{
  "source_commit": "e65bc3c0b6",
  "snapshot": "2026-10-09",
  "reply_graph": {
    "debates": 112,
    "moves": 3609,
    "replies": 2444,
    "with_target": 2444,
    "multiple_targets": 472,
    "edges": 2978,
    "opposite_side_edges": 2968,
    "reply_to_reply_edges": 1733,
    "timed_edges": 2978,
    "target_starts_no_later": 2978
  },
  "opponents": {
    "debates": 291,
    "appearances": 582,
    "speakers": 183,
    "three_opponents": 55,
    "unique_pairs": 269,
    "repeated_pairs": 21,
    "repeated_pair_debates": 43,
    "strict_reversal_pairs": 2,
    "median_margin_range": 3.0,
    "same_process_pair_groups": 12,
    "same_process_reversals": 0,
    "same_process_median_range": 2.0
  },
  "models": {
    "speaker_only": {
      "appearances": 295,
      "speakers": 80,
      "debates": 188,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.42227502967294017,
      "within_correlation": -0.08846360956124773,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.863012215390133,
      "slope": -0.08445500593458803
    },
    "speaker_process_role": {
      "appearances": 295,
      "speakers": 80,
      "debates": 188,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "cohort",
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.49346278111014447,
      "within_correlation": -0.10820639560275462,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.8460800247792193,
      "slope": -0.0986925562220289
    },
    "plus_broad_topic": {
      "appearances": 295,
      "speakers": 80,
      "debates": 188,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "cohort",
        "side",
        "topic"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.81856080835278,
      "within_correlation": -0.18187924658691124,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.7260925411314507,
      "slope": -0.163712161670556
    },
    "equal_person": {
      "appearances": 295,
      "speakers": 80,
      "debates": 188,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "cohort",
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": true,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.384683072043976,
      "within_correlation": -0.10819465820586877,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.847706850332752,
      "slope": -0.0769366144087952
    },
    "opponent_min5": {
      "appearances": 203,
      "speakers": 60,
      "debates": 145,
      "threshold": 5,
      "controls": [
        "cohort",
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.32624015423271424,
      "within_correlation": -0.06736715267964757,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.644792003792712,
      "slope": -0.06524803084654285
    },
    "earlier": {
      "appearances": 151,
      "speakers": 42,
      "debates": 93,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.5005203170492867,
      "within_correlation": -0.10454815519147738,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.656948233080779,
      "slope": -0.10010406340985734
    },
    "later": {
      "appearances": 82,
      "speakers": 31,
      "debates": 48,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.3618415468703145,
      "within_correlation": -0.08295009549845314,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.8867294137509245,
      "slope": -0.0723683093740629
    },
    "same_process_opponent_proxy": {
      "appearances": 180,
      "speakers": 54,
      "debates": 132,
      "threshold": 3,
      "controls": [
        "cohort",
        "side"
      ],
      "equal_person": false,
      "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": 0.06465930638350828,
      "within_correlation": 0.01164852031481044,
      "residual_opponent_sd": 2.4595845653097115,
      "slope": 0.012931861276701656
    }
  },
  "matched_sample_pooled_proxy": {
    "appearances": 180,
    "speakers": 54,
    "debates": 132,
    "threshold": 3,
    "controls": [
      "cohort",
      "side"
    ],
    "equal_person": false,
    "own_score_change_per_5_opponent_points": -0.023005885928690097,
    "within_correlation": -0.004228371047517558,
    "residual_opponent_sd": 2.5093206902154286,
    "slope": -0.004601177185738019
  }
}