con": 0 }, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 81.89941666666665, "evidenceWarrant": 76.14425, "responsiveness": 85.23433333333334, "relevanceBurden": 84.68283333333333, "precisionClarity": 85.52833333333334, "calibrationCharity": 76.26441666666668 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 75.1670202020202, "evidenceWarrant": 66.44318181818181, "responsiveness": 82.78212121212121, "relevanceBurden": 81.17565656565657, "precisionClarity": 82.19116161616161, "calibrationCharity": 79.23671717171717 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 } }, { "number": 302, "id": "rauser-barker-god-worthy-worship-2020", "title": "Randal Rauser vs Dan Barker — Is the Christian God Worthy of Worship?", "motion": "Is the Christian God worthy of worship?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ziG-K5cJNWg", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 82, "con_gap": -1, "speakers": { "pro": "Randal Rauser", "con": "Dan Barker" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Christian worship-worthiness versus skeptical moral criticism; broad set only", "public_moves": 30, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 0 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -1, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 84.57000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 76.395, "responsiveness": 84.09500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.12499999999999, "precisionClarity": 86.42999999999999, "calibrationCharity": 83.41 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 82.94, "evidenceWarrant": 74.2875, "responsiveness": 86.2825, "relevanceBurden": 87.20666666666666, "precisionClarity": 83.95, "calibrationCharity": 73.42166666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -1.6300000000000097, "evidenceWarrant": -2.1075000000000017, "responsiveness": 2.187499999999986, "relevanceBurden": 2.0816666666666777, "precisionClarity": -2.4799999999999898, "calibrationCharity": -9.98833333333333 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -0.4075000000000024, "evidenceWarrant": -0.4215000000000004, "responsiveness": 0.43749999999999717, "relevanceBurden": 0.31225000000000164, "precisionClarity": -0.247999999999999, "calibrationCharity": -0.998833333333333 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.32608333333333595 }, { "number": 303, "id": "craig-nugent-god-existence-2017", "title": "William Lane Craig vs Michael Nugent — Does God Exist?", "motion": "Does God exist?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wmlcmVye4hM", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 76, "con": 78, "con_gap": 2, "speakers": { "pro": "William Lane Craig", "con": "Michael Nugent" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "General theism & naturalism", "narrow": true, "reason": "God-existence defense versus atheism", "public_moves": 44, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 6, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 7, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 76.03988095238095, "evidenceWarrant": 65.73309523809523, "responsiveness": 83.94642857142857, "relevanceBurden": 82.11702380952381, "precisionClarity": 81.89404761904763, "calibrationCharity": 67.06869047619048 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 76.16318181818181, "evidenceWarrant": 66.56557575757574, "responsiveness": 86.05393939393939, "relevanceBurden": 82.71027272727272, "precisionClarity": 81.07951515151515, "calibrationCharity": 82.41398484848486 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 0.1233008658008572, "evidenceWarrant": 0.8324805194805123, "responsiveness": 2.107510822510818, "relevanceBurden": 0.5932489177489089, "precisionClarity": -0.814532467532473, "calibrationCharity": 15.345294372294376 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.0308252164502143, "evidenceWarrant": 0.16649610389610248, "responsiveness": 0.42150216450216366, "relevanceBurden": 0.08898733766233632, "precisionClarity": -0.0814532467532473, "calibrationCharity": 1.5345294372294376 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.1608870129870068 }, { "number": 304, "id": "swinburne-ehrman-god-suffering-2009", "title": "Richard Swinburne vs Bart Ehrman — God and Suffering", "motion": "Does Christianity adequately explain suffering?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hrrcb1WcfzM", "date": "2026-10-08", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 78, "con": 85, "con_gap": 7, "speakers": { "pro": "Richard Swinburne", "con": "Bart Ehrman" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Christian explanation of suffering versus skeptical challenge", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 2, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 4, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 77.61636363636364, "evidenceWarrant": 65.27681818181817, "responsiveness": 82.47681818181817, "relevanceBurden": 82.63227272727273, "precisionClarity": 83.82, "calibrationCharity": 79.11363636363637 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 84.46666666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 77.43333333333332, "responsiveness": 88.04166666666667, "relevanceBurden": 87.18333333333332, "precisionClarity": 87.95, "calibrationCharity": 85.775 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 6.850303030303024, "evidenceWarrant": 12.156515151515151, "responsiveness": 5.564848484848497, "relevanceBurden": 4.551060606060588, "precisionClarity": 4.13000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 6.661363636363632 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.712575757575756, "evidenceWarrant": 2.4313030303030305, "responsiveness": 1.1129696969696994, "relevanceBurden": 0.6826590909090882, "precisionClarity": 0.413000000000001, "calibrationCharity": 0.6661363636363632 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": -0.018643939393938602 }, { "number": 305, "id": "mclatchie-paulogia-christianity-resurrection-2023", "title": "Jonathan McLatchie vs Paulogia — Christianity’s Origins and the Resurrection", "motion": "Is the physical resurrection of Jesus the best explanation for Christianity's origins?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z4y40nZit6g", "date": "2026-10-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 83, "con": 80, "con_gap": -3, "speakers": { "pro": "Jonathan McLatchie", "con": "Paulogia" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Resurrection & historical evidence", "narrow": true, "reason": "Resurrection defense versus skeptical historical account", "public_moves": 25, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 2 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -3, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.075, "evidenceWarrant": 74.30000000000001, "responsiveness": 86.70500000000001, "relevanceBurden": 85.34, "precisionClarity": 85.745, "calibrationCharity": 83.14500000000001 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.30000000000001, "evidenceWarrant": 70.2, "responsiveness": 84.73750000000001, "relevanceBurden": 81.1, "precisionClarity": 83.5625, "calibrationCharity": 79.3 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -4.7749999999999915, "evidenceWarrant": -4.1000000000000085, "responsiveness": -1.9675000000000011, "relevanceBurden": -4.240000000000009, "precisionClarity": -2.1825000000000045, "calibrationCharity": -3.845000000000013 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -1.1937499999999979, "evidenceWarrant": -0.8200000000000017, "responsiveness": -0.39350000000000024, "relevanceBurden": -0.6360000000000013, "precisionClarity": -0.21825000000000047, "calibrationCharity": -0.38450000000000134 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.646000000000003 }, { "number": 306, "id": "meyer-atkins-intelligent-design-science-2010", "title": "Stephen Meyer vs Peter Atkins — Intelligent Design and Science", "motion": "Is intelligent design a legitimate scientific explanation for biological origins?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSZlPZvIOC0", "date": "2026-10-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 80, "con": 73, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "Stephen Meyer", "con": "Peter Atkins" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "pro", "topic": "Cosmology, science & design", "narrow": true, "reason": "Intelligent-origin explanation versus naturalistic method; creator/design-only, not full personal theism", "public_moves": 22, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 4 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 4 }, "non_side": "con", "gap": -7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 80.4375, "evidenceWarrant": 68.48125, "responsiveness": 85.93125, "relevanceBurden": 84.36250000000001, "precisionClarity": 84.37500000000001, "calibrationCharity": 77.975 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 72.045, "evidenceWarrant": 63.105, "responsiveness": 77.22, "relevanceBurden": 78.42500000000001, "precisionClarity": 78.61, "calibrationCharity": 69.595 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": -8.392499999999998, "evidenceWarrant": -5.376250000000006, "responsiveness": -8.711250000000007, "relevanceBurden": -5.9375, "precisionClarity": -5.765000000000015, "calibrationCharity": -8.379999999999995 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": -2.0981249999999996, "evidenceWarrant": -1.0752500000000011, "responsiveness": -1.7422500000000014, "relevanceBurden": -0.890625, "precisionClarity": -0.5765000000000015, "calibrationCharity": -0.8379999999999996 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.22075000000000333 }, { "number": 307, "id": "ehrman-white-bible-misquote-jesus-2009", "title": "Bart Ehrman vs James White — Does the Bible Misquote Jesus?", "motion": "Does the Bible misquote Jesus?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5K-AOfj1Axg", "date": "2026-10-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 88, "con": 86, "con_gap": -2, "speakers": { "pro": "Bart Ehrman", "con": "James White" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Scripture, revelation & doctrine", "narrow": false, "reason": "Biblical textual reliability defense versus skeptical history; broad set only", "public_moves": 32, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 0, "con": 1 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 2, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 88.49035714285715, "evidenceWarrant": 81.80714285714286, "responsiveness": 89.63214285714285, "relevanceBurden": 89.2667857142857, "precisionClarity": 88.90535714285714, "calibrationCharity": 88.21714285714286 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 86.19649999999999, "evidenceWarrant": 80.66399999999999, "responsiveness": 88.7535, "relevanceBurden": 86.56200000000001, "precisionClarity": 87.449, "calibrationCharity": 84.19800000000001 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 2.2938571428571635, "evidenceWarrant": 1.1431428571428768, "responsiveness": 0.8786428571428502, "relevanceBurden": 2.7047857142856913, "precisionClarity": 1.4563571428571436, "calibrationCharity": 4.019142857142853 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 0.5734642857142909, "evidenceWarrant": 0.22862857142857537, "responsiveness": 0.17572857142857004, "relevanceBurden": 0.4057178571428537, "precisionClarity": 0.14563571428571437, "calibrationCharity": 0.40191428571428534 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.06891071428571038 }, { "number": 308, "id": "schieber-rauser-religious-disagreement-2017", "title": "Justin Schieber vs Randal Rauser — Religious Disagreement and God", "motion": "Is religious disagreement evidence against God’s existence?", "youtube": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G_jSS5Z4oFU", "date": "2026-10-09", "model": "5.6 Sol", "rubric": "Slugfester Reassessment Rubric v2", "pro": 85, "con": 78, "con_gap": -7, "speakers": { "pro": "Justin Schieber", "con": "Randal Rauser" }, "ranking_eligible": true, "cohort": "later", "theist_side": "con", "topic": "Evil, suffering & hiddenness", "narrow": true, "reason": "Theism under religious-disagreement and hiddenness challenge", "public_moves": 19, "public_fallacies": { "pro": 1, "con": 5 }, "public_anytags": { "pro": 1, "con": 5 }, "non_side": "pro", "gap": 7, "dimensions": { "pro": { "logicalCoherence": 85.81666666666666, "evidenceWarrant": 73.625, "responsiveness": 89.75, "relevanceBurden": 88.25, "precisionClarity": 88.52499999999999, "calibrationCharity": 84.73333333333333 }, "con": { "logicalCoherence": 80.29166666666667, "evidenceWarrant": 68.3, "responsiveness": 79.525, "relevanceBurden": 81.45, "precisionClarity": 82.91666666666667, "calibrationCharity": 77.09166666666667 } }, "adjustments": { "pro": 0, "con": 0 }, "dimension_gaps": { "logicalCoherence": 5.5249999999999915, "evidenceWarrant": 5.325000000000003, "responsiveness": 10.224999999999994, "relevanceBurden": 6.799999999999997, "precisionClarity": 5.60833333333332, "calibrationCharity": 7.641666666666666 }, "contributions": { "logicalCoherence": 1.3812499999999979, "evidenceWarrant": 1.0650000000000006, "responsiveness": 2.044999999999999, "relevanceBurden": 1.0199999999999996, "precisionClarity": 0.5608333333333321, "calibrationCharity": 0.7641666666666667 }, "adjustment_gap": 0, "rounding_gap": 0.16375000000000384 } ]