[ { "number": 196, "move_id": "m12", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m04" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m13", "speaker": "Josh Rasmussen", "targets": [ "m12" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m14", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m13" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m15", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m03" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m16", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m01", "m02" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m17", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m02", "m10" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m18", "speaker": "Josh Rasmussen", "targets": [ "m10", "m17" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m19", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "m05" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 196, "move_id": "m20", "speaker": "Josh Rasmussen", "targets": [ "m09", "m19" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "evolved-biological-consciousness", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "phases-same-entity", "panentheist-consciousness-field" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "correlation-not-production", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "anesthesia-brain-dependence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "brain-permits-consciousness", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "anesthesia-brain-dependence" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "phase-emergence", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "brain-permits-consciousness" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "wetness-analogy-fails", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "phase-emergence" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "promissory-ignorance-challenge", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "wetness-analogy-fails" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "fundamental-consciousness-avoids-miracle", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "modest-emergent-materialism", "promissory-ignorance-challenge" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "neural-explanatory-bridges", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "fundamental-consciousness-avoids-miracle" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "science-excludes-subjectivity", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "neural-explanatory-bridges" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "dissipative-life-consciousness", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "conscious-cosmos-creates-other" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "novel-material-properties", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "responsiveness-continuum", "conscious-cosmos-creates-other" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "cosmic-directionality", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "novel-material-properties" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "values-constructed-from-life", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "prehuman-objective-beauty", "cosmic-directionality" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "relational-creative-ground", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "values-constructed-from-life" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "entropy-arrow-direction", "speaker": "Anil Seth", "targets": [ "cosmic-directionality", "relational-creative-ground" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "shaping-points-to-god", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "entropy-arrow-direction" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 197, "move_id": "ritual-embodied-metaphor", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "human-spiritual-need", "ego-attenuation-spirituality" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "morality-needs-desire-and-belief", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "divine-mind-grounds-moral-facts" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "wellbeing-goal-supports-assessment", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "divine-mind-grounds-moral-facts", "nature-cannot-cross-is-ought-gap" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "biblical-slavery-undercuts-divine-guide", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "christianity-historical-practical-fruits" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "chess-shows-goal-relative-objectivity", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "secular-ethics-too-minimal-for-sacrifice", "nature-cannot-cross-is-ought-gap" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "revelation-lacks-public-verification", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-provides-epistemic-leverage" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "conditional-ought-from-wellbeing", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "nature-cannot-cross-is-ought-gap" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "good-must-exist-before-moral-action", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "morality-needs-desire-and-belief", "wellbeing-goal-supports-assessment" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "scripture-regulates-with-liberty-ideal", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "biblical-slavery-undercuts-divine-guide" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "shellfish-contrast-rejects-context-defense", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "scripture-regulates-with-liberty-ideal" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "atheism-is-wrong-comparison-class", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "christianity-historical-practical-fruits" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "independent-confirmation-corrects-brains", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "naturalistic-brain-circularity" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "intrinsic-good-is-self-desirable", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "wellbeing-goal-supports-assessment", "conditional-ought-from-wellbeing" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "veil-of-ignorance-reduces-bias", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "intrinsic-good-is-self-desirable" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "self-interest-can-produce-cooperation", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "secular-ethics-too-minimal-for-sacrifice", "intrinsic-good-is-self-desirable" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "conditional-goals-are-not-morality", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "conditional-ought-from-wellbeing", "self-interest-can-produce-cooperation" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "sociopath-tests-motivation-standard", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "veil-of-ignorance-reduces-bias", "self-interest-can-produce-cooperation" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "wellbeing-facts-are-objective", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "intrinsic-good-is-self-desirable", "sociopath-tests-motivation-standard" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "data-still-passes-through-brain", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "independent-confirmation-corrects-brains", "wellbeing-facts-are-objective" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "conflicting-revelations-remain-unresolved", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-provides-epistemic-leverage", "data-still-passes-through-brain" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "scripture-guides-nonabolitionist-societies", "speaker": "John Ferrer", "targets": [ "biblical-slavery-undercuts-divine-guide", "shellfish-contrast-rejects-context-defense", "atheism-is-wrong-comparison-class" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 198, "move_id": "arbitrary-standard-allows-objective-measurement", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "good-must-exist-before-moral-action", "intrinsic-good-is-self-desirable", "conditional-goals-are-not-morality" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "con-no-self-and-fission-successors", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pro-hemisphere-fission-trilemma", "pro-fixed-physical-facts-modal-argument", "pro-extrinsic-identity-objection" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "pro-basic-causation-and-tu-quoque", "speaker": "Dustin Crummett", "targets": [ "con-induction-closure-and-energy" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "pro-contingent-supervenience-conceivability", "speaker": "Dustin Crummett", "targets": [ "con-neuroscience-genetics-morphology" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "con-necessary-supervenience-explains-pairing", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pro-contingent-supervenience-conceivability" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "pro-contingent-laws-explain-more", "speaker": "Dustin Crummett", "targets": [ "con-necessary-supervenience-explains-pairing" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "con-closure-genetics-and-animal-souls", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pro-contingent-soul-body-laws", "pro-contingent-laws-explain-more" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "pro-interaction-objection-conceded-and-generalized", "speaker": "Dustin Crummett", "targets": [ "con-induction-closure-and-energy", "con-closure-genetics-and-animal-souls" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "con-energy-transfer-requires-deviation", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pro-basic-causation-and-tu-quoque", "pro-interaction-objection-conceded-and-generalized" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "con-consciousness-favors-theism-concession", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pro-contingent-soul-body-laws" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 199, "move_id": "pro-dualism-weirdness-calls-for-theism", "speaker": "Dustin Crummett", "targets": [ "con-consciousness-favors-theism-concession" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-immediate-selective-knowledge-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-expected-evidence-absence-test", "con-hiddenness-from-nonbelief" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-vacuum-not-nothing-causal-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-zero-energy-natural-cosmos", "con-quantum-tunneling-natural-origin" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-past-boundary-expanding-cosmologies", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-zero-energy-natural-cosmos", "con-quantum-tunneling-natural-origin" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-mental-properties-resist-reduction", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-mind-brain-dependence" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-contingent-reality-needs-explanation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-zero-energy-natural-cosmos" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-logic-and-pizza-ontology-objection", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-ontological-possibility-entailment" ], "score": 57 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-quantum-causation-beginningless-models", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-beginning-personal-creator", "pro-vacuum-not-nothing-causal-reply" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-no-boundary-prior-universe-models", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-vacuum-not-nothing-causal-reply", "pro-past-boundary-expanding-cosmologies" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-natural-social-morality", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-divine-ground" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-empty-tomb-historical-dispute", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-pizza-parody-coherence-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-logic-and-pizza-ontology-objection" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-quantum-interpretations-bounded-models", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-quantum-causation-beginningless-models", "con-no-boundary-prior-universe-models" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-objective-not-intersubjective-morality", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-natural-social-morality" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-multiple-sources-majority-history", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-empty-tomb-historical-dispute" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-extraordinary-claim-burden", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-immediate-selective-knowledge-reply", "pro-past-boundary-expanding-cosmologies" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-natural-knowledge-of-harm", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-objective-not-intersubjective-morality" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-late-gospels-martyrdom-insufficient", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-multiple-sources-majority-history" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-inner-experience-needs-verification", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-personal-experience-cumulative-case", "pro-immediate-selective-knowledge-reply" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-cumulative-evidence-closing", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-expected-evidence-absence-test", "con-extraordinary-claim-burden", "con-inner-experience-needs-verification" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-natural-complexity-closing", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-pizza-parody-coherence-reply", "pro-cumulative-evidence-closing" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-empty-tomb-late-alternatives", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-multiple-sources-majority-history" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-core-facts-majority-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-empty-tomb-historical-dispute", "con-empty-tomb-late-alternatives" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-simultaneous-timeless-causation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-quantum-causation-beginningless-models" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-physical-time-model-objection", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-simultaneous-timeless-causation" ], "score": 51 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-suffering-evil-god-fit", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-divine-ground", "pro-objective-not-intersubjective-morality" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-morally-sufficient-reasons-evil-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-suffering-evil-god-fit" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "con-current-data-material-universe", "speaker": "Victor Stenger", "targets": [ "pro-mental-properties-resist-reduction" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 200, "move_id": "pro-evolutionary-defeater-for-naturalism", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-mind-brain-dependence", "con-current-data-material-universe" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "correlations-still-require-explanation", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "split-brain-produces-independent-personalities", "brain-damage-alters-soul-attributes" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "brain-is-retrieval-instrument", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "brain-damage-alters-soul-attributes" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "neuroplasticity-shows-two-way-causation", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "interaction-must-be-detectable" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "physicalism-undermines-self-and-freedom", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "soul-is-circular-explanation" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "an-explanation-is-not-made-true-by-default", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "correlations-still-require-explanation" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "identity-is-a-changing-label", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "identity-persists-through-change", "physicalism-undermines-self-and-freedom" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "consciousness-may-emerge", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "consciousness-is-irreducible", "intentionality-is-nonphysical" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "split-persons-remain-whole", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "personhood-is-indivisible", "unified-visual-field-requires-subject" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "compatibilist-agency-distinguishes-coercion", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "free-will-requires-soul" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "determinism-undermines-rational-belief", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "compatibilist-agency-distinguishes-coercion" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "belief-truth-is-independent-of-choice", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "determinism-undermines-rational-belief" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "raised-hands-demonstrate-freedom", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "compatibilist-agency-distinguishes-coercion" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "computer-can-mimic-response", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "raised-hands-demonstrate-freedom" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "causality-supports-rationality", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "determinism-undermines-rational-belief" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "seven-arguments-set-change-standard", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "an-explanation-is-not-made-true-by-default" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "reliable-method-is-required", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "seven-arguments-set-change-standard", "mental-and-brain-properties-differ" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "mind-is-produced-by-brain", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "mental-and-brain-properties-differ", "consciousness-is-irreducible" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "felt-pain-exceeds-brain-description", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "mind-is-produced-by-brain" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "split-brain-supports-two-individuals", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "correlations-still-require-explanation", "personhood-is-indivisible" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "soul-grounds-latent-capacities", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "split-brain-supports-two-individuals", "soul-is-circular-explanation" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "why-one-soul-package", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-grounds-latent-capacities" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "qualities-do-not-demonstrate-entity", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-grounds-latent-capacities" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "soul-case-is-not-gap-reasoning", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "an-explanation-is-not-made-true-by-default", "qualities-do-not-demonstrate-entity" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "methodological-not-philosophical-naturalism", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-case-is-not-gap-reasoning" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "interaction-is-ontologically-basic", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "interaction-must-be-detectable", "reliable-method-is-required" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "interaction-remains-unconfirmed", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "interaction-is-ontologically-basic" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "brain-damage-disrupts-instrument", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "brain-damage-alters-soul-attributes" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "disabled-soul-is-explanatorily-unneeded", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "brain-damage-disrupts-instrument" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "near-death-claims-have-tests", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "soul-case-is-not-gap-reasoning" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "determined-brain-cannot-ground-trust", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "near-death-claims-have-tests", "belief-truth-is-independent-of-choice" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "affirmative-closing-case-stands", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "qualities-do-not-demonstrate-entity", "reliable-method-is-required", "consciousness-may-emerge" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 201, "move_id": "negative-closing-demands-demonstration", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "affirmative-closing-case-stands", "soul-case-is-not-gap-reasoning", "interaction-is-ontologically-basic" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "christian-upbringing-encouraged-inquiry", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "darwinism-ended-youthful-faith" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "faith-strength-tracks-evidence", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "science-uses-evidence", "god-answers-stifle-investigation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "theism-supported-rise-of-science", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "god-answers-stifle-investigation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "evidence-makes-faith-label-redundant", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "faith-strength-tracks-evidence" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "designer-postulate-explains-nothing", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-points-beyond-multiverse" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "multiverse-anthropic-interim-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-points-beyond-multiverse" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "anthropic-principle-is-truism", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "multiverse-anthropic-interim-explanation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "uncreated-god-escapes-created-regress", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "designer-postulate-explains-nothing" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "complex-explanations-can-explain-simple-events", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "designer-postulate-explains-nothing" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "complexity-must-arise-from-simplicity", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "uncreated-god-escapes-created-regress", "complex-explanations-can-explain-simple-events" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "christian-violence-disobeys-christ", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "unquestionable-faith-removes-justification" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "religious-premises-create-logical-path-to-harm", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "atheist-states-also-produced-atrocities" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "fanatical-ideology-not-religion-alone", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "religious-premises-create-logical-path-to-harm", "promised-paradise-can-rationalize-violence" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "common-morality-reflects-gods-image", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "moral-zeitgeist-changes-without-scripture" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "naturalism-removes-moral-criteria", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "evolution-built-prosocial-dispositions" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "rebellion-against-genes-seems-incoherent", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "evolution-built-prosocial-dispositions" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "unpleasant-world-can-still-be-true", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "naturalism-removes-moral-criteria" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "contraception-shows-gene-rebellion", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "rebellion-against-genes-seems-incoherent" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "neighbor-command-includes-stranger", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "promised-paradise-can-rationalize-violence" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "resurrection-too-local-for-cosmic-theism", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "resurrection-is-central-evidence" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 202, "move_id": "darwin-removes-gardener-inference", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "garden-order-indicates-owner" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "explanation-can-stop-at-big-bang", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "beginning-universe-requires-cause" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "cause-does-not-establish-standard-god", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "beginning-universe-requires-cause" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "eternal-person-inconsistent-explanation", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "timeless-cause-must-be-personal" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "artifact-analogy-does-not-establish-design", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-best-explained-by-design" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "omnipotence-cannot-cause-free-choice", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "omnipotence-could-create-free-obedience" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "mental-properties-support-immaterial-self", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "cause-does-not-establish-standard-god" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "causal-principle-bars-brute-beginning", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "explanation-can-stop-at-big-bang" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "fine-tuning-not-law-or-chance", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "artifact-analogy-does-not-establish-design" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "specified-improbability-signals-design", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "artifact-analogy-does-not-establish-design" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "experience-does-not-establish-god-objectively", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "immediate-experience-can-warrant-god-belief" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "causal-principle-bounded-within-universe", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "causal-principle-bars-brute-beginning" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "god-could-move-will-without-coercion", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "omnipotence-cannot-cause-free-choice" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "molinism-preserves-libertarian-alternatives", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "god-could-move-will-without-coercion" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "materialism-fails-personal-identity", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "cause-does-not-establish-standard-god" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "late-documents-undercut-resurrection-evidence", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "disciples-unexpected-resurrection-belief" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "pauline-visions-differ-from-bodily-narratives", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "empty-tomb-and-appearances-established" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "objective-morality-independent-of-command", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "objective-values-entail-god" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "no-naturalistic-resurrection-alternative-offered", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "late-documents-undercut-resurrection-evidence" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "small-big-bang-causal-analogy-fails", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "causal-principle-bars-brute-beginning" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 203, "move_id": "cosmic-probability-lacks-reference-class", "speaker": "Antony Flew", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-not-law-or-chance" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "evolved-compassion-and-reciprocity", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "conscience-points-beyond-darwinian-interest" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "pre-christian-and-nonchristian-compassion", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "western-secular-values-derive-from-christianity" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "atrocities-not-unique-to-atheism", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "atheist-regimes-as-secular-test" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "religiosity-correlates-with-charitable-giving", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "afterlife-sanctions-do-not-secure-conduct" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "darwinian-mechanisms-explain-only-self-interest", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "evolved-compassion-and-reciprocity" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "natural-evil-does-not-disprove-existence", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "natural-suffering-challenges-judeo-christian-god" ], "score": 53 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "authoritative-law-requires-lawgiver", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "evolved-compassion-and-reciprocity" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "rational-perspective-taking-explains-slavery-judgment", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "authoritative-law-requires-lawgiver" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "equal-consideration-grounded-in-interests", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "removing-god-removes-human-dignity" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "secular-equality-smuggles-spiritual-equality", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "equal-consideration-grounded-in-interests" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "social-reason-constructs-moral-codes", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "authoritative-law-requires-lawgiver", "secular-equality-smuggles-spiritual-equality" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "moral-legitimacy-comes-from-better-reasons", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "scripture-requires-independent-judgment" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "conscience-opposes-darwinian-self-interest", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "afterlife-sanctions-do-not-secure-conduct", "evolved-compassion-and-reciprocity" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "cosmic-accountability-supports-morality", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "afterlife-sanctions-do-not-secure-conduct" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "suffering-is-bad-through-impartial-perspective", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "secular-equality-smuggles-spiritual-equality" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "lawful-universe-enables-science-and-relief", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "natural-suffering-challenges-judeo-christian-god" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "reciprocity-cannot-generate-obligation", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "evolved-compassion-and-reciprocity", "social-reason-constructs-moral-codes", "suffering-is-bad-through-impartial-perspective" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "tectonics-and-free-will-are-life-enabling-costs", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "natural-suffering-challenges-judeo-christian-god" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "atheist-morality-need-not-be-subjectivist", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "reciprocity-cannot-generate-obligation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "lawful-universe-good-does-not-outweigh-suffering", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "lawful-universe-enables-science-and-relief", "tectonics-and-free-will-are-life-enabling-costs" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 204, "move_id": "darwinian-reason-empathy-is-parsimonious", "speaker": "Peter Singer", "targets": [ "conscience-points-beyond-darwinian-interest", "darwinian-mechanisms-explain-only-self-interest", "authoritative-law-requires-lawgiver", "reciprocity-cannot-generate-obligation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "negative-naturalism-prior-objection", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "naturalism-simpler-prior" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "no-maximal-perfect-world", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "perfect-creator-perfect-universe" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "goods-compensation-and-background-evidence", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "inductive-unjustified-evils", "evolutionary-evil-favors-naturalism", "nonresistant-nontheism-contradiction" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "active-passive-potentiality-reply", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "immutability-freedom-incompatibility" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "existential-inertia-and-quantifier-objections", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pure-act-first-actualizer" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "attribute-gap-modal-and-mental-objections", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "pure-act-divine-attributes", "finite-past-divine-cause", "privation-entails-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "secular-necessary-moral-truths", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "theism-human-value-responsibility" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "existential-inertia-circularity-reply", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "existential-inertia-and-quantifier-objections" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "finite-chains-and-extrinsic-creation-reply", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "existential-inertia-and-quantifier-objections", "attribute-gap-modal-and-mental-objections" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "moral-platonism-explanatory-challenge", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "secular-necessary-moral-truths" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "privation-missing-good-and-agony", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "privation-entails-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "heaven-model-perfect-world", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "no-maximal-perfect-world" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "four-dimensional-perfect-world", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "perfect-creator-perfect-universe", "heaven-model-perfect-world" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "hiddenness-as-permissible-evil", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "nonresistant-nontheism-contradiction" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 205, "move_id": "isolated-seeker-defeats-free-will-defense", "speaker": "Ben Watkins", "targets": [ "hiddenness-as-permissible-evil" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "allegorical-genesis-compatible-evolution", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "evolution-conflicts-historical-fall" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "fall-redemption-not-entailed-by-fallibility", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "allegorical-genesis-compatible-evolution" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "original-sin-as-inherited-disability", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "fall-redemption-not-entailed-by-fallibility" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "god-as-creative-context-not-extra-cause", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "scientific-simplicity-without-god" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "natural-composer-explains-sublime-art", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "god-as-creative-context-not-extra-cause" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "evolved-brain-consciousness-ends-at-death", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "consciousness-resists-material-reduction" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "divine-fidelity-sustains-consciousness", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "evolved-brain-consciousness-ends-at-death" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "prehistoric-art-exceeds-survival-needs", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "creative-capacities-as-evolutionary-byproducts" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "scientific-processes-make-divine-creativity-superfluous", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "creation-as-continuous-divine-sustaining" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "incarnation-resurrection-answer-suffering", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "evolutionary-suffering-challenges-beneficent-god" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "incarnation-too-parochial-for-cosmos", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "incarnation-resurrection-answer-suffering" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "designer-hypothesis-undermines-scientific-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "god-as-creative-context-not-extra-cause", "creation-as-continuous-divine-sustaining" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "divine-action-complements-complete-causal-process", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "designer-hypothesis-undermines-scientific-explanation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "prayer-hearing-conflicts-with-simplicity", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "classical-divine-simplicity-uncomposed-source" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "divine-tasks-require-organized-complexity", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "classical-divine-simplicity-uncomposed-source" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 206, "move_id": "god-as-ground-not-finite-entity", "speaker": "Rowan Williams", "targets": [ "prayer-hearing-conflicts-with-simplicity", "divine-tasks-require-organized-complexity" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "archetypes-underlie-memetic-catchiness", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "memes-and-archetypes-are-distinct" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "cross-cultural-god-battles-are-unrevealing", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "archetypes-underlie-memetic-catchiness" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "stories-prioritize-the-world-of-facts", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "cross-cultural-god-battles-are-unrevealing" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "manuscript-evolution-needs-traceable-evidence", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "cain-story-deepens-through-cultural-transmission" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "sacrifice-motif-progresses-through-scripture", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "manuscript-evolution-needs-traceable-evidence" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "evolution-and-divine-inspiration-are-different-claims", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacrifice-motif-progresses-through-scripture" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "christian-mercy-is-a-nontrivial-cultural-achievement", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "cultural-christianity-is-not-truth-endorsement" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "ethical-fruits-do-not-establish-christian-miracles", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "christian-mercy-is-a-nontrivial-cultural-achievement" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "virgin-birth-image-carries-metaphorical-truth", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "ethical-fruits-do-not-establish-christian-miracles" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "science-depends-on-religiously-derived-axioms", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "science-delivers-precise-predictive-reality" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "christian-facilitation-does-not-validate-doctrine", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "science-depends-on-religiously-derived-axioms" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "mythological-reasoning-is-multiperspectival", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "christian-facilitation-does-not-validate-doctrine" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "literal-predators-make-dragons-unnecessary", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "dragon-fight-encodes-exploration-and-renewal" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "dragon-is-imagistic-meta-category-of-predator", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "literal-predators-make-dragons-unnecessary" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "dragon-language-can-mislead-about-ontology", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "dragon-is-imagistic-meta-category-of-predator" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "adaptive-memes-can-link-culture-and-genome", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "memes-are-nongenetic-darwinian-replicators" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 207, "move_id": "baldwin-effect-can-naturalize-archetype-evolution", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "baldwin-effect-genetically-assimilates-learning" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "sanctification-defense-starts-after-avoidable-fall", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "manifest-presence-fails-to-produce-sanctified-love", "right-motive-cognitively-robust-theism" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "world-design-objection-relocates-to-suffering", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "sanctification-defense-starts-after-avoidable-fall", "seeking-apostate-left-without-presence" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "hiddenness-and-suffering-bump-in-rug", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "world-design-objection-relocates-to-suffering" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "triumphant-good-requires-evil-overcome", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "hiddenness-and-suffering-bump-in-rug", "sanctification-defense-starts-after-avoidable-fall" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "soul-building-leaves-collateral-unsanctified", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "triumphant-good-requires-evil-overcome", "just-judgment-accommodates-excusable-nonbelief" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "excusable-nonbelief-is-not-condemned", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "soul-building-leaves-collateral-unsanctified", "seeking-apostate-left-without-presence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "fatherly-love-analogy-cannot-invert-love", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "manifest-presence-fails-to-produce-sanctified-love", "right-motive-cognitively-robust-theism" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "eternal-perspective-and-fallen-agents-change-father-analogy", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "fatherly-love-analogy-cannot-invert-love", "loving-father-analogy-requires-availability" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "god-could-have-created-agents-with-faces", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "eternal-perspective-and-fallen-agents-change-father-analogy", "triumphant-good-requires-evil-overcome" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "earned-virtue-requires-formative-process", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "god-could-have-created-agents-with-faces" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "universal-revelation-would-strengthen-resurrection-evidence", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "right-motive-cognitively-robust-theism", "manifest-presence-fails-to-produce-sanctified-love" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "more-evidence-can-entrench-wrong-motives", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "universal-revelation-would-strengthen-resurrection-evidence" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "less-hidden-not-fully-disclosed", "speaker": "Tyler Vela", "targets": [ "more-evidence-can-entrench-wrong-motives" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 208, "move_id": "human-motives-are-individual-and-complex", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "less-hidden-not-fully-disclosed", "seeking-apostate-left-without-presence" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "hiddenness-concerns-evidences-personal-effect", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "natural-theology-must-enter-total-evidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "evidence-need-not-control-action", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "hiddenness-concerns-evidences-personal-effect", "personal-revelation-is-the-relevant-kind" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "belief-formation-is-not-voluntary", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "evidence-need-not-control-action" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "changed-appraisal-may-be-gradual-disclosure", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "belief-formation-is-not-voluntary", "hiddenness-may-be-temporally-local" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "better-understanding-is-not-personal-revelation", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "changed-appraisal-may-be-gradual-disclosure" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "delayed-salvation-plan-is-vulnerable-to-interruption", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "hiddenness-may-be-temporally-local" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "enough-evidence-and-intentional-hiding-conflict", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "natural-theology-must-enter-total-evidence", "hiddenness-may-be-temporally-local" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "alexs-changed-willingness-weakens-stable-nonresistance", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "single-nonresistant-case-creates-explanatory-burden", "better-understanding-is-not-personal-revelation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "current-seeking-exceeds-reasonable-threshold", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "alexs-changed-willingness-weakens-stable-nonresistance" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "introspection-is-fallible-for-believers-and-nonbelievers", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "current-seeking-exceeds-reasonable-threshold" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "subtle-motivation-is-possible-but-not-established", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "introspection-is-fallible-for-believers-and-nonbelievers" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "motivational-resistance-does-occur-in-some-cases", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "subtle-motivation-is-possible-but-not-established" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "unverified-relationship-demands-too-much", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "relationship-may-precede-propositional-belief", "different-psychologies-have-different-gateways", "costly-practice-cannot-precede-adequate-belief" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "requiring-unintelligible-sacrifice-is-cruel", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "relationship-may-precede-propositional-belief", "different-psychologies-have-different-gateways" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "divine-disclosure-routes-vary-and-faith-still-matters", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "unverified-relationship-demands-too-much", "requiring-unintelligible-sacrifice-is-cruel" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "leap-of-faith-may-precede-experience", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "costly-practice-cannot-precede-adequate-belief", "requiring-unintelligible-sacrifice-is-cruel" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "acting-as-if-can-manufacture-confirmation", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "leap-of-faith-may-precede-experience", "theism-may-be-human-response-to-existential-silence" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "awareness-of-meaninglessness-may-point-to-meaning", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "theism-may-be-human-response-to-existential-silence", "acting-as-if-can-manufacture-confirmation" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "delayed-disclosure-may-produce-goods-for-others", "speaker": "Lukas Ruegger", "targets": [ "delayed-salvation-plan-is-vulnerable-to-interruption", "acting-as-if-can-manufacture-confirmation" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 209, "move_id": "minimal-personal-sign-would-suffice", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "delayed-disclosure-may-produce-goods-for-others", "divine-disclosure-routes-vary-and-faith-still-matters" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-prefers-evidential-hiddenness-formulation", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-formulates-deductive-hiddenness-argument" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-concedes-some-evidential-pressure", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-prefers-evidential-hiddenness-formulation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-accepts-seeking-and-shifts-to-temporary-reasons", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-prefers-evidential-hiddenness-formulation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-invokes-antecedent-christian-resources", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-perfect-love-should-secure-reciprocal-relationship" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-development-eternity-and-limited-perspective", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-perfect-love-should-secure-reciprocal-relationship" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-goods-can-arise-within-relationship", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-development-eternity-and-limited-perspective" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-conscience-enables-less-explicit-relationship", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-perfect-love-should-secure-reciprocal-relationship", "schmid-goods-can-arise-within-relationship" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-hiddenness-may-be-redemptive-mercy", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-goods-can-arise-within-relationship" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-demographic-pattern-undercuts-individualized-defenses", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-hiddenness-may-be-redemptive-mercy", "paterson-development-eternity-and-limited-perspective" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-demographics-do-not-determine-ultimate-salvation", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-demographic-pattern-undercuts-individualized-defenses" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-naturalism-simply-predicts-demographic-distribution", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-demographics-do-not-determine-ultimate-salvation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-inclusivism-leaves-present-relational-deprivation", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-demographics-do-not-determine-ultimate-salvation" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-concedes-genuine-seekers-and-divine-hiding", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-rejects-asymmetric-psychologizing", "schmid-inclusivism-leaves-present-relational-deprivation" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-delayed-disclosure-may-avoid-apostasy-and-enable-testimony", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-inclusivism-leaves-present-relational-deprivation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-humble-disclosure-preserves-relational-freedom", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-perfect-love-should-secure-reciprocal-relationship" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-skeptical-theism-undermines-positive-theistic-inference", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-development-eternity-and-limited-perspective", "paterson-delayed-disclosure-may-avoid-apostasy-and-enable-testimony" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-defends-calibrated-epistemic-humility", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-skeptical-theism-undermines-positive-theistic-inference" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-redemptive-goods-still-fit-existing-relationship", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-delayed-disclosure-may-avoid-apostasy-and-enable-testimony", "paterson-defends-calibrated-epistemic-humility" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "paterson-cross-shows-redemption-through-divine-silence", "speaker": "Dan Paterson", "targets": [ "schmid-parental-silence-in-tragedy-favors-naturalism" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 210, "move_id": "schmid-concedes-coherence-but-retains-naturalistic-simplicity", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "paterson-cross-shows-redemption-through-divine-silence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "generic-ultimacy-does-not-establish-religion", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "ambiguity-allows-reasonable-disagreement" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "ambiguity-protects-noncoercive-relation", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "generic-ultimacy-does-not-establish-religion" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "both-sides-fall-short-of-proof", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "hiddenness-probabilistic-not-deductive" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "hiddenness-implies-recognition-is-unimportant", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "ambiguity-protects-noncoercive-relation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "king-analogy-fails-and-geography-dominates", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "ambiguity-protects-noncoercive-relation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "high-god-awareness-fits-disguised-king", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "hiddenness-implies-recognition-is-unimportant", "king-analogy-fails-and-geography-dominates" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "concedes-experience-often-grounds-faith", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "experience-grounding-and-apologetic-repair" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "sincere-seeker-psychology-remains-uncertain", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "experience-grounding-and-apologetic-repair" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "jesus-divinity-requires-prior-faith", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "ambiguity-protects-noncoercive-relation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "historical-jesus-secure-divinity-not-obvious", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "jesus-divinity-requires-prior-faith" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "religious-goods-do-not-require-creedal-litmus", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "psychological-origin-does-not-settle-truth" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "selective-skepticism-is-inconsistent", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "worldviews-require-humility-and-integrity" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "nonliteral-practice-centered-pluralism-coherent", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "pluralism-also-claims-privileged-truth" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "loving-god-would-not-punish-honest-error", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "belief-controlled-by-history-and-place", "king-analogy-fails-and-geography-dominates" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "experiential-diversity-is-not-decisive", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "experience-grounding-and-apologetic-repair" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "prior-beliefs-shape-experience", "speaker": "Julian Baggini", "targets": [ "experiential-diversity-is-not-decisive", "concedes-experience-often-grounds-faith" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 211, "move_id": "jesus-evidence-joins-philosophical-case", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "jesus-divinity-requires-prior-faith", "generic-ultimacy-does-not-establish-religion", "prior-beliefs-shape-experience" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "gospels-ancient-biography-response", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "gospels-symbolic-myth-not-history" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "scripture-adapted-to-events-response", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "gospels-symbolic-myth-not-history" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "natural-theories-fail-comparative-criteria", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pauline-revelation-likely-hallucination", "missing-body-underdetermined", "natural-explanations-remain-available" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "ordinary-causes-more-common-reply", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "natural-theories-fail-comparative-criteria" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "scripture-eschatology-origin-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "unexpected-resurrection-belief" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "women-polemic-paul-empty-tomb-replies", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "five-empty-tomb-indicators", "paul-same-body-transformation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "multiple-natural-causes-and-vision-science", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "unexpected-resurrection-belief", "natural-theories-fail-comparative-criteria" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "epistles-visions-no-missing-body", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "paul-same-body-transformation" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "psalm-orphic-dependence-rebuttal", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "gospels-symbolic-myth-not-history" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "daniel-expectation-and-specific-evidence", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "scripture-eschatology-origin-explanation", "ordinary-causes-more-common-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 212, "move_id": "exceptional-evidence-not-established", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "resurrection-passes-explanatory-tests", "gospels-ancient-biography-response", "five-empty-tomb-indicators", "daniel-expectation-and-specific-evidence", "pauline-revelation-likely-hallucination" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "wealth-reduces-misery-only-to-threshold", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "happiness-conflicted-desire" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "prosperity-can-enable-environmental-action", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "global-capitalism-threatens-the-commons", "capitalist-market-requires-collective-limits" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "happiness-as-causal-byproduct", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "wealth-reduces-misery-only-to-threshold" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "authoritarian-capitalism-breaks-democratic-link", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "capitalism-unparalleled-material-production", "free-markets-lift-the-poor" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "marx-recognized-power-problem-imperfectly", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "centralization-corruption-and-complexity" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "oceans-require-international-cooperation", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "prosperity-can-enable-environmental-action" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "marxian-analysis-more-complex-than-manifesto", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "economic-class-history-too-narrow", "binary-class-moralization", "capitalism-creates-wealth-despite-inequality" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "marxist-label-invites-radical-reading", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "marxian-analysis-more-complex-than-manifesto" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "personal-and-social-repair-together", "speaker": "Slavoj Žižek", "targets": [ "meaning-through-maximal-responsibility" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 213, "move_id": "local-repair-builds-social-capacity", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "personal-and-social-repair-together" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "religion-describes-participatory-patterns-not-mechanics", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "metaphorical-truth-preserves-useful-falsehoods" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "literal-errors-and-prescriptions-require-distinction", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "religion-describes-participatory-patterns-not-mechanics", "census-rule-encodes-limits-on-total-control" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "genesis-contains-heaven-earth-pattern", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "literal-errors-and-prescriptions-require-distinction" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "scripture-describes-lived-experience", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "evolved-stories-must-be-retested-for-new-environments" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "nonarbitrariness-entails-evolutionary-process", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "scripture-describes-lived-experience" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "tradition-is-embodied-participation", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "patriarchal-traits-may-now-be-dangerous", "retain-loving-motifs-discard-obsolete-patterns" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "external-judgment-needs-a-goal-and-standpoint", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "retain-loving-motifs-discard-obsolete-patterns" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "goals-and-evolved-values-guide-comparison", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "external-judgment-needs-a-goal-and-standpoint" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "god-transcends-being-and-grounds-pattern", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "dogma-blocks-archetype-criticism" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "religious-language-scales-and-christianity-needs-renewal", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "dogma-blocks-archetype-criticism" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "christian-hierarchy-is-love-not-the-sexual-application", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "obsolete-patterns-deny-lived-homosexual-experience" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "scripture-condemns-behavior-not-identity", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "obsolete-patterns-deny-lived-homosexual-experience" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "tribal-scripture-shows-obsolete-moral-patterns", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "scripture-condemns-behavior-not-identity" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "love-enemies-humanizes-without-erasing-boundaries", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "tribal-scripture-shows-obsolete-moral-patterns" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "plural-traditions-require-cross-tradition-navigation", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "love-enemies-humanizes-without-erasing-boundaries" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "christianity-improves-through-christian-participation", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "plural-traditions-require-cross-tradition-navigation" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "evolutionary-substrate-enables-critical-revision", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "christianity-improves-through-christian-participation" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "reform-must-occur-organically-from-within", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "evolutionary-substrate-enables-critical-revision" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "final-evolutionary-level-allows-christian-critique", "speaker": "Stephen Woodford", "targets": [ "reform-must-occur-organically-from-within" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 214, "move_id": "final-patterns-of-reality-ground-evolution", "speaker": "Jonathan Pageau", "targets": [ "final-evolutionary-level-allows-christian-critique" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "nonbelief-can-arise-from-blameless-error", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "nonresistant-nonbelief-conflicts-with-divine-love" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "loving-god-should-correct-blameless-error", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "nonbelief-can-arise-from-blameless-error" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "modest-religious-experience-could-correct-nonbelief", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "nonbelief-can-arise-from-blameless-error" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "epistemic-distance-preserves-freedom", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "nonresistant-nonbelief-conflicts-with-divine-love", "loving-god-should-correct-blameless-error", "modest-religious-experience-could-correct-nonbelief" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "known-goods-do-not-explain-extreme-suffering", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "epistemic-distance-preserves-freedom" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "divine-knowledge-permits-unknown-justifications", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "suffering-more-expected-under-atheism", "known-goods-do-not-explain-extreme-suffering" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "developing-world-enables-moral-goods", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "suffering-more-expected-under-atheism", "known-goods-do-not-explain-extreme-suffering" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "needless-evil-cannot-be-justified-by-response-goods", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "developing-world-enables-moral-goods" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "fallible-humans-add-unique-goods", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "needless-evil-cannot-be-justified-by-response-goods" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "evil-argument-is-an-internal-critique", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "fallible-humans-add-unique-goods" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "moral-realism-and-dignity-favor-theism", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "emotivism-expresses-welfare-preferences" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "moral-disputes-often-concern-facts", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "moral-realism-and-dignity-favor-theism" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "christianity-explains-dignity-and-obligation", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "emotivism-expresses-welfare-preferences", "moral-disputes-often-concern-facts" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "evil-undermines-christian-loving-god", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "divine-knowledge-permits-unknown-justifications", "developing-world-enables-moral-goods", "fallible-humans-add-unique-goods" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "moral-creator-identified-through-christ", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "evil-undermines-christian-loving-god" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 215, "move_id": "honest-nonbelief-complicates-divine-judgment", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "sincere-seekers-judged-by-culpability" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "religious-authority-has-eroded", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "science-is-powerful-but-narrow" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "good-life-is-not-measurable-as-happiness", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "religious-authority-has-eroded" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "wellbeing-is-open-to-objective-study", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "good-life-is-not-measurable-as-happiness" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "life-worth-living-is-not-scientifically-proved", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "wellbeing-is-open-to-objective-study" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "miracles-concern-suspension-of-natural-laws", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "spiritual-experience-does-not-validate-doctrine" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "conviction-must-scale-with-evidence", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "miracles-concern-suspension-of-natural-laws" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "healthy-religion-can-reform-sick-religion", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "religious-moderation-protects-unsupported-claims" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "nonreligious-regimes-do-not-represent-skeptical-inquiry", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "healthy-religion-can-reform-sick-religion" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "religious-tradition-shaped-modern-moral-values", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "nonreligious-regimes-do-not-represent-skeptical-inquiry" ], "score": 59 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "moral-selection-precedes-scriptural-authority", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "religious-tradition-shaped-modern-moral-values" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "usefulness-does-not-establish-truth", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "religion-addresses-purpose-and-moral-order" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "moral-fruit-supports-designed-order", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "usefulness-does-not-establish-truth" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "metaphysical-label-does-not-remove-evidential-contact", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "moral-fruit-supports-designed-order" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "soul-and-god-are-not-physical-object-claims", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "metaphysical-label-does-not-remove-evidential-contact" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "scriptural-record-remains-morally-mixed", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "abraham-story-rejects-human-sacrifice" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "interpretive-community-enables-moral-development", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "scriptural-record-remains-morally-mixed", "ancient-scripture-fails-timeless-moral-standard" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "religious-experience-has-nonliteral-truth", "speaker": "Rabbi David Wolpe", "targets": [ "scientist-can-partition-evidential-standards" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 216, "move_id": "modern-conversation-should-replace-privileged-ancient-authority", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "human-cognition-does-not-exhaust-reality" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "mind-combination-underdetermines-god", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "panpsychism-points-religiously" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "pantheism-opposes-classical-creator", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "panpsychism-points-religiously" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "practice-before-complete-theology", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "pantheism-opposes-classical-creator" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "fine-tuning-needs-distribution", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-favors-theism" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "unknown-variables-limit-confidence", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-favors-theism" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "scientific-reaction-supports-significance", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-needs-distribution", "unknown-variables-limit-confidence" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "logical-range-defeats-precise-odds", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-favors-theism", "scientific-reaction-supports-significance" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "order-remains-explanatory-mystery", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-needs-distribution", "logical-range-defeats-precise-odds" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "scriptural-awareness-does-not-solve-hiddenness", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "arbitrary-grace-permits-unbelief", "unbelief-built-into-cosmos" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "mystical-access-is-not-the-point", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "unequal-access-intensifies-hiddenness" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "hidden-person-called-to-virtue", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "unequal-access-intensifies-hiddenness" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "wrong-religion-may-be-worse", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "practice-before-complete-theology", "hidden-person-called-to-virtue" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "practice-matters-more-than-conceptual-error", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "wrong-religion-may-be-worse" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "unequal-maps-create-dilemma", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "religions-share-starting-ground" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "hiddenness-enables-freedom-and-story", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "unequal-maps-create-dilemma" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "animal-experience-remains-uncertain", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "animal-suffering-presses-triomni-god" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "moral-intuition-cuts-against-theism", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "animal-experience-remains-uncertain" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "mysterious-residue-expected-under-freedom", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "animal-suffering-presses-triomni-god", "moral-intuition-cuts-against-theism" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "animal-pain-may-be-more-intense", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "animal-experience-remains-uncertain", "mysterious-residue-expected-under-freedom" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "heaven-shows-suffering-not-required", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "mysterious-residue-expected-under-freedom" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "earthly-progression-has-distinct-value", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "heaven-shows-suffering-not-required" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "human-violence-fixes-eternal-rank", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "earthly-progression-has-distinct-value" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "divine-love-not-oppressive-hierarchy", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "human-violence-fixes-eternal-rank" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "freedom-can-remove-gods-intended-life", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "divine-love-not-oppressive-hierarchy", "earthly-progression-has-distinct-value" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "freedom-and-glorification-constrain-world", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "freedom-can-remove-gods-intended-life" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "evil-targets-specific-religions", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "freedom-and-glorification-constrain-world" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 217, "move_id": "ordinary-practice-bears-fruit", "speaker": "Ross Douthat", "targets": [ "evil-targets-specific-religions" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-popular-success-philosophical-groundlessness", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-faded-before-promised-dawn" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-epistemic-asymmetry", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-critique-easier-than-worldview", "con-atheistic-case-still-has-arguments" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-atheism-does-not-entail-scientific-theory", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-epistemic-asymmetry", "pro-science-also-needs-second-level-judgments" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-dawkins-appeals-to-simplified-science", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-atheism-does-not-entail-scientific-theory" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-new-covenant-removes-old-law", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-emotivism-and-internal-moral-critique" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-concedes-possible-past-permissibility", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-emotivism-and-internal-moral-critique" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-same-god-retains-historical-burden", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-new-covenant-removes-old-law", "pro-concedes-possible-past-permissibility" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-will-check-leviticus-claim", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-leviticus-does-not-prohibit-slavery" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-shame-ineffective-but-reactive", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-faith-shaming-cultural-cost" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-polemics-create-division", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-shame-ineffective-but-reactive" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-legitimate-religious-harms-remain", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-polemics-create-division" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "pro-institutional-failure-not-uniquely-religious", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-legitimate-religious-harms-remain" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-conversion-stories-target-dawkins-not-atheism", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-conversions-show-counterproductive-impact", "pro-narratives-reveal-reasoning-depth" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-god-delusion-insufficient-not-theism-refuted", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-conversions-show-counterproductive-impact" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-religious-experience-private-not-public-proof", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-narratives-reveal-reasoning-depth" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 218, "move_id": "con-selective-experience-strengthens-hiddenness", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-conversions-show-counterproductive-impact", "pro-narratives-reveal-reasoning-depth" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "expected-world-evidence-of-absence", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "ultimate-beliefs-beyond-proof" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "believer-bears-proof-burden", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "ultimate-beliefs-beyond-proof" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "religion-as-internal-validation", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "science-and-faith-enrich", "ultimate-beliefs-beyond-proof" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "scientific-theories-change", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "expected-world-evidence-of-absence", "believer-bears-proof-burden" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "cumulative-evidence-stabilizes-science", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scientific-theories-change" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "ungrounded-values-reflect-society", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "religion-as-internal-validation" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "values-from-social-evolution", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "ungrounded-values-reflect-society" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "secular-values-risk-projection", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "values-from-social-evolution" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "science-corrects-belief-distortion", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "secular-values-risk-projection", "shared-risk-of-wishful-belief" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "meaning-available-without-religion", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "science-and-faith-enrich", "ungrounded-values-reflect-society" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "evil-challenges-divine-power", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "christianity-confronts-suffering-tension" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "faith-motivates-relief", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "evil-challenges-divine-power" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "selective-credit-defies-falsification", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "faith-motivates-relief" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "old-resurrection-story-insulated", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "ultimate-beliefs-beyond-proof" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "jesus-claimed-historically-reliable", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "resurrection-needs-proportional-evidence", "old-resurrection-story-insulated" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "meaning-without-jesus", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "jesus-claimed-historically-reliable" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "incarnation-places-god-in-history", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "meaning-without-jesus" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "comparative-worldviews-break-bubble", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "incarnation-places-god-in-history", "jesus-claimed-historically-reliable" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "science-does-not-answer-why", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "meaning-available-without-religion", "values-from-social-evolution" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 219, "move_id": "sentient-flourishing-moral-standard", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "morality-needs-beyond-us-framework", "secular-values-risk-projection" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-02-humility-not-pedestal", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-01-political-instrumentalization" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-03-personal-crisis", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-02-source-of-conversion" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-04-faith-and-reason-coexist", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-02-source-of-conversion" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-05-explicit-truth-belief", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-03-politics-versus-doctrinal-truth" ], "score": 59 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-06-scripture-and-apologetics-study", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-03-politics-versus-doctrinal-truth" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-08-new-atheism-hardened", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-04-atheism-as-minimal-disbelief" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-10-curious-developmental-reading", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-05-scriptural-moral-objections" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-11-scriptural-wisdom", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-05-scriptural-moral-objections" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-12-theological-limit-concession", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-06-original-sin-and-atonement" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-13-freedom-and-forgiveness", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-06-original-sin-and-atonement" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "con-07-celestial-dictator", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-13-freedom-and-forgiveness" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-14-apologetics-and-doubt", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-08-atheist-justification-standard" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "con-09-dogmatism-on-both-sides", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-14-apologetics-and-doubt" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-15-activist-atheist-certainty", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-09-dogmatism-on-both-sides" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "con-10-christian-certainty-counterexample", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-15-activist-atheist-certainty" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-16-concedes-some-christian-certainty", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-10-christian-certainty-counterexample" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "assurance-prompts-inquiry", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-10-christian-certainty-counterexample" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "extraordinary-factual-assent", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-05-explicit-truth-belief" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "benefit-truth-gap", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-01-peace-and-connection" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-17-experience-reading-and-miracles", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "extraordinary-factual-assent" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-18-fruits-as-empirical-testament", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "extraordinary-factual-assent", "benefit-truth-gap" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "con-12-truth-claim-confirmation", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "pro-17-experience-reading-and-miracles", "pro-18-fruits-as-empirical-testament" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-19-explicit-resurrection-belief", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-12-truth-claim-confirmation" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-20-policy-over-rhetoric", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-13-trump-humility-tension" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 220, "move_id": "pro-21-immigration-as-exploitation", "speaker": "Ayaan Hirsi Ali", "targets": [ "con-14-immigration-universal-love-tension" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-02", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-01" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-03", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-01" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-05", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-01" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-07", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-04", "con-06", "con-07" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-08", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-07" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-08", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-08" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-09", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-04" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-10", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-04", "pro-05" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-11", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-04" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-09", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-11" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-10", "con-11" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-12", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-06", "pro-12" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-13", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-06" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-13", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-13" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-14", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-13" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-14", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-12", "con-13", "con-14" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-15", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-14" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-16", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-06", "pro-14" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-15", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-15" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-17", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-15" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-16", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-17" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-18", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-02", "pro-03" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "con-19", "speaker": "Don Loeb", "targets": [ "pro-03" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 221, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "Michael Huemer", "targets": [ "con-13", "con-20" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-02", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-04", "con-05" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-04", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-06", "con-07" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-05", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-08" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-07", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-11" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-10", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-10" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-12" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-13", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-12", "pro-13" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-14", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-13" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-14", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-10" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-15", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-14" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-15", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-10", "pro-15" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-16", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-15" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-17", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-04", "pro-07", "pro-09" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-18", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-05", "pro-06" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-18" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-19", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-17" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-19", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-17" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-20", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-05" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "pro-21", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "con-04" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 222, "move_id": "con-20", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "pro-22" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-evolution-waste-and-redundancy", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-as-divine-means" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-timelessness-answers-duration", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-evolution-waste-and-redundancy" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-bottom-up-explanation-removes-design", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-compatible-with-plan", "pro-evolution-as-divine-means" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-laws-remain-unexplained", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-bottom-up-explanation-removes-design" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-constants-near-good-argument", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-laws-remain-unexplained" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-fine-tuner-does-not-explain", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-laws-remain-unexplained" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-timeless-god-stops-regress", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-fine-tuner-does-not-explain" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-multiverse-not-ad-hoc", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-multiverse-also-evidential-leap" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-priors-mediate-explanations", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-multiverse-not-ad-hoc" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-transcendent-mind-exceeds-concepts", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-complex-god-disrupts-explanation", "con-divine-simplicity-implausible" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-science-cannot-prove-transcendent", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-god-as-scientific-question" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-natural-harms-challenge-purpose", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-human-capacities-fit-purpose" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-lawful-creation-entails-harms", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-natural-harms-challenge-purpose" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-miracles-conflict-with-nonintervention", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-lawful-creation-entails-harms" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-rare-miracles-convey-message", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-miracles-conflict-with-nonintervention" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-selective-miracles-inconsistent", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-rare-miracles-convey-message" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-constant-intervention-destroys-order", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-selective-miracles-inconsistent" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-jesus-miracle-cluster-inconsistent", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-rare-miracles-convey-message", "pro-constant-intervention-destroys-order" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-nobility-exceeds-misfiring-description", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-evolved-generalized-altruism-rule" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-explanation-does-not-dismiss-altruism", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-nobility-exceeds-misfiring-description" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-morality-signposts-holy-god", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-evolved-generalized-altruism-rule", "con-moral-terms-need-no-spirit" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-beauty-lacks-obvious-fitness-value", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-beauty-has-natural-analogy" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "pro-joy-suggests-transcendence", "speaker": "Francis Collins", "targets": [ "con-beauty-has-natural-analogy" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 223, "move_id": "con-neural-explanation-preserves-beauty", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-beauty-lacks-obvious-fitness-value", "pro-joy-suggests-transcendence" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-unobserved-undefined-hidden-variables", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-hidden-information-may-be-observable" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-experimental-inference-assumption-dependent", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-experiments-undermine-noncontextual-realism" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-quantumness-placeholder-not-theory", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-hidden-information-may-be-observable" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-wrong-paper-model-exists", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-quantumness-placeholder-not-theory" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-toy-model-defines-variables", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-unobserved-undefined-hidden-variables", "con-quantumness-placeholder-not-theory" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-si-supported-by-scientific-practice", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-experimental-inference-assumption-dependent", "pro-locality-tradeoff-favors-si-violation" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-classical-carryover-selective", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-experimental-inference-assumption-dependent", "pro-locality-tradeoff-favors-si-violation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-protocol-cannot-reset-hidden-state", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-wrong-paper-model-exists", "pro-toy-model-defines-variables" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-repeated-measurements-address-state-ignorance", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-protocol-cannot-reset-hidden-state", "con-hidden-variables-lack-independent-need" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-test-allows-drift-escape", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-repeated-measurements-address-state-ignorance" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-noncommuting-measurement-protocol", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-test-allows-drift-escape" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-models-not-class-are-falsifiable", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-hidden-variables-lack-independent-need", "con-test-allows-drift-escape" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-remote-detector-causation-unclear", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-detector-degrees-as-hidden-variables", "pro-evolution-law-still-incomplete" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-local-law-selects-detector-eigenstate", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-remote-detector-causation-unclear" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-amplification-may-distort-outcome", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-local-law-selects-detector-eigenstate" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-detector-variables-preserve-born-mean", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-amplification-may-distort-outcome" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-measurement-setting-enters-evolution-law", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-remote-detector-causation-unclear", "con-amplification-may-distort-outcome" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-complex-causal-chain-unsupported", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-measurement-setting-enters-evolution-law" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-one-incomplete-model-not-entire-class", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-complex-causal-chain-unsupported" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-incompleteness-alone-not-disqualifying", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-one-incomplete-model-not-entire-class" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-decoherence-scale-defines-detector", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-small-observers-support-contextuality" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-si-violation-needs-strong-rationale", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-locality-tradeoff-favors-si-violation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-no-experimental-reason-yet", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-one-incomplete-model-not-entire-class" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-locality-also-historically-successful", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-si-supported-by-scientific-practice", "con-no-experimental-reason-yet" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-experiments-must-guide-theory-building", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-no-experimental-reason-yet" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "con-protocol-operationally-under-specified", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-repeated-measurements-address-state-ignorance", "pro-experiments-must-guide-theory-building" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 224, "move_id": "pro-earlier-paper-supplies-thresholds", "speaker": "Sabine Hossenfelder", "targets": [ "con-protocol-operationally-under-specified" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-cd-analogy-supports-missing-framework", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-brain-cannot-deduce-experience" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-physical-chain-does-not-reduce-melody", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-cd-analogy-supports-missing-framework" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-cd-analogy-supports-missing-framework" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-painter-constituted-by-same-paint", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-experience-is-only-given-starting-point", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-painter-constituted-by-same-paint" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-organized-matter-may-yield-emergence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality", "pro-experience-is-only-given-starting-point" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-physics-does-not-exhaust-matter", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-science-models-without-settling-ontology", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-physics-does-not-exhaust-matter" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-birth-supports-material-emergence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality", "con-organized-matter-may-yield-emergence" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-birth-creates-dissociation-not-consciousness", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-birth-supports-material-emergence", "con-nonbiological-development-could-yield-consciousness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-composition-still-needs-conscious-whole", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-life-images-dissociated-mental-process" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-biology-images-dissociation", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-composition-still-needs-conscious-whole" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-silicon-capacities-create-attribution-symmetry", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-silicon-simulation-does-not-instantiate-life" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-artificial-organ-supports-noncarbon-consciousness", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-silicon-simulation-does-not-instantiate-life" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-artificial-consciousness-needs-categorical-jump", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-artificial-organ-supports-noncarbon-consciousness" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-human-minds-inferred-by-organismic-analogy", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-producing-conscious-computer-need-not-solve-hard-problem" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-alien-capacities-support-consciousness-attribution", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-human-minds-inferred-by-organismic-analogy" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-strong-emergence-lacks-deduction", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-organized-matter-may-yield-emergence", "con-active-process-may-produce-consciousness" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-idealism-bears-stronger-burden", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-quantitative-brain-cannot-deduce-experience", "pro-quantitative-matter-cannot-bridge-quality" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-missing-principle-may-block-deduction", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-artificial-consciousness-needs-categorical-jump", "con-idealism-bears-stronger-burden" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-materialism-assumes-nonexperiential-reality", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-idealism-bears-stronger-burden", "con-missing-principle-may-block-deduction" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-physical-interventions-suggest-causal-asymmetry", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-shared-world-is-transpersonal-experience" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-world-properties-differ-from-personal-consciousness", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-shared-world-is-transpersonal-experience" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-body-mediates-bidirectional-world-interaction", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-physical-interventions-suggest-causal-asymmetry", "con-world-properties-differ-from-personal-consciousness" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-neural-interventions-fit-idealist-appearance", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-physical-interventions-suggest-causal-asymmetry" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-function-cannot-establish-private-consciousness", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-black-box-test-cannot-distinguish-consciousness" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "con-alien-tests-metabolism-criterion", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-metabolism-marks-tentative-boundary" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 225, "move_id": "pro-radically-alien-consciousness-remains-uncertain", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-alien-tests-metabolism-criterion" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "corinthians-lexical-punishment-reply", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "corinthian-ministry-context" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "passive-satisfaction-clarification", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "temporal-atonement-definition" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "temporal-order-of-justice", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "temporal-atonement-definition" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "merit-as-gracious-reward", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "romans-four-blessed-man" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "matthew-prison-context", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "matthew-last-penny-case" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "treasury-merit-indulgence-reply", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "passive-satisfaction-clarification", "merit-as-gracious-reward" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "justification-sanctification-distinction", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "passive-satisfaction-clarification" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "mortal-venial-defense", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "justification-sanctification-distinction" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "diverse-patristic-views", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "early-postmortem-witness" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "mortal-venial-unbiblical", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "mortal-venial-defense" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "postjudgment-regret-diagnostic", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "corinthian-ministry-context" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "completion-before-heaven-concession", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "seamless-imputed-righteousness" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "final-day-timing-challenge", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "corinthians-loss-as-discipline" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "final-judgment-before-beatific-vision", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "final-day-timing-challenge" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "new-nature-direct-entrance", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "completion-before-heaven-concession" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "augustine-qualified-concession", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "early-postmortem-witness" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "hebrews-limited-to-life", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "postmortem-discipline-syllogism", "postjudgment-regret-diagnostic" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "thief-remission-answer", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "new-nature-direct-entrance" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "thief-perfectly-saved-by-faith", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "thief-remission-answer" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "finished-not-total-salvation", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "seamless-imputed-righteousness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "atonement-remains-necessary", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "romans-four-blessed-man", "justification-sanctification-distinction" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "development-converging-models", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "late-doctrinal-development", "diverse-patristic-views", "augustine-qualified-concession" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "second-corinthians-five-answer", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "new-nature-direct-entrance" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "corinthians-revelation-not-purification", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "corinthians-loss-as-discipline", "corinthians-lexical-punishment-reply" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "horn-closing-transforming-love", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "seamless-imputed-righteousness", "new-nature-direct-entrance" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "white-closing-development", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "early-postmortem-witness", "development-converging-models" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 226, "move_id": "white-closing-romans-burden", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "merit-as-gracious-reward", "atonement-remains-necessary", "horn-closing-transforming-love" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-theoretical-nihilism-cannot-be-lived", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-literature-gives-meaning-but-science-governs-truth" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-meaningless-universe-with-social-religion", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-theoretical-nihilism-cannot-be-lived" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-practice-attracts-more-than-doctrine", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-christian-background-grounds-fragile-liberal-goods" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-faith-as-embodied-encounter-and-orientation", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-practice-attracts-more-than-doctrine" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-relational-goods-have-intrinsic-value", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-evolved-humans-generate-noncosmic-meaning" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-gene-propagation-is-ultimate-purpose", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-relational-goods-have-intrinsic-value" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-reduction-is-tragic-anti-human-flattening", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-gene-propagation-is-ultimate-purpose", "marriott-proximate-love-overlies-evolutionary-function" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-unpleasant-truth-need-not-fit-human-experience", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-reduction-is-tragic-anti-human-flattening" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-atheism-entails-meat-puppets-not-love-saturated-reality", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-unpleasant-truth-need-not-fit-human-experience" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-imagination-and-meaning-are-scientifically-explainable", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-science-is-one-story-among-ways-of-knowing" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-mechanism-does-not-exhaust-lived-event", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-imagination-and-meaning-are-scientifically-explainable" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-spiritual-intuitions-require-rational-filtering", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-science-is-one-story-among-ways-of-knowing", "oldfield-mechanism-does-not-exhaust-lived-event" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-reason-and-intuition-need-collective-wisdom", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-spiritual-intuitions-require-rational-filtering" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-comforting-spirituality-invites-wishful-thinking", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-reason-and-intuition-need-collective-wisdom" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-encounter-tips-intellectual-draw", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-comforting-spirituality-invites-wishful-thinking" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-science-is-closest-objective-corrective", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-encounter-tips-intellectual-draw" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-science-can-point-toward-profound-meaning", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-science-is-closest-objective-corrective" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-accepts-lived-theoretical-inconsistency", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-science-can-point-toward-profound-meaning" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "marriott-final-reflection-sympathetic-but-unpersuaded", "speaker": "James Marriott", "targets": [ "oldfield-science-can-point-toward-profound-meaning" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-final-reflection-asks-why-nihilism-is-unlivable", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-accepts-lived-theoretical-inconsistency" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 227, "move_id": "oldfield-final-reflection-adopts-self-skepticism", "speaker": "Elizabeth Oldfield", "targets": [ "marriott-comforting-spirituality-invites-wishful-thinking" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-sufficient-core-not-exhaustive-detail", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-gospel-discrepancies-undermine-reliability", "ehrman-passover-chronology-contradiction" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-early-sources-eyewitnesses-and-josephus", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-gospel-discrepancies-undermine-reliability", "ehrman-passover-chronology-contradiction" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-diverse-attestation-preserves-proclamation-core", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-john-revoices-jesus-theologically" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-detail-changes-leave-substance-unguarded", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-essential-preservation-allows-recontextualization" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-historically-secure-core-of-jesus-activities", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-mark-luke-passion-portrayals-conflict" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-oral-transmission-changed-stories", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-early-sources-eyewitnesses-and-josephus" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-cumulative-errors-defeat-reliability", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-sufficient-core-not-exhaustive-detail", "evans-early-sources-eyewitnesses-and-josephus", "evans-manuscript-evidence-yields-stable-teaching", "evans-trinitarian-interpolation-did-not-create-doctrine" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-lost-earliest-copies-block-certainty", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-manuscript-evidence-yields-stable-teaching", "evans-trinitarian-interpolation-did-not-create-doctrine" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-identifiable-interpolations-do-not-erase-teaching", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-lost-earliest-copies-block-certainty" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-variants-change-attributed-sayings", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-identifiable-interpolations-do-not-erase-teaching" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-eyewitness-core-within-living-memory", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-gospels-anonymous-not-eyewitness-claims", "ehrman-oral-transmission-changed-stories" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-early-church-evidence-weighs-against-invention", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-gospels-anonymous-not-eyewitness-claims", "ehrman-oral-transmission-changed-stories" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-expansion-defeated-universal-eyewitness-control", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-eyewitness-core-within-living-memory", "evans-early-church-evidence-weighs-against-invention" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-specialists-use-new-testament-historically", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-independent-documentation-is-sparse" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-contextual-corroboration-supports-gospels", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-independent-documentation-is-sparse", "ehrman-expansion-defeated-universal-eyewitness-control" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-lost-copying-generations-block-preservation-claim", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-manuscript-evidence-yields-stable-teaching", "evans-identifiable-interpolations-do-not-erase-teaching" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "ehrman-complete-reliability-is-theological-not-historical", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "evans-eyewitness-core-within-living-memory", "evans-early-church-evidence-weighs-against-invention", "evans-specialists-use-new-testament-historically", "evans-contextual-corroboration-supports-gospels" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-facts-do-not-entail-skeptical-inference", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-lost-copying-generations-block-preservation-claim", "ehrman-complete-reliability-is-theological-not-historical" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 228, "move_id": "evans-faith-does-not-require-perfect-harmonization", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "ehrman-cumulative-errors-defeat-reliability", "ehrman-complete-reliability-is-theological-not-historical" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "paul-earthly-markers-reply", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "paul-omits-earthly-locations" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "crucifixion-explains-pauls-focus", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "paul-omits-earthly-locations" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "dying-god-parallels-contested", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "savior-deity-reference-class" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "archaeology-makes-fiction-odd", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "gospels-as-literary-parables" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "historical-setting-does-not-corroborate-jesus", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "gospels-correlate-with-setting" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "pauline-markers-remain-cosmically-compatible", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "paul-earthly-markers-reply" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "josephus-may-repeat-christians", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "josephus-core-with-glosses" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "silence-alone-conceded-insufficient", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "ancient-biography-comparison" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "probability-not-certainty", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "silence-alone-conceded-insufficient" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "galatians-james-best-but-ambiguous", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "paul-knows-original-followers" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "jewish-origin-resists-pagan-import", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "preexistent-jewish-angel-model" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "borrowing-through-judaization", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "jewish-origin-resists-pagan-import" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "independent-early-tradition-behind-q", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "gospels-as-literary-parables" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "q-cannot-be-dated-early", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "independent-early-tradition-behind-q" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "nazareth-epithet-absent-from-paul", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "independent-early-tradition-behind-q" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "josephus-vocabulary-and-context-defense", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "outside-evidence-not-independent" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "last-supper-earthbound-betrayal", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "pauline-markers-remain-cosmically-compatible" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "irenaeus-opposes-later-gnostic-reading", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "preexistent-jewish-angel-model" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "josephus-passage-contextual-interpolation", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "josephus-vocabulary-and-context-defense" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "verisimilitude-is-screen-not-blank-check", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "historical-setting-does-not-corroborate-jesus" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "accurate-fiction-still-not-historicity", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "verisimilitude-is-screen-not-blank-check" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "gospel-eyewitness-authorship-may-be-zero", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "apostles-not-disciples-in-paul" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "carrier-best-point-is-founder-precedent", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "rapid-legendary-founder-precedents" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "eyewitness-blackout-and-historical-color", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "gospels-correlate-with-setting" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "luke-does-not-use-josephus", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "eyewitness-blackout-and-historical-color" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "pagan-material-rewritten-as-jewish-superiority", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "jewish-origin-resists-pagan-import" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "paul-historical-material-and-authority-check", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "revelation-and-scripture-sources" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "physical-burial-before-visionary-appearances", "speaker": "Craig Evans", "targets": [ "pauline-markers-remain-cosmically-compatible" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 229, "move_id": "cosmic-jesus-still-physical", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "physical-burial-before-visionary-appearances" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-04", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-02", "con-03" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-04", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-02" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-05", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-04", "con-05" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-06", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-07", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-06", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-06", "con-07" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-08", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-06" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-09", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-09", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-03" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-10", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-09", "pro-11" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-10" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-11", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-12" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-13", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-11" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-14", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-12" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-13", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-15" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-14", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-14", "pro-15" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-16", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-16" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-17", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-06" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-17" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "pro-18", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-08", "con-17" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 230, "move_id": "con-18", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-18" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-01", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-01", "pro-02" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-02", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-01", "pro-03" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-05", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-06", "pro-07" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-10", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-08", "pro-09" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-10" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-11", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-04", "pro-05" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-12", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-01", "pro-02", "pro-03" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-13", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-10", "pro-11" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-14", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-15", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-10", "pro-11" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-17", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-06", "pro-07" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-13", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-05", "con-17" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-19", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-03" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-18", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-13" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-20", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-14", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-09", "con-10" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-21", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-08", "pro-14" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-15", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-06", "con-07", "con-08", "con-22" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-16", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-07", "con-22" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-23", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-16" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-14", "con-23" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-24", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-11" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 231, "move_id": "con-25", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-10", "pro-11" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-01" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-13", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-01" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-02", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-03", "pro-05" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-15", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-02" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-03", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-14" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-04", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-15" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-05", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-15" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-06", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-04" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-07", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-01", "pro-05" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-08", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-01", "pro-15" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-16", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-07", "con-08" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-09", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-05", "pro-16" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-10", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-16" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-12", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-07", "pro-08" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-14", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-08" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-12", "con-14" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-15", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-17" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "con-16", "speaker": "Graham Oppy", "targets": [ "pro-08", "pro-17" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 232, "move_id": "pro-19", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "con-18" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-01", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-02" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-03", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-01" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-04", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-03" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-04", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-04" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-05", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-03", "con-04" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-05", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-05" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-06", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-04", "con-05" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-06", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-06" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-07", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-07" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-08", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-08" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-09", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-08" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-09", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-09" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-10", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-10" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-11", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-11" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-12", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-11" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-12", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-12" ], "score": 57 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-13", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-12" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-13", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-13" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-14", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-14" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-15", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-14" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-15", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-15" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-16", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-15" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "pro-17", "speaker": "Alister McGrath", "targets": [ "con-17" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-18", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-18" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-19", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-18" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 233, "move_id": "con-20", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "pro-18" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-04-attention-and-presence", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-05-perceptual-encoding" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-05-experience-real-deal", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-05-perceptual-encoding" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-06-matter-phase", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-03-matter-as-representation" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "con-06-illusion-challenge", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-05-experience-real-deal" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-08-illusion-fallibility", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-06-illusion-challenge" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "con-07-entropy-argument", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-05-experience-real-deal", "pro-08-illusion-fallibility" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-09-richer-than-dashboard", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-07-entropy-argument", "con-08-fitness-encoding" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "con-10-being-versus-observing", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-05-experience-real-deal", "pro-09-richer-than-dashboard" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-11-epistemic-boundary", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-09-world-for-itself", "con-10-being-versus-observing" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-12-imaginative-contact", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-10-being-versus-observing" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-15-freedom-and-developing-god", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-13-qualified-divine-attributes", "con-14-immanent-transcendent-god" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "con-15-computationally-irreducible-purpose", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "pro-15-freedom-and-developing-god" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 234, "move_id": "pro-16-purpose-as-co-creation", "speaker": "Iain McGilchrist", "targets": [ "con-16-human-perspective" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-reasons-determine-arithmetic", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-magic-eight-ball-undercutter" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-first-mover-counterexample", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-recursive-reasons-dichotomy" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-round-square-rejoinder", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-first-mover-counterexample" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-correlation-not-identity", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-brain-damage-prediction" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-empirical-equivalence", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-brain-damage-prediction" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-predictive-confirmation-reply", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-empirical-equivalence" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-emergent-property-reply", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-property-difference-thesis", "pro-truth-and-weight-properties" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-truth-external-to-brain", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-truth-and-weight-properties" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-unassessable-soul-objection", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-property-difference-thesis" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-personhood-spectrum", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-nondegreed-personhood" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-transcendent-ground-of-personhood", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-discrete-physical-personhood" ], "score": 55 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-inverted-qualia", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-brain-damage-prediction", "con-emergent-property-reply" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-inductive-other-minds", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-inverted-qualia" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-private-access-mapping", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-brain-damage-prediction", "con-inductive-other-minds" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-model-prediction-verification", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-private-access-mapping" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-conscious-subject-to-soul", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-unassessable-soul-objection" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-interaction-separate-from-existence", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-unassessable-soul-objection" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-primitive-interaction", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-unassessable-soul-objection" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-primitive-label-not-mechanism", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-primitive-interaction" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "pro-interaction-gap-concession", "speaker": "Eric Hernandez", "targets": [ "con-primitive-label-not-mechanism" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 235, "move_id": "con-conditional-soul-concession", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-conscious-subject-to-soul", "pro-interaction-separate-from-existence" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-local-cognitivism-suffices", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-semantic-pluralism" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "con-semantics-removes-default", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "pro-local-cognitivism-suffices" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-drowning-child-reason", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-reasons-require-relations" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "con-private-understanding-insufficient", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "pro-drowning-child-reason" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-welfare-is-explanation", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-private-understanding-insufficient" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-empirical-test-illicit", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-no-independent-test" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "con-agreement-underdetermines-metaethics", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "pro-empirical-test-illicit" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-clear-cases-justify", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-agreement-underdetermines-metaethics" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "con-intuition-is-private-evidence", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "pro-clear-cases-justify" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-private-evidence-still-justifies", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-intuition-is-private-evidence" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-zorpian-facts-are-moral-facts", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-zorpian-parity" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-disciplinary-understanding-shifts-burden", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-claimed-intelligibility-not-enough" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "con-logic-is-conditionally-normative", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "pro-disciplinary-understanding-shifts-burden" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-norms-guide-goal-revision", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-logic-is-conditionally-normative" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-burden-awaits-evidence", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-academic-selection-hypothesis" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 236, "move_id": "pro-parsimony-omits-normativity", "speaker": "Eric Sampson", "targets": [ "con-psychological-parsimony" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "miracles-least-probable-by-definition", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "criteria-govern-probability" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "probability-paradox-blocks-proof", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "affirmative-motion-conclusion" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "case-does-not-require-gospel-inerrancy", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "gospels-late-and-anonymous", "oral-transmission-changes-stories" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "ehrman-grants-appearance-beliefs", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "gospels-late-and-anonymous" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "historical-conclusion-before-theology", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "probability-paradox-blocks-proof" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "crucifixion-not-positive-evidence", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "crucifixion-and-disciple-bedrock" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "apollonius-parity-challenge", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "resurrection-explains-three-facts" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "tangible-visions-recur", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "scripture-alone-does-not-explain-belief", "resurrection-explains-three-facts" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "conditional-divine-causation", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "miracles-least-probable-by-definition", "probability-paradox-blocks-proof" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "apollonius-source-comparison", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "apollonius-parity-challenge" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "apparitions-not-bodily-resurrection", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "tangible-visions-recur" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "enemy-conversion-not-miracle-evidence", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "paul-appearance-bedrock", "ehrman-grants-appearance-beliefs" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "source-standard-applied-inconsistently", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "case-does-not-require-gospel-inerrancy", "apollonius-source-comparison" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 237, "move_id": "public-evidence-requirement", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "historical-conclusion-before-theology", "conditional-divine-causation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-supernatural-claims-undemonstrated", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-cumulative-indicia" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-scriptural-story-is-not-miracle-evidence", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-cumulative-indicia", "pro-gospel-transmission-reliability" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "pro-limited-evidence-preserves-free-trust", "speaker": "Stuart Knechtle", "targets": [ "con-communicative-god-leaves-burden-unmet" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-natural-account-of-cooperation", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-christianity-explains-altruism-hope" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "pro-jesus-transformed-roman-morality", "speaker": "Stuart Knechtle", "targets": [ "con-natural-account-of-cooperation" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-social-benefit-does-not-warrant-supernatural-core", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-christianity-explains-altruism-hope", "pro-jesus-transformed-roman-morality" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-religious-desire-does-not-show-truth", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-christianity-explains-altruism-hope" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-biblical-violence-challenges-character", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-love-and-wrath-are-coherent" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-report-cannot-establish-forgiveness", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-jesus-claims-divinity", "pro-gospel-transmission-reliability" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "pro-multifaceted-return-to-faith", "speaker": "Stuart Knechtle", "targets": [ "con-rationality-requires-reality-consistency", "con-communicative-god-leaves-burden-unmet" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "pro-six-source-resurrection-reply", "speaker": "Stuart Knechtle", "targets": [ "con-scriptural-story-is-not-miracle-evidence", "con-report-cannot-establish-forgiveness" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-observed-effect-needs-causal-link", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-cumulative-indicia", "pro-six-source-resurrection-reply" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 238, "move_id": "con-forgiveness-and-hell-undermine-justice", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-love-and-wrath-are-coherent" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-delayed-gratification-separable-from-human-sacrifice", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-sacrifice-discovers-the-future" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-disastrous-ancient-memes-need-not-be-redeemed", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-sacrifice-discovers-the-future", "peterson-harris-morality-implies-sacrifice" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-concedes-some-fictions-outperform-truth", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-stories-codify-selected-behavior" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-sacrifice-becomes-psychological-abstraction", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-delayed-gratification-separable-from-human-sacrifice", "harris-disastrous-ancient-memes-need-not-be-redeemed" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-sacred-books-receive-exceptional-authority", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-sacrifice-becomes-psychological-abstraction" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-interpretation-problem-also-afflicts-facts", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-sacred-books-receive-exceptional-authority" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-dogma-precedes-books-and-enables-perception", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-sacred-books-receive-exceptional-authority" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-sectarian-dogma-is-revisable", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-dogma-precedes-books-and-enables-perception" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-religion-provides-replaceable-bad-reasons", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-stories-codify-selected-behavior", "peterson-sacrifice-discovers-the-future" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-grounding-is-consciousness-not-external-purpose", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-interpretation-problem-also-afflicts-facts" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-wellbeing-measurement-remains-black-box", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-conscious-experience-defines-moral-domain", "harris-grounding-is-consciousness-not-external-purpose" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-tradition-contains-moral-updating", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-sectarian-dogma-is-revisable", "harris-religion-provides-replaceable-bad-reasons" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-evolved-heuristics-usually-remain-useful", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-quantification-corrects-story-bias" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-common-humanity-grounds-resistance-to-tribal-dogma", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-evolved-heuristics-usually-remain-useful" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-secular-ethos-remains-unidentified-black-box", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-common-humanity-grounds-resistance-to-tribal-dogma", "harris-grounding-is-consciousness-not-external-purpose" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "harris-story-benefits-do-not-require-divine-authorship", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "peterson-stories-codify-selected-behavior", "peterson-secular-ethos-remains-unidentified-black-box" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 239, "move_id": "peterson-final-value-structure-concession-and-challenge", "speaker": "Jordan Peterson", "targets": [ "harris-conscious-experience-defines-moral-domain", "harris-grounding-is-consciousness-not-external-purpose", "harris-story-benefits-do-not-require-divine-authorship" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "laws-and-consciousness-precede-modern-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-implies-goal-directedness" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "life-requires-tunable-law-types", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "dark-energy-window-supports-fine-tuning" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "multiverse-needs-fine-tuned-generator", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "multiverse-inference-commits-inverse-gambler-error" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "good-outcomes-do-not-create-right-to-harm", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "suffering-enables-serious-responsibility" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "benefactors-have-limited-rights-to-impose-hardship", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "good-outcomes-do-not-create-right-to-harm" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "compensation-and-necessity-limit-divine-permission", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "good-outcomes-do-not-create-right-to-harm" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "vulnerability-creates-responsibility-and-compassion", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "gratuitous-natural-suffering-challenges-love" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "state-and-parental-authority-have-different-grounds", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "benefactors-have-limited-rights-to-impose-hardship" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "maturity-analogy-does-not-fit-divine-nonintervention", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "benefactors-have-limited-rights-to-impose-hardship" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "limited-designer-fits-purpose-and-suffering", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "design-explains-laws-conscious-agents", "suffering-enables-serious-responsibility" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "benefaction-not-immaturity-grounds-parental-rights", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "state-and-parental-authority-have-different-grounds", "maturity-analogy-does-not-fit-divine-nonintervention" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "perfect-god-is-the-simpler-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "limited-designer-fits-purpose-and-suffering" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "empirical-fit-can-outweigh-default-simplicity", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "perfect-god-is-the-simpler-explanation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "suffering-enables-character-and-radical-freedom", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "gratuitous-natural-suffering-challenges-love", "limited-designer-fits-purpose-and-suffering" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "unknown-facts-do-not-block-best-evidence-reasoning", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "compensation-and-necessity-limit-divine-permission" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "cosmic-sin-intuition-opposes-omnipotent-creator", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "compensation-and-necessity-limit-divine-permission", "suffering-enables-character-and-radical-freedom" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "human-limits-do-not-excuse-unlimited-creator", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "benefactors-have-limited-rights-to-impose-hardship", "benefaction-not-immaturity-grounds-parental-rights" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "pragmatic-advantage-does-not-create-state-right", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "human-limits-do-not-excuse-unlimited-creator" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 240, "move_id": "alternatives-fit-facts-but-need-further-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "three-nontraditional-purpose-hypotheses", "empirical-fit-can-outweigh-default-simplicity" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "law-unknown-reality-does-not-block-hypothesis-rejection", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "ward-physics-opens-underlying-reality-question" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "law-hidden-agency-error-defeats-experiential-trust", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "ward-transcendent-experience-points-beyond-physical" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "ward-agency-detector-could-track-real-god", "speaker": "Keith Ward", "targets": [ "law-hidden-agency-error-defeats-experiential-trust" ], "score": 57 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "ward-rejects-omnipotence-and-posits-fellow-sufferer", "speaker": "Keith Ward", "targets": [ "law-historical-child-suffering-evidence-against-god" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "ward-lawful-existence-necessarily-carries-destruction", "speaker": "Keith Ward", "targets": [ "law-good-and-evil-god-face-symmetric-evidence" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "law-defeater-argument-does-not-depend-on-debunking-story", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "ward-agency-detector-could-track-real-god" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 241, "move_id": "ward-mind-is-fundamental-not-anthropomorphic-projection", "speaker": "Keith Ward", "targets": [ "law-hidden-agency-error-defeats-experiential-trust" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-gospel-rephrases-for-new-community", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-updating-definition-presupposes-inauthenticity" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-mark-retains-control-and-fulfillment", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-mark-john-ground-and-control-contrast", "crossan-passion-versions-authentic-not-historical" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-explicit-parable-markers-limit-extension", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-loaves-parable-preserves-demand", "crossan-emmaus-stranger-parable" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-loaves-sign-points-to-spiritual-need", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-loaves-parable-preserves-demand" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-emmaus-centers-prophetic-fulfillment", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-emmaus-stranger-parable" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-dependence-changes-attestation-value", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-source-reconstructions-are-hypothesis-laden" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-christological-titles-contest-caesar", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-worldview-grounds-historical-revelation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-synoptic-variation-can-harmonize", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-dependence-changes-attestation-value" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-copying-reduces-four-witnesses-to-one-stream", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-synoptic-variation-can-harmonize" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-divinity-is-presence-not-natural-violation", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-divine-consistency-does-not-bind-god" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-prophecy-is-retrospective-hope", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-emmaus-centers-prophetic-fulfillment" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-miracles-are-selective-authenticating-signs", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-divinity-is-presence-not-natural-violation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "white-bodily-resurrection-grounds-justification", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "crossan-prophecy-is-retrospective-hope", "crossan-gospel-rephrases-for-new-community" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 242, "move_id": "crossan-preenlightenment-question-is-significance", "speaker": "John Dominic Crossan", "targets": [ "white-explicit-parable-markers-limit-extension", "white-loaves-sign-points-to-spiritual-need" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-nonexistence-needs-account", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-biblical-god-denial" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-fiction-definition-and-impossibility", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-nonexistence-needs-account" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-godzilla-caution", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-fiction-definition-and-impossibility" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-science-requires-evidential-constraint", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-godzilla-caution" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-science-presupposes-logic-and-uniformity", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-science-requires-evidential-constraint" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-religious-faith-assumed-without-reason", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-science-presupposes-logic-and-uniformity" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-future-uniformity-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-religious-faith-assumed-without-reason" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-logic-cannot-validate-itself-noncircularly", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-religious-faith-assumed-without-reason" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-observed-uniformity-is-evidence", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-future-uniformity-challenge" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-scientific-method-self-corrects", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-logic-cannot-validate-itself-noncircularly" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-personal-continuity-cannot-be-proved", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-scientific-method-self-corrects" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-alternatives-need-possibility-and-documentary-support", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-personal-continuity-cannot-be-proved" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-god-hypothesis-predicts-public-consistency", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-god-precondition-for-intelligibility" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-defines-noncontingent-transcendent-god", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-christian-god-is-adapted-anthropomorphic-deity" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-transcendence-description-remains-unsupported", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-defines-noncontingent-transcendent-god" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-evidence-search-must-fit-transcendence", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-transcendence-description-remains-unsupported" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-faith-is-trust-based-on-evidence", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-religious-faith-assumed-without-reason" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-scriptural-story-is-not-independent-evidence", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-faith-is-trust-based-on-evidence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-jesus-denial-lacks-demonstrated-test", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-jesus-historicity-is-uncertain-and-composite" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-absence-of-evidence-and-comparative-history", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-jesus-historicity-is-uncertain-and-composite" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-historical-claims-require-corroboration", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-absence-of-evidence-and-comparative-history" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-borrowing-claim-needs-source-validation", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-moses-narrative-borrows-and-lacks-demographic-evidence" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-document-dating-and-peer-review-corroborate", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-borrowing-claim-needs-source-validation" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-personal-repetition-gap-reintroduces-trust", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-document-dating-and-peer-review-corroborate" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-transcendence-and-omnipotence-need-accurate-definitions", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-transcendence-description-remains-unsupported" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-credentials-do-not-verify-theology", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-transcendence-and-omnipotence-need-accurate-definitions" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-belief-is-true-aspect-of-christian-description", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-credentials-do-not-verify-theology" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-belief-fact-is-not-theological-truth", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-belief-is-true-aspect-of-christian-description" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-expert-appeal-must-specify-relevant-expertise", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-belief-fact-is-not-theological-truth" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-consensus-requires-broad-convergence", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-expert-appeal-must-specify-relevant-expertise" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-christian-expert-consensus-reductio", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-consensus-requires-broad-convergence" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-sectarian-sample-is-not-consensus", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-christian-expert-consensus-reductio" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-god-addition-is-not-explanatory", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-god-not-god-exhausts-options" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-abstract-logic-needs-worldview-account", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-god-addition-is-not-explanatory" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-logical-relations-hold-without-god", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-abstract-logic-needs-worldview-account" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "slick-no-god-universe-is-impossible", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "aron-logical-relations-hold-without-god" ], "score": 51 }, { "number": 243, "move_id": "aron-explanation-requires-mechanism", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "slick-no-god-universe-is-impossible" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-stage-two-underdetermination", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-stage-structure" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-competing-foundations", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-stage-structure" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-unlimited-needs-auxiliaries", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-unlimited-parsimony" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-perfections-remain-brute", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-perfect-being-explanatory-scope" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-unlimited-does-not-entail-perfect", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-unlimited-parsimony" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-common-sense-against-idealism", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-idealism-to-necessary-mind" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-idealist-intuitions-cultural", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-common-sense-against-idealism" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-idealism-still-underdetermines-theism", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-idealism-to-necessary-mind" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-conscious-foundation-counts-theistic", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-idealism-still-underdetermines-theism" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-trinity-perfect-community", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-unlimited-does-not-entail-perfect" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-omniscience-removes-third-perspective-need", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-trinity-perfect-community" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-experiential-self-knowledge-distinction", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-omniscience-removes-third-perspective-need" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-person-count-regress", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-experiential-self-knowledge-distinction" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-parsimony-balanced-with-scope", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-unlimited-needs-auxiliaries", "con-perfections-remain-brute", "con-person-count-regress" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-consciousness-construction-parity", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-parsimony-balanced-with-scope", "pro-idealism-to-necessary-mind" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-consciousness-ontological-continuity", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-consciousness-construction-parity" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "con-dissociation-is-descriptive", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-consciousness-ontological-continuity" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 244, "move_id": "pro-best-explanation-until-rival", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "con-competing-foundations", "con-perfections-remain-brute", "con-dissociation-is-descriptive" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "layered-consciousness", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "combination-symmetry" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "leave-gap-open", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "physics-intrinsic-gap" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "experience-first-unification", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "leave-gap-open" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "richness-dilemma", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "experience-first-unification" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "minimal-subjectivity", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "richness-dilemma" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "parsimony-of-intrinsic-nature", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "leave-gap-open" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "sample-extrapolation", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "parsimony-of-intrinsic-nature" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "calibrated-alternative", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "sample-extrapolation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "fallible-introspection", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "experience-first-unification" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "qualified-revelation", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "fallible-introspection" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "essential-accidental-selection", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "minimal-subjectivity" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "water-counterexample", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "qualified-revelation" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "appearance-is-experience", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "water-counterexample" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "discriminating-intrinsic-access", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "appearance-is-experience" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "illusion-and-basic-seemings", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "discriminating-intrinsic-access" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "opposed-starting-commitments", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "illusion-and-basic-seemings" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "physics-not-physicalism", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "opposed-starting-commitments" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "observational-equivalence", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "physics-not-physicalism" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "practical-theory-connections", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "observational-equivalence" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "no-resolving-method", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "illusion-and-basic-seemings" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "seemings-foundation", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "no-resolving-method" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "convergence-constraint", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "seemings-foundation" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "veracity-versus-truth", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "ego-loss-testimony" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "sensory-mystical-parity", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "veracity-versus-truth" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "psychosis-convergence-test", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "sensory-mystical-parity" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "uniform-experience-reply", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "psychosis-convergence-test" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "public-model-test", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "uniform-experience-reply" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "worldview-coherence", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "public-model-test" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "agency-does-explanatory-work", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "essence-energies-synthesis" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "purpose-without-anthropomorphism", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "agency-does-explanatory-work" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "ego-death-soul-challenge", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "ego-loss-testimony" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "real-self-no-soul", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "ego-death-soul-challenge" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "independent-language-correspondence", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "awesome-evidence-reductio" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "contrastive-likelihoods", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "independent-language-correspondence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "condition-on-cosmic-structure", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "contrastive-likelihoods" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "concession-and-remaining-scope", "speaker": "Philip Goff", "targets": [ "condition-on-cosmic-structure" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 245, "move_id": "modal-distance-limitation", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "concession-and-remaining-scope" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "eternal-possession", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "alone-world-knowledge", "changing-truths" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "causal-self-knowledge", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "alone-world-knowledge" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "modal-not-temporal", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "eternal-possession", "causal-self-knowledge" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "necessary-not-contingent", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "causal-self-knowledge" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "eternal-causal-embrace", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "modal-not-temporal", "necessary-not-contingent" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "causal-not-receptive", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "necessary-not-contingent" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "rival-models", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "subsistent-being", "exclude-composition" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "unmoved-not-immovable", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "dependent-motion" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "causal-circle-concern", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "unmoved-not-immovable" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "actual-for-all-effects", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "unmoved-not-immovable" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "internal-actualizer", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "causal-circle-concern", "actual-for-all-effects" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "playwright-knowledge", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "changing-truths" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "creative-will-qualification", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "providential-collapse", "explanatory-difference" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "subsistence-answer", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "internal-actualizer", "rival-models" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "additional-metaphysics-needed", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "subsistence-answer" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "rational-ideas", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "necessary-propositions" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "parthood-test", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "rational-ideas" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "precontained-differences", "speaker": "Gregory Pine", "targets": [ "explanatory-difference", "explanation-stopping-point" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 246, "move_id": "specify-freedom", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "freedom-and-concurrence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-necessity-countermodel-burden", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-atheist-conduct-metaphysical-fit" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-plato-impersonal-good", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-god-the-human-grounding" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-agency-consistency-model", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-equality-not-observation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-buddhist-compassion-model", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-atheist-conduct-metaphysical-fit" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-ultimate-good-parity", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-god-the-human-grounding" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-reciprocity-not-enemy-love", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-causal-versus-truth-question" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-history-is-not-necessity", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-holland-christian-roots", "scrivener-reciprocity-not-enemy-love" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-cynic-social-distinction-precursors", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-holland-christian-roots" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-concedes-ultimate-stopping-point", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-ultimate-good-parity" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-cross-protects-the-weak", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-ultimate-good-parity" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-cross-not-deductive", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-cross-protects-the-weak" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-shared-suffering-alternative", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-cross-protects-the-weak" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-personal-logos-rights", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-cross-not-deductive" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-buddhism-reflection-maximal-cross", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-shared-suffering-alternative" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-outrage-objective-obligation", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-private-morality-enforcement-tension" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-evolution-weakness-racism", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-causal-versus-truth-question" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-evolved-empathy-not-truthmaker", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-evolution-weakness-racism" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-impersonal-good-unfitting", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-plato-impersonal-good" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "scrivener-trinitarian-love-ultimate", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "folley-ultimate-good-parity" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-first-principles-disagreement", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "scrivener-jesus-scriptural-development" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 247, "move_id": "folley-subjectivity-qualified-reconciliation", "speaker": "Joe Folley", "targets": [ "folley-private-morality-enforcement-tension", "scrivener-outrage-objective-obligation" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-platonism-concession", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-uncreated-abstracta" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-virtual-divine-ideas", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-necessary-distinct-dilemma" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-concepts-need-conceptual-distinction", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-necessary-distinct-dilemma" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-properties-distinguish-abstracta", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-virtual-divine-ideas" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-ideal-not-imaginary", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-properties-distinguish-abstracta" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-plurality-within-intellect", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-ideal-not-imaginary" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-conceptual-explanatory-work", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-plurality-within-intellect" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-intentional-object-dilemma", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-conceptual-explanatory-work" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-terminology-not-nonexistence", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-intentional-object-dilemma" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-numerically-distinct-natures", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-nature-identity-uniqueness" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-provisional-nature-identity-concession", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-nature-identity-uniqueness" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-different-natures-equivocal", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-numerically-distinct-natures" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-primitive-distinctness", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-different-natures-equivocal" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-transitivity-survives-primitives", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-primitive-distinctness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-nature-level-primitive", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-transitivity-survives-primitives" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-divine-number-brute", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-nature-level-primitive" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-person-number-distinction", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-nature-identity-uniqueness" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-properties-presuppose-distinction", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-person-number-distinction" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-higher-divinity-participation", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-person-number-distinction" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-concedes-explanatory-order", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-properties-presuppose-distinction" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-common-divinity-not-lion", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-higher-divinity-participation" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-concedes-route-with-costs", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-common-divinity-not-lion" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-resists-higher-genus", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-higher-divinity-participation", "pro-concedes-route-with-costs" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-common-divinity-explanation", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-resists-higher-genus" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-perfection-not-explanation", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-nature-level-primitive" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-inference-not-explanation", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-perfection-not-explanation" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-causal-ground-uniqueness", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-perfection-not-explanation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-stipulated-relational-change", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-extrinsic-predication" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-signification-concern", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-extrinsic-predication" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-extrinsic-knowledge-challenge", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-extrinsic-predication" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-stipulation-concession", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-stipulated-relational-change" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-knowledge-scope-not-creator", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-extrinsic-predication" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-tree-counterexample", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-signification-concern", "con-extrinsic-knowledge-challenge" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-intrinsic-knower-extrinsic-contrast", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-extrinsic-knowledge-challenge", "con-knowledge-scope-not-creator" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-asymmetric-union-intuition", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-distinct-hypostatic-relation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-theological-language-revision", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-distinct-hypostatic-relation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-unilateral-union-analogy", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-asymmetric-union-intuition" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-ordinary-extrinsic-language", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-theological-language-revision" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "pro-christological-predication", "speaker": "Christopher Tomaszewski", "targets": [ "con-theological-language-revision" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-holding-hands-reciprocity", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-unilateral-union-analogy" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 248, "move_id": "con-theological-face-value", "speaker": "Joseph Schmid", "targets": [ "pro-ordinary-extrinsic-language", "pro-christological-predication" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "unusual-goals-not-irrational", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "tuesday-external-reasons" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "consensus-intuitive-warrant", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "unusual-goals-not-irrational" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "survey-representativeness", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "consensus-intuitive-warrant" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "reflection-expertise", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "survey-representativeness" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "sociological-consensus-caution", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reflection-expertise" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "present-values-condition-advice", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "idealized-self-authority" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "semantics-needs-empirical-study", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "semantic-naturalist-defense" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "sacrificial-dilemma-validity", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reflection-utilitarian-prediction" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "two-paths-to-utilitarian-judgment", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "sacrificial-dilemma-validity" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "psychological-convergence-alternative", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reflection-utilitarian-prediction", "two-paths-to-utilitarian-judgment" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "rational-impartial-description", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "realism-intelligibility-challenge" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "instrumental-definition-not-authority", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "rational-impartial-description" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "primitive-reasons-not-unique", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "instrumental-definition-not-authority" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "pain-evaluation-not-independent", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "introspective-hedonism" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "phenomenology-does-not-disclose-independence", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "introspective-hedonism" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "badness-precedes-aversion", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "phenomenology-does-not-disclose-independence" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "experience-versus-philosophical-inference", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "badness-precedes-aversion" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "qualia-scope-limitation", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "experience-versus-philosophical-inference" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "alien-parity-objection", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "primitive-reasons-not-unique" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "unintelligible-to-me-not-everyone", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "alien-parity-objection" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "interdefining-conceptual-loop", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "primitive-reasons-not-unique" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "predictive-contact-breaks-loop", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "interdefining-conceptual-loop" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "specialist-disagreement-utilitarianism", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reflection-utilitarian-prediction" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "minority-view-counterevidence", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "specialist-disagreement-utilitarianism" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "retrospective-agreement-not-truth", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "utilitarians-ahead-of-history" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "cultural-transmission-convergence", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "utilitarians-ahead-of-history" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "prior-weighted-moral-updating", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "cultural-transmission-convergence" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "reasons-need-not-motivate", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "desire-independent-authority-challenge" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "epistemic-parity-denied", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reasons-need-not-motivate" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "human-attitudes-versus-external-tests", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "counterintuitive-cases-prediction" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "conditional-consistency-not-endorsement", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "conditional-detector-acceptance" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "anti-realist-parity-acknowledgment", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "conditional-consistency-not-endorsement" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "reflection-not-mere-moral-vocabulary", "speaker": "Matthew Adelstein", "targets": [ "genealogical-lexicalization-explanation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 249, "move_id": "environmental-contingency-final-reply", "speaker": "Lance Bush", "targets": [ "reflection-not-mere-moral-vocabulary" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "logic-describes-reality", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "necessary-mind-outline" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "truth-bearers-not-makers", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "logic-describes-reality" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "sentences-and-correspondence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "truth-bearers-not-makers" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "translation-shares-one-truth", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "sentences-and-correspondence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "fictional-translation-comparison", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "translation-shares-one-truth" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "empty-world-truth", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "sentences-and-correspondence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "empty-world-fact-not-sentence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "empty-world-truth" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "infinite-unexpressed-truths", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "sentences-and-correspondence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "potential-linguistic-combinations", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "infinite-unexpressed-truths" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "ocean-not-abstract", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "potential-linguistic-combinations" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "brain-pattern-abstraction", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "ocean-not-abstract" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "mathematics-not-fiction", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "fictional-translation-comparison" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "fiction-and-math-correspondence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "mathematics-not-fiction" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "necessary-truths-not-contingent-tokens", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "fiction-and-math-correspondence" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "necessary-reality-contingent-descriptions", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "necessary-truths-not-contingent-tokens" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "biochemical-ideas", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "truth-bearers-not-makers" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "ideas-share-content", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "biochemical-ideas" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "keys-without-third-entity", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "ideas-share-content" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "keys-reopen-universals", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "keys-without-third-entity" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "idea-object-distinction", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "fictional-translation-comparison" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "ideas-not-independent-objects", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "idea-object-distinction" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "concrete-abstract-status-challenge", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "ideas-not-independent-objects" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "english-label-comparison", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "concrete-abstract-status-challenge" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "social-truth-independent-reality", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "concrete-abstract-status-challenge" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "social-construction-bearer-challenge", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "social-truth-independent-reality" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "knowledge-needs-real-object", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "english-label-comparison" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "knowledge-with-constructed-labels", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "knowledge-needs-real-object" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "whose-idea-is-shared-truth", "speaker": "James Anderson", "targets": [ "knowledge-with-constructed-labels" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 250, "move_id": "instances-make-propositions-dispensable", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "whose-idea-is-shared-truth" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "limited-and-ambitious", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "conditional-symmetry" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "qualified-comparative-burden", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "limited-and-ambitious" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "reversibility-concession", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "qualified-comparative-burden" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "disposition-and-possible-worlds", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "overcoming-evil-desire" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "competing-desires", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "disposition-and-possible-worlds" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "necessary-nonwrongdoing", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "competing-desires" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "available-evil-worlds", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "necessary-nonwrongdoing" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "power-versus-desire", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "available-evil-worlds" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "creation-psychology", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "design-moral-neutrality" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "conscious-victims", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "creation-psychology" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "probability-not-possibility", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "conscious-victims" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "maximal-cruelty-and-comparison", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "probability-not-possibility" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "tentative-psychology-remainder", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "maximal-cruelty-and-comparison" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "symmetric-noncreation-option", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "tentative-psychology-remainder" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "absence-need-not-exclude-being", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "intrinsic-possibility-space" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "parasitic-evil-and-ultimacy", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "absence-need-not-exclude-being" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "reverse-privation", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "parasitic-evil-and-ultimacy" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "existence-as-good-condition", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "reverse-privation" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "mixed-ontology-option", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "existence-as-good-condition" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "probability-space-restatement", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "mixed-ontology-option" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "intrinsic-existence-challenge", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "probability-space-restatement" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "functional-goodness-reframing", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "four-moral-accounts" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "objective-evil-scope", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "functional-goodness-reframing" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "unknown-divine-purpose", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "objective-evil-scope" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "reframing-unresolved", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "unknown-divine-purpose" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "command-does-not-show-love", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "four-moral-accounts" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "conceptual-evil-requirement", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "command-does-not-show-love" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "conditional-command-concession", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "conceptual-evil-requirement" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "challenger-burden", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "conditional-command-concession" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "compatibility-count-qualification", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "challenger-burden" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "compatibility-not-certainty", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "compatibility-count-qualification" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "reversal-and-world-comparison", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "free-will-reversal" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "bliss-and-comparative-cruelty", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "reversal-and-world-comparison" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "mirror-world-qualification", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "bliss-and-comparative-cruelty" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "mixed-world-counterexample", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "mirror-world-qualification" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 251, "move_id": "middle-spectrum-qualification", "speaker": "Max Baker-Hytch", "targets": [ "mixed-world-counterexample" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "remedial-virtues", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "virtue-not-pleasure" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "selective-intervention", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "agency-and-fall" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "heaven-suffering-reply", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "heaven-free-will-test" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "law-of-triumph", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "remedial-virtues" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "random-soul-building", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "selective-intervention" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "not-every-harm-needed", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "exact-amount-challenge" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "rainforest-consequences", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "rainforest-life" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "possibility-needs-warrant", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "law-of-triumph" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "suffering-bad-not-definition", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "virtue-not-pleasure" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "animal-beneficiary-challenge", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "random-soul-building" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "relationship-goal", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "relationship-concession" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "relationships-and-alternatives", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "relationship-goal" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "permission-clarification", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "exact-amount-challenge" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "virtue-criterion-reply", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "virtue-consequence-overlap" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "conditional-virtue-concession", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "virtue-not-pleasure" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "parental-counterfactual", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "parental-knowledge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "allowing-correction", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "parental-knowledge" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "independent-internal-critique", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "realism-escape" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "logical-limit-concession", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "omnipotence-limits" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "dream-perspective-closing", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "parental-counterfactual" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 252, "move_id": "emotion-distinction", "speaker": "Alex O'Connor", "targets": [ "dream-perspective-closing" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "worldview-explanatory-costs", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "evidential-chip-framing" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "rejects-hard-exclusivism", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "hiddenness-maternal-analogy" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "belief-condition-is-unjust", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "sincere-seeking-can-save" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "seeking-means-serving-god", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "belief-condition-is-unjust" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "annihilation-still-penalizes-nonbelief", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "seeking-means-serving-god" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "practice-presupposes-belief-reason", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "practice-can-precede-belief" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "choose-best-expected-path", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "practice-presupposes-belief-reason" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "tiny-probability-cannot-displace-values", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "choose-best-expected-path" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "ethical-life-has-lower-belief-cost", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "christian-practice-forms-virtue" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "theism-adds-ultimate-good", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "ethical-life-has-lower-belief-cost" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "eternal-reward-converts-sacrifice", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "theism-adds-ultimate-good" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "christlike-test-restores-trade", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "substitution-scenario-is-inapplicable" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "hell-expresses-prioritized-love", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "christlike-test-restores-trade" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "jesus-could-use-same-refusal", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "hell-expresses-prioritized-love" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "loving-parent-overrides-destructive-choice", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "lewis-hell-is-qualified-fallback" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "concedes-pressure-against-eternal-torment", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "loving-parent-overrides-destructive-choice" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "annihilation-leaves-relational-logic", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "concedes-pressure-against-eternal-torment" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "one-nonbeliever-suffices", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "theism-is-widespread" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "freedom-requires-unforced-choice", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "one-nonbeliever-suffices" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "choice-requires-known-option", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "freedom-requires-unforced-choice" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "hiddenness-enables-cooperation", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "choice-requires-known-option" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "other-goods-replace-lost-inquiry", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "hiddenness-enables-cooperation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "commitment-does-not-require-certainty", "speaker": "Zac Sechler", "targets": [ "other-goods-replace-lost-inquiry" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 253, "move_id": "ordinary-belief-is-the-relevant-certainty", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "commitment-does-not-require-certainty" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-vision-development-theory", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-paul-versus-gospels", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-case", "pro-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-paul-body-exchange", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-case" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-empty-tomb-evidence-quality", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-case" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-gospel-legend-growth", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-case", "pro-sincere-appearances" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-visions-prior-fit", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-sincere-appearances", "pro-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-intentionality-and-hallucination-cost", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-visions-prior-fit" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-paul-continuity", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-paul-versus-gospels", "con-paul-body-exchange" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-paul-lexical-rebuttal", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-paul-versus-gospels", "con-paul-body-exchange" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-grief-and-paul-vision-mechanisms", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-sincere-appearances", "pro-intentionality-and-hallucination-cost" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-jewish-pauline-parallels", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-paul-continuity", "pro-paul-lexical-rebuttal" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-guards-and-symbolic-tomb", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-case" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-adverse-witness-vision-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-grief-and-paul-vision-mechanisms" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-direct-pauline-transformation-texts", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-jewish-pauline-parallels" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-guard-polemic-and-literary-method", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-guards-and-symbolic-tomb" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-rubicon-comparison-rebuttal", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-empty-tomb-evidence-quality" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-mark-literary-markers", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-guard-polemic-and-literary-method" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-romans-present-life-context", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-paul-continuity", "pro-direct-pauline-transformation-texts" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-intentionality-circularity", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-intentionality-and-hallucination-cost" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-exchange-usage-and-context", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-paul-lexical-rebuttal", "pro-direct-pauline-transformation-texts" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "con-selective-appearance-expectation", "speaker": "Richard Carrier", "targets": [ "pro-intentionality-and-hallucination-cost", "pro-adverse-witness-vision-challenge" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-closing-comparative-fit", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-vision-development-theory", "con-empty-tomb-evidence-quality", "con-exchange-usage-and-context", "con-selective-appearance-expectation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 255, "move_id": "pro-closing-natural-rivals", "speaker": "Michael Licona", "targets": [ "con-grief-and-paul-vision-mechanisms", "con-mark-literary-markers", "con-intentionality-circularity" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-attribution-and-necessary-cause", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-religious-versus-political-violence", "pro-secular-law-protects-liberty", "pro-medical-deception-and-measles", "pro-prayer-instead-of-treatment" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-meta-analytic-beneficial-pattern", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-secular-country-outcomes", "pro-medical-deception-and-measles", "pro-prayer-instead-of-treatment" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-intelligence-correlation-is-fickle", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-faith-rejects-scientific-evidence" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-evolution-rejection-not-essential", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-faith-rejects-scientific-evidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-faith-means-committed-trust", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-faith-rejects-scientific-evidence" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-old-covenant-not-prescriptive", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-scriptural-violence-commands" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-cross-country-needs-multivariate-analysis", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-secular-country-outcomes" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-climate-acceptance-data", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-climate-denial-policy" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "pro-belief-benefit-is-placebo", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "con-meta-analytic-beneficial-pattern" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-specific-beliefs-require-studies", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-belief-benefit-is-placebo" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "pro-dissent-punished-as-capital-crime", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "con-faith-means-committed-trust" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-misuse-does-not-establish-intrinsic-cause", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-dissent-punished-as-capital-crime" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "pro-lacks-greek-expert-concession", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "con-faith-means-committed-trust" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-medical-trust-analogy", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-faith-rejects-scientific-evidence" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-single-study-cannot-counter-meta-analysis", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-secular-country-outcomes" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "pro-placebo-and-personal-experience-reply", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "con-meta-analytic-beneficial-pattern", "con-single-study-cannot-counter-meta-analysis" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-cross-country-homonegativty-reply", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-youth-homelessness-from-rejection" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "pro-interpretive-variability-enables-atrocity", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "con-misuse-does-not-establish-intrinsic-cause" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 256, "move_id": "con-words-do-not-cause-deliberate-misuse", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-interpretive-variability-enables-atrocity" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "con-science-best-for-empirical-facts", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "pro-evidence-constrains-inquiry", "pro-observation-corrects-speculation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "con-mind-body-conceptual-obstacle", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "pro-scientific-optimism" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "con-specialist-philosophical-skill", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "pro-philosophy-loses-domains" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "pro-science-can-pursue-fundamentals", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "con-ultimate-explanation-limit" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "pro-science-explains-morality", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "con-is-ought-limit" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "pro-conceptualism-is-empty", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "con-identity-distinction", "con-mirror-conceptual-puzzle" ], "score": 53 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "con-thought-experiment-refutes-theory", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "pro-conceptualism-is-empty" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 257, "move_id": "con-origins-do-not-justify-morality", "speaker": "Stephen Law", "targets": [ "pro-science-explains-morality" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-method-analogy-closed-worldview", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-method-divine-supervision" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-manuscript-streams-against-interpolation", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-paul-distortion-gnostic-reception" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-consistent-testing-of-miracles", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-method-divine-supervision" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-methodological-atheism-limits", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-method-analogy-closed-worldview" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-ancient-history-provisional", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-method-analogy-closed-worldview" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-cosmopolitan-source-availability", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-composition-inconsistent-source-theory" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-no-standardization-manuscript-variation", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-paul-distortion-gnostic-reception" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-cross-saying-contemporary-sense", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-temple-saying-variants" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-jewish-monotheism-against-pagan-myth", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-cosmopolitan-source-availability" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-hadith-temporal-difference", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-eyewitness-suppression-speculative" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-mission-context-sequence", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-mission-sayings-community-products" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-pauline-internal-discontinuity", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-no-standardization-manuscript-variation" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-context-explains-authorial-variation", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-pauline-internal-discontinuity" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-pauls-conversion-literary-parallels", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-context-explains-authorial-variation" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-common-phrase-not-literary-borrowing", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-pauls-conversion-literary-parallels" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-existence-evidence-criterion", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-method-analogy-closed-worldview" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-orality-variation-not-verbatim", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-hadith-temporal-difference" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-forgery-needs-pauline-standing", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-pauline-internal-discontinuity" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-paul-simon-magus-development", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-forgery-needs-pauline-standing" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-interpolation-needs-lost-streams", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-pauline-internal-discontinuity" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "con-interpolation-internal-fit", "speaker": "Robert Price", "targets": [ "pro-interpolation-needs-lost-streams" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-consistency-as-truth-test", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-ancient-history-provisional" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-scripture-comparative-coherence", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-inerrancy-barrier-to-understanding" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 258, "move_id": "pro-harmony-across-authors", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "con-inerrancy-barrier-to-understanding" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-seeming-and-neuronal-digest-dilemma", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-illusionism-reframes-hard-problem" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-method-not-experience-denial", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-seeming-and-neuronal-digest-dilemma" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-nonmaterialist-burden-limitation", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-seeming-and-neuronal-digest-dilemma" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-specific-hypothesis-demand", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-method-not-experience-denial", "con-nonmaterialist-burden-limitation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-nondual-experience-implies-idealism", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-attention-schema-and-first-person-method" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-panpsychist-alternative", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-nondual-experience-implies-idealism" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-field-ontology-and-single-subjectivity", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-panpsychist-alternative" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-regularity-and-explanatory-gain", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-field-ontology-and-single-subjectivity" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-lawful-mind-and-perceptual-dashboard", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-regularity-and-explanatory-gain" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-dashboard-ontology-neutrality", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-lawful-mind-and-perceptual-dashboard" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-ontological-economy-and-mental-modulation", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-dashboard-ontology-neutrality" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-neural-correlation-demand", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-ontological-economy-and-mental-modulation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-matter-as-dissociative-appearance", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-neural-correlation-demand" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-minimal-dissociative-boundary", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-matter-as-dissociative-appearance" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-inferential-isolation-and-clinical-evidence", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-minimal-dissociative-boundary" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-clinical-to-cosmic-scope-gap", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-inferential-isolation-and-clinical-evidence" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-biology-as-dissociative-boundary", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-clinical-to-cosmic-scope-gap" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-experience-without-metaconsciousness", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-ordinary-perceptual-dissociations" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-ownerless-experience-and-metacognition", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-experience-without-metaconsciousness" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-overbroad-illusion-label", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-ownerless-experience-and-metacognition" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-reification-as-specific-target", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-overbroad-illusion-label" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-idealist-reinterpretation-of-physical-causes", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-reification-as-specific-target" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-concession-on-brute-regularities", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-idealist-reinterpretation-of-physical-causes" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-primitive-properties-and-useful-ego", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-concession-on-brute-regularities" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-porous-dissociation-and-weak-effects", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-controlled-telepathy-revision-condition" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-absence-of-controlled-psi-support", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-porous-dissociation-and-weak-effects" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "pro-specific-dream-coincidence", "speaker": "Bernardo Kastrup", "targets": [ "con-absence-of-controlled-psi-support" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 259, "move_id": "con-limits-of-immediate-psi-rebuttal", "speaker": "Susan Blackmore", "targets": [ "pro-specific-dream-coincidence" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-transcendence-conscious-choice", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-life-precarious-and-imperfect" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-world-testifies-creator", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-universe-needs-no-assumption" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-earth-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-cosmos-hostile-not-designed", "con-life-precarious-and-imperfect" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-evolution-tested-and-evidenced", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-morality-and-organic-complexity" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-scriptural-violence-and-hell", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-torah-compassion-circumcision-benefit", "pro-divine-law-against-murder" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-secular-civil-rights", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-secular-eugenics-risk", "pro-divine-law-against-murder" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-circumcision-requires-consent", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-torah-compassion-circumcision-benefit" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-hanukkah-rejects-secular-humanism", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-hanukkah-resisted-tyranny" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-atheism-necessary-not-sufficient", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-secular-eugenics-risk" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-accepts-guided-evolution", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-evolution-tested-and-evidenced" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-mutation-probability-guidance", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-evolution-tested-and-evidenced" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-fossil-gaps-and-eye", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-evolution-tested-and-evidenced" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-einstein-pantheist-distinction", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-einstein-claim-inaccurate" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-fossils-contingency-unfalsifiability", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-mutation-probability-guidance", "pro-fossil-gaps-and-eye" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-selection-fact-not-ethic", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-secular-eugenics-risk", "pro-divine-law-against-murder" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-transitional-links-still-missing", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-fossils-contingency-unfalsifiability" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-religious-source-of-equal-worth", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-secular-civil-rights", "con-atheism-necessary-not-sufficient", "con-selection-fact-not-ethic" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-court-source-and-deism-limit", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-jewish-law-treats-nonjews" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-deism-possible-theism-falsified", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-world-testifies-creator" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-court-claim-remains-unsupported", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-court-source-and-deism-limit" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-god-supreme-moral-authority", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-secular-civil-rights", "con-atheism-necessary-not-sufficient", "con-selection-fact-not-ethic" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-personal-relational-god", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-first-cause-regress-gap", "con-deism-possible-theism-falsified" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-dna-natural-morality-challenge", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-transcendence-conscious-choice", "pro-religious-source-of-equal-worth", "pro-god-supreme-moral-authority" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "con-covenant-specialness-and-violence", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-chosenness-is-mission" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 260, "move_id": "pro-war-context-and-mainstream-repudiation", "speaker": "Shmuley Boteach", "targets": [ "con-scriptural-violence-and-hell", "con-covenant-specialness-and-violence" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-misuse-does-not-disprove", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-scriptural-violence", "con-surveillance-and-hell" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-order-and-moral-source", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-religion-primitive-explanation" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-authority-claim-unearned", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-misuse-does-not-disprove" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-dogma-is-not-god", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-authority-claim-unearned", "con-human-noncentrality" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-misuse-concession-and-scope", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-scriptural-violence", "con-authority-claim-unearned" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-texts-mean-what-they-command", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-misuse-concession-and-scope" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-target-is-god-not-texts", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-texts-mean-what-they-command" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-morality-precedes-revelation", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-morality-needs-governor" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-creator-unsupported-private-only", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-target-is-god-not-texts", "pro-morality-needs-governor" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-personal-experience-confirms-god", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-creator-unsupported-private-only" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-morality-not-temporary-power", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-morality-precedes-revelation" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-innate-morality-and-religious-corruption", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-morality-not-temporary-power" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-atheists-also-do-evil", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-innate-morality-and-religious-corruption" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-private-experience-no-public-proof", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-personal-experience-confirms-god" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-secular-evil-conceded", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-atheists-also-do-evil" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-scientific-belief-coexistence", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-order-and-moral-source" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-transcendence-without-supernatural", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-personal-experience-confirms-god" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-personal-god-and-order", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-scientific-belief-coexistence", "con-transcendence-without-supernatural" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-growth-from-insecurity-not-truth", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-personal-god-and-order" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-knowledge-expands-unanswered-questions", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-growth-from-insecurity-not-truth" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-suffering-has-natural-causes", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-knowledge-expands-unanswered-questions" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-morality-is-created-pattern", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-morality-precedes-revelation", "con-innate-morality-and-religious-corruption" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-framework-not-daily-command", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-private-belief-no-coercion", "con-authority-claim-unearned" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "con-faith-specific-extraordinary-harms", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "pro-atheists-also-do-evil", "pro-framework-not-daily-command" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 261, "move_id": "pro-closing-existence-burden", "speaker": "Al Sharpton", "targets": [ "con-creator-unsupported-private-only", "con-faith-specific-extraordinary-harms" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "religious-end-zone-challenge", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "specific-doctrines-explain-religious-conduct" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "paradise-as-isis-end-zone", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "religious-end-zone-challenge" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "multiple-religious-goals-limit-parsimony", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "paradise-as-isis-end-zone" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "isis-scope-limits-end-zone-claim", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "multiple-religious-goals-limit-parsimony" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "implicit-motives-limit-doctrine-only-explanation", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "isis-scope-limits-end-zone-claim" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "self-understanding-and-tradition-explain-specific-beliefs", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "implicit-motives-limit-doctrine-only-explanation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "secular-alternatives-can-supply-religious-goods", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "religious-adaptation-informs-flourishing" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "nested-institutions-fit-evolved-group-psychology", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "secular-alternatives-can-supply-religious-goods" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "secular-reason-can-design-workable-social-order", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "nested-institutions-fit-evolved-group-psychology" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "psychology-does-not-settle-moral-truth", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "moral-dumbfounding-reveals-intuitive-judgment" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "dumbfounding-truth-inference-rejected", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "psychology-does-not-settle-moral-truth" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "possible-minds-expand-moral-scope", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "anthropocentric-emergent-moral-truth", "equal-rights-as-emergent-social-truth" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "flourishing-allows-contextual-equality", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "equal-rights-as-emergent-social-truth" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "alien-morality-tests-universal-sufficiency", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "possible-minds-expand-moral-scope" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "conscious-suffering-without-evolutionary-history", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "alien-morality-tests-universal-sufficiency" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "species-psychology-shapes-rights", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "conscious-suffering-without-evolutionary-history" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "evolution-informs-descriptive-psychology", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "species-psychology-shapes-rights" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "moral-guidance-can-reject-evolved-dispositions", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "species-psychology-shapes-rights" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "meaning-and-narrative-challenge-experiential-sums", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "moral-guidance-can-reject-evolved-dispositions" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "remembered-self-broadens-well-being", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "meaning-and-narrative-challenge-experiential-sums" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "purpose-exceeds-remembered-happiness", "speaker": "Jonathan Haidt", "targets": [ "remembered-self-broadens-well-being" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 262, "move_id": "meaning-can-enter-broad-well-being", "speaker": "Sam Harris", "targets": [ "purpose-exceeds-remembered-happiness" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "evolution-evidence-challenges", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "extinction-undercuts-design" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "atheism-predates-darwin", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "atheism-darwin-dependence" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "eye-adaptation-evidence", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "evolution-evidence-challenges" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "scripture-history-evidence-reply", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "design-reaches-architect-only" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "science-self-corrects-and-works", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "evolution-evidence-challenges" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "loss-does-not-explain-origin", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "eye-adaptation-evidence" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "microevolution-scope-limit", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "eye-adaptation-evidence", "science-self-corrects-and-works" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "unfalsifiable-explanation-and-faith", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "specified-complexity-design-inference", "design-reaches-architect-only" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "naturalistic-evil-and-morality", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "god-as-goodness-standard", "atheism-lacks-objective-morality" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "atheism-does-not-fix-politics", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "worldviews-have-moral-consequences" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "human-significance-not-size", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "cosmic-disorder-objection" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "design-limits-preserve-faith", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "unfalsifiable-explanation-and-faith" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "evolved-altruism-blood-example", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "atheism-lacks-objective-morality" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "evolution-moral-mixed-bag", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "naturalistic-evil-and-morality", "evolved-altruism-blood-example" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "biblical-genocide-objection", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "god-as-goodness-standard" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "fallen-world-hard-choices", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "biblical-genocide-objection" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "rebellion-theology-is-nihilistic", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "fallen-world-hard-choices" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "incarnation-solidarity-answer", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "rebellion-theology-is-nihilistic", "theocracy-authoritarian-cost" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "atonement-cannot-remove-responsibility", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "incarnation-solidarity-answer" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "forgiveness-pays-debt-not-history", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "atonement-cannot-remove-responsibility" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "fossil-record-limits-common-descent", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "eye-adaptation-evidence", "science-self-corrects-and-works" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "cosmic-waste-and-god-projection", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "big-bang-theistic-fit", "human-significance-not-size" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "secular-atrocity-parity", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "atheism-does-not-fix-politics", "theocracy-authoritarian-cost" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "mother-teresa-defense", "speaker": "William Dembski", "targets": [ "theocracy-authoritarian-cost" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "mother-teresa-poverty-counter", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "mother-teresa-defense" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "atheism-allows-many-ethics", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "secular-atrocity-parity" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "nazism-not-secular-counter", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "secular-atrocity-parity" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 263, "move_id": "certainty-undermines-inquiry", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "incarnation-solidarity-answer", "forgiveness-pays-debt-not-history" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-purpose-arrives-with-brains", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-organisms-and-cosmic-organization" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-universe-activity-and-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-purpose-arrives-with-brains" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-separates-fine-tuning-question", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-universe-activity-and-fine-tuning" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-evolution-guided-by-awareness", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-separates-fine-tuning-question" ], "score": 54 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-properties-of-parts-and-whole", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-evolution-guided-by-awareness" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-unknowns-support-openness", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-properties-of-parts-and-whole" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-complex-organization-produces-sentience", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-unknowns-support-openness" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-hard-problem-and-cell-awareness", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-complex-organization-produces-sentience" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-cell-responsiveness-does-not-solve-consciousness", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-hard-problem-and-cell-awareness" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-complexity-after-host-interruption", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-hard-problem-and-cell-awareness" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-awareness-versus-perception", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-complexity-after-host-interruption" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-observer-and-incomplete-science", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-part-based-testable-science" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-consciousness-needs-scientific-explanation", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-observer-and-incomplete-science" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-transcendence-as-nondual-knowledge", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-consciousness-needs-scientific-explanation" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-transcendence-from-evolved-brains", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-transcendence-as-nondual-knowledge" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-gratitude-and-deeper-consciousness", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-transcendence-from-evolved-brains" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-admits-mechanism-unknown", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-gratitude-and-deeper-consciousness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-subjective-traditions-challenge", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-admits-mechanism-unknown" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-explain-not-dismiss-mysticism", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-subjective-traditions-challenge" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-promissory-note-objection", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-explain-not-dismiss-mysticism" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-quantum-leaps-and-meaning", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-questions-quantum-evolution-language" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-quantum-equivocation", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-quantum-leaps-and-meaning" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-broad-metaphorical-quantum-use", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-quantum-equivocation" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-metaphor-must-clarify-continuity", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-broad-metaphorical-quantum-use" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "chopra-credentials-and-conscious-usage", "speaker": "Deepak Chopra", "targets": [ "dawkins-metaphor-must-clarify-continuity" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 264, "move_id": "dawkins-faith-and-obscurantism-harms", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "chopra-spiritual-experience-and-wise-science" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "multiple-parameters-have-narrow-life-permitting-ranges", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "theory-level-fine-tuning-reframe" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "value-sensitive-theism-outpredicts-naturalism", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "unknown-naturalistic-likelihood-without-distribution" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "modest-not-overwhelming-confirmation", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "unknown-naturalistic-likelihood-without-distribution" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "theism-must-be-less-fine-tuned-successor", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "modest-not-overwhelming-confirmation" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "future-physics-reduces-but-does-not-erase-confirmation", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "theism-must-be-less-fine-tuned-successor" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "naturalism-does-not-entail-current-physics-package", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "future-physics-reduces-but-does-not-erase-confirmation" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "low-likelihood-disconfirms-only-comparatively", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "observer-selection-does-not-predict-cosmic-low-entropy" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "life-need-not-be-gods-only-purpose", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "observer-selection-does-not-predict-cosmic-low-entropy" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "weighted-average-symmetry-for-both-worldviews", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "life-need-not-be-gods-only-purpose" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "low-entropy-enables-discovery-and-beauty", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "observer-selection-does-not-predict-cosmic-low-entropy" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "discoverability-is-underspecified", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "low-entropy-enables-discovery-and-beauty" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "priors-and-all-evidence-separate-from-local-confirmation", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "weighted-average-symmetry-for-both-worldviews" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "vague-priors-do-not-entail-posterior-ordering", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "priors-and-all-evidence-separate-from-local-confirmation" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "free-parameters-support-counterfactual-variation", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "naturalism-does-not-entail-current-physics-package" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "probability-measure-determines-small-variation", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "free-parameters-support-counterfactual-variation" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "denial-of-infinity-is-a-disjunction-not-one-arbitrary-limit", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "unlimited-attributes-have-coherence-prior" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "local-induction-does-not-require-global-uniformity", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "unlimited-attributes-have-coherence-prior" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "coherence-can-outweigh-global-immodesty", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "local-induction-does-not-require-global-uniformity" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "theism-must-select-biological-and-miracle-details", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "unembodied-designer-does-not-require-physical-fine-tuning" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "three-creation-options-preserve-theistic-prediction", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "theism-must-select-biological-and-miracle-details" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "supernatural-agent-takes-larger-prior-hit", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "unembodied-designer-does-not-require-physical-fine-tuning" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "unconstrained-pivoting-cannot-immunize-naturalism", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "naturalism-is-not-committed-to-a-fine-tuned-multiverse" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "option-count-depends-on-partition-granularity", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "three-creation-options-preserve-theistic-prediction" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "rival-partition-needed-to-lower-biological-life", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "option-count-depends-on-partition-granularity" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "same-auxiliary-move-threatens-disconfirmation-symmetrically", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "unconstrained-pivoting-cannot-immunize-naturalism" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 265, "move_id": "deeper-physics-must-explain-all-fine-tuned-parameters", "speaker": "Miles Donahue", "targets": [ "same-auxiliary-move-threatens-disconfirmation-symmetrically" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-confidence-is-not-method", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-faith-means-trust" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-demonstration-foundational", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-comparative-case-framing" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-shared-rational-confidence", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-confidence-is-not-method" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-reasonable-process-not-enough", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-shared-rational-confidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-focus-on-justified-god-belief", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-reasonable-process-not-enough", "pro-justification-aims-at-truth" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-sufficient-evidence-and-independent-checks", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-focus-on-justified-god-belief" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-formulates-possibility-rule", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-sufficient-evidence-and-independent-checks" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-categorical-possibility-inference", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-formulates-possibility-rule" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-history-tests-demonstration", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-categorical-possibility-inference" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-history-uses-reports-and-corroboration", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-history-tests-demonstration" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-rule-bars-supernatural-belief", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-composite-possibility-requires-known-parts" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-supernatural-lacks-possibility-basis", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-rule-bars-supernatural-belief" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-standard-methods-have-no-extra-rule", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-supernatural-lacks-possibility-basis" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-higgs-is-testable-known-physics", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-standard-methods-have-no-extra-rule" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-higgs-analogy-exposes-catchall", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-higgs-is-testable-known-physics" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-candidate-versus-acceptance", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-higgs-analogy-exposes-catchall" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-cern-and-theism-use-likelihoods", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-higgs-is-testable-known-physics" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-supernatural-has-no-confirmed-kind", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-cern-and-theism-use-likelihoods" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-absence-is-not-violation", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-supernatural-has-no-confirmed-kind" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-natural-reference-class-clarification", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-absence-is-not-violation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-science-allows-radical-novelty", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-natural-reference-class-clarification" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-unknown-cause-does-not-license-god", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-science-allows-radical-novelty" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-bayes-treats-theism-like-higgs", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-unknown-cause-does-not-license-god" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-likelihood-fit-cannot-create-candidate", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-bayes-treats-theism-like-higgs" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-bayes-misapplied-to-cosmic-supernatural", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-bayes-treats-theism-like-higgs" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-low-prior-absorbs-ad-hocness", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-likelihood-fit-cannot-create-candidate", "pro-bayes-misapplied-to-cosmic-supernatural" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-supernatural-priors-need-investigation", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-low-prior-absorbs-ad-hocness" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-priors-update-toward-truth", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-bayes-misapplied-to-cosmic-supernatural" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-science-converges-on-public-evidence", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-priors-update-toward-truth" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-fine-tuning-as-likelihood-evidence", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-science-converges-on-public-evidence" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-fine-tuning-needs-alternative-possibility", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-fine-tuning-as-likelihood-evidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "con-physicists-recognize-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuning-needs-alternative-possibility" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 266, "move_id": "pro-appearance-and-anthropic-fit", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-physicists-recognize-fine-tuning" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-macro-and-micro-marvels-compatible", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-natural-world-sustains-awe" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-intention-makes-cosmos-artistry", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-natural-world-sustains-awe" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-accountability-extents-question", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-human-responsibility-without-just-god" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-divine-command-can-license-killing", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-accountability-extents-question" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-naturalism-unmoved-by-amalekites", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-divine-command-can-license-killing" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-victim-perspective-and-present-danger", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-naturalism-unmoved-by-amalekites" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-gerasene-story-is-not-beautiful", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-macro-and-micro-marvels-compatible" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-gerasene-story-has-spiritual-meaning", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-gerasene-story-is-not-beautiful" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-christianity-displaced-demonism", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-pattern-seeking-produces-symbols" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-contemporary-christian-witchcraft-counterexample", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-christianity-displaced-demonism" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-rival-miracles-discrimination-problem", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-gerasene-story-has-spiritual-meaning" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-counterfeits-do-not-negate-genuine", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-rival-miracles-discrimination-problem" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-hume-comparative-probability", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-counterfeits-do-not-negate-genuine" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "wilson-ancients-knew-ordinary-natural-course", "speaker": "Douglas Wilson", "targets": [ "hitchens-hume-comparative-probability" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 267, "move_id": "hitchens-virgin-birth-is-recurring-religious-pattern", "speaker": "Christopher Hitchens", "targets": [ "wilson-ancients-knew-ordinary-natural-course", "wilson-counterfeits-do-not-negate-genuine" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-purpose-questions-limited", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-science-compatible-roles" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-meaning-outside-system", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-purpose-questions-limited" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-football-does-not-establish-cosmic-purpose", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-meaning-outside-system" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-creation-from-love", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-football-does-not-establish-cosmic-purpose" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-creator-is-presupposed", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-creation-from-love" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-red-sea-science-and-story-purpose", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-literalism-and-test-cases" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-asks-for-classification-rule", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-red-sea-science-and-story-purpose" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-scientific-incompatibility-rule", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-asks-for-classification-rule" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-ordeal-was-unnecessary", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-child-sacrifice-polemic" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-dramatic-reversal-made-lesson-effective", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-ordeal-was-unnecessary" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-story-remains-child-abuse", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-dramatic-reversal-made-lesson-effective" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-agrees-ordeal-is-abuse-under-other-reading", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-story-remains-child-abuse" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-asks-to-inspect-charity-measure", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-putnam-community-evidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-charity-covers-religious-and-secular-causes", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-asks-to-inspect-charity-measure" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-community-mechanism-is-plausible", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-putnam-community-evidence" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-religion-has-not-disappeared", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-secular-community-substitute" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "dawkins-history-trends-secular", "speaker": "Richard Dawkins", "targets": [ "sacks-religion-has-not-disappeared" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 268, "move_id": "sacks-transcendence-supports-dignity-and-hope", "speaker": "Jonathan Sacks", "targets": [ "dawkins-moral-common-ground-with-supernatural-divide" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-incomplete-physics-deductive-route", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-global-observational-underdetermination" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-modus-tollens-causal-principle", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-material-principle-parity" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-fundamental-interactions-and-events", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-causation-physically-explained" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-design-does-not-establish-total-cause", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-physical-order-design-inference" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-first-cause-could-be-physical", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-dependent-regress-first-cause", "loke-first-cause-libertarian-agency" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-timeless-models-ground-time", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-fundamental-interactions-and-events" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-causal-interaction-asymmetry-reply", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-fundamental-interactions-and-events" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-agency-without-deliberation", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-first-cause-could-be-physical" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-designer-causes-ordered-state", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-design-does-not-establish-total-cause" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-impersonal-nonmetric-instability", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-first-cause-could-be-physical" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-events-remain-temporal-in-reduced-theories", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-timeless-models-ground-time" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-efficient-cause-breaks-material-symmetry", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-material-principle-parity" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-malament-manchak-global-structure", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-incomplete-physics-deductive-route" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-future-induction-analogy", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-malament-manchak-global-structure" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-abc-relations-not-fundamental", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-events-remain-temporal-in-reduced-theories" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-events-all-the-way-down", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-abc-relations-not-fundamental" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-nonmetric-extension-challenge", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-nonmetric-past-alternative" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-nonmetric-has-no-length", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-nonmetric-extension-challenge" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-withholding-without-metric-objection", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-impersonal-nonmetric-instability" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-personal-control-over-disposition", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-first-cause-could-be-physical", "linford-nonmetric-has-no-length", "linford-withholding-without-metric-objection" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-material-principle-independent-support", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-efficient-cause-breaks-material-symmetry" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-material-parallel-still-lacks-differentiator", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-material-principle-independent-support" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-reasons-without-efficient-causes", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-material-parallel-still-lacks-differentiator" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-material-only-transformation-parallel", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-efficient-cause-breaks-material-symmetry", "loke-material-parallel-still-lacks-differentiator" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "loke-causal-principle-covers-any-cause", "speaker": "Andrew Loke", "targets": [ "linford-material-only-transformation-parallel" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 269, "move_id": "linford-parity-consequence-for-totality", "speaker": "Daniel Linford", "targets": [ "loke-causal-principle-covers-any-cause" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-good-god-evil-fruit", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-nonliteral-and-conquest-language" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-evil-compatible-with-greater-good", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-suffering-prayer-and-need" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-nonbelief-preserves-freedom", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-debate-as-hiddenness-evidence" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-bible-genres-and-amalekite-survival", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-good-god-evil-fruit" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-evil-language-and-compensation", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-good-god-evil-fruit" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-corrupt-doctor-church-analogy", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-church-abuse-against-revelation" ], "score": 59 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-resurrection-textual-conflict", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-grief-and-natural-alternative", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-power-physical-contradiction", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-change-pure-actuality" ], "score": 52 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-explanation-reversal-to-god", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-contingency-necessary-being" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-scientific-testability-and-prayer", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-philosophical-question-framing" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-quantum-something-from-nothing", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-finite-past-first-cause" ], "score": 53 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-resurrection-core-and-early-origin", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-resurrection-textual-conflict" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-quantum-and-actuality-clarification", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-power-physical-contradiction", "barker-explanation-reversal-to-god", "barker-quantum-something-from-nothing" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-church-analogy-inapt", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-corrupt-doctor-church-analogy" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-ra-and-israelite-parity", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-evil-language-and-compensation" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-locomotive-energy-and-physical-effect", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-quantum-and-actuality-clarification" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-prayer-envelope-test", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-nonbelief-preserves-freedom" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-genocide-goodness-crosscheck", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-bible-genres-and-amalekite-survival", "horn-evil-language-and-compensation" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-scripture-alternatives-and-life-authority", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-good-god-evil-fruit", "barker-genocide-goodness-crosscheck" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-objective-harm-and-job-test", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-moral-commands-require-person", "horn-natural-law-universal-facts" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "horn-paul-groups-and-empty-tomb-closing", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "barker-resurrection-textual-conflict", "barker-grief-and-natural-alternative" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-women-and-tomb-conflicts-closing", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-resurrection-core-and-early-origin", "horn-paul-groups-and-empty-tomb-closing" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 270, "move_id": "barker-appearance-as-vision-closing", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "horn-paul-groups-and-empty-tomb-closing" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-insists-on-christian-specificity", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-defines-cumulative-christian-hypothesis" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-natural-origin-and-nonuniqueness", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-finite-past-and-causal-universe", "craig-personal-timeless-cause" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-complexity-natural-and-god-neutral", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-fine-tuning-trilemma" ], "score": 57 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-local-objective-morality", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-objective-values-require-god" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-resurrection-source-and-natural-alternatives", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-three-resurrection-facts" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-extraordinary-evidence-and-comparative-sightings", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-three-resurrection-facts" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-neurological-alternative-to-religious-experience", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-immediate-experience-as-knowledge" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-cumulative-route-and-neutrality-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-insists-on-christian-specificity" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-evolution-describes-not-prescribes", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-local-objective-morality", "pigliucci-biblical-morality-challenge" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-gospels-and-resurrection-not-pagan-myth", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-resurrection-source-and-natural-alternatives" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-reburial-hallucination-and-origin-replies", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-resurrection-source-and-natural-alternatives", "pigliucci-extraordinary-evidence-and-comparative-sightings" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-induced-experience-needs-independent-defeater", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-neurological-alternative-to-religious-experience" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-regress-quantum-and-ignorance-reply", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-finite-past-and-causal-universe", "craig-personal-timeless-cause" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-fine-tuning-probability-and-gap", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-fine-tuning-trilemma" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-adaptation-is-real-and-goodness-dilemma", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-evolution-describes-not-prescribes" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-limits-falsifiability-and-positive-atheist-burden", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-cumulative-route-and-neutrality-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-mythology-and-gospel-question-begging", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-gospels-and-resurrection-not-pagan-myth" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-symmetric-burden-for-nonexistence", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-limits-falsifiability-and-positive-atheist-burden" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-quantum-vacuum-and-uncaused-god-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-regress-quantum-and-ignorance-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-law-or-chance-still-unshown", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-fine-tuning-probability-and-gap" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-sanctions-do-not-make-wrongness", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-adaptation-is-real-and-goodness-dilemma" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-scholarship-uniqueness-and-jewish-context", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-mythology-and-gospel-question-begging" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-brain-mediation-does-not-defeat-veridicality", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-neurological-alternative-to-religious-experience" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-rational-nonbelief-without-impossibility-proof", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-symmetric-burden-for-nonexistence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-quantum-causality-remains-uncertain", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-quantum-vacuum-and-uncaused-god-reply" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-simpler-hallucination-explanation", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-induced-experience-needs-independent-defeater", "craig-brain-mediation-does-not-defeat-veridicality" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-adaptation-suffices-and-good-independent", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-sanctions-do-not-make-wrongness" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-absence-evidence-expectation-test", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-rational-nonbelief-without-impossibility-proof" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "craig-divine-nature-identifies-the-good", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "pigliucci-adaptation-suffices-and-good-independent" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 271, "move_id": "pigliucci-miracles-violate-laws-and-face-rivals", "speaker": "Massimo Pigliucci", "targets": [ "craig-scholarship-uniqueness-and-jewish-context", "craig-absence-evidence-expectation-test" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-motion-scope-is-generic-theism", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-suffering-and-nonconsent" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-evidence-can-raise-multiple-hypotheses", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-underdetermined-observations" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-scope-simplicity-and-plausibility", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-natural-alternative-models", "con-unknown-natural-parity" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-pantheist-model-equal-scope", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-scope-simplicity-and-plausibility" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-theistic-model-variation", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-moral-goodness-predicts-arena", "pro-atheistic-factor-product" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-rarity-does-not-show-design", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-life-permitting-cosmic-conditions" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-equal-explanation-not-god-specific", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-evidence-can-raise-multiple-hypotheses" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-information-does-not-require-agent", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-biological-information-rarity" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-priors-need-empirical-basis", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-bayesian-likelihood-framework", "pro-atheistic-factor-product" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-design-is-positive-causal-inference", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-information-does-not-require-agent" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-embodiment-expands-moral-opportunity", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-theistic-model-variation" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-positive-framing-still-underdetermined", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-design-is-positive-causal-inference" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-nonembodied-agents-not-excluded", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-embodiment-expands-moral-opportunity" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-biological-meaning-physically-constrained", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-design-is-positive-causal-inference" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-functional-target-selection", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-biological-meaning-physically-constrained" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-no-bridge-from-rarity-to-intelligence", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-functional-target-selection" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-morally-perfect-model-specified", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-theistic-model-variation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-property-x-parity", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-morally-perfect-model-specified" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-higher-law-moves-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-natural-alternative-models" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-necessary-law-parity", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-higher-law-moves-fine-tuning" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-prediction-discriminates-models", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-scope-simplicity-and-plausibility" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-current-best-explanation-over-future-gap", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-unknown-natural-parity" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "pro-design-detection-by-specification", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-no-bridge-from-rarity-to-intelligence" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 272, "move_id": "con-eternal-natural-ground-can-change", "speaker": "Tom Jump", "targets": [ "pro-necessary-being-stops-regress" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-hiddenness-saving-relationship", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-reasonable-nonbelief" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-theism-and-science", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-naturalistic-science-success" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-interactionist-mind", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-brain-dependence" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-evolution-efficiency-and-improbability", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-evolutionary-waste" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-skeptical-theism-and-reassurance", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-pointless-suffering" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-big-bang-underdetermination", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-universe-beginning-cause" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-fine-tuning-open-physics", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-fine-tuning-design" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-timeless-causation-mystery", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-contingency-explanation", "craig-universe-beginning-cause" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-moral-worth-without-god", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-objective-morality-ground" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-resurrection-source-challenge", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-experience-veridicality", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-immediate-experience" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-origin-and-simultaneous-cause", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-big-bang-underdetermination", "dacey-timeless-causation-mystery" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-fine-tuning-persists", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-fine-tuning-open-physics" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-divine-nature-moral-ground", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-moral-worth-without-god" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-resurrection-alternative-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-resurrection-source-challenge" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-personal-cause-explanatory-gap", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-origin-and-simultaneous-cause", "craig-contingency-explanation" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-intention-attribution-symmetry", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-hiddenness-saving-relationship" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-revelation-opportunity-above-zero", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-hiddenness-saving-relationship" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-science-method-reply", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-theism-and-science" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-dependent-nonreductive-mind", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-interactionist-mind" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-evolution-function-and-probability", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-evolution-efficiency-and-improbability" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-closing-methodological-naturalism", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-science-method-reply" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-closing-mind-causation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-dependent-nonreductive-mind" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-closing-evolution-inference", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-evolution-function-and-probability" ], "score": 54 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-closing-necessary-explanation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-personal-cause-explanatory-gap" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "craig-closing-resurrection-and-experience", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "dacey-resurrection-source-challenge", "dacey-experience-veridicality" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-closing-hiddenness-love", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-hiddenness-saving-relationship" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-closing-evolution-lottery", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-closing-evolution-inference" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-closing-compensation-not-justification", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-skeptical-theism-and-reassurance" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-closing-resurrection-uncertainty", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-resurrection-alternative-reply" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 273, "move_id": "dacey-closing-abandoned-deity-and-costs", "speaker": "Austin Dacey", "targets": [ "craig-closing-resurrection-and-experience", "craig-skeptical-theism-and-reassurance" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-suffering-does-not-entail-nonexistence", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-unanswered-prayer-disconfirmation", "con-incompatible-divine-attributes" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-biblical-clarity-defense", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-revelation-clarity-objection" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-biblical-specificity-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-impossibility-of-contrary", "pro-transcendental-syllogism" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-scripture-supplies-theology", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-biblical-specificity-challenge" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-romans-one-nonneutrality", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-biblical-specificity-challenge" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-lack-belief-burden-distinction", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-romans-one-nonneutrality" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-logic-borrowing-challenge", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-incompatible-divine-attributes" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-biblical-logic-source-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-logic-borrowing-challenge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-logic-as-mental-tool", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-divine-attributes-ground-knowledge", "pro-logic-borrowing-challenge" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-divine-omniscience-supplies-moral-context", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-biblical-injustice-examples" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-public-revelation-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-scripture-supplies-theology" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-internal-witness-and-justification", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-public-revelation-challenge" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-authority-circularity-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-internal-witness-and-justification" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-ultimate-foundation-circularity", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-authority-circularity-challenge" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-rival-revelation-test", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-internal-witness-and-justification", "pro-ultimate-foundation-circularity" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-rival-revelation-coherence-test", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-rival-revelation-test" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-possible-reconciliation-blocks-contradiction", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-incompatible-divine-attributes" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-interpretive-plurality-cost", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-possible-reconciliation-blocks-contradiction" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-prayer-will-condition", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-unanswered-prayer-disconfirmation" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-will-qualification-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-prayer-will-condition" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-miracle-studies-would-not-resolve-worldview", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-unanswered-prayer-disconfirmation" ], "score": 50 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-miracle-evidence-could-change-mind", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-miracle-studies-would-not-resolve-worldview" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-harm-standard-authority-challenge", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-harm-minimization-standard", "con-overall-harm-account" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-harm-effects-objectivity", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-harm-standard-authority-challenge" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-divine-judgment-context", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-canaanite-parity-objection" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-biblical-indications-of-logic", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-biblical-logic-source-challenge" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "con-rival-hindu-grounding", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-trinity-grounds-one-and-many", "pro-biblical-indications-of-logic" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 274, "move_id": "pro-hindu-unity-undermines-distinctions", "speaker": "Eli Ayala", "targets": [ "con-rival-hindu-grounding" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "knowledge-of-god-purpose-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evidential-evil-formal-chain" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "rebellion-explains-moral-evil", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "suffering-hiddenness-and-hypothetical-revelation-evils" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "eternal-life-outweighs-temporal-suffering", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evidential-evil-formal-chain" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "logical-probability-framework-challenge", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "unknown-properties-probability-theorem" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "agent-relative-divine-permission", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evidential-evil-formal-chain" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "badness-versus-wrongness-context", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evidential-evil-formal-chain", "unknown-properties-probability-theorem" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "divine-permission-circularity-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evidential-evil-formal-chain" ], "score": 61 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "hiddenness-scripture-and-hell-replies", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "suffering-hiddenness-and-hypothetical-revelation-evils" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "creator-not-perfect-god-gap", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "origin-beginning-personal-cause", "fine-tuning-design-inference" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "equal-priors-good-indifferent-evil", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-design-inference" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "resurrection-supernatural-agent-gap", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "resurrection-historical-case" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "religious-experience-disagreement-and-correlation", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "personal-experience-basic-knowledge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "nontheological-moral-realism-burden", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "objective-morality-requires-god" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "minimal-creator-cumulative-case", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "creator-not-perfect-god-gap", "equal-priors-good-indifferent-evil" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "ignorance-is-not-equiprobability", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "equal-priors-good-indifferent-evil" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "moral-realism-needs-explanatory-ground", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "nontheological-moral-realism-burden" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "resurrection-identifies-god-of-israel", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "resurrection-supernatural-agent-gap" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "experience-rational-unless-defeated", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "religious-experience-disagreement-and-correlation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "necessary-moral-truths-without-god", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "objective-morality-requires-god", "moral-realism-needs-explanatory-ground" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "divine-command-exempts-god-objection", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "agent-relative-divine-permission", "divine-permission-circularity-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "yahweh-character-undercuts-resurrection-identity", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "resurrection-identifies-god-of-israel" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "jesus-beliefs-character-undercut-vindication", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "resurrection-identifies-god-of-israel" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "temporal-entry-compatible-with-necessity", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "necessary-person-ontological-contradiction", "necessary-moral-truths-without-god" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "divine-nature-constrains-commands", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "divine-command-exempts-god-objection" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "perfect-goodness-definition-shift-closing", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "minimal-creator-cumulative-case" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "equiprobability-defends-induction-closing", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "logical-probability-framework-challenge", "ignorance-is-not-equiprobability" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "uncaused-eternal-ground-answer", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "origin-beginning-personal-cause" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "unrestricted-causation-applies-to-god", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "uncaused-eternal-ground-answer" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "actual-infinity-subtraction-reply", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "origin-beginning-personal-cause" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "good-does-not-offset-apparent-evil-inference", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "badness-versus-wrongness-context" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "haiti-salvific-purpose-example", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "good-does-not-offset-apparent-evil-inference" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "modern-miracle-and-legend-growth-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "resurrection-historical-case", "resurrection-identifies-god-of-israel" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "foreknowledge-backward-causation-objection", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "foreknowledge-does-not-entail-fatalism" ], "score": 59 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "eternal-hell-goodness-objection", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "hiddenness-scripture-and-hell-replies" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 275, "move_id": "robust-bayesian-alternative-final-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "equiprobability-defends-induction-closing" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-divine-command-does-not-make-morality-objective", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-worldviews-must-accommodate-moral-facts" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-moral-knowledge-begins-from-basic-recognition", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-divine-command-does-not-make-morality-objective" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-unnecessary-harm-as-moral-criterion", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-moral-knowledge-begins-from-basic-recognition" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-perfect-god-and-violent-bible-diverge", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-stoning-and-genocide-require-reinterpretation" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-bible-is-a-diverse-ancient-anthology", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-perfect-god-and-violent-bible-diverge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-folklore-and-competing-versions-undermine-reverence", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-bible-is-a-diverse-ancient-anthology" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-distinct-genres-resist-single-folklore-label", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-folklore-and-competing-versions-undermine-reverence" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-cultural-development-lacks-factual-accuracy", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-distinct-genres-resist-single-folklore-label" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-factual-failures-undermine-trust", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-jesus-and-love-govern-interpretation" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-historical-error-does-not-entail-total-unreliability", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-jesus-medical-ignorance-undermines-authority" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-sheep-and-goats-centers-conduct", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-judgment-by-belief-is-morally-arbitrary" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-unforgivable-sin-concerns-willful-rejection-of-present-truth", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-judgment-by-belief-is-morally-arbitrary" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-submission-and-finality-make-judgment-unjust", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-unforgivable-sin-concerns-willful-rejection-of-present-truth" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-judgment-tracks-available-light-and-chosen-alienation", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-judgment-by-belief-is-morally-arbitrary", "con-submission-and-finality-make-judgment-unjust" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-truth-seekers-are-not-willful-rejecters", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-judgment-tracks-available-light-and-chosen-alienation" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-private-conscious-states-defeat-public-verification-rule", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-evidence-must-indicate-or-uniquely-fit" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-fallibility-and-proportional-evidence", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-private-conscious-states-defeat-public-verification-rule" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-external-world-skepticism-shows-rule-is-overstrong", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-evidence-must-indicate-or-uniquely-fit", "con-fallibility-and-proportional-evidence" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-objective-means-independently-corroborable", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-private-conscious-states-defeat-public-verification-rule" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-system-internal-evidence-still-tests-biblical-claims", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-external-world-skepticism-shows-rule-is-overstrong" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-skeptical-scenario-targets-criterion-not-evidence", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-system-internal-evidence-still-tests-biblical-claims" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-noah-reference-treats-disputed-story-as-event", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-distinct-genres-resist-single-folklore-label" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-literary-allusion-does-not-require-historical-endorsement", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-noah-reference-treats-disputed-story-as-event" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "pro-salvation-is-reconciliation-with-inclusivist-room", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-truth-seekers-are-not-willful-rejecters" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-divergent-salvation-readings-undermine-clarity", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-salvation-is-reconciliation-with-inclusivist-room" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 276, "move_id": "con-mind-independent-reality-is-unavoidable-practical-ground", "speaker": "Aron Ra", "targets": [ "pro-external-world-skepticism-shows-rule-is-overstrong", "pro-skeptical-scenario-targets-criterion-not-evidence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-moral-reality-sounds-theological", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-fallibilist-moral-realism", "shermer-reasons-without-divine-middleman" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-christianity-followed-abolition", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-christian-building-blocks-of-rights" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-equal-worth-scope-challenge", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-interchangeable-moral-perspectives" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-autonomy-blocks-sacrifice", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-equal-worth-scope-challenge" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-eighteenth-century-rights-revolution", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-equal-worth-scope-challenge" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-gregorian-rights-genealogy", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-eighteenth-century-rights-revolution" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-theological-authority-for-equal-rights", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-eighteenth-century-rights-revolution" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-franklin-rational-foundation", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-theological-authority-for-equal-rights" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-obligation-to-enforceable-right", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-franklin-rational-foundation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-reasoning-versus-revelation-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-obligation-to-enforceable-right" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-image-of-god-and-universal-family", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-reasoning-versus-revelation-challenge" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-promises-harm-and-reciprocity", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-post-christian-values-detached" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-galatians-context-limits-rights-reading", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-image-of-god-and-universal-family" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-cultural-source-of-individualism", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-equal-worth-scope-challenge" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-science-mirrors-politics", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-cultural-source-of-individualism" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-reason-constrains-special-pleading", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-science-mirrors-politics" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-prosocial-morality-concession-and-limit", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-evolved-genuine-altruism", "shermer-species-relative-universality" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-birthrights-enforcement-and-human-preference", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-equal-worth-scope-challenge" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "shermer-jesus-texts-contextual-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "scrivener-image-of-god-and-universal-family" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 277, "move_id": "scrivener-incarnation-grounds-common-humanity", "speaker": "Glen Scrivener", "targets": [ "shermer-jesus-texts-contextual-challenge" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-atheism-removes-hope-and-moral-ground", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-preventable-suffering-evidential-evil" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-atheism-allows-morality-and-afterlife", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-atheism-removes-hope-and-moral-ground" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-hell-worsens-consolation", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-atheism-removes-hope-and-moral-ground" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-cross-shares-suffering", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-hell-worsens-consolation", "tooley-preventable-suffering-evidential-evil" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-free-will-permits-moral-evil", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-preventable-suffering-evidential-evil" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-hell-as-informed-rejection", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-hell-worsens-consolation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-limited-harm-preserves-freedom", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-free-will-permits-moral-evil" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-final-judgment-time-limit", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-hell-as-informed-rejection" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-science-targets-christian-claims", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-scientists-share-science-not-worldview" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-common-descent-evidence", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-scientists-share-science-not-worldview" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-flood-and-sun-evidence", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-christian-history-and-free-forgiveness" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-return-prediction-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-christian-history-and-free-forgiveness" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-transfiguration-fulfills-kingdom-saying", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-return-prediction-challenge" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-two-strands-of-eschatological-timing", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-return-prediction-challenge" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-generation-texts-reinforce-imminence", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-transfiguration-fulfills-kingdom-saying" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-generation-means-kind-reply", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-generation-texts-reinforce-imminence" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-christian-moral-doctrine-objections", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-christian-history-and-free-forgiveness", "lennox-hell-as-informed-rejection" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-final-justice-and-resurrection-trust", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-preventable-suffering-evidential-evil", "tooley-limited-harm-preserves-freedom" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-possession-testimony-is-anecdotal", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-possession-claims-are-testable" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-simplicity-favors-reductive-history", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-eternal-ultimate-reality" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-complex-mind-can-explain-book", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-simplicity-favors-reductive-history" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-substitutionary-punishment-analogy", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-cross-shares-suffering", "lennox-christian-history-and-free-forgiveness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-composite-noah-and-miracle-reliability", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-christian-history-and-free-forgiveness" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "lennox-sources-and-literary-genre", "speaker": "John Lennox", "targets": [ "tooley-composite-noah-and-miracle-reliability" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 278, "move_id": "tooley-necessary-ethical-truths", "speaker": "Michael Tooley", "targets": [ "lennox-created-meaning-versus-ultimate-meaning", "lennox-atheism-removes-hope-and-moral-ground" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-god-attributes-definition", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-affirmative-burden-nonbelief" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-naturalism-reasoning-and-free-will", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-divine-foreknowledge-free-will-incompatibility" ], "score": 53 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-evil-requires-moral-standard", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-suffering-against-good-god" ], "score": 54 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-free-will-objection-redirected", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-divine-foreknowledge-free-will-incompatibility" ], "score": 45 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-personal-cause-restated", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-affirmative-burden-nonbelief" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-moral-value-not-preference", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-suffering-against-good-god" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-harm-principle-and-scripture-counterexample", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-objective-moral-ground", "slick-moral-value-not-preference" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-divine-not-human-free-will", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-naturalism-reasoning-and-free-will", "slick-free-will-objection-redirected" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-logic-reification-objection", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-logic-mind-dependence", "slick-logic-universality-christian-ground" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-causation-category-boundary", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-personal-first-cause", "slick-personal-cause-restated" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-divine-mental-sequence-regress", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-personal-first-cause" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-fine-tuning-design-answer", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-affirmative-burden-nonbelief" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-fine-tuning-natural-alternative", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-fine-tuning-design-answer" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-evidence-welcome-observation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-affirmative-burden-transcendent-evidence" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-scientism-self-validation-reply", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-evidence-welcome-observation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-command-theory-and-harm-definition", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-morality-grounded-in-divine-nature" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-laws-of-logic-propositional-status", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-logic-reification-objection" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-concepts-as-brain-models", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-laws-of-logic-propositional-status" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-evolutionary-altruism", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-objective-moral-ground" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-self-sacrifice-gene-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-evolutionary-altruism" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-own-actions-foreknowledge-correction", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-human-foreknowledge-analogy" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-harm-as-practical-compass", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-moral-value-not-preference" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-harm-standard-justification-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-harm-as-practical-compass" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-private-experience-not-public-proof", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-evidence-welcome-observation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-religious-experience-rival-explanation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-private-experience-not-public-proof" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-unanswered-prayer-asymmetry", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-observable-evidence-and-prayer", "barker-suffering-against-good-god" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-prayer-failure-limited-conclusion", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-unanswered-prayer-asymmetry" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-prayer-studies-and-compassion", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-unanswered-prayer-asymmetry" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-prayer-agency-and-christian-motivation", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-prayer-studies-and-compassion" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "slick-closing-logic-distinction", "speaker": "Matt Slick", "targets": [ "barker-logic-reification-objection", "barker-concepts-as-brain-models" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-closing-natural-explanations-first", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-affirmative-burden-transcendent-evidence", "slick-personal-first-cause" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-closing-nothing-from-nothing-reversal", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-personal-first-cause" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 279, "move_id": "barker-closing-propositions-natural-minds", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "slick-laws-of-logic-propositional-status", "slick-closing-logic-distinction" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-observer-selection", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-design" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-evolved-morality", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-objective-good" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-martyr-sincerity", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-natural-miracles" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-ontology-not-behavior", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-evolved-morality" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-origin-not-truth", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-natural-miracles" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-materialism-reason", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-science-tests" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-case-by-case", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-natural-miracles" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-causal-inconsistency", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-beginner" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-empathy", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-ontology-not-behavior" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-demonstrable-miracle", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-case-by-case" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-literary-details", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-resurrection-case" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-apocalyptic-jesus", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-redemption" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-myth-history", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-history-method" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-moral-author", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-empathy" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-cosmic-uncertainty", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-beginner" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-timeless-cause", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-causal-inconsistency" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "c-brain-probability", "speaker": "Dennis Nørmark", "targets": [ "p-origin-not-truth" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-free-will", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-mind-brain" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 280, "move_id": "p-closing", "speaker": "Frank Turek", "targets": [ "c-natural-miracles", "c-mind-brain" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "mundane-accuracy-does-not-transfer", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "luke-acts-author-access-through-paul" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "proclamation-is-not-the-event", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "early-creed-and-appearance-proclamation", "acts-transmits-early-jerusalem-preaching" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "group-pressure-and-martyrdom-limit", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "apostolic-conduct-supports-sincerity" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "comparative-bayesian-fit", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "supernatural-cause-needs-independent-demonstration" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "multiple-natural-explanations-need-not-unify", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "naturalistic-rivals-face-specific-problems" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "unsupported-drug-story-is-not-an-answer", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "naturalistic-rivals-face-specific-problems" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "plausible-rival-would-defeat-comparative-case", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "multiple-natural-explanations-need-not-unify", "unsupported-drug-story-is-not-an-answer" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "resurrection-probability-is-not-calculable", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "comparative-bayesian-fit" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "bayesian-probability-does-not-require-repeat-cases", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "resurrection-probability-is-not-calculable" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "appearance-cessation-distinguishes-resurrection-reports", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "multiple-natural-explanations-need-not-unify" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "early-sources-do-not-require-gospel-reliability", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "sources-fall-short-of-historical-ideals", "narrative-development-supports-legend" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "historical-and-philosophical-beliefs-remain-assessable", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "resurrection-probability-is-not-calculable" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "unconstrained-divine-accommodation-reduces-explanatory-force", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "comparative-bayesian-fit" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "free-love-response-to-hiddenness", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "divine-hiddenness-from-unanswered-search" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "closing-doubt-and-theological-costs", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "background-probability-and-divine-purpose", "free-love-response-to-hiddenness" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 281, "move_id": "methodological-naturalism-as-limited-heuristic", "speaker": "Blake Giunta", "targets": [ "supernatural-cause-needs-independent-demonstration", "resurrection-probability-is-not-calculable" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "religious-diversity-no-criterion", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "personal-experience-immediate-warrant" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "secular-moral-truth-makers", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "objective-moral-values-argument" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "euthyphro-autonomy-objection", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "objective-moral-values-argument" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "physics-over-apriori-cosmology", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "actual-infinite-past-objection" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "cause-needs-independent-content", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "cause-syllogism-personal-mind" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "fine-tuning-probability-space-objection", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-trilemma" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "testable-multiverse-alternative", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "multiverse-objections-design-conclusion" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "dismissal-and-kant-antithesis-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "physics-over-apriori-cosmology" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "deductive-cause-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "cause-needs-independent-content" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "local-fly-analogy-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-probability-space-objection" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "multiverse-evidence-small-world-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "testable-multiverse-alternative" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "divine-nature-not-voluntarism", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "secular-moral-truth-makers", "euthyphro-autonomy-objection" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "experience-defeater-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "religious-diversity-no-criterion" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "kant-method-clarification", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "dismissal-and-kant-antithesis-reply" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "source-transmission-fourfold-alternatives", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "three-facts-resurrection-inference" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "ganesh-comparative-evidence", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "three-facts-resurrection-inference" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "historical-criteria-support-facts", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "source-transmission-fourfold-alternatives" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "jewish-context-vindication", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "source-transmission-fourfold-alternatives" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "ganesh-context-jewish-unexpectedness", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "ganesh-comparative-evidence" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "naturalistic-causal-models", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "deductive-cause-reply" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "naturalist-track-record", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "historical-criteria-support-facts" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "emmaus-myth-development", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "historical-criteria-support-facts", "jewish-context-vindication" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "personal-explanation-first-state", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "naturalistic-causal-models" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "singularity-needs-explanation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "naturalistic-causal-models" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "resurrection-uniqueness-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "naturalist-track-record" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "jewish-expectation-emmaus-answer", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "emmaus-myth-development" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "timeless-person-concept-objection", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "personal-explanation-first-state" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "smith-model-clarification", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "singularity-needs-explanation" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "hume-testimony-update-qualification", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "resurrection-uniqueness-reply" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "criterion-remains-unanswered", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "experience-defeater-reply" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "martyrdom-sincerity-not-truth", "speaker": "Andrew Pyle", "targets": [ "jewish-expectation-emmaus-answer" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 282, "move_id": "other-religions-defeasible-entitlement", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "criterion-remains-unanswered" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-universe-beginning-transcendent-cause", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-hawking-conditional-singularity-quotation" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-hawking-imaginary-time-reply", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-hawking-conditional-singularity-quotation" ], "score": 51 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-gaps-and-current-cosmology-rebuttal", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-universe-beginning-transcendent-cause", "pro-hawking-imaginary-time-reply" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-multiverse-selection-fine-tuning", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuned-constants" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-resurrection-sources-and-alternatives", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-four-facts-and-explanation" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-intelligence-best-explanation", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-gaps-and-current-cosmology-rebuttal" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-resurrection-claims-and-history-standards", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-resurrection-sources-and-alternatives" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-quantum-cosmos-qualified-alternative", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-universe-beginning-transcendent-cause", "pro-fine-tuned-constants" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-empirical-multiverse-and-certainty-challenge", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-quantum-cosmos-qualified-alternative" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-designer-complexity-regress", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-intelligence-best-explanation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-fine-tuner-origin-separate-question", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-designer-complexity-regress" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-begging-question-complexity-reply", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuner-origin-separate-question" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-explanation-need-not-explain-explainer", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-begging-question-complexity-reply" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-genesis-as-parable-not-history", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-compatible-with-creation" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-adam-as-moral-humanity-interpretation", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-genesis-as-parable-not-history" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-immaterial-infinity-answer", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-bounded-infinity-cosmos-answer" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-suffering-character-not-existence", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-suffering-prayer-and-benevolence" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-suffering-targets-good-christian-god", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-suffering-character-not-existence" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-legend-preferred-over-hallucination", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-four-facts-and-explanation", "pro-resurrection-claims-and-history-standards" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-original-witness-martyr-distinction", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-legend-preferred-over-hallucination" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-martyrdom-does-not-establish-truth", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-original-witness-martyr-distinction" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-origin-of-faith-needs-event", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-martyrdom-does-not-establish-truth" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-historical-founder-plus-legend", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-origin-of-faith-needs-event" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-near-death-consciousness-evidence", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-brain-dependence-and-finite-life" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "con-near-death-is-not-after-death", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-near-death-consciousness-evidence" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-dying-brain-recovery-challenge", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-near-death-is-not-after-death" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-costly-altruism-beyond-self-interest", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-goodness-without-reward-or-threat" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-jesus-teachings-beneficial-reply", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-jesus-moral-teachings-critique" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 283, "move_id": "pro-human-gap-incarnation-and-salvation", "speaker": "Dinesh D'Souza", "targets": [ "con-salvation-created-problem" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-naturalistic-comparison-standard", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-positive-atheism-needs-warrant" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-psychological-being-objection", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-qualified-atheistic-knowledge" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-warrant-reply-to-bertrand", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-qualified-atheistic-knowledge", "con-framework-question-begging-and-symmetric" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-theism-incorporates-science", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-naturalistic-comparison-standard" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-psychological-being-correction", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-psychological-being-objection" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-knowledge-not-conclusive-proof", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-warrant-reply-to-bertrand" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-objective-moral-premises-contested", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-objective-moral-grounding" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-causal-intuitions-limited-at-origin", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-contingency-needs-necessary-mind" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-divine-attributes-not-derived", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-contingency-needs-necessary-mind", "pro-cosmic-beginning-creator" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-agrees-nonconclusive-but-asks-warrant", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-knowledge-not-conclusive-proof" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-controversy-requires-premise-examination", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-objective-moral-premises-contested" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-moral-experience-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-objective-moral-premises-contested" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-persistent-controversy-reduces-support", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-controversy-requires-premise-examination" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-laws-begin-origin-may-lack-scientific-explanation", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-cosmic-beginning-creator" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-personal-explanation-of-origin", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-laws-begin-origin-may-lack-scientific-explanation", "con-divine-attributes-not-derived" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-peer-disagreement-reduces-confidence", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-controversy-requires-premise-examination" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-moral-wrongness-does-not-settle-grounding", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-objective-moral-grounding" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-religious-diversity-undercuts-testimony", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-supports-christian-theism" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-causal-not-temporal-priority", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-laws-begin-origin-may-lack-scientific-explanation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-timeless-mind-raises-more-questions", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-causal-not-temporal-priority" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-generic-theism-before-christianity", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-religious-diversity-undercuts-testimony" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-expertise-treated-asymmetrically", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-ancient-myth-scholarship-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-abstract-laws-have-no-causal-power", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-laws-begin-origin-may-lack-scientific-explanation" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-bodyless-mind-more-mysterious", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-personal-explanation-of-origin" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-basic-action-model-of-divine-causation", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-bodyless-mind-more-mysterious" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-secular-morality-and-meaning-live", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-theism-importance-purpose-value" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-reports-do-not-establish-miracles", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-supports-christian-theism" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "con-naturalistic-sociological-christian-origin", "speaker": "Klemens Kappel", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-supports-christian-theism" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 284, "move_id": "pro-christianity-historically-anchored", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "con-naturalistic-sociological-christian-origin", "con-reports-do-not-establish-miracles" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-designer-regress-and-natural-selection", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-design-demands-designer" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-values-are-mind-dependent-yet-justifiable", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-requires-god" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-singer-and-hitler-corrections", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-atheism-cannot-secure-human-value" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-scripture-unreliable-and-psalm-charge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-design-demands-designer", "pro-objective-morality-requires-god" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-natural-altruism-and-human-morality", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-requires-god" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-ridley-uncertainty-reply", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-natural-altruism-and-human-morality" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-hitler-correction-and-singer-reply", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-singer-and-hitler-corrections" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-testimony-context-resolves-contradiction", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-self-testimony-contradiction" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-psalm-predicts-rather-than-endorses", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-scripture-unreliable-and-psalm-charge" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-designer-can-be-nonmaterial-uncaused", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-designer-regress-and-natural-selection" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-naturalism-also-posits-uncaused-origin", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-designer-regress-and-natural-selection" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-spirit-negative-description-answer", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-spirit-positive-definition-question" ], "score": 66 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-spirit-remains-undefined", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-spirit-negative-description-answer" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-resurrection-is-falsification-condition", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-falsifiability-question" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-eve-perfect-capacity-answer", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-eve-perfect-creation-question" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-created-impulse-followup", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-eve-perfect-capacity-answer" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-least-harm-extreme-case-qualified", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-requires-god" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-nazi-intention-challenge", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-least-harm-extreme-case-qualified" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-shared-human-laws-answer", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-nazi-intention-challenge" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-nazi-comparison-followup", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-shared-human-laws-answer" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "pro-hell-as-free-choice-and-sacrificial-rescue", "speaker": "Kyle Butt", "targets": [ "con-hell-threat-morally-bankrupt" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-table-talk-and-darwin-qualifications", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-hitler-correction-and-singer-reply" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-historical-resurrection-and-jesus-qualification", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-is-falsification-condition" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-human-dignity-without-sin-premise", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-hell-as-free-choice-and-sacrificial-rescue" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 285, "move_id": "con-bible-human-and-unreliable", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-testimony-context-resolves-contradiction", "pro-psalm-predicts-rather-than-endorses", "pro-interpretive-disagreement-reflects-reader-prejudice" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-authors-retrospectively-fit-stories", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-partial-cumulative-thesis", "pro-seed-sacrifice-redemption-trajectory" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-jewish-messiah-expectations", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-partial-cumulative-thesis" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-early-records-and-verification-criteria", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-verifiable-facts-before-fulfillment" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-specificity-through-genealogy-and-temple-window", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-specific-unambiguous-prospective-standard" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-interpretation-and-multi-author-covenant", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-specific-unambiguous-prospective-standard" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-messiah-prophet-divine-and-salvation", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-jewish-messiah-expectations" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-reasonable-confidence-not-certainty", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-early-records-and-verification-criteria" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-prospective-versus-backward-reading", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-specificity-through-genealogy-and-temple-window", "pro-interpretation-and-multi-author-covenant" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-isaiah-arm-redemption-context", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-jewish-messiah-expectations", "con-prospective-versus-backward-reading" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-isaiah-not-explicitly-messianic", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-isaiah-servant-redemption", "pro-isaiah-arm-redemption-context" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-genesis-three-retrospective-messianism", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-seed-sacrifice-redemption-trajectory" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-isaac-typology-depends-on-later-jesus-story", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-seed-sacrifice-redemption-trajectory" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-prophecies-operate-as-contextual-unit", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-specific-unambiguous-prospective-standard", "con-isaiah-not-explicitly-messianic" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-context-without-specific-prediction-insufficient", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-prophecies-operate-as-contextual-unit" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-specific-examples-with-context", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-context-without-specific-prediction-insufficient" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-testimony-and-criteria-not-established", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-specific-examples-with-context", "pro-early-records-and-verification-criteria" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-original-intent-from-context", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-prospective-versus-backward-reading" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-interpretive-framework-risks-tautology", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-original-intent-from-context" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-two-part-prophecy-and-event-demonstration", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-specific-examples-with-context", "pro-early-records-and-verification-criteria" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-two-stage-prediction-then-fulfillment", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-two-part-prophecy-and-event-demonstration" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-old-testament-lamb-death-theme", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-isaiah-not-explicitly-messianic", "con-genesis-three-retrospective-messianism" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-christian-lens-versus-jewish-history", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-partial-cumulative-thesis", "pro-old-testament-lamb-death-theme" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "pro-jewish-converts-counter-framework-dependence", "speaker": "Samuel Nesan", "targets": [ "con-christian-lens-versus-jewish-history" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 286, "move_id": "con-specific-prediction-outperforms-textual-ambiguity", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "pro-jewish-converts-counter-framework-dependence", "pro-old-testament-lamb-death-theme" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-spaceless-timeless-being-incoherent", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-cause-beyond-spacetime-and-matter" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-fine-tuning-reverses-adaptation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuning-implies-intelligent-design" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-prior-to-time-is-incoherent", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-cause-beyond-spacetime-and-matter" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-gaps-favor-natural-investigation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-cause-best-explained-as-supreme-being" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-morality-needs-no-god", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-best-explained-by-god" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-multiple-constants-and-multiverse-alternative", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuning-implies-intelligent-design", "pro-cause-best-explained-as-supreme-being" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-observer-selection-undercuts-unique-design", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-fine-tuning-implies-intelligent-design" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-values-are-mental-harm-is-verifiable", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-best-explained-by-god" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-harm-grounds-objective-assessment", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-objective-morality-best-explained-by-god", "pro-moral-truth-independent-of-belief" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-cosmological-premise-begs-question", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-universe-began-and-had-cause" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-objective-moral-truths-need-explanation", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-morality-needs-no-god", "con-values-are-mental-harm-is-verifiable" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-evaluate-best-explanation-not-gap-label", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-gaps-favor-natural-investigation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-hiddenness-allows-evidence-without-certainty", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-absence-of-good-public-evidence" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-abstract-objects-support-immaterial-coherence", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-spaceless-timeless-being-incoherent" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-human-mind-analogy-for-design", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-spaceless-timeless-being-incoherent" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-unseen-causes-inferred-from-effects", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-absence-of-good-public-evidence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-multiverse-does-not-remove-explanatory-burden", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-multiple-constants-and-multiverse-alternative" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-moral-grounding-distinct-from-atheist-conduct", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-morality-needs-no-god", "con-values-are-mental-harm-is-verifiable" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-power-requires-time-and-physical-work", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-cause-beyond-spacetime-and-matter" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-mind-is-function-not-separate-thing", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-human-mind-analogy-for-design" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "con-formal-case-remains-unconvincing", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "pro-cause-best-explained-as-supreme-being", "pro-fine-tuning-implies-intelligent-design", "pro-objective-morality-best-explained-by-god" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-disagreement-does-not-negate-existence", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-theistic-disagreement-undercuts-guidance" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 287, "move_id": "pro-cumulative-case-best-explains-reality", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-formal-case-remains-unconvincing", "con-absence-of-good-public-evidence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-apollonius-evidence-is-later-and-interested", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-apollonius-parallel" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-joseph-smith-witnesses-and-character-disanalogy", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-mormon-witness-comparator" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "pro-gospels-are-anonymously-attributed", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "con-luke-investigated-named-witnesses", "con-peter-source-and-first-person-access" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "pro-alien-story-tests-claim-specific-evidence", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "con-luke-ordinary-accuracy-supports-historical-care" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "pro-martyrdom-shows-conviction-not-truth", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "con-early-christian-costly-sincerity", "con-peter-source-and-first-person-access", "con-james-family-access-and-costly-belief" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-extraordinary-evidence-is-offered", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-comparative-evidence-over-miracle-testimony" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-first-person-experience-differs-from-inherited-belief", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-martyrdom-shows-conviction-not-truth", "pro-alien-story-tests-claim-specific-evidence" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-gospel-identity-has-internal-and-external-support", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-gospels-are-anonymously-attributed" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-jewish-context-resists-pagan-borrowing", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-ancient-redeemer-patterns" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-mythic-parallels-can-express-fulfilled-hope", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-ancient-redeemer-patterns" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "con-memory-retains-central-life-changing-events", "speaker": "Luuk Vandeweghe", "targets": [ "pro-memory-is-reconstructive" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 288, "move_id": "pro-resurrection-remains-faith-not-public-knowledge", "speaker": "Michael Shermer", "targets": [ "con-extraordinary-evidence-is-offered" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "pro-god-as-ultimate-reality", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-theistic-axiom-challenge" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "con-nonnatural-moral-properties", "speaker": "Erik Wielenberg", "targets": [ "pro-nonnaturalness-challenge" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "pro-godless-love-reduction", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-intrinsic-love-challenge" ], "score": 56 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "con-objectivity-entails-axioms", "speaker": "Erik Wielenberg", "targets": [ "pro-evidence-for-axioms-challenge" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "pro-obedience-resembles-love", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-goodness-obligation-gap" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "con-properties-without-platonism", "speaker": "Erik Wielenberg", "targets": [ "pro-abstract-objects-explanation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "pro-created-for-love-and-judgment", "speaker": "Adam Lloyd Johnson", "targets": [ "con-accountability-clarification" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 289, "move_id": "con-evolutionary-convergence", "speaker": "Erik Wielenberg", "targets": [ "pro-lucky-coincidence-challenge" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-narrows-overall-force", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-states-likelihood-inference" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-classical-attributes-create-problem", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-defines-comparative-hypotheses" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-specificity-costs-prior", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-school-bus-background", "rauser-soul-making-expectation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-soul-making-leaves-unobserved-suffering", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-soul-making-expectation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-defeater-relative-to-held-beliefs", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-specificity-costs-prior" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-animal-suffering-concession-and-options", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-soul-making-leaves-unobserved-suffering" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-animal-resurrection-needs-independent-support", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-animal-suffering-concession-and-options" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-biblical-creation-renewal-support", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-animal-resurrection-needs-independent-support" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-grants-limited-scriptural-support", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-biblical-creation-renewal-support" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-indifference-broader-than-naturalism", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-moral-platonism-reverse-analogy" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-platonist-package-restated", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-indifference-broader-than-naturalism" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-entailment-breaks-analogy", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-platonist-package-restated" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-qualified-bare-theism-concession", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-entailment-breaks-analogy" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-unknown-reason-parallels-ad-hoc-escape", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-cognitive-closure-limited" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-apprenticeship-analogy", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-unknown-reason-parallels-ad-hoc-escape" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-basic-moral-knowledge-resists-closure", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-apprenticeship-analogy" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-permissible-suffering-threshold", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-deontic-ledger-objection" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-extreme-cases-beyond-cutoff", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-permissible-suffering-threshold" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-soldier-testimony-cautions", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-extreme-cases-beyond-cutoff" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-post-hoc-adaptation-challenge", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-soldier-testimony-cautions" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-fallible-testimony-deference", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-post-hoc-adaptation-challenge" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-counterfactual-life-balance", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-soldier-testimony-cautions" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-world-level-effects", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-counterfactual-life-balance" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-unknown-effects-symmetry", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-world-level-effects" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-family-caregiving-causal-example", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-unknown-effects-symmetry" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "malpass-caregiving-alternative", "speaker": "Alex Malpass", "targets": [ "rauser-family-caregiving-causal-example" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 290, "move_id": "rauser-final-individual-causal-history", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "malpass-caregiving-alternative" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-hostility-argument-assumes-anthropocentrism", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-hostility-plus-scale-favors-naturalism" ], "score": 69 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-finite-perspective-limits-suffering-inference", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-apparently-pointless-suffering-favors-naturalism" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-implicit-relationship-can-exist-without-belief", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-nonresistant-unbelief-favors-naturalism" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-proper-basicality-needs-nonpermissive-constraints", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-experience-can-ground-basic-theistic-belief" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-concedes-explanatory-legitimacy-only", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-transcendent-agency-is-explanatorily-permissible" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-moral-intuition-can-be-prima-facie-naturalistically", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-god-best-explains-moral-cognition" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-moral-disagreement-is-theistically-surprising", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-god-best-explains-moral-cognition" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-grandeur-does-not-answer-hostility", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-hostility-argument-assumes-anthropocentrism" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-unknown-reasons-require-asymmetry", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-implicit-relationship-can-exist-without-belief" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-particularism-starts-from-natural-belief-formation", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-proper-basicality-needs-nonpermissive-constraints" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-psychopathy-tests-universal-sanction", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-proper-basicality-needs-nonpermissive-constraints" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-normal-functioning-qualifies-universal-sanction", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-psychopathy-tests-universal-sanction" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-normality-threshold-challenges-methodist-test", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-normal-functioning-qualifies-universal-sanction" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-rational-updating-is-not-proper-basicality", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-experience-can-ground-basic-theistic-belief" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-justice-seeking-can-be-implicit-divine-relationship", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-nonresistant-unbelief-favors-naturalism" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-conscious-reciprocal-relationship-adds-moral-benefits", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-justice-seeking-can-be-implicit-divine-relationship" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-temporary-distance-may-protect-future-relationship", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-conscious-reciprocal-relationship-adds-moral-benefits" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-naturalism-still-owes-moral-intuition-mechanism", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-moral-intuition-can-be-prima-facie-naturalistically" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-mechanism-unknown-may-still-favor-theism", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-naturalism-still-owes-moral-intuition-mechanism" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "pro-closing-answers-moral-disagreement", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "con-moral-intuition-can-be-prima-facie-naturalistically", "con-moral-disagreement-is-theistically-surprising", "con-mechanism-unknown-may-still-favor-theism" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-closing-reductio-demands-limits", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-normality-threshold-challenges-methodist-test" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-closing-conscious-relation-remains-withheld", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-justice-seeking-can-be-implicit-divine-relationship", "pro-temporary-distance-may-protect-future-relationship" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-closing-hostility-not-maximal-hospitality", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-hostility-argument-assumes-anthropocentrism" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 291, "move_id": "con-closing-possibility-does-not-equal-likelihood", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "pro-finite-perspective-limits-suffering-inference" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-facts-values-duties-distinction", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-life-fairness-shared-values" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-competing-objective-standards", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-transcendent-source-across-eras" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-values-ground-right-and-wrong", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-competing-objective-standards" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-fact-does-not-entail-obligation", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-values-ground-right-and-wrong" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-golden-rule-descriptive-cooperation", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-golden-rule-cross-cultural-duty" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-common-values-transcendent-lord", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-objective-wellbeing-facts" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-conditional-ought-without-cosmic-binding", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-common-values-transcendent-lord" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-divine-sanction-shares-motivation-limit", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-common-values-transcendent-lord" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-contrary-consequences-divine-command-test", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-common-values-transcendent-lord" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-agreement-does-not-prove-metaphysics", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-humane-orientation-commonality" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-no-external-purpose-no-internal-problem", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-higher-god-given-purpose" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-gifts-point-to-assigned-calling", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-no-external-purpose-no-internal-problem" ], "score": 72 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-atheism-ends-in-forgetting", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-no-external-purpose-no-internal-problem" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-finitude-does-not-remove-value", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-atheism-ends-in-forgetting" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-god-purpose-regress-challenge", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-higher-god-given-purpose" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-divine-being-and-accountability", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-god-purpose-regress-challenge" ], "score": 62 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "pro-jesus-love-mercy-and-justice", "speaker": "S.J. Thomason", "targets": [ "con-salvation-system-moral-objection" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-atonement-extortion-objection", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-jesus-love-mercy-and-justice" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 292, "move_id": "con-eternal-heaven-identity-objection", "speaker": "Scott Clifton", "targets": [ "pro-heaven-is-not-earth-forever" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-broader-martyr-definition", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-three-part-martyr-test" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-definition-does-not-supply-evidence", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-broader-martyr-definition" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-small-number-changes-burden", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-sincerity-not-proof" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-early-varied-group-sources", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-small-number-changes-burden" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-acts-is-indirect", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-early-varied-group-sources" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-multiple-attestation", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-acts-is-indirect" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-survey-aggregation-objection", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-multiple-attestation" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-group-reference-bulls-analogy", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-survey-aggregation-objection" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-early-creed-not-group-firsthand", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-group-reference-bulls-analogy" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-multiple-sources-without-wholesale-trust", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-early-creed-not-group-firsthand" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-graded-central-deaths", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-deaths-mostly-limited" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-two-person-sincere-error", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-graded-central-deaths" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-two-central-witnesses", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-two-person-sincere-error" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-legends-can-grow-despite-checkability", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-cultural-resistance-and-living-witnesses" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-five-hundred-public-challenge", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-legends-can-grow-despite-checkability" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-hyper-skepticism-method-challenge", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-legends-can-grow-despite-checkability" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "con-initial-mental-check-not-refusal", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-hyper-skepticism-method-challenge" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-cost-supports-sincerity", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-initial-mental-check-not-refusal" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 293, "move_id": "pro-final-sincerity", "speaker": "Sean McDowell", "targets": [ "con-final-insufficient" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "rauser-inspired-text-and-moral-intuition", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "copan-canonical-continuity" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "rauser-marcionite-label-overreach", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "copan-marcionite-authority-concern" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "rauser-hyperbole-leaves-civilian-problem", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "copan-war-rhetoric-and-survivors" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "copan-citadels-drive-out-and-survivors", "speaker": "Paul Copan", "targets": [ "rauser-hyperbole-leaves-civilian-problem" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "rauser-textual-civilians-and-close-contact-killing", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "copan-citadels-drive-out-and-survivors" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "copan-identity-not-ethnicity", "speaker": "Paul Copan", "targets": [ "rauser-identity-removal-can-be-genocide" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "copan-defeasible-intuition", "speaker": "Paul Copan", "targets": [ "rauser-alternative-readings" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "rauser-intrinsic-wrongness-closing", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "copan-defeasible-intuition" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 294, "move_id": "copan-unique-contextual-judgment", "speaker": "Paul Copan", "targets": [ "rauser-intrinsic-wrongness-closing" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-appreciates-nuanced-scope", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-unequal-martyrdom-evidence" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-sparse-james-causation", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-four-witness-core" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-acts-brevity-supports-historicity", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-sparse-james-causation" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-james-brother-political-motive", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-james-brother-multiple-attestation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-james-lawbreaking-points-to-preaching", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-james-brother-political-motive" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-nero-scapegoat-problem", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-tacitus-belief-directed-persecution" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-probability-over-possibility", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-nero-scapegoat-problem" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-nonuniform-roman-practice", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-probability-over-possibility" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-recantation-card-challenge", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-risk-before-arrest" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-recantation-costs-status-and-reputation", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-recantation-card-challenge" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-recanting-does-not-erase-benefit", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-recantation-costs-status-and-reputation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-public-association-analogy", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-recanting-does-not-erase-benefit" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-association-itself-unproven", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-public-association-analogy" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-paul-sincere-but-different-category", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-sincerity-not-objective-truth" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-trauma-proposal-conceded-speculative", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-trauma-account-is-unsupported-speculation" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-collective-evidence-stops-early", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-collective-acts-and-paul-evidence" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-apostle-as-public-messenger", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-collective-evidence-stops-early" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-inference-stacking", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-apostle-as-public-messenger" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-two-lines-support-group-preaching", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-inference-stacking" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-named-leaders-not-all-eleven", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-two-lines-support-group-preaching" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-named-apostates-would-expose-abandonment", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-disappearance-allows-multiple-outcomes" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-strongest-case-is-expected-suffering", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-disappearance-allows-multiple-outcomes" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "con-positive-evidence-needed-for-all", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-strongest-case-is-expected-suffering" ], "score": 94 }, { "number": 295, "move_id": "pro-compare-whole-narratives", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "con-minimal-sincere-experiences-scenario" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-creed-flourishing-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-mere-christianity-qualified-case" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-creed-restoration-and-purpose", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-creed-flourishing-challenge" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-demand-for-present-benefit", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-creed-restoration-and-purpose" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-emulating-jesus-present-practice", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-demand-for-present-benefit" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-humanism-nature-derivative-challenge", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-revisable-open-method" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-species-value-and-cooperation", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-image-grounded-species-worth", "con-humanism-nature-derivative-challenge" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-subjective-value-pressure", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-species-value-and-cooperation" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-humanism-not-dependent-on-self-liking", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-subjective-value-pressure" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-scriptural-hierarchy-equality-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-image-grounded-species-worth" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-unvalued-infant-challenge", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-humanism-not-dependent-on-self-liking" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-equal-rights-as-humanist-policy", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-unvalued-infant-challenge" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-moral-intuition-and-imago-coherence", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-equal-rights-as-humanist-policy" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-test-intuitions-not-rationalize", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-moral-intuition-and-imago-coherence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-fallible-properly-basic-intuitions", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-test-intuitions-not-rationalize" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-divine-premise-public-burden", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-fallible-properly-basic-intuitions" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-species-codification-objection", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-equality-as-foundational-declaration" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-rights-require-collective-protection", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-species-codification-objection" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-goodness-and-objective-rights", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-rights-require-collective-protection" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-rights-versus-what-should-be-rights", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-goodness-and-objective-rights" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-egalitarian-image-and-entitlement", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-rights-versus-what-should-be-rights", "pro-scriptural-hierarchy-equality-challenge" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-codification-can-fail-its-values", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-egalitarian-image-and-entitlement" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-revisability-categorical-rights-challenge", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-revisable-open-method", "pro-codification-can-fail-its-values" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-equality-logically-constrains-revision", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-revisability-categorical-rights-challenge" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-physics-analogy-and-missing-premise", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-equality-logically-constrains-revision" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-qualified-categorical-equality-response", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-physics-analogy-and-missing-premise" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-objective-rights-final-clarification", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-qualified-categorical-equality-response" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "pro-hope-focused-on-afterlife-challenge", "speaker": "Matt Dillahunty", "targets": [ "con-hope-motivates-action" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-dispensationalism-not-mere-christianity", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-hope-focused-on-afterlife-challenge" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 296, "move_id": "con-renewed-creation-hope-reply", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "pro-hope-focused-on-afterlife-challenge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-probabilistic-history-standards", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-bible-as-historical-data" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-consensus-not-a-substitute", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-crucifixion-bedrock", "pro-early-appearance-belief", "pro-paul-conversion-experience" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-miracle-burden", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-best-explanation" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-gospel-source-limitations", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-early-appearance-belief", "pro-empty-tomb-corroboration" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-paul-vision-and-mundane-error", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-paul-conversion-experience", "pro-early-appearance-belief" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-limited-grants-on-witnesses", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-crucifixion-bedrock", "pro-paul-conversion-experience", "pro-early-appearance-belief" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-five-hundred-identifiability", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-early-appearance-belief" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-twelve-attestation-reply", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-limited-grants-on-witnesses" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-creed-is-transmitted-report", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-twelve-attestation-reply" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-creed-historical-core", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-creed-is-transmitted-report" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-bereavement-experience", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-creed-historical-core" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-group-experience-not-hallucination", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-bereavement-experience" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-social-transmission-alternative", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-group-experience-not-hallucination" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-selective-appearances-fit", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-social-transmission-alternative" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-uncommitted-alternatives-challenge", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-bereavement-experience", "con-social-transmission-alternative" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-professed-versus-experienced", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-creed-historical-core" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-first-witness-persecution-gap", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-early-appearance-belief" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-acts-and-early-suffering-sources", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-first-witness-persecution-gap" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-person-specific-recantation-gap", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-acts-and-early-suffering-sources" ], "score": 93 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-recantation-inference", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-person-specific-recantation-gap" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-empty-tomb-status-challenge", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-corroboration" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-embarrassment-correction-and-limit", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-empty-tomb-corroboration" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-criterion-and-mark-theme-reply", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-embarrassment-correction-and-limit" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-mark-theme-and-ending-objection", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-criterion-and-mark-theme-reply" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-mark-ending-context", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-mark-theme-and-ending-objection" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "con-closing-insufficiency", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-resurrection-best-explanation", "pro-selective-appearances-fit" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 297, "move_id": "pro-closing-worldview-and-best-explanation", "speaker": "Mike Winger", "targets": [ "con-closing-insufficiency" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-agnostic-burden-and-classical-target", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-defines-motion-and-god" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-contingency-and-time-uncertainty", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-contingency-to-necessary-ground", "horn-finite-beginning-and-cause" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-fine-tuning-comparison-objection", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-fine-tuning-to-design" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-moral-premises-not-established", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-objective-morality-and-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-deduction-needs-probability-and-alternatives", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-defines-motion-and-god", "horn-contingency-to-necessary-ground", "horn-finite-beginning-and-cause", "horn-fine-tuning-to-design", "horn-objective-morality-and-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-hiddenness-and-suffering-as-evidence", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-defines-motion-and-god", "horn-objective-morality-and-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-rival-supernatural-concepts", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-contingency-to-necessary-ground", "horn-finite-beginning-and-cause", "horn-fine-tuning-to-design", "horn-objective-morality-and-perfect-goodness" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-premises-need-reasonable-support", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-deduction-needs-probability-and-alternatives" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-defends-contingency-and-definition", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-contingency-and-time-uncertainty" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-defends-beginning-and-time-route", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-contingency-and-time-uncertainty" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-perception-supports-moral-facts", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-moral-premises-not-established", "lataster-hiddenness-and-suffering-as-evidence" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-one-unlimited-source-against-rivals", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-rival-supernatural-concepts" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-suffering-conditional-expectation", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-perception-supports-moral-facts" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-rivals-still-require-comparison", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-one-unlimited-source-against-rivals" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-hiddenness-permits-reasons", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-nonresistant-nonbelief-expectation" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-attributes-jointly-narrow-conclusion", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-rivals-still-require-comparison", "lataster-moral-premises-not-established" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-agnosticism-and-theism-comparison", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-premises-need-reasonable-support", "horn-attributes-jointly-narrow-conclusion" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-hiddenness-excuses-and-free-choice", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-hiddenness-permits-reasons" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-manifestation-versus-alien-challenge", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-nonresistant-nonbelief-expectation" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "cross-exam-limb-example-qualified", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-manifestation-versus-alien-challenge" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "cross-exam-eternalist-theories-clarified", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-defends-beginning-and-time-route" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-deduction-more-likely-premises", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-deduction-needs-probability-and-alternatives", "lataster-agnosticism-and-theism-comparison" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-infinite-god-universe-challenge", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-finite-beginning-and-cause" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-infinite-collection-versus-unlimited-being", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-infinite-god-universe-challenge" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-simplicity-is-not-entity-count", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-rival-supernatural-concepts" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-moral-knowledge-challenge", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-objective-morality-and-perfect-goodness", "horn-perception-supports-moral-facts" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-natural-moral-faculty-reply", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-moral-knowledge-challenge" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "horn-closing-convergence", "speaker": "Trent Horn", "targets": [ "lataster-rivals-still-require-comparison", "lataster-agnosticism-and-theism-comparison" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 298, "move_id": "lataster-closing-conditional-grants-and-rivals", "speaker": "Raphael Lataster", "targets": [ "horn-closing-convergence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-agrees-generic-theism-not-refuted", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-narrows-loving-god" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-reason-and-desire-jointly-shape-belief", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-information-can-overcome-influence" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-questions-probability-not-possibility", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-one-person-defeats-universal" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-postmortem-possibility", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-asks-basis-for-postmortem-chance" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-romans-universal-tension", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-postmortem-possibility" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-romans-targets-knowing-rejection", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-romans-universal-tension" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-missionary-implication-question", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-postmortem-possibility" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-motivated-evaluation-study", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-one-person-defeats-universal" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-study-allows-exceptions", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-motivated-evaluation-study" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-therapy-shows-causal-opacity", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-present-thought-content-is-accessible" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-conclusion-not-independent-argument", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-openness-and-intellectual-deconversion" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-loving-god-must-bridge-belief-gap", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-conclusion-not-independent-argument" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-belief-and-relationship-not-fixed-steps", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-loving-god-must-bridge-belief-gap" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-minority-remains-unanswered", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-self-serving-disclosure-demands" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "con-private-report-lacks-public-access", "speaker": "Michael Jones", "targets": [ "pro-unequal-disclosure-leaves-gap" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-asks-why-belief-barrier-remains", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-eventual-justice-answers-case" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 299, "move_id": "pro-shared-duty-to-check-desire", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "con-desire-aware-public-method" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-restores-machine-welfare-qualification", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-machines-can-have-welfare" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-accepts-instrumental-reward-and-punishment", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-civilization-reduces-cruel-punishment" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-moral-progress-subtracts-responsibility", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-civilization-reduces-cruel-punishment" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-self-control-is-biological-and-unchosen", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-builds-foreseeing-self-control", "pro-capacity-thresholds-and-diminished-control" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-runner-analogy-challenges-desert", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-builds-foreseeing-self-control" ], "score": 60 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-intuition-is-an-unreliable-guide", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-freedom-evolves-and-undetermined-will-is-undesirable" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-restores-context-to-runner-and-two-stage-passages", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-runner-analogy-challenges-desert", "con-intuition-is-an-unreliable-guide" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-deterministic-chaos-supports-autonomy", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-independence-burden-challenge", "con-intuition-is-an-unreliable-guide" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-sapolsky-values-the-relevant-capacity", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-self-control-is-biological-and-unchosen" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-evolution-needs-uncontrollable-variation-not-indeterminism", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-independence-burden-challenge" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "con-options-do-not-free-the-chooser", "speaker": "Robert Sapolsky", "targets": [ "pro-evolution-needs-uncontrollable-variation-not-indeterminism" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-civilization-counteracts-causes-and-excuses-incapacity", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-multiscale-development-shapes-choice", "con-self-control-is-biological-and-unchosen", "con-options-do-not-free-the-chooser" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 300, "move_id": "pro-fair-nonawful-sanctions", "speaker": "Daniel Dennett", "targets": [ "con-accepts-instrumental-reward-and-punishment", "con-moral-progress-subtracts-responsibility" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-rejects-substitution-and-reads-denial-as-nonkilling", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-substitution-portrays-deception-and-failure" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-short-crucifixion-and-possible-survival", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-multiple-sources-and-crucifixion-practice" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-quran-allows-death-without-opponents-victory", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-rejects-substitution-and-reads-denial-as-nonkilling" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-uppermost-followers-and-gospel-as-interpretive-route", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-divine-rescue-and-varieties-of-raising" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-psalms-describe-rescue-before-death", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-early-corinthians-creed" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-uppermost-can-be-spiritual-victory", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-uppermost-followers-and-gospel-as-interpretive-route" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-assumption-and-vision-chain-compatible-with-quran", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-early-corinthians-creed", "wood-persecution-shows-sincere-belief" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-crucifixion-has-multiple-lethal-mechanisms", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-short-crucifixion-and-possible-survival" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-miracle-counts-undercut-linear-embellishment", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-gospel-development-as-trend" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-earliest-creed-precedes-later-gospel-critique", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-gospel-development-as-trend", "ally-women-reporting-develops-across-gospels" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-smith-title-and-acts-affirm-death", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-psalms-describe-rescue-before-death", "ally-assumption-and-vision-chain-compatible-with-quran" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-james-and-paul-do-not-establish-friend-and-foe-pattern", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-early-corinthians-creed" ], "score": 70 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-location-and-physicality-conflicts", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-miracle-counts-undercut-linear-embellishment" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-q-assumption-and-sign-of-jonah", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-smith-title-and-acts-affirm-death" ], "score": 67 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-consistent-critical-methods-across-traditions", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-gospel-development-as-trend" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-critical-scholars-reject-islam-and-quran-is-instructional", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-consistent-critical-methods-across-traditions" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-guards-spices-and-saints-as-later-additions", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-consistent-critical-methods-across-traditions" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-zeller-and-q-are-speculative", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-q-assumption-and-sign-of-jonah" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-omission-does-not-establish-invention", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-guards-spices-and-saints-as-later-additions" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-q-scholarship-and-assumption-distinction", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-zeller-and-q-are-speculative" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-john-spices-conflict-with-womens-purchase", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-omission-does-not-establish-invention" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-gospel-command-has-legal-context", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-uppermost-followers-and-gospel-as-interpretive-route" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "wood-closing-critical-consensus-remains", "speaker": "David Wood", "targets": [ "ally-q-scholarship-and-assumption-distinction" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-closing-concedes-consensus-but-questions-warrant", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-closing-critical-consensus-remains" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 301, "move_id": "ally-closing-survival-and-ascension-are-conditional", "speaker": "Shabir Ally", "targets": [ "wood-closing-critical-consensus-remains" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-face-value-with-metaphor", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-prooftexting-context-critique" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-genre-no-default-reading", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-face-value-with-metaphor", "barker-expert-disagreement-communication" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-psalm-human-authorship-inclusion", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-bereaved-lament-analogy" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-anger-not-final-word", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-psalm-human-authorship-inclusion" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-no-explicit-condemnation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-anger-not-final-word" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-perfection-principle-circularity", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-four-christian-principles" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-rape-imagery-divine-agency", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-genre-no-default-reading" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-creed-scripture-distinction", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-rape-imagery-divine-agency" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-cancer-rhetoric-harm", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-religion-cancer-qualified" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-distinguishes-people-from-religion", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-cancer-rhetoric-harm" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-psalm14-whole-psalm-universal", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-psalm14-harm-to-atheists" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-framework-explicitly-conditional", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-perfection-principle-circularity" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-internal-reasonableness-and-disagreement", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-framework-explicitly-conditional" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-canaanite-victim-challenge", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-creed-scripture-distinction" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-range-of-conquest-readings", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-canaanite-victim-challenge" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-recurring-violence-pattern", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-range-of-conquest-readings" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-rejects-copan-aligns-noncommand", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-recurring-violence-pattern" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-pattern-over-metaphor", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-four-christian-principles" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-literary-ambiguity-broad-message", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-expert-disagreement-communication", "barker-internal-reasonableness-and-disagreement", "barker-pattern-over-metaphor" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-final-moral-denunciation", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-literary-ambiguity-broad-message" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "barker-closing-fallibility-shared-aims", "speaker": "Dan Barker", "targets": [ "rauser-closing-background-framework" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 302, "move_id": "rauser-closing-universal-fallibility", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "barker-closing-fallibility-shared-aims" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "reason-over-conflicting-faith", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "experience-warrant" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "immaterial-self-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "bodyless-mind-change" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "changelessness-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "bodyless-mind-change" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "foreknowledge-modal-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "foreknowledge-freedom-dilemma" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "logical-evil-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "evil-world" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "probabilistic-evil-prior-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "cosmic-scale-and-human-marginality", "evil-world" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "good-nature-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "euthyphro-evil-god" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "formal-command-consistency-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "religion-corrupts-morality" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "comparative-religious-defeaters-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "reason-over-conflicting-faith" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "kalam-uncertainty", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "beginning-cause", "personal-first-cause" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "theorem-scope", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "beginning-cause" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "design-scrutiny", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "fine-tuning-design" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "moral-premise-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "morality-god" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "experience-comparative-caution", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "experience-warrant" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "uniform-beginning-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "kalam-uncertainty", "theorem-scope" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "fine-tuning-laws-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "natural-reality-fit", "design-scrutiny" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "rational-committee-normativity-critique", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "natural-objective-morality", "moral-premise-challenge", "species-inclusive-impartial-contract" ], "score": 64 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "emergent-consciousness-qualified-reply", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "immaterial-self-reply" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "renewed-suffering-free-world-reply", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "logical-evil-reply" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "renewed-evil-god-and-nature-reply", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "good-nature-reply" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "command-killing-and-repentance-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "formal-command-consistency-reply", "good-nature-reply" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "quantum-cause-challenge", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "uniform-beginning-reply" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "pure-reason-impartiality-response", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "rational-committee-normativity-critique" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "net-zero-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "quantum-cause-challenge" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "normative-grounding-reply", "speaker": "William Lane Craig", "targets": [ "natural-objective-morality", "moral-premise-challenge", "pure-reason-impartiality-response" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 303, "move_id": "resurrection-development", "speaker": "Michael Nugent", "targets": [ "resurrection-case" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-logical-limits-and-necessary-goods", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-triad-and-extenuating-circumstances" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-benefit-condition-fails-for-victims", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-responsibility-and-creator-condition" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-heaven-counterexample", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-logical-limits-and-necessary-goods" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-natural-evil-opportunities", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-benefit-condition-fails-for-victims" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-tsunami-and-sanctity", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-benefit-condition-fails-for-victims" ], "score": 71 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-starving-children-and-egocentric-benefit", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-natural-evil-opportunities", "swinburne-tsunami-and-sanctity" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-qualified-good-of-usefulness", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-starving-children-and-egocentric-benefit" ], "score": 73 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-holocaust-victims-did-not-choose", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-qualified-good-of-usefulness" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-permission-historical-choice-and-counterfactual", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-holocaust-victims-did-not-choose" ], "score": 68 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-diverse-reasons-for-different-evils", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-range-of-biblical-answers" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-prophetic-apocalyptic-conflict", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-diverse-reasons-for-different-evils" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-divine-permission-reconciles-hostile-forces", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-prophetic-apocalyptic-conflict" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-incarnation-sharing-and-redemption", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-apparent-nonintervention" ], "score": 79 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "ehrman-authors-and-unfulfilled-imminent-kingdom", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "swinburne-incarnation-sharing-and-redemption" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-resurrection-and-delay-parables", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-authors-and-unfulfilled-imminent-kingdom" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 304, "move_id": "swinburne-final-heaven-sequence", "speaker": "Richard Swinburne", "targets": [ "ehrman-heaven-counterexample", "ehrman-final-response-to-suffering" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-best-not-necessary", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-opening-natural-preference" ], "score": 92 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-natural-options-fit", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-best-not-necessary" ], "score": 63 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-maximal-data-answer", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-single-sincere-origin" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-eyewitness-premise-disputed", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-maximal-data-answer" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-interconnection-without-truth", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-undesigned-fit-example" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-casualness-discriminator", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-interconnection-without-truth" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-discrepancy-two-direction-effect", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-interconnection-without-truth" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-kernels-do-not-transfer", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-undesigned-fit-example", "pro-casualness-discriminator" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-confirmation-enables-trilemma", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-kernels-do-not-transfer" ], "score": 84 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-specific-claims-and-witnesses", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-modest-persecution-case" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-persecution-does-not-resolve-mistake", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-modest-persecution-case" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-testimony-only-prior", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-divine-sign-context" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "pro-testimony-can-overcome-prior", "speaker": "Jonathan McLatchie", "targets": [ "con-testimony-only-prior" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-qualified-threshold-and-dependence", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-testimony-can-overcome-prior" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 305, "move_id": "con-closing-naturalistic-preference", "speaker": "Paulogia", "targets": [ "pro-confirmation-enables-trilemma", "pro-testimony-can-overcome-prior" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-thermodynamic-information", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-information-cause" ], "score": 65 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "meyer-order-versus-functional-sequence", "speaker": "Stephen Meyer", "targets": [ "atkins-thermodynamic-information" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-valid-questions", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-historical-method" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "meyer-rosetta-mind-cause", "speaker": "Stephen Meyer", "targets": [ "atkins-valid-questions" ], "score": 78 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-mind-material-brain", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-rosetta-mind-cause" ], "score": 58 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "meyer-operations-versus-origins", "speaker": "Stephen Meyer", "targets": [ "atkins-intelligent-falling-analogy" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-interconnected-science", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-operations-versus-origins" ], "score": 75 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "meyer-research-agenda", "speaker": "Stephen Meyer", "targets": [ "atkins-incomplete-inquiry" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "meyer-origin-versus-mutation", "speaker": "Stephen Meyer", "targets": [ "atkins-mutation-selection" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-simple-processes-no-design", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-order-versus-functional-sequence" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 306, "move_id": "atkins-noncoding-already-investigated", "speaker": "Peter Atkins", "targets": [ "meyer-noncoding-dna-prediction" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-challenges-early-witness-count", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-early-lines-and-no-central-control" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "printed-editions-versus-manuscript-denominators", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-printed-comparison" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-p75-multiple-line-answer", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-p75-representativeness-challenge" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "tenacity-versus-conjectural-emendation", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-tenacity-premise" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-semantic-impact", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-printed-comparison" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-hebrews-consistency-challenge", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-hebrews-explicit-meaning" ], "score": 88 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-classical-consistency-challenge", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "tenacity-versus-conjectural-emendation" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-classical-limited-uncertainty", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-classical-consistency-challenge" ], "score": 91 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-classical-usable-text-followup", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-classical-limited-uncertainty" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-mark-external-and-harmonization-challenge", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-mark-anger-significance" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-mark-internal-evidence-and-nuance", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-mark-external-and-harmonization-challenge" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-bottleneck", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "white-tenacity-premise", "white-p75-multiple-line-answer" ], "score": 89 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "apostolic-use-rejects-perfect-copy-standard", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-personal-inspiration" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "ehrman-apostolic-standard-concession", "speaker": "Bart Ehrman", "targets": [ "apostolic-use-rejects-perfect-copy-standard" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-one-text-emerges", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-bottleneck" ], "score": 82 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-essential-beliefs-qualification", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-adultery-addition", "ehrman-mark-ending-addition", "ehrman-disputed-jesus-sayings" ], "score": 90 }, { "number": 307, "move_id": "white-final-motion-denial", "speaker": "James White", "targets": [ "ehrman-historical-bibles" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "analogy-assumption-and-degree-burden", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "landlord-disagreement-tension" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "fundamental-errors-require-correction", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "analogy-assumption-and-degree-burden" ], "score": 87 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "virtue-and-staged-pedagogy", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "fundamental-errors-require-correction" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "freedom-moral-knowledge-and-fair-judgment", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "fundamental-errors-require-correction" ], "score": 74 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "team-needs-top-down-clarity", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "virtue-and-staged-pedagogy" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "mistake-accommodation-and-shared-moral-framework", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "team-needs-top-down-clarity", "fundamental-errors-require-correction" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "claimed-revelation-still-needs-clarification", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "mistake-accommodation-and-shared-moral-framework" ], "score": 86 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "exclusivism-not-required", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "fundamental-errors-require-correction" ], "score": 77 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "truth-and-interpersonal-harm-without-exclusivism", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "exclusivism-not-required" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "acquaintance-before-propositions", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "claimed-revelation-still-needs-clarification" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "mutual-awareness-is-richer", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "acquaintance-before-propositions" ], "score": 83 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "infant-coworker-and-dialogue-goods", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "mutual-awareness-is-richer" ], "score": 80 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "natural-convergence-underdetermines", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "detailed-convergence-counterfactual" ], "score": 76 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "specific-doctrines-resist-natural-convergence", "speaker": "Justin Schieber", "targets": [ "natural-convergence-underdetermines" ], "score": 85 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "agreement-does-not-entail-current-atheistic-support", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "specific-doctrines-resist-natural-convergence", "detailed-convergence-counterfactual" ], "score": 81 }, { "number": 308, "move_id": "internal-disagreement-and-relational-goods", "speaker": "Randal Rauser", "targets": [ "defeasible-cumulative-weight" ], "score": 79 } ]